Combination chemotherapy and radiotherapy for Hodgkin's disease

Chemotherapy, radiotherapy and combined modality for Hodgkin's disease, with emphasis on second cancer risk

BACKGROUND

Second malignancies (SM) are a major late effect of treatment for Hodgkin's disease (HD). Reliable comparisons of SM risk between alternative treatment strategies are lacking.

OBJECTIVES

Radiotherapy (RT), chemotherapy (CT) and combined chemo-radiotherapy (CRT) for newly-diagnosed Hodgkin's disease are compared with respect to SM risk, overall (OS) and progression-free (PFS) survival. Further, involved-field (IF-)RT is compared to extended-field (EF-)RT.

SEARCH STRATEGY

We searched the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register, PubMed, EMBASE, CancerLit, LILACS, relevant conference proceedings, trials lists and publications.

SELECTION CRITERIA

RCTs accruing 30+ patients and completing accrual before/during 2000, comparing at least two treatment modalities for newly-diagnosed HD.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Individual patient data were collected and assessed for data quality. Trialists submitted additional information concerning methods and data quality. Peto Odds Ratios (OR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated for OS, PFS and SM-free survival. Secondary acute leukemia (AL), non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) and solid tumours (ST) were also analysed separately.

MAIN RESULTS

37 trials (9312 patients) were analysed: 15 (3343) for RT vs. CRT, 16 (2861) for CT vs. CRT, 3 (415) for RT vs. CT and 10 (3221) for IF-RT vs. EF-RT.CRT was superior to RT in terms of OS (OR=0.76, CI=0.66 to 0.89, p=0.0004), PFS (OR=0.49, CI=0.43 to 0.56, p<0.0001) and SM (OR=0.78. CI=0.62 to 0.98, p=0.03). The superiority of CRT also applied to early and advanced stages (mainly IIIA) separately. Excess SM with RT is due mainly to ST and is apparently caused by greater need for salvage therapy after RT.CRT was superior to CT in terms of PFS (OR=77, CI 0.68 to 0.77, p<0.0001). OS was better with CRT for early stages only (OR=0.62, CI 0.44 to 0.88, p=0.006). SM risk was higher with CRT (OR=1.38, CI 1.00 to 1.89, p=0.05), although not significant for early stages alone. This effect, also seen in AL and ST separately, was due directly to first-line treatment. Data were insufficient to compare RT to CT.EF-RT was superior to IF-RT (each additional to CT in most trials) in terms of PFS (OR=81, CI 0.68 to 0.95, p=0.009) but not OS. No significant difference in SM was observed.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

CRT seems to be optimal for most early stage (I-II) HD patients. For advanced stages (III-IV), CRT better prevents progression/relapse but CT alone seems to cause less SM. RT alone gives a higher overall SM risk than CRT due to increased need for salvage therapy. Reduced SM risk after IF-RT instead of EF-RT could not be demonstrated. Due to the large number of studies excluded because no IPD were received, to the inclusion of many outdated treatments and to the limited amount of long-term data, one must be cautious in applying these results to current therapies.

Analysis of long-term outcomes of combined modality therapy for cutaneous T-cell lymphoma

BACKGROUND

Although cutaneous T-cell lymphoma (CTCL), including mycosis fungoides (MF) and Sézary syndrome, is often responsive to treatment, few current therapies increase survival or consistently induce durable remissions, especially in advanced disease.

OBJECTIVE

In an effort to improve treatment efficacy and outcome in CTCL, a combined modality protocol using 3 to 4 consecutive phases of therapy was initiated in 1987 at M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, Tex.

METHODS

During a period of 15 years between 1987 and 2001, 95 patients with early-stage (Ia-IIa, n = 50) and late-stage (IIb-IVb, n = 45) MF were treated with subcutaneous interferon-alpha and oral isotretinoin, followed by total-skin electron beam therapy, and long-term maintenance therapy with topical nitrogen mustard and interferon-alpha. Patients with late-stage (IIb-IVb) disease also received 6 cycles of combination chemotherapy before electron beam therapy.

