Involved field radiation therapy for early stage Hodgkin's disease in children: preliminary results

The evolving role of radiation therapy in pediatric Hodgkin's disease

Identifying the optimal treatment of pediatric Hodgkin's disease has been at the forefront of clinical investigation in recent years. Results of a number of large clinical trials have driven paradigm shifts in how physicians approach this often curable disease. In an effort to balance the goals of maximizing survival while minimizing acute toxicities and late complications, the recommended indications, targets, doses and schedules of chemotherapy and radiation have and continue to evolve. Recent attempts to decrease the total volume of tissue receiving radiation without requiring a significant escalation in cytotoxic chemotherapy have shown promise in low, intermediate and high risk patients. Utilizing risk-adapted, response-based treatment, researchers hope to uncover a subpopulation that may not require previously considered standard treatment modalities.

Gonadal function in young patients successfully treated for Hodgkin disease

BACKGROUND

Gonadal function in pediatric and young adult survivors of Hodgkin disease is not very well defined. This study evaluates the outcome following the Multiple Drug Protocol (MDP) and the results are compared to the published experience.

PROCEDURE

Ovarian and testicular function was assessed in 65 patients (36 males) with Hodgkin disease in first or second complete remission after treatment with either radiation (RT, n = 13), chemotherapy (CT, n = 9), or both (n = 43). Chemotherapy consisted of six cycles of the MDP (doxorubicin, procarbazine, prednisone, vincristine, and cyclophosphamide). Median age at diagnosis was 13.1 years (range, 2.4-22.6) and median age at evaluation was 22.6 years (range, 15.1-33.7), which was 6.7 years (range, 2.0-19.8) after the completion of all treatments. For the purpose of analysis, patients were divided into three groups: group A, patients who received only RT that did not include the pelvis (8 females, 5 males); group B, patients who received CT but no pelvic RT (15 females, 25 males); and group C, patients who received CT plus pelvic RT (6 females, 6 males).

RESULTS

All patients progressed spontaneously through puberty and evaluable patients were found to be sexually mature (Tanner stage IV and V). Serum follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) was increased in 0/5, 13/25, and 5/6 and testicular volume was decreased in 1/3, 4/11, and 2/3 group A, B, and C male patients, respectively. Leydig cell dysfunction was uncommon; 91% and 88% of males had normal serum concentrations of luteinizing hormone (LH) and testosterone, respectively. FSH and LH were increased in 0/8, 3/15, and 2/6 group A, B, and C female patients, respectively, at last follow-up, indicating a 17% prevalence of ovarian dysfunction. Serial data in seven females whose initial levels of FSH/LH were elevated revealed normalization in four. Six females delivered eight normal children.

CONCLUSIONS

The majority of males who received CT +/- RT have evidence of germ cell dysfunction, while Leydig cell function is unaffected in most. In females, although abnormal function early after the end of treatment was observed, ovarian function remained or returned to normal in most young women. Thus, in females the results of hormone testing performed early after treatment may not be predictive of their eventual reproductive potential.

Growth and final height after treatment for childhood Hodgkin disease

PURPOSE

To evaluate in children the impact of contemporary treatment for Hodgkin disease on the pattern of growth and final height.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We studied 80 patients (54 males) aged <14 years at diagnosis, with newly diagnosed, pathologically confirmed Hodgkin disease, treated at a single institution. Forty six patients received chemotherapy (CT) + radiotherapy (RT), 23 patients received RT alone, and 11 patients received CT alone. Heights were obtained at diagnosis, at the end of treatment, 1, 2, and 3 years after the end of treatment and at attainment of final height. Heights were converted to age- and sex-adjusted SD scores (SDS).

RESULTS

There was a significant change in height SDS at the end of treatment compared to height SDS at diagnosis for all three groups (CT + RT: -0.33, p<0.001; RT: +0.09, p=0.027; CT: -0.24, p=0.012). Over the 3 years following treatment, the rate of change of height SDS was not statistically different between the three treatment groups. Final height SDS was decreased for patients receiving RT + CT (-0.41 SDS, p=0.02; n=31). The change in final height SDS for patients receiving RT or CT only was -0.36 (n=14) and +0.42 (n=4), respectively. Loss of final height SDS correlated with younger age at diagnosis (p=0.005). Patients receiving higher RT doses tended to fare worse (p=0.08).

CONCLUSIONS

Pediatric patients treated for Hodgkin disease with the combination of RT and CT suffer a small but significant decrease in their final height SDS. Younger patients and those treated with higher RT doses appear to experience the greatest loss of height potential.

