The cytopathology of synovial sarcoma: a study of six cases, with emphasis on architecture and histopathologic correlation

Synovial sarcoma: cytopathology of 51 cases highlighting the application of ancillary molecular testing

INTRODUCTION

Among sarcomas, synovial sarcoma (SS) is defined by its unique SS18 cytogenetic translocation. Fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy is in a key position to exploit this uniqueness for diagnostic purposes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Our cytopathology files were searched for examples of SS with histopathologic verification. FNA biopsy, imprint smears, and core needle biopsy (CNB) were performed using standard techniques.

RESULTS

Fifty-one cases from 49 patients (male/female ratio, 1:1; age range, 12-79 years; mean age, 40 years) met the inclusion criteria. Of the 51 cases, 44 (86%) were FNAs, 6 were cytology imprints, and 1 was pleural fluid. Eleven aspirates had concurrent CNB. All cases had tissue confirmation. The biopsy sites included extremities (n = 24; 47%), trunk (n = 12; 24%), lung (n = 8; 16%), head or neck (n = 6; 12%), and pleural fluid (n = 1; 2%). The aspirates were from primary (n = 36; 71%), metastatic (n = 12; 24%), and recurrent (n = 3; 5%) neoplasms. The cytologic diagnoses were SS (69%), suspicious for SS (12%), malignancy (10%), spindle cell neoplasm (4%), and malignancy other than SS (6%). In general, smears and imprints contained dense cell aggregates and single cells composed of a monotonous population having fusiform, rounded, or ovoid banal nuclei and scant cytoplasm. Poorly differentiated SS showed both large epithelioid cell and small cell cytomorphology. When performed, SS18 immunohistochemical and genetic testing was positive in all 19 FNA and 3 CNB cases.

CONCLUSIONS

When coupled with appropriate ancillary testing, FNA biopsy allows for a specific, accurate diagnosis of SS in most cases.

Mediastinal sarcomas: experience using fine needle aspiration cytopathology

Fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology is a sparsely used diagnostic method in the evaluation of mediastinal sarcomas in most medical centers worldwide with most literature citations regarding this category of malignancies consisting of small series and individual case reports. Most of these published studies highlight vascular sarcomas such as epithelioid hemangioendothelioma, and angiosarcoma, various subtypes of liposarcoma including well-differentiated liposarcoma, myxoid liposarcoma, and pleomorphic liposarcoma, malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumor, and sarcomas of uncertain differentiation, primary synovial sarcoma and the Ewing sarcoma family of tumors. This paucity of cytopathology reports regarding mediastinal sarcomas is in marked contrast to the almost daily application of endobronchial ultrasound (EBUS)-guided FNA biopsy for sampling mediastinal lymph nodes and mediastinal masses for primary and metastatic carcinomas which, of course, are considerably more common that any type of sarcoma in this location. EBUS, endoscopic ultrasound-guided (EUS) needle biopsy, and percutaneous image-guided biopsy using either core needle, fine-needle, or both can serve a potentially useful role for diagnostic sampling of mediastinal sarcomas, be they primary or metastatic. This review catalogues much of the published data regarding FNA cytopathology and its application to mediastinal sarcomas. An attempt is made to primarily highlight case series rather than individual case reports; however, due to the paucity of these, case reports are cited and discussed where appropriate.

From fine-needle aspiration cytology to fluorescent in-situ hybridization in an unusual case of pharyngeal synovial sarcoma

Synovial sarcoma arising in the pharynx is a rare entity, with very few cases described in literature, mainly as surgical-oriented case reports. We report the case of a healthy 20-year old man who presented with a painless right neck mass, clinically suspicious for a thyroid nodule. Ultrasound scan and fine-needle aspiration cytology failed to provide a definitive result, although suggesting a mesenchymal proliferation, in accordance with magnetic resonance imaging findings. Therefore, the lesion was removed with a minimally invasive surgical intervention. Definitive histologic and immunohistochemical examination of the surgical specimen revealed a biphasic synovial sarcoma, further validated by the detection of SS18 gene rearrangement on fluorescent in-situ hybridization examination. Although rarely, synovial sarcoma may arise in the pharynx. Radiological, cytological, histological and molecular findings are needed along each step of the diagnostic process.

Diagnosis of recurrent synovial sarcoma by fine needle aspiration cytology--a case report

Cytodiagnosis of synovial sarcoma can be a daunting task, owing to the varied cytomorphological appearances possible, depending on whether the tumour is monophasic or biphasic in architecture. We report herewith a case of recurrent synovial sarcoma in a young male who presented with a swelling in the neck. The diagnosis was established by fine needle aspiration cytology.

