Sequence analysis and immunofluorescence study of alpha- and beta-tubulins in Reticulomyxa filosa: implications of the high degree of beta2-tubulin divergence

Molecular evidence for β-tubulin neofunctionalization in Retaria (Foraminifera and radiolarians)

Foraminifera and radiolarians are closely related amoeboid protists (i.e., retarians) often characterized by their shells and pseudopodia. Previous studies hypothesized that the unusual "Type 2" β-tubulin (β2) is critically involved in forming helical filaments (HFs), a unique microtubule (MT) assembly/disassembly intermediate found in foraminiferan reticulopodia. Such noncanonical β-tubulin sequences have also been found in two radiolarian species and appear to be closely related to the foraminiferan β2. In this study, we report 119 new β-tubulin transcript sequences from six foraminiferans, four radiolarians, and a related non-retarian species. We found that foraminiferan and radiolarian β2-tubulins share some of the unusual substitutions in the structurally essential and usually conserved domains. In the β-tubulin phylogeny, retarian β2-tubulin forms a monophyletic clade, well separated from the canonical β-tubulin (β1) ubiquitous in eukaryotes. Furthermore, we found that foraminiferan and radiolarian β2-tubulin lineages were under positive selection, and used homology models for foraminiferan α- and β-tubulin hexamers to understand the structural effect of the positively selected substitutions. We suggest that the positively selected substitutions play key roles in the transition of MT to HF by altering the lateral and longitudinal interactions between α- and β-tubulin heterodimers. Our results indicate that the unusual β2-tubulin is a molecular synapomorphy of retarians, and the β-tubulin gene duplication occurred before the divergence of Foraminifera and radiolarians. The duplicates have likely been subjected to neofunctionalization responsible for the unique MT to HF assembly/disassembly dynamics, and/or other unknown physiological processes in retarian protists.

Phylogeny and ultrastructure of Miliammina fusca: evidence for secondary loss of calcification in a Miliolid Foraminifer

The classification of the Foraminifera, a widely distributed group of largely marine protists, has traditionally been based on morphological characters. The most important of these are the composition and structure of the shell or "test." Here, we use both phylogenetic analysis of the genes for small subunit rRNA and beta-tubulin and ultrastructural analysis to document a reversion in wall type from more derived calcareous tests to an agglutinated test. These data indicate that the genus Miliammina, and possibly other members of the Rzehakinidae, should be placed in the Order Miliolida as opposed to their current assignment in Order Textulariida. We also address the effects this reversion may have had on the ability of rzehakinacids to effectively colonize marginal marine environments. Finally, the hypothesis that some multilocular agglutinated foraminiferans descended from calcareous lineages has implications for interpretation of the foraminiferal fossil record.

A close relationship between Cercozoa and Foraminifera supported by phylogenetic analyses based on combined amino acid sequences of three cytoskeletal proteins (actin, α-tubulin, and β-tubulin)

Recently, there has been increasing molecular evidence of phylogenetic affinity between Cercozoa and Foraminifera in the eukaryotic lineage. We performed phylogenetic analyses based on the combined (concatenated) amino acid sequence data of actin, alpha-tubulin, and beta-tubulin from a wide variety of eukaryotes, including the foraminifers Planoglabratella opercularis and Reticulomyxa filosa, as well as cercomonad and chlorarachniophyte members of Cercozoa. A monophyletic lineage composed of two foraminiferan species branched with the centroheliozoan species Raphidiophrys contractilis was reconstructed in both Bayesian and maximum-likelihood (ML) analyses under 'linked' models, enforcing a single set of the parameters (the parameter for among-site rate variation and branch lengths) on the entire combined alignment. Considering the extremely divergent nature of Foraminifera and Raphidiophyrs tubulins, the union of these lineages recovered is most probably a long-branch attraction artifact due to ignoring gene-specific evolutionary processes. On the other hand, the foraminiferan lineage was within the radiation of Cercozoa in Bayesian analyses under 'unlinked' model conditions, accommodating differences in evolutionary processes across the three genes in the combined alignment. The Foraminifera+Cercozoa affinity recovered in the latter multi-gene analyses is most likely genuine, and thus our data presented here provide further support for the close relationship between these two protist lineages.

Structural and functional implications of an unusual foraminiferal beta-tubulin

We have obtained sequence data for beta-tubulin genes from eight species of Foraminifera (forams) and alpha-tubulin sequences from four species, sampling major taxonomic groups from a wide range of environments. Analysis of the beta-tubulin sequences demonstrates that foram beta-tubulins possess the highest degree of divergence of any tubulin gene sequenced to date and represent a novel form of the protein. In contrast, foram alpha-tubulin genes resemble the conventional alpha-tubulins seen in other organisms. Partition homogeneity analysis shows that the foraminiferal beta-tubulin gene has followed an evolutionary path that is distinct from that of all other organisms. Our findings indicate that positive selective pressure occurred on the beta-tubulin subunit in ancestral forams prior to their diversification. The specific substitutions observed have implications for microtubule (MT) assembly dynamics. The regions most strongly affected are implicated in lateral contacts between protofilaments and in taxol binding. We predict that these changes strengthen lateral contacts between adjacent dimers in a manner similar to that induced by taxol binding, thus allowing the formation of the tubulin "helical filaments" observed in forams by electron microscopy. Our results also indicate that substantial changes to these portions of the beta-tubulin molecule can be made without sacrificing essential MT functions.

