Hepatic artery ligation for liver metastasis in colorectal carcinoma

Treatment of Liver Metastases by Arterial Injection of Adriamycin/Mitomycin C Lipiodol Suspension

Sixty-one patients with liver metastases were treated with hepatic arterial injection of Adriamycin/Mitomycin C oil suspension (ADMOS). The liver metastases originated from the gastrointestinal tract in 41 patients and from other organs in 20 patients. Sixty-nine liver tumors were analyzed in these 61 patients. Computed tomography (CT) after ADMOS injection (Lip-CT) gave more information in 19 cases (31%) than enhanced CT with a water-soluble contrast medium. With Lip-CT, Lipiodol tumor enhancement was observed in 64 of 69 lesions. The patterns of Lipiodol uptake in the tumors were classified into 4 types: Homogeneous accumulation (20%), heterogeneous accumulation (16%); accumulation with a central defect (57%); and no accumulation (7%). A tumor response was achieved in 41 of 69 lesions (59%). Anticancer effects were also shown as a decrease in serum CEA levels. The one year survival rate estimated by the Kaplan-Meier method was 43 per cent and the median survival time was 337 days. The results were better among patients who received multiple doses of ADMOS. Only minimal side effects were associated with ADMOS. The method is considered to be an excellent diagnostic and therapeutic procedure for liver metastases.

Scanning electron microscopy study of the blood supply of human colorectal liver metastases

AIMS

The failure of hepatic artery directed treatment of colorectal liver metastases may reflect a major portal venous contribution to tumour blood supply. This study provides ultrastructural details of the blood supply of colorectal liver metastases and their association with the portal vein and hepatic artery.

METHODS

Resected liver specimens from six patients with colorectal liver metastases were examined by histology and scanning electron microscopy (SEM), following vascular resin casting.

RESULTS

Nine metastatic colorectal adenocarcinomas were identified. The main feature of all tumours on SEM was direct communication between hepatic sinusoids and tumour vessels. A direct portal venous connection with tumour vessels was observed in a single specimen, whilst a direct arteriole connection was not identified.

CONCLUSIONS

It appears that both the hepatic artery and portal vein contribute to the blood supply of colorectal liver metastases through sinusoidal connections with tumour specific blood vessels. SEM provides useful additional information on the morphological features of tumour vasculature.

Electrochemical lesions in the rat liver support its potential for treatment of liver tumors

BACKGROUND

An effective therapy is needed for patients with surgically unresectable liver tumors who have very limited life expectancy. One possible treatment is electrochemical tumor necrosis. This study investigated the natural history of electrochemical lesions in the normal rat liver.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A direct current generator, connected to platinum electrodes, was used to create controlled areas of liver necrosis. Animals were sacrificed 2 days, 2 weeks, 2 months, and 6 months after treatment and the macroscopic and histological appearance of the necrotic lesions was followed.

RESULTS

No animal died as a result of electrolysis; postoperatively, all gained weight normally. Liver enzymes were significantly (P < 0.001) elevated after treatment, but returned to normal after a week. Two days after electrolysis, histology confirmed an ellipsoidal area of coagulative necrosis at the site of the electrode tip and commonly a segment of peripheral necrosis. After 2 weeks there was histological evidence of healing. By 6 months, very little necrotic tissue remained within a small fibrous scar.

CONCLUSIONS

Electrolysis is a safe method for creating defined areas of liver necrosis that heal well with no associated mortality. This study supports the potential of electrolysis for treating patients with unresectable liver tumors.

Global approach to hepatic metastases from colorectal cancer: indication and outcome of intra-arterial chemotherapy and other hepatic-directed treatments

Liver metastases of colorectal cancer is present in more than 20% of new diagnosed patients and in 40-60% of relapsed patients. It is a life-threatening prognostic aspect. Hepatic resection, when possible, is the best therapeutic modality, although the overall survival rate is still low (30%). Angiography and intraoperative ultrasonography are useful for resection. The number of hepatic metastases and the surgical margin are probably the most significant prognostic factors. Colorectal cancer may spread predominantly to the liver making regional treatment strategies viable options. Subtotal hepatic resections and segmentectomies are potentially curable procedures for single or small numbers of hepatic metastases without other sites of disease. However, there have been no prospective randomized trials comparing patients with unresected liver metastases and resected metastases. Regional chemotherapy with floxuridine seems usefull combined with hepatic resection or as palliative therapy. Gastric ulcer and biliary sclerosis are the main related toxicities. Patients with localized, unresectable hepatic metastases or concomitant bad medical condition may be candidates for radiation, percutaneous ethanol injection, cryosurgery, percutaneous radiofrequency, hypoxic flow-stop perfusions with bioreductive alkylating agents, hepatic arterial ligation, embolization and chemoembolization. These new hepatic-directed modalities of treatment are being investigated and may offer new approaches to providing palliation and prolonging survival. This review will report the possibilities of intra-arterial chemotherapy and other novel hepatic-directed approaches to the treatment of liver metastases from colorectal cancer.