Fine-needle aspiration biopsy of monophasic variant of spindle epithelial tumor with thymus-like differentiation of the thyroid: report of one case and review of the literature

Spindle epithelial tumor with thymus-like differentiation (SETTLE) is a rare biphasic tumor of the thyroid with approximately 20 well-documented cases reported in the English literature. Although a monophasic variant of SETTLE is conceivable, the majority of the reported cases were truly biphasic tumors. A minimal amount of epithelial component was present in the reported cases of so-called spindle-cell predominant SETTLE. Here, we report an apparently monophasic case of SETTLE in a 16-yr-old girl, in which no epithelial cells were identified in either fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) or the subsequent hemithyroidectomy specimen. The FNAB smears were moderately cellular and composed of single and loosely grouped spindle cells with homogenous metachromatic material, which could be mistaken as amyloid, erroneously suggesting medullary thyroid carcinoma. The compact nodules of uniform spindle cells in histology sections raised the possibility of monophasic synovial sarcoma. The spindle cells stained positive for both cytokeratin and vimentin, but were negative for thyroglobulin and calcitonin as well as neuroendocrine markers, confirming the diagnosis of SETTLE.

Biphasic parapharyngeal synovial sarcoma: a cytologic and immunocytologic report of a case

BACKGROUND

Synovial sarcoma is a rare soft tissue sarcoma in the head and neck region and parapharyngeal space. There is no previous cytologic report of synovial sarcoma of parapharynx. The cytologic and immunocytochemical findings of a parapharyngeal biphasic synovial sarcoma together with diagnostic pitfalls are described.

CASE REPORT

A 21-year-old girl presented with a 6-month history of progressive right arm pain, neck mass and upper aerodigestive tract obstruction. On physical examination there was a large painless mass arising from the right-sided parapharyngeal space causing airway obstruction. Initial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) revealed a large tumor in the right-sided parapharyngeal space. Fine needle aspiration through cervical region was performed and was reported as benign spindle cell tumor. Smears were cellular and composed mostly of tight and loose clusters of spindle cells. Epitheloid cells could also be identified intermingled with them. She underwent near total resection of the tumor. Pathologic report disclosed the diagnosis of synovial sarcoma. She then received postoperative adjuvant external radiotherapy.

CONCLUSION

Due to rarity of this tumor in this region and nonspecific cytologic features, we could not differentiate this tumor from the other more common spindle cell neoplasms. Considering synovial sarcoma in this region and immunocytochemistry can be helpful in rendering a correct initial diagnosis of this tumor.

Fine-needle aspiration of neurilemoma (schwannoma). A clinicocytopathologic study of 116 patients

The preoperative fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) diagnoses in 116 surgically excised neurilemomas were reviewed and compared with the corresponding histopathologic diagnoses made on surgical specimens and with clinical data. In addition, the utility of adjunctive techniques was analyzed and other spindle-cell lesions in the differential diagnoses were discussed. An unequivocal, benign diagnosis was rendered by FNAC in 80 cases, 67 of which were correctly labelled as neurilemoma in a review of the original cytology reports. There were 6 false-positive malignant diagnoses while 23 smears were considered insufficient and 7 inconclusive as to whether benign or malignant. On reevaluation, the diagnostic smears in most cases contained spindle cells with wavy nuclei embedded in a fibrillar, occasionally collagenous, and/or myxoid matrix and Antoni A/Antoni B tissue fragments. A moderate to abundant admixture of round to oval cells was also frequent. Nuclear palisading was seen in 41 smears with distinctive Verocay bodies in 10. Markedly pleomorphic nuclei were seen in smears from 8 ancient and 6 conventional neurilemomas, and slight to moderate nuclear pleomorphism was observed in 38 additional cases. Thus most neurilemomas have distinct cytomorphologic features that allow correct diagnosis. The major problem in FNAC of neurilemoma is to obtain sufficient material. Furthermore aspirates showing predominantly Antoni A features, nuclear pleomorphism, and/or myxoid changes can easily be confused with other types of benign or malignant soft-tissue tumors.

Fine needle aspiration biopsy of gastrointestinal stromal tumor presenting as an umbilical mass (Sister Mary Joseph's Nodule)

The Sister Mary Joseph (SMJ) nodule is a clinical sign of metastatic cancer involving the umbilicus. The vast majority of these instances represent adenocarcinomas arising from ovarian or colorectal primaries. We present a patient who presented with ascites and the SMJ lesion that turned out to be a metastatic gastrointestinal stromal tumor after fine needle aspiration biopsy was performed. The lesion was subsequently histologically confirmed. Gastrointestinal stroma tumor involving the umbilicus is exceedingly uncommon and only rarely presents in this fashion. The cytomorphological features, differential diagnosis, and comparison with the tissue specimen are made.