RESULTS

Combined modality therapy yielded a response rate of 85% with a 60% complete response rate. Among 38 patients with early-stage disease and 18 patients with late-stage disease achieving complete response, 9 (24%) patients with early-stage MF and 3 (17%) patients with late-stage MF achieved sustained remissions lasting more than 5 years. The median disease-free survival (DFS) for early and late stages of disease was 62 and 7 months, with 5-year Kaplan-Meier estimated rates of 50% and 27%, respectively. Current median overall survival times on combined modality are 145 months for patients with early-stage disease and 36 months for those with late-stage disease. Death was attributable to CTCL disease in 17 (55%) of 31 cases. The Kaplan-Meier estimates for 5-year survival are 94% for early-stage and 35% for late-stage disease. Univariate survival analysis in this patient population reveals statistically significant associations of clinical stage with overall response rates (P =.02), DFS (P =.03), and overall survival (P <.0001); age with DFS (P =.001) and overall survival (P =.04); and T stage (P <.0001) and lactate dehydrogenase (P =.007) with overall survival. By multivariate analysis using a Cox proportional hazards model, only age was significantly associated with DFS (hazard ratio 2.9), and only stage with overall survival (hazard ratio 18.2).

CONCLUSION

This nonrandomized and uncontrolled CTCL study gives supportive evidence that this multiphased combined modality regimen is well tolerated and may yield higher response rates and DFS than total-skin electron beam therapy alone, but provides no evidence for a change in survival.

Treatment of cutaneous T cell lymphoma: current status and future directions

The treatment of cutaneous T cell lymphoma (CTCL), which includes mycosis fungoides and Sezary syndrome, has been in a state of continual change over recent decades, as new therapies are constantly emerging in the search for more effective treatments for the disease. However, prognosis and survival of patients with CTCL remains dependent upon overall clinical stage (stage IA-IVB) at presentation, as well as response to therapy. Past therapies have been limited by toxicity or the lack of consistently durable responses, and few treatments have been shown to actually alter survival, especially in the late stages of disease. Even aggressive chemotherapy has not been shown to improve overall survival compared to conservative sequential therapy in advanced disease, and adds the risk of immunosuppressive complications. Over the last decade, extracorporeal photopheresis has been the only single treatment that has been shown to improve survival in patients with Sezary syndrome, although its true efficacy and place in combination therapy remain unclear. Much of the focus of current research has been on combinations of skin-directed therapies and biological response modifiers, which improve response rates. The results of various trials over the years have also brought into favor the use of post-remission maintenance therapy with topical corticosteroids, topical mechlorethamine (nitrogen mustard), interferon-alpha, or phototherapy to prevent disease relapse. Recent novel developments in CTCL therapy include oral bexarotene, a retinoid X receptor-selective retinoid that has activity in all stages of CTCL, and the topical gel formulation of bexarotene, which plays a role in treating localized lesions. US Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved, oral systemic bexarotene has the advantage of a 48% overall response rate at a dosage of 300 mg/m(2)/day, and avoids immunosuppression and risk of central line and catheter-related infectious complications that are associated with other systemic therapies. Monitoring of triglycerides and use of concomitant lipid-lowering agents and thyroid replacement is required in most patients. Also recently FDA-approved, denileukin diftitox is the first of a novel class of fusion toxin proteins and is selective for interleukin-2R (CD25+) T cells, targeting the malignant T cell clones in CTCL. Denileukin diftitox is associated with capillary leak syndrome in 20 to 30% of patients, which may be ameliorated by hydration and corticosteroids. Higher response rates are possible by combining bexarotene with "statin" drugs and active CTCL therapies. Studies are being conducted on combining bexarotene and denileukin diftitox with other modalities. Biological response modifier therapies that are in current or future investigational trials include topical tazarotene, pegylated interferon, interleukin-2, and interleukin-12. At the forefront of systemic chemotherapy development, pegylated liposomal doxorubicin, gemcitabine, and pentostatin appear to have the greatest potential for success in CTCL therapy. Bone marrow transplantation, which is currently limited by the risk of graft-versus-host disease, offers the greatest potential for disease cure. Further developments for CTCL may include more selective immunomodulatory agents, vaccines, and monoclonal antibodies.

