Genetics as a diagnostic tool in sarcomatoid renal-cell cancer

Morphologic manifestations of gene-specific molecular alterations ("genetic addictions") in mouse models of disease

Neoplasia in both animals and humans results in part from lasting activation of tumor-promoting genes ("oncogenes") or diminished function of genes responsible for preventing neoplastic induction ("tumor suppressor genes"). The concept of "genetic addiction" has emerged to indicate that neoplastic cells cannot maintain a malignant phenotype without sustained genotypic abnormalities related to aberrant activity of oncogene(s) and/or inactivity of tumor suppressor gene(s). Interestingly, some genetic abnormalities reliably produce distinct morphologic patterns that can be used as structural signatures indicating the presence of a specific molecular alteration. Examples of such consistent genetic/microanatomic pairings have been identified for mutated oncogenes, such as rising mucin-producing capacity with RAS overexpression, and mutated tumor suppressor genes-including PTEN eliciting cell hypertrophy, RB1 dictating neuroendocrine differentiation, and TRP53 encouraging sarcomatous transformation. Familiarity with the concept of genetic addiction, as well as the ability to recognize such regular genomic-phenotypic relationships, are of paramount importance for comparative pathologists who are engaged in phenotyping genetically engineered mice to help unravel genomic intricacies in both health and disease.

Advances and controversies in grading and staging of renal cell carcinoma

Despite the considerable progress made in our understanding of the pathogenesis, genetics, and pathology of renal cell carcinoma (RCC), difficulties remain relating to the prediction of clinical outcome for individual cases. Although there is evidence to show that high-grade tumors have a poorer prognosis when compared to those of low grade, debate remains regarding the predictive value of grading, especially for those tumors classified into the intermediate grades. Numerous composite morphologic and nuclear grading systems have been proposed for RCC and although that of the Fuhrman classification have achieved widespread usage, the validity of the grading criteria of this classification has been questioned. In addition, there are few studies that have attempted to validate the Fuhrman system for RCCs beyond that of the clear cell subtype. Recent studies have indicated that grading of papillary RCC should be based on nucleolar prominence alone and that the components of the Fuhrman grading classification do not provide prognostic information for chromophobe RCC. Independent of tumor grade, the prognostic importance of tumor stage for RCC is well recognized. The Union Internationale Contre le Cancer/American Joint Committee for Cancer Staging and End Results Reporting TNM staging system is now in its sixth edition (2002) and recent refinements have focused on defining size cut points that will identify apparently localized tumors that will develop recurrence and/or metastases despite attempted curative surgery. In parallel with these studies it has been shown that infiltration of the renal sinus is an important prognostic factor, being observed in almost all tumors >7 cm in diameter. Questions remain as to the appropriate stratification of regional extension of RCC, as defined in the T3 tumor-staging category. Recent modifications to this category have been suggested combining the level of infiltration of the venous outflow tract with the presence or absence of infiltration of the adrenal gland and/or perirenal fat. Similarly, the utility of classifying lymph node involvement by tumor is debated, although it is well recognized that lymph node infiltration is associated with a poor prognosis. Although the current TNM classification does provide useful prognostic information it would appear that further modifications are justified to enhance the predictive value of staging for RCC.

Origin of renal cell carcinomas

Cancer is a heritable disorder of somatic cells: environment and heredity are both important in the carcinogenic process. The primal force is the "two hits" of Knudson's hypothesis, which has proved true for many tumours, including renal cell carcinoma. Knudson et al. [1, 2] recognised that familial forms of cancer might hold the key to the identification of important regulatory elements known as tumour-suppressor genes. Their observations (i.e., that retinoblastoma tend to be multifocal in familial cases and unifocal in sporadic presentation) led them to propose a two-hit theory of carcinogenesis. Furthermore, Knudson postulated that patients with the familial form of the cancer would be born with one mutant allele and that all cells in that organ or tissue would be at risk, accounting for early onset and the multifocal nature of the disease. In contrast, sporadic tumours would develop only if a mutation occurred in both alleles within the same cell, and, as each event would be expected to occur with low frequency, most tumours would develop late in life and in a unifocal manner [3, 4]. The kidney is affected in a variety of inherited cancer syndromes. For most of them, both the oncogene/tumour-suppressor gene involved and the respective germline mutations have been identified. Each of the inherited syndromes predisposes to distinct types of renal carcinoma. Families with hereditary predisposition to cancer continue to provide a unique opportunity for the identification and characterisation of genes involved in carcinogenesis. A surprising number of genetic syndromes predispose to the development of renal cell carcinoma, and genes associated with five of these syndromes have been already identified: VHL, MET, FH, BHD and HRPT2. Few cancers have as many different types of genetic predisposition as renal cancer, although to date only a small proportion of renal cell cancers can be explained by genetic predisposition.