Surgical treatment of malignant liver tumours

Surgical resection is the mainstay of treatment for malignant liver tumours and offers the only chance of cure. Advances in radiological imaging, surgical technique and peri-operative management have enabled liver resection to be performed safely. Partial hepatectomy is indicated for the treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma and hepatic metastases from colorectal cancer. In addition, it may be utilized for selected patients with liver metastases from other primary tumours. Total hepatectomy with transplantation may be of benefit in some patients with unresectable neuroendocrine metastases or small hepatocellular carcinomas. The role of cryosurgery has not been precisely defined, and it needs to be compared with other palliative therapies such as ethanol injection and hepatic artery embolization.

Current treatment for colorectal cancer metastatic to the liver

Surgery is currently the only available treatment option which offers the potential for cure for patients with liver metastases from colorectal cancer. Of those who undergo a potentially curative operation for their primary tumour but subsequently recur, almost 80% will develop evidence of metastatic disease within the liver. Greater experience and improvements in technique in liver surgery, with an increasingly aggressive surgical approach to metastatic colorectal cancer to the liver, has resulted in prolonged disease-free survival with 5-year rates varying from 21% to 48%. In order to increase these numbers further and to treat patients not eligible for surgical therapy, new treatment modalities and strategies have been developed. This review presents an update of the current treatment for colorectal disease metastatic to the liver.

Treatment of colorectal liver metastases by cryotherapy

One hundred fifty-eight procedures were performed on 136 patients with unresectable hepatic metastases using hepatic cryotherapy to ablate the tumors. The median age was 62 years. Patients included 90 males and 46 females. Fifty-eight patients had synchronous metastases, 55 had bilobar lesions, and 90 had precryo chemotherapy. Median preoperative carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) level was 14.4 ng/dl. The numbers of lesions treated, frozen, and resected were two and one. Median survival of all patients was 30 months. Survival for 39 patients was 37 months. Patients with a CEA level > 100 ng/dl had a statistically worse survival rate than those with a level < 100 ng/dl (P < .001). Twenty patients underwent recryotherapy with median survival of 34 months. Recurrent disease developed in 78% of patients--82% of the patients developed liver recurrence. Complication rates were comparable to liver resection. Operative mortality was 3.7%. Hepatic cryotherapy is effective and safe in treating colorectal hepatic metastases under ultrasound guidance.

Management strategies for colorectal liver metastases--Part II

Liver metastases are relatively common in colorectal cancer and a small proportion of patients may benefit from resection of these liver metastases. In a selected subgroup of patients, 5-year survival rates of 25-35% may be achieved following liver resection. These survival figures compare favourably with those of patients with untreated liver secondaries. In the second part of this review the surgical and non-surgical treatment options for treating colorectal liver metastases are examined in detail.

The aetiology and management of hepatic metastases

Hepatic metastases are a common event in the metastatic spread of primary tumours and indicate advanced disease. However, the presence of hepatic metastases does not necessarily imply incurability; in selected patients resection of hepatic metastases may result in 5-year survival rates of 25-35%, usually in patients with colorectal liver metastases in whom solitary metastases are more frequent than with other primary tumours. However, hepatic metastases from Wilm's tumours, adrenal tumours, renal cell carcinoma, and neuroendocrine tumours may also be resected with similar success rates. A poor prognosis after resection of hepatic metastases is likely when there are more than three metastatic deposits, involved resection margins (often as a result of 'wedge' resections), when there is extrahepatic disease, or nodal involvement at the primary tumour site. Cyto-reductive procedures may provide excellent palliation and possibly long-term survival in selected patients with hepatic metastases unsuitable for resection. However, further study is required to establish the appropriate role for these treatments.

Treatment of colorectal cancer: hepatic metastasis

Almost one-third of patients dying from colorectal cancer have tumor limited to the liver. Systemic chemotherapy is the appropriate palliative management of patients with metastases to the liver and other sites. For many patients with isolated hepatic metastases, systemic chemotherapy is also the most appropriate treatment. However, results with systemic chemotherapy indicate that one-third or less of patients will respond to such treatments, and long-term survival is rare. In this report we provide information concerning the natural history of colorectal hepatic metastases, followed by the expected benefits with systemic chemotherapy. This information provides background for the regional therapeutic strategies of surgical resection, cryosurgery, and hepatic artery chemotherapy. We discuss the selection factors appropriate for such treatments, morbidity and mortality, and the potential long-term benefits of such approaches. The last section focuses on surgical considerations in hepatic resection and hepatic artery chemotherapy.