Hodgkin's disease in children in Kuwait

Between 1968 and 1981, 78 children younger than age 15 years were diagnosed, staged, treated, and followed up for a minimum period of 2 years. Most cases (64%) were in their first decade and the male-to-female ratio was 1.9:1. Mixed cellularity type occurred in 49% and nodular sclerosis in 32%. Lymphocytic depletion type was rare and occurred in only 4% of the cases. More than one half (53%) had Stages III and IV at presentation. The mediastinum was involved in 38%. The treatment of Stages I and II was mainly by radiotherapy, and Stages III and IV by combination of radiotherapy and chemotherapy. The total survival was 75% and relapse-free survival was 53%. Since 1975, lymphography became a routine investigation and staging laparotomy was performed in selected case. The mantle field was extended to include the para-aortic bar and spleen in Stage II with enlarged mediastinum, Stage IIIs after laparotomy, and cases in which laparotomy was thought to be indicated but was not performed. The new policy resulted in marked improvement in survival (from 56% to 87%) and relapse-free survival (from 32% to 70%). The stage at presentation was the main prognostic factor, although in the second period of the study, the difference between Stage I and II disappeared.

Involved field (IF) irradiation with or without chemotherapy in the management of children with Hodgkin's disease

The present policy at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center (MSKCC) of treating children with Hodgkin's disease [HD] is as follows: involved field (IF) irradiation only (3,600 rad) for Stages IA and IIA; IF irradiation (2,400 or 2,000 rad) combined with multidrug chemotherapy (MDP) protocol for all other stages. A somewhat higher recurrence rate is accepted for Stages IA and IIA in view of the good salvage rate for these recurrences and in view of side effects of more aggressive types of radiation treatment. One hundred forty-two patients with HD, 2-19 years of age, were treated at MSKCC between 1970 and 1981; 98 of these were treated according to the present policy (SP group), and 44 (NP group) were treated differently. All SP patients underwent staging laparotomy. The follow-up time was 12 to 146 months with a median of 65 months; two patients were lost to follow-up. For the SP group, all stages, 10-year disease-free survival is 77%, and 10-year survival is 93%. By comparison, in the NP group 10-year disease-free survival is 64%, and 10-year survival is 80%. The disease-free survival of SP patients in Stages IA and IIA treated with IF radiation alone is 72%, and survival is 95%. The disease-free survival of SP patients in advanced stages treated with combined radiation and chemotherapy is 87%; the salvage rate of recurrent disease in these stages is poor. The survival was apparently better (P = 0.07) in the SP group as compared to the NP group. All 6 patients of the SP group who died had a nodular sclerosing type of HD. None of the patients in the SP group have developed secondary malignancies, and no severe bone growth retardations or late effects to other organs were observed. In our opinion, IF irradiation alone might at present be suitable treatment for children in Stages IA and IIA of Hodgkin's disease, and addition of IF radiation with low doses of MPD improves the survival of patients in advanced stages.

An evaluation of long-term survival and treatment complications in children with Hodgkin's disease

Between April 1969 and July 1977, 83 patients, 16 years or younger, with pathologically staged IA-IIIB Hodgkin's disease were seen and treated at the Joint Center for Radiation Therapy. The five-year actuarial relapse-free and overall survivals were 82 and 95%, respectively, with a median follow-up from diagnosis of 65 months. Relapse occurred in 6/50 Stage IA-IIA, 2/9 Stage IIB, 4/9 Stage IIIA, and 3/15 Stage IIIB patients. Of patients who relapsed, 11/15 are currently disease-free following retreatment with chemotherapy. Nine patients with Stage IV disease were also evaluated. Four of seven patients initially treated with chemotherapy remain free of disease. Forty-two patients in this study were treated with mantle and para-aortic irradiation alone, thus avoiding the risk of sterility associated with pelvic irradiation or MOPP chemotherapy while retaining a high probability for long-term disease-free survival. Complications of radiation therapy included growth retardation and thyroid function abnormalities in some patients. Standing height measurements were normal regardless of age at initial treatment, however, 16 of 23 patients 3-12 years old at initial treatment had sitting heights measuring more than one standard deviation below the mean. Intraclavicular distances were shortened in some patients and examples are shown. Thyroid stimulating hormone levels were elevated in 21 of 37 patients evaluated. Radiation therapy, without adjuvant chemotherapy remains an important treatment approach for children with early stage Hodgkin's disease.

Management of stages I to III Hodgkin disease in children

Thirty-seven children, ages 4 through 16 years, presented with clinical stages I, II, or III Hodgkin disease. In nine (24%) patients, laparotomy and splenectomy resulted in a pathologic stage that varied from the clinical stage. Of 36 patients with pathologic stages I, II, and III, 26 have been followed for more than two years from diagnosis. Pathologic stages I and IIA disease were found in 21 patients, and 19 received radiation therapy alone (usually mantle-field), with 90% disease-free survival and 95% overall survival (median follow-up 46 months). Five patients had stage IIB disease; two had progression of disease while received combined modality therapy. Of ten patients with stage III disease, five have had relapses and five have remained in complete remission. All relapses occurred in patients receiving either irradiation or chemotherapy but not both. This experience supports extended-field irradiation alone as adequate treatment for stages 1 and IIA Hodgkin disease in children, but suggests that for stages IIB and III, single modality treatment is not adequate.