Primary intravascular synovial sarcoma: A disease of young adult women? report of a case diagnosed by aspiration biopsy and review of the literature

Intravascular synovial sarcoma (IVSS) is an extremely rare tumor with only four well-documented cases in the English literature. All tumors were located in large veins of the lower extremities or trunk in young women except for one case occurring in a 54-yr-old woman. We report here an additional case of IVSS arising from the superior vena cava in a 32-yr-old woman who presented with a cervical mass and superior vena cava syndrome. A fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) was performed and showed a malignant biphasic tumor with spindle cell and epithelioid components. The tumor cells were negative for CD31, CD34, factor VIII, desmin, smooth muscle actin, and S-100 protein, and had positive staining for vimentin and cytokeratin (AE1/AE3) predominantly in the spindle and epithelial components, respectively. A diagnosis of synovial sarcoma was made and confirmed in a subsequent transvascular biopsy demonstrating chromosomal translocation t(X, 18) by fluorescence in situ hybridization using a dual color, break-apart-style probe for SYT. Although clinically similar to previously reported IVSS, this is the first case arising in large veins of the upper portion of the trunk and diagnosed by FNAB.

Monophasic synovial sarcoma: a cytologic spectrum

Synovial sarcoma (SS) is a high-grade sarcoma that can be diagnosed in cytology with certainty only when it presents with a biphasic pattern. Monophasic SS (MSS), however, is a diagnostic consideration when a uniform spindle cell population is present. The purpose of this study was to evaluate a series of cytologic cases of MSS and its cytologic presentation. Twenty-one FNAs of histologically confirmed MSS were reviewed. Specimens consisted of tissue fragments and single cells containing scant granular cytoplasm, medium-sized nuclei, and coarse chromatin. A monotonous spindle pattern with comma-shaped nuclei was present in 5 cases. Sixteen cases contained oval and spindled nuclei. Eight of these specimens contained round nuclei, and 5 of these cases showed prominent nucleoli and cohesive clusters, reminiscent of biphasic SS. We conclude that a spectrum of cytologic findings can be seen in MSS, including a secondary population of cells with morphology usually typical of biphasic SS.

Cytohistologic correlations in 56 synovial sarcomas in 36 patients: the Institut Curie experience

Synovial sarcoma (SS) is a high-grade malignant soft tissue tumor that manifests different phenotypic subtypes that may render their cytologic evaluation challenging. Although several cytologic studies of SS have been published, correlative studies of cytologic and corresponding histologic features are limited. To better define the cytological features of various SS forms, we reviewed the cytologic and the corresponding histologic material of 56 tumors from 36 patients. Classical patterns were defined as dispersed or small clusters of cells with bland chromatin, inconspicuous nucleoli, oval to spindle-shaped cytoplasm and branching tumor tissue fragments, vessel stalks, acinar structures in scant mucin background, seen in all 53 (94.7%) cellular cases. Epithelial, squamous, round cells, mast cells, necrosis, comma-like nuclei, marked nuclear atypia, secretory mucin, and rosette-like structures were also occasionally observed. Comparing the histological subtype we noted that epithelial cells and secretory mucin were restricted to biphasic SS, round cells to poorly differentiated SS, and comma-like nuclei to monophasic fibrous SS. We conclude that the classical pattern is highly suggestive of SS of all three monophasic, biphasic, or poorly differentiated subtypes. These characteristics, along with molecular genetic studies, may improve the cytologic diagnosis of SS.

Fine-needle aspiration cytology of articular and periarticular lesions

BACKGROUND

The cytologic diagnosis of joint and articular surface-based lesions traditionally has been accomplished by examination of fluids or effusions. Although exfoliative cytology remains an accurate diagnostic test, not all joint-based lesions will produce effusions that are amenable to this type of examination. Fine-needle aspiration (FNA) represents an excellent alternative to traditional cytologic or histologic methods of diagnosis in joint pathology.

METHODS

The authors reviewed FNA materials for the period 1992-2001 from lesions of joint spaces and periarticular soft tissues. All diagnoses based on cytologic materials that were included in this study were confirmed with histologic follow-up. Cytologic and histologic materials were prepared using standard methods.