Extralymphatic Hodgkin's disease. Prognosis and response to therapy

Three hundred eighteen patients with pathologic stage IA and IB, IIA and IIB, and IIIA Hodgkin's disease who entered into Stanford University Medical Center randomized trials comparing radiation therapy alone to radiation therapy plus six cycles of adjuvant chemotherapy were evaluated. Of these, 54 patients had extralymphatic (E) lesions. There were five relapses among these patients (9 percent), not different from the 37 relapses among the remaining 264 patients (14 percent) with Hodgkin's disease confined to the lymphatic system. Actuarial survival and freedom from relapse were not significantly different for patients with or without extralymphatic disease. The survival of patients with extralymphatic disease was similar whether they received radiation therapy alone or radiation therapy plus chemotherapy.

Combined modality treatment of Hodgkin's disease confined to lymph nodes. Results eight years later

Eighty-seven patients with newly diagnosed Hodgkin's disease, pathologic stages IA, IIA, IIB and IIIA, were assigned at random to receive either extended field radiotherapy alone or that therapy followed by six cycles of MOPP (nitrogen mustard, Oncovin, procarbazine, prednisone) chemotherapy. Patients were entered into the study from January 1970 to January 1974. Patients were followed for a median of 69 + months from the end of all treatments. Patients whose disease was less than stage IIIA had a 31 per cent relapse rate with radiotherapy alone compared to a 6 per cent relapse rate with combined modality treatment (P = 0.04). No deaths from Hodgkin's disease have occurred in patients who received combined modality therapy, whereas 24 per cent of the patients who received radiotherapy alone have died with active disease. However, three patients with stage IIIA disease who were treated with both modalities have died from other causes (myocardial infarction, adenocarcinoma of lung, acute leukemia). Combined modality therapy of patients with early Hodgkin's disease may be superior to radiotherapy alone, especially for certain subgroups of patients discussed in detail.

Hodgkin's disease, stages I and II occurring below the diaphragm

Between February 12, 1968 and August 17, 1977, 473 consecutive patients with Hodgkin's disease were entered into protocol studies at Stanford University Medical Center (SUMC). 242 of these 473 patients were pathological Stage I or II; 223 patients had disease above the diaphragm and 19 patients had disease confined below the diaphragm. When compared to patients with disease above the diaphragm, patients with Hodgkin's disease below the diaphragm were more frequently male (74% vs. 53%, p = 0.14), were on the average older (40 vs. 27, p less than .005) and more frequently had the histologic subtype of mixed cellularity (32% vs. 12%, p = .04). There was no difference in either survival or relapse-free survival between patients with Hodgkin's disease above the diaphragm and patients with disease below the diaphragm receiving similar treatment plans.

Hodgkin's disease: radiotherapeutic management at a cancer oriented community hospital

Seventy-eight patients with Hodgkin's disease were treated with radiation therapy between July 1966 and July 1976 (30 Stage I, 28 Stage II, 20 Stage III). The mean follow-up period is greater than 5 years. 90% of Stage I, 86% of Stage II, 65% of Stage III, and 82% (64/78) of all patients are NED after radiotherapy alone. Since laparotomy option (1970) 89% (50/56) of patients are NED. Fourteen patients were failures. Chemotherapy "rescued" 6 of 14. Seven have died, 1 is alive with disease, and 1 died of leukemia. Absolute survival is 90% (70/78). Failures were more frequent in patients with unfavorable histological types (9/14), and Stage III disease, primarily IIIS+ or B category (7/14). Sites of failures were mainly extranodal, primarily lung (10/14) and bone (2/14), and are consistent with hematogenous dissemination. Laparotomy performed in 41 patients identified unsuspected splenic involvement in 9 cases (22%), but was a distinct failure in confirming most "small node" positive lymphangiograms. Two patients developed acute myelocytic leukemia, both while NED 5 years posttherapy. One patient had also received adjunctive MOPP. There has been no impairment in the quality of survival that could be directly attributed to radiotherapy.

