Long-term survival of a stage 4 neuroblastoma patient despite persistent bone marrow disease following autologous bone marrow transplantation

Long-term analysis of children with metastatic neuroblastoma treated in the ENSG5 randomised clinical trial

BACKGROUND

The European Neuroblastoma Study Group 5 (ENSG5) trial showed that time-intensive "rapid" induction chemotherapy (COJEC) was superior to "standard" 3-weekly chemotherapy for children with high-risk metastatic neuroblastoma. Long-term outcomes of the ENSG5 trial were analysed.

PROCEDURE

Patients with metastatic neuroblastoma aged ≥12 months were randomly assigned to "standard" or "rapid" induction, receiving the same chemotherapy drugs and doses. Event-free survival (EFS) and overall survival (OS) were analysed and prognostic factors evaluated. Amongst patients surviving >5 years, a population of children with persistent metastatic disease after the end of treatment was identified and described.

RESULTS

Ten-year EFS was 18.2% (95% confidence interval: 12.2-25.2) for the "standard" arm and 26.8% (19.5-34.7) for the "rapid" arm (hazard ratio [HR] 0.85, P = 0.28). Ten-year OS for the "standard" arm was 19.7% (13.4-26.8) and 28.3% (20.8-36.2) for the "rapid arm" (HR 0.83, P = 0.19). There was a trend for worse EFS and OS for patients having MYCN amplification (HR 1.37 and 1.40, respectively) and those with partial and mixed response to induction (HR 1.69 and 1.75 for EFS and 1.66 and 2.00 for OS, respectively). Among 69 patients who survived >5 years, six had persistent metastatic disease after the end of treatment.

CONCLUSION

The benefit of the "rapid" induction regimen seems to be maintained in the long term, although the small number of survivors could justify the lack of statistical significance. MYCN amplification and poor metastatic response to induction could be associated with worse outcomes. A small group of patients with persistent metastatic disease that survived long term has been described.

Long-term outcomes in patients with stage IV neuroblastoma

AIM OF STUDY

Long-term outcome studies in survivors with stage IV neuroblastoma (NB) are sparse. This review evaluates late complications and long-term outcomes in stage IV NB survivors.

METHODS

A retrospective review of stage IV NB survivors was performed to analyze outcomes, including long-term morbidity, recurrence, and survival.

MAIN RESULTS

Of 153 patients with stage IV NB, 52 (34%) survived (male-female, 26:26). Age at diagnosis was 29.1 +/- 31.7 months in survivors. Eighteen were 1 year or younger and 34 were older than 1 year compared with 10 nonsurvivors 1 year or younger and 91 older than 1 year (P = .0003, Fisher's Exact test). Primary tumor sites were adrenal (35), retroperitoneal (11), mediastinal (3), pelvic (2), and no primary with tumor metastases identified (1). Ten survivors had favorable and 16 had unfavorable histology compared with 1 favorable and 18 unfavorable in nonsurvivors (P = .01). Four survivors had MYCN amplification (> or = 10 copies) and 2 deletions of 1p and 11q. Sites of metastasis in survivors and nonsurvivors were similar. Treatment in survivors included surgery in 51 (75% [39/51] complete tumor resection [CTR]); chemotherapy, 50; radiation, 17; stem cell transplantation, 20; and bone marrow transplant, 1. In nonsurvivors, 13 (25%) of 53 (P < < .0001) had CTR, 18 stem cell transplantation, and 12 bone marrow transplant. Six patients had tumor recurrence but survived (mean, 9.3 +/- 8.3 years; range, 6 months-24 years). Recurrence was local (1), distant (2), and both (3) and was treated by resection, chemotherapy, and radiation. The mean age of survivors was 12.4 +/- 8.3 years (range, 2-34 years). In all stage IV cases, event-free survival was 30% and overall survival was 34%. Long-term complications occurred in 23 (44%) survivors, including endocrine disturbances (7), orthopedic (5), cataracts (2), adhesive bowel obstruction (2), hypertension (1), bronchiolitis (1), blindness (1), peripheral neuropathy (1), nonfunctioning kidney (1), cholelithiasis (1), and thyroid nodule (1).

CONCLUSION

Only 34% of patients with stage IV NB survived despite aggressive multimodal therapy. Age of younger than 1 year, favorable pathology, CTR, and no recurrence were the only statistically significant factors that favored survival. Forty-four percent of survivors experienced late morbidity, and tumor recurred in 6 (11.5%) of 52. Patients should be monitored for tumor recurrence and long-term sequelae. New methods of treatment are required to achieve better outcomes.