RESULTS

The authors found six relatively common lesions that were amenable to diagnosis by FNA. These included rheumatoid nodule, gouty tophi, ganglion cysts, pigmented villonodular synovitis, synovial chondromatosis, and synovial sarcoma. There are potential pitfalls in discriminating gout from pseudogout and synovial chondromatosis from chondrosarcoma.

CONCLUSIONS

In most instances, mass-producing lesions of the joint space or the periarticular soft tissues can be diagnosed successfully by FNA. The common lesions are easily recognizable and are cytologically distinctive.

Cytologic diagnosis of gastrointestinal stromal tumor with emphasis on the differential diagnosis with leiomyosarcoma

BACKGROUND

Gastrointestinal stromal tumor (GIST) has only recently been distinguished histologically and immunochemically from morphologically similar neoplasms of the abdomen.

METHODS

The authors reviewed 15 cytologic cases of GIST (14 fine-needle aspiration [FNA] specimens and 1 peritoneal fluid specimen) and compared them with 23 cases of leiomyosarcoma (LMS) arising in the abdomen or pelvis (all FNAs). Immunochemistry (IC) was performed on both the cytologic and subsequent tissue specimens if sufficient specimen was available.

RESULTS

Cytologic samples of GISTs typically showed irregularly outlined clusters of uniform spindle cells that were spread easily without crush artifact. The cells had wispy cytoplasm with long, delicate, filamentous extensions (13 cases; 87%). A prominent vascular pattern was common (9 cases; 60%); pleomorphism (1 case; 7%) was uncommon. The LMSs showed three-dimensional, tightly cohesive, sharply marginated syncytia of spindle cells, often with nuclear crush artifact. The cytoplasm/stroma had a distinct wiry, refractile appearance (21 cases; 91%); delicate filamentous cytoplasmic extensions (5 cases; 22%) and prominent vessels (3 cases; 13%) were less common. LMSs more commonly exhibited pleomorphism (14 cases; 61%). Epithelioid cytomorphology, mitoses, and necrosis occasionally were observed in both tumor types. IC for c-kit (on cytologic material) was positive in 10 of 10 cases of GIST (usually diffuse and strong) and 2 of 19 cases of LMS (focal). CD34 positivity favored GIST (4 of 9 cases) over LMS (1 of 19 cases). Smooth muscle actin was positive in 20 of 20 LMSs (strong and diffuse) and 6 of 10 GISTs (usually focal). Desmin was positive in 12 of 20 LMSs and was only focally positive in 1 of 11 GISTs. Correlation of IC results was excellent between cytologic and tissue specimens.

CONCLUSIONS

Delicate cytoplasmic processes; a prominent vascular pattern; a lack of nuclear pleomorphism; and a c-kit-positive, desmin-negative immunoprofile are characteristic features of GIST and help distinguish these tumors from LMS in cytologic specimens.

PNET-like features of synovial sarcoma of the lung: a pitfall in the cytologic diagnosis of soft-tissue tumors

Fine-needle aspiration (FNA) cytology of soft-tissue tumors is evolving. As more experience is gained, we are becoming aware of potential pitfalls. We describe 2 cases of synovial sarcoma of the lung, primary and metastatic, in patients who had FNA biopsy performed on a lung mass. The cytologic smears showed extremely cellular groups of malignant small round cells, intersected by small blood vessels, with numerous loose single cells, in a background of macrophages and mature lymphocytes. The tumors displayed monomorphic cells forming rosettes and displaying occasional mitoses. A diagnosis of neuroendocrine tumor/primitive neuroepithelial tumor (PNET) was suspected. Furthermore, this suspicion was supported by immunohistochemical stains, which showed positivity for a neuroendocrine marker, Leu 7 (case 1), and for a neural marker, CD 99 (O 13 or HBA 71) (both cases); and negativity for cytokeratins (case 1). The resection specimen of case 1 had mostly tightly packed small round cells, with occasional rosettes, similar to the FNA biopsy, and focal areas composed of spindle cells, organized in a focal fibrosarcoma-like and hemangiopericytoma-like pattern. A balanced translocation between chromosomes X and 18, demonstrated by both karyotyping and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH), enabled us to make a diagnosis of synovial sarcoma, which was histologically classified as poorly differentiated. Case 2 was a metastatic biphasic synovial sarcoma of the arm, with a prominent epithelial component. Synovial sarcoma, when composed mainly of small round cells on cytologic smears, is a great mimicker of neuroendocrine/PNET tumors, with light microscopic and immunohistochemical overlap. Awareness of this potential pitfall may aid in preventing a misdiagnosis. Its recognition is of major concern, especially for the poorly differentiated variant, because it is associated with a worse prognosis.