The evolution of collagen expression in sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma

The development of a sarcomatoid morphotype is recognized as an extreme form of dedifferentiation in renal cell carcinoma and is associated with a poor prognosis. Although sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma shows pronounced spindle cell morphology, clear cell renal cell carcinoma may show early spindle cell change with cellular elongation, and the prognostic significance of this is debated. To determine the relationship between sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma and clear cell renal cell carcinoma showing early spindle cell change, we have investigated collagen expression using immunohistochemistry in these 2 tumor types. Both sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma and early spindle cell change tumors showed pericellular interstitial expression of collagen types I and III, whereas sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma also showed cytoplasmic expression of these collagen types. Expression of these collagen types in typical clear cell renal cell carcinoma was, in occasional cases, limited to faint and patchy staining in a pericellular interstitial distribution. Tumor cells did not stain for collagen type IV in sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma, early spindle cell change, or typical clear cell renal cell carcinoma. In sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma, there was diffuse pericellular expression of collagen type V and patchy pericellular expression of collagen type VI, whereas early spindle cell change tumors showed patchy pericellular staining with antibodies to collagen type V. Collagen type VI expression in early spindle cell change was largely confined to the vascular adventitia and areas of scarring, although very occasional foci of faint interstitial staining were also seen. In typical clear cell renal cell carcinoma, staining of collagen types V and VI was limited to the vascular adventitia and foci of desmoplasia, whereas no staining of tumor cell cytoplasm were seen. This study has shown that collagen expression of sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma differs from that of early spindle cell change and provides validating evidence that these 2 morphotypes should not be considered together for classification purposes.

[Sarcomatoid carcinoma of the kidney: a case report]

Sarcomatoid carcinoma of the kidney is an uncommon tumor associated with a very poor prognosis. Because this tumor can be occasionally difficult to distinguish from renal sarcoma, immunohistochemistry and electronmicroscopy are sometimes necessary for diagnosis. Therapy is actually essentially surgical because if adjuvant therapies should follow radical nephrectomy, no standardized regimen has been at present defined.

Clinical significance of allelic loss of chromosome region 5q22.3 approximately q23.2 in nonpapillary renal cell carcinoma

To analyze the clinical significance of copy number gain and loss at chromosome region 5q21 approximately q23, 105 nonpapillary renal cell carcinomas (RCC) were examined by interphase cytogenetic analysis using the dual-color fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) technique. DNA probes for D5S23 (5p15.2), cCI5-243 (5q21.2 approximately q21.3), and cCI5-215 (5q22.3 approximately q23.2) were used, and the signals for cCI5-243 and cCI5-215 were compared with those for D5S23 as the numerical control. Aneusomy (three or more copies) of chromosome 5 was found in 22 tumors (21.0%). Aneusomy was significantly correlated with loss at 5q21 approximately q23, while disomy with gain at 5q21 approximately q23 (P<0.05). Aneusomy was also significantly related to poor disease-specific survival (P<0.01). Gain and loss at cCI5-243 were seen in 34 (32.4%) and 59 (56.2%) tumors, respectively, while gain and loss at cCI5-215 occurred in 55 (52.4%) and 45 (42.9%) cases, respectively. The frequency of gain at cCI5-215 was significantly correlated with a smaller tumor diameter (7 cm or less, P<0.05), while loss with a larger one (>7 cm, P<0.05). Both loss at cCI5-215 and aneusomy of chromosome 5 were significantly related to poor disease-specific survival (P<0.05). In conclusion, alterations of chromosome 5 (including allelic loss of 5q22.3 approximately q23.2) could be a useful genetic marker for predicting the patient prognosis of RCC.

Chromosome changes in sarcomatoid renal carcinomas are different from those in renal cell carcinomas

Sarcomatoid renal carcinoma (SRC) is an uncommon and highly malignant renal tumor with sarcomatous morphology or with both sarcomatous and carcinomatous components. The tumors are generally referred to as dedifferentiated or transformed renal cell carcinomas (RCC). Information on their genomic changes is scarce. Data from a cytogenetic study of four cases of SRC are presented in this article. Combined with a few other cases from the literature, it appears that genomic changes in most cases of SRC have little in common with those characterizing conventional RCC. Sarcomatoid transformation thus may occur occasionally in RCC without the characteristic chromosome changes but also, and perhaps more frequently, in a subgroup of RCC without the characteristic chromosome changes.