Evidence for a direct conversion between two tubulin polymers--microtubules and helical filaments--in the foraminiferan, Allogromia laticollaris

In Allogromia, tubulin lattices transform between microtubule and helical filament states. Helical filaments are composed of approximately 10-nm-thick tubulin filaments wound into approximately 30-nm diameter coils. The transition pathway between these two lattice states was examined in vitro in detergent-lysed pseudopods. Microtubules represented the majority of the assembled tubulin polymers in the detergent extracted pseudopodia. However, microtubules transformed into helical filaments upon exposure to 10 mM Ca2+ or 50 mM Mg2+. The conversion of microtubules into helical filaments involved fragmentation of the tubulin lattice and reduction in total polymer length. Divalent cations were required for the maintenance of the helical filament state; their removal resulted in the loss of helical filaments and the re-formation of microtubules. The data support a direct transition model in which the tubulin lattice interconverts between the helical filament and microtubule states, independently of tubulin subunit concentration. We propose a structural model for the direct pathway whereby disruption of longitudinal bonds between tandem tubulin dimers in protofilaments causes the microtubule lattice to unwind into helical filaments--continuous ribbons of laterally connected tubulin dimers--from the microtubule end. Helical filaments may rewind into microtubules as longitudinal intersubunit bonds reform.

Molecular evidence that Reticulomyxa filosa is a freshwater naked foraminifer

Reticulomyxa filosa is a freshwater protist possessing fine granular, branching and anastomosing pseudopodia and therefore traditionally placed in the class Granuloreticulosea, order Athalamida, as a sister group to the order Foraminiferida. Recent studies have revealed remarkable similarities in pseudopodial motility and ultrastructure between R. filosa and foraminifera (e.g. Allogromia laticollaris), prompting us to conduct a molecular phylogenetic analysis of these seemingly disparate organisms. We sequenced the complete small-subunit of the ribosomal DNA of the cultured strain of R. filosa and compared it to the corresponding sequences of other protists including 12 species of foraminifera. We also sequenced and analyzed the actin coding genes from R. filosa and two species of foraminifera, Allogromia sp. and Ammonia sp. The analysis of both data sets clearly shows that R. filosa branches within the clade of foraminifera, suggesting that R. filosa is in fact a freshwater naked foraminiferan.

Expression of Reticulomyxa filosa alpha- and beta-tubulins in Escherichia coli yields soluble and partially correctly folded material

Tubulins are highly conserved multidomain proteins that have to interact with eukaryotic chaperonins to gain their correct three-dimensional conformation. The prokaryotic chaperonin system of GroEL/ES is able to generate intermediate folding states but not natively folded tubulin. To create a system for studying these folding intermediates, tubulins from the giant amoeba Reticulomyxa filosa (alpha 2- and beta 2-tubulin) were expressed in Escherichia coli singly or in tandem. In all cases, soluble tubulin was generated in amounts of 5-10 mg/l culture. This is the first reported expression of soluble tubulin in bacterial cells. Of particular interest was the observation that upon coexpression with R. filosa beta 2-tubulin, proteolytic degradation of alpha 2-tubulin was reduced and more full-length product remained intact. This observation points to a specific interaction of alpha 2- and beta 2-tubulins in the E. coli cell. The sites of interaction are most probably the same that are responsible for the binding of native alpha 2- and beta 2-tubulin. The established expression system therefore seems well suited for further studies concerning the folding of tubulins.

Multiple forms of tubulin: different gene products and covalent modifications

Tubulin, the subunit protein of microtubules, is an alpha/beta heterodimer. In many organisms, both alpha and beta exist in numerous isotypic forms encoded by different genes. In addition, both alpha and beta undergo a variety of posttranslational covalent modifications, including acetylation, phosphorylation, detyrosylation, polyglutamylation, and polyglycylation. In this review the distribution and possible functional significance of the various forms of tubulin are discussed. In analyzing the differences among tubulin isotypes encoded by different genes, some appear to have no functional significance, some increase the overall adaptability of the organism to environmental challenges, and some appear to perform specific functions including formation of particular organelles and interactions with specific proteins. Purified isotypes also display different properties in vitro. Although the significance of all the covalent modification of tubulin is not fully understood, some of them may influence the stability of modified microtubules in vivo as well as interactions with certain proteins and may help to determine the functional role of microtubules in the cell. The review also discusses isotypes of gamma-tubulin and puts various forms of tubulin in an evolutionary context.

Expression of Reticulomyxa filosa tubulins in Pichia pastoris: regulation of tubulin pools

We expressed the alpha2- and beta2-tubulin isoforms of the giant freshwater amoeba Reticulomyxa filosa in the methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris. Single expression lead to little or no detectable material. Coexpression of both tubulins, however, resulted in a significant increase of expressed proteins. At the same time, the detectable internal tubulins of the host yeast cell were downregulated. This finding indicates the functionality of the expressed amoeba tubulins. Further regulation phenomena were observed on the level of equilibrium between the two R. filosa tubulin isoforms and on the level of the total tubulin pool. The P. pastoris/R. filosa system therefore seems to be an accessible system for the simultaneous study of the various mechanisms involved in tubulin regulation.