Combined modality therapy of Hodgkin's disease: a report on the Stanford Trials

A total of 440 previously untreated patients with Hodgkin's disease have been treated on randomized clinical trials at Stanford University, testing the value of combined modality therapy. A group of 244 patients with stages I, II and III were treated between 1968 with radiotherapy alone or combined with adjuvant MOPP chemotherapy. The adjuvant MOPP significantly improves the initial freedom from relapse (FFR) duration but improvement in survival is only minimal and not yet significant. The ability to induce a second durable remission after initial treatment failure results in freedom from second relapse rates (FF2dR) which more closely parallel survival figures than FFR. Adjuvant MOPP cannot yet be recommended as a routine adjuvant in the radiation maanagement of Hodgkin's disease. A pilot trial of the role of radiation therapy in the chemotherapy management of stage IV patients does not indicate an advantage of the irradiation. Preliminary analyses of new treatment programs in 163 patients with all stages of disease treated between 1974--1977 indicate improved survival and FFR rates, the majority of patients receiving combined modality therapy. Only three patients have died and nine patients have relapsed during the three year period of these new trials.

MVPP chemotherapy combined with radiotherapy in the treatment of Hodgkin's disease in children

Thirty-four children with Hodgkin's disease were treated during the years 1969--75. After radiotherapy, 7--15 cycles of MVPP were given within 24--53 months. In order to avoid chronic leukopenia, leukocyte counts were made frequently during chemotherapy, and the drug doses adjusted accordingly. A complete remission was obtained in 32 of the 34 children. Two patients died because of progressive disease. Twelve of the 32 survivors have been followed for at least 5 years, and a further 12 for at least 3 years. Three children are still on chemotherapy, whereas the remaining 29 being followed are in continued complete remission.

Stages IIB and IIIB Hodgkin's disease. Results of combined modality treatment

Between April 1969, and December 1974, 23 IIB and 26 IIIB surgically staged patients with Hodgkin's disease were treated at the Joint Center for Radiation Therapy. Stage IIB patients received either mantle and para-aortic-splenic pedicle, or total modal irradiation (TNI) alone or with the addition of combination chemotherapy. Relapse-free survival is 83% and overall survival 88%. Eleven patients received combination chemotherapy in addition to mantle and para-aortic irradiation, and both the relapse-free and overall survival are 100%. Of the stage IIIB patients, seven received TNI alone with four relapses, and 19 were treated with TNI and MOPP with two relapses. These relapse rates are significantly different (p less than 0.05). The relapse-free and overall survival for all stage IIIB patients is 66% and 84% respectively. These data imply that irradiation alone is not adequate treatment for stage IIIB Hodgkin's disease, and that with the addition of combination chemotherapy both the disease-free and overall survival is similar to that of early stage Hodgkin's disease without systemic symptoms. The ideal management of stage IIB Hodgkin's disease is less certain; it is our plan to study the efficacy of combined modality treatment.

Combination chemotherapy of Hodgkin's disease in children

Forty-five children with advanced Hodgkin's disease (stages III and IV) received combination chemotherapy in three schedules: MOPP (mustargen, Oncovin, procarbazine, prednisolone); COPP (cyclophosphamide was substituted for mustargen); and CVPP (cyclophosphamide, vinblastine, procarbazine, prednisone). The results showed the efficacy of all drug combinations (93% complete and partial remissions). However, the superiority of the MOPP program in prolonging the duration of the complete remission rate was demonstrated. Of 29 patients who showed complete response, 24 continued in complete remission from 8 to 53 months (median duration, 21 months). The other five patients relapsed within 2 to 6 months. Thirty-six of the 45 treated patients are still alive after an average period of follow-up of 19 months. The nine patients who died were followed for an average of seven months. The histologic type, prior chemotherapy, and the age of the patients influenced the results of treatment. The role of maintenance therapy is not discussed in this series

Long term remissions with combined modality therapy for advanced Hodgkin's disease