Evolving classification of renal cell neoplasia

The development of consensus classifications for renal epithelial neoplasia in 1996 and 1997 led to the recognition of renal adenoma, renal oncocytoma and metanephric adenoma/adenofibroma as benign tumors and conventional (clear cell) renal cell carcinoma (RCC), papillary RCC, chromophobe RCC and collecting duct carcinoma as malignant morphotypes. While the overwhelming majority of renal adenomas and metanephric adenomas are benign, malignant transformation of both types have been described and genetic predictors of malignant transformation are as yet unknown. The main groups of malignant renal tumors are associated with characteristic genetic changes; conventional RCC (-3p), papillary RCC (+7, +17, -Y), chromophobe RCC (hypodiploid). Recent studies have also shown focal loss of heterozygosity of 3p segments in papillary and chromophobe RCC, indicating that 3p mutations are not confined to the conventional RCC morphotype and suggesting the presence of an important tumor suppressor gene at this site. Sarcomatoid metaplasia may occur in any morphotype and this is associated with a poor prognosis. More recently additional varieties of conventional RCC (multilocular cystic RCC), collecting duct carcinoma (medullary renal carcinoma) and papillary RCC (Types 1 and 2), each showing a characteristic morphology, have been recognized.

Molecular cytogenetic characterization of early and late renal cell carcinomas in von Hippel-Lindau disease

Deletions of 3p25, gains of chromosomes 7 and 10, and isochromosome 17q are known cytogenetic aberrations in sporadic renal cell carcinoma (RCC). In addition, a majority of RCCs have loss of heterozygosity (LOH) of the Von Hippel-Lindau (VHL) gene located at chromosome band 3p25. Patients who inherit a germline mutation of the VHL gene can develop multifocal RCCs and other solid tumors, including malignancies of the pancreas, adrenal medulla, and brain. VHL tumors follow the two-hit model of tumorigenesis, as LOH of VHL, a classic tumor suppressor gene, is the critical event in the development of the neoplastic phenotype. In an attempt to define the cytogenetic aberrations from early tumors to late RCC further, we applied spectral karyotyping (SKY) to 23 renal tumors harvested from 6 unrelated VHL patients undergoing surgery. Cysts and low-grade solid lesions were near-diploid and contained 1-2 reciprocal translocations, dicentric chromosomes, and/or isochromosomes. A variety of sole numerical aberrations included gains of chromosomes 1, 2, 4, 7, 10, 13, 21, and the X chromosome, although no tumors had sole numerical losses. Three patients shared a breakpoint at 2p21-22, and three others shared a dicentric chromosome 9 or an isochromosome 9q. In contrast to the near-diploidy of the low-grade lesions, a high-grade lesion and its nodal metastasis were markedly aneuploid, revealed loss of VHL by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), and contained recurrent unbalanced translocations and losses of chromosome arms 2q, 3p, 4q, 9p, 14q, and 19p as demonstrated by comparative genomic hybridization (CGH). By combining SKY, CGH, and FISH of multiple tumors from the same VHL kidney, we have begun to identify chromosomal aberrations in the earliest stages of VHL-related renal cell tumors. Our current findings illustrate the cytogenetic heterogeneity of different VHL lesions from the same kidney, which supports the multiclonal origins of hereditary RCCs. Published 2001 Wiley-Liss, Inc.

Sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma of papillary origin. A case report and cytogenic evaluation

Sarcomatoid renal cell carcinoma (SRCC) is an aggressive tumor variant thought to arise predominantly from dedifferentiation of clear cell carcinoma. A few reports of SRCC associated with non-clear cell tumors led to the presumption that SRCC may arise from any renal cell carcinoma, although direct evidence of this is lacking. Cytogenetic studies on 3 previously documented SRCCs associated with papillary renal cancers showed either 3p deletions or absence of trisomy 7, 17 in the sarcomatoid tumors, suggesting origin from a coexistent clear cell tumor. The present case represents the first conclusive evidence of direct progression of non-clear cell carcinoma to SRCC with both tumor components containing multiple copies of chromosomes 7 and 17. Many genetic anomalies, including p53 mutations, frequently recognized in SRCC were not recognized in this case, highlighting the importance of cytogenetic evaluation of all SRCC. The patient is well and without evidence of tumor progression 1 year after surgery, and the sinister outlook of SRCC in association with clear cell carcinoma may not apply in SRCC of non-clear cell origin.

Sarcomatoid renal carcinoma: the final common dedifferentiation pathway of renal epithelial malignancies

Sarcomatoid renal carcinoma (SRC) is an aggressive neoplasm with an age and gender distribution similar to that of conventional (clear cell) renal cell carcinoma (RCC). Genetic and morphologic evidence indicates that the tumor results from de-differentiation of renal epithelial malignancy and associations with RCC, papillary renal carcinoma, chromophobe renal carcinoma and collecting duct carcinoma have been reported. The tumor is composed of sheets of malignant spindle cells that have immunohistochemical and ultrastructural features of both stromal and epithelial cells, and may contain myxoid areas containing osteoclast-like giant cells or pleomorphic sarcomatoid spindle cells resembling rhabdomyoblasts. Rare cases of osteogenic SRC have been described. The tumor shows marked proliferative activity in growth kinetic studies and is usually associated with a poor patient survival that is best predicted by staging.