A new treatment program for advanced Hodgkin's disease employing five-drug combination chemotherapy and low dose radiation to the sites of bulk disease (nodal or parenchymal) was designed in 1969. Eighty patients have now been treated, 60 of whom have achieved a complete remission. More significantly, only 5 of the 60 completed responders have relapsed with follow-up from 1-6 years. The cumulative survival at 5 years of patients entering complete remission is 92%. For those patients not sustaining a complete remission, it is 19% at 2 years. This program has resulted in substantially lower relapse rates than previously reported by other investigators, probably because of the administration of radiotherapy in the manner described. Hopefully, a significant number of these patients may be cured of their disease.

Improved survival in hodgkin's disease

All patients below the age of 66 whose Hodgkin's disease was treated at the Massachusetts General Hospital between July 1, 1965 and June 30, 1973 were analyzed. The patients were divided into an early group seen before November 1, 1968 and a later group seen after that date. Survival and survival without recurrence were calculated by the actuarial method of Berkson and Gage, and compared with figures obtained from a historical series seen at this institution between 1948 and 1964. In the most recent period (1969-1973), 87% of patients with all stages of Hodgkin's disease were alive five years after diagnosis, a remarkable improvement over the 65% survival of the 1965-1968 group and the 34% survival of the historical series. The excellent survival of the recent group was a result of improved management of patients with advanced disease (Stages III and IV), most plausibly attributed to better appreciation of the extent of disease by surgical staging and to the shift from total nodal irradiation to combination chemotherapy for initial treatment of these patients. Recurrence after irradiation was extremely uncommon in patients in Stage IA and IIA (lymphangiogram-negative, asymptomatic) subjected to aging laparotomy, while similarly staged and irradiated patients in Stages IB and IIB (lymphangiogram-negative, symptomatic) did much less well. Except for the surgically staged patients in Stages IA and IIA, the continuing high relapse rate indicates that five-year survival, even when relapse-free, is not synonymous with cure, and emphasizes the need for caution in predicting the ultimate cure rate with current therapy.

Testicular function after combination chemotherapy for Hodgkin's disease

Fertility was estimated by sperm counts and hormone assays in 8 patients treated for Hodgkin's disease with at least 6 courses of combination chemotherapy. This consisted of an alkylator (mechloretamine or cyclophosphamide), a vinca alkaloid (vinblastine or vincristine), procarbazine and prednisone. Azoospermia was found in 7 of the 8 patients on examination 12-29 months after termination of chemotherapy. In 1 patient semen quality improved gradually, and a sperm count of 5 mill/ml was found at 21 months. Serum FSH levels were increased in all but 1 patient who was, nevertheless, azoospermic. The levels of testosterone and LH were generally within normal limits. Thus, the germinal tissue is seriously damaged by this type of chemotherapy. The resulting infertility seems to be complete and of long duration. Partial recovery of spermatogenesis may, however, sometimes take place after prolonged unsustained remission.

[Intra- or Postoperative Chemoprophylaxis? (author's transl)]

The surgical cure rates for most operable cancers have remained unchanged over the past few decades despite progress in local treatment and "prophylactic" preor postoperative radiotherapy. Due to the limitations of primary and secondary prophylaxis (prevention and "early" diagnosis), tertiary prophylaxis (adjuvant chemotherapy to prevent relapse or dissemination) has aroused considerable interest in tumor management recently. Definite progress in prolongation of the postoperative tumorfree interval has been obtained in controlled studies of breast cancer, osteogenic sarcomas and other target neoplasms. Long-term chemoprophylaxis has proved to be more effective than peroperative short courses of chemotherapy.

The results of radiotherapy for Hodgkins' disease

The results of radiation therapy in 212 patients with stages I and II Hodgkin's disease treated between 1963 and 1973 show that approximately 60% remain disease-free following treatment. Multiple node involvement in stage II, particularly associated with infraclavicular node disease, is identified as a group where the relapse rate is high. This presentation is associated particularly with NS. In a group of 78 patients treated with radiotherapy following staging laparotomy and splenectomy approximately 80% remain in complete remission. The preliminary results of treatment in PS IIIa patients are substantially the same as those for PS I and II; the results of treatment for NS and MC disease are similar. The significance of involvement of the spleen is discussed. Although it is probable that Hodgkin's disease spreads to the spleen through the blood stream it is suggested that splenic involvement does not necessarily indicate that the involvement of other extralymphatic structures such as liver and marrow has occurred. However, when the nodes in the porta hepatis are involved splenic Hodgkin's disease may well be associated with an increased risk of occult hepatic infiltration.

Radiation enteritis in children. A retrospective review, clinicopathologic correlation, and dietary management

The clinicopathologic features of radiation enteritis are reviewed in 44 children receiving whole abdominal radiation therapy between 1961-1972 at the Institut Gustave-Roussy. Five of 14 long-term survivors (36%) developed severe delayed radiation injury with small bowel obstruction, occurring within 2 months after completion of irradiation. All had previously had acute radiation reaction during therapy. Histologic appearance in the small bowel at the time of delayed radiation injury revealed severe villus blunting, lymphatic dilatation, and moderately dense inflammatory infiltrate. All patients with delayed radiation injury showed marked clinical improvement coincident with a fractionated low-residue, low-fat diet, free of gluten and free of milk and milk products. The abnormal small bowel roentgenographs and small bowel biopsies reverted to a normal appearance in association with the diet. No exacerbation of radiation enteritis has been seen following dietary therapy.

A combined modality approach to the treatment of Hodgkin's disease. Preliminary results of a prospectively randomized clinical trial

Eighty-seven previously untreated patients with pathologic Stage IA, II (A or B), or IIIA Hodgkin's disease were randomized over a 48-month period to receive either megavoltage extended field radiotherapy alone or megavoltage radiotherapy limited to involved lymph node sites (including at least an upper mantle field) followed by combination chemotherapy with nitrogen mustard, vincristine, prednisone, and procarbazine (MOPP). Four patients (4.6%) failed to achieve remission with initial radiotherapy. Seventy-two evaluable patients have currently completed therapy. Ten of 41 patients achieving remission with radiation alone have relapsed, compared to only 1 of 31 receiving radiation plus chemotherapy. Seven patients have died, 3 of whom failed to achieve remission with initial radiotherapy. The other 4 had Stage IIIA disease treated with radiation alone. Severe myelosuppression occurred infrequently during chemotherapy, and neither serious infections nor second neoplasms have observed. Although these preliminary results are encouraging, longer followup is required to determine the ultimate effects of combined modality therapy on survival and long-term complications.

Hodgkin's disease in children. A retrospective analysis: 1958-73

One hundred nine children with Hodgkin's disease consecutively treated at The Princess Margaret Hospital, Toronto, during 1958-1973 are reviewed. Crude 5-year survival rates, regardless of stage, were 1958-64--50%; 1965-68--73%; and 1969-73--95%. The corresponding 5-year relapse-free rates were 19%, 20%, and 57%. This progressive improvement in results was associated with the sequential introduction of lymphography and laparotomy with splenectomy, the change from involved field to extended field irradiation, and the introduction of multiple agent chemotherapy, at first for generalized relapse and recently as elective initial therapy, combined with extended field irradiation for children in advanced stages.

The management of stages I, II, and III Hodgkin's disease with combined radiotherapy and chemotherapy

An analysis and progress report is presented of the randomized clinical trials testing the value of adjuvant MOPP chemotherapy with irradiation in the management of Hodgkin's disease. The 213 patients with Stages IA through IIIB have been followed for periods of up to 64 months. The chemotherapy controls the occult disease, resulting in significant improvement in disease-free survival (p = .002). Over-all survival is not yet affected, however, with combined 5-year survival results of 92% and 88% in the two groups. The treatment program is difficult but feasible. No increased incidence of second malignancies has been observed in this study group. It is premature to conclude that adjuvant MOPP chemotherapy is indicated in the radiation management of Hodgkin's disease.