Arterial therapy of hepatic colorectal metastases

Considerable experience of the treatment of irresectable hepatic colorectal metastases has accumulated over the past three decades. In this review, the rationale for hepatic artery treatment of colorectal metastases to the liver is presented and various access techniques and chemotherapeutic agents for infusion are discussed. Randomized trials of hepatic artery chemotherapy (HAC) are analysed, and the promising results of recent studies combining less toxic and more effective agents are summarized. Continuous infusion pumps provide the most reliable and long-lasting access for HAC. Appropriate surgical techniques and medical management can minimize complications. Although tumour progression is best controlled by HAC, a clear-cut survival advantage has yet to be demonstrated. While hepatic artery infusion chemotherapy cannot yet be recommended outside investigational protocols, the experience gained so far should stimulate further studies.

Surgical options in the treatment of hepatic metastasis from colorectal cancer

Current data indicate that liver resection is the only available treatment that regularly produces long-term survival with possible cure in patients with metastatic colorectal carcinoma to the liver. Although a number of clinical or pathologic factors predicts a poor outcome, the only absolute contraindications to liver resection are general health incompatible with recovery from major hepatic resection or clear evidence of wide dissemination of disease. Important areas for future study include the potential role of adjuvant regional chemotherapy after resection and cryoablation of "close" margins. For patients with unresectable disease, operative therapy also plays an important role. Multiple operative modalities hold promise in palliative treatment in the setting of clinically incurable disease. It is imperative that a large randomized trial of regional chemotherapy be performed allowing no crossover and with mortality as an endpoint. Additionally, the role of cryoablation begs systematic investigation to ensure proper use of this modality.

Intraportal chemotherapy for colorectal hepatic metastases

One-third of colorectal cancer patients suffer from liver metastases on initial diagnosis. Overt liver metastases appear to be the first site of relapse for 40% to 50% of the patients with operable disease. The fact that tumor cells can be discovered in the mesenteric blood during surgery may indicate that circulating tumor cells give rise to metastases. Experimental investigations have shown that metastatic tumors reaching a diameter of 5 to 7 mm are predominantly perfused by the arterial route, which explains the unsuccessful attempts to treat established liver metastases through the portal vein. However, because metastases in the liver presumably arise via blood flow through the portal vein, adjuvant intraportal chemotherapy might permit ready access of the drug to small liver deposits in a way that systemic chemotherapy might not. The interest in portal adjuvant cytotoxic liver infusion in radically resected colorectal cancer patients is based on an early publication by Taylor, who in 1979 reported on a significant reduction of the incidence of liver metastases in a group of patients randomly assigned to perioperative adjuvant portal infusion with 5-fluorouracil. Based on these results, several groups initiated prospective randomized trials comparing intraportal infusion of various regimens to surgery alone. Results of most of these trials have been published during the last few years. All but one demonstrate improved overall survival and disease-free survival and a reduction of the incidence of liver recurrences in the adjuvant-treated patient group. Ongoing meta-analyses of the randomized trial data may confirm this tendency soon.

Chemotherapy in colorectal carcinoma

The use of chemotherapy in patients with colorectal carcinoma has changed considerably in recent years. New drugs, drug combinations, and innovative methods of administration are now available for the palliative treatment of patients with metastatic disease. Based on the results of recent clinical trials, adjuvant chemotherapy appears to prolong survival for certain patients who have undergone surgical resection of colorectal cancer. This review article includes a summary of pertinent medical literature and ongoing clinical trials, and provides treatment recommendations.

The therapeutic effect of OK-432-combined adoptive immunotherapy against liver metastases from gastric or colorectal cancers

Twenty-four patients with liver metastases from gastric or colorectal cancer were treated with OK-432-combined adoptive immunotherapy (AIT). Lymphocytes isolated from regional lymph nodes or peripheral blood were cultured with medium containing T cell growth factor and sonicated tumor extract antigen (SE-Ag) for 9-13 days. The cultured lymphocytes were transferred mainly through the hepatic artery after the administration of OK-432, a streptococcal preparation. Sixteen of the 24 patients received a low dose of anti-cancer agents between the OK-432 injection and cell transfer. When cultured without SE-Ag, regional lymph node lymphocytes (RLNL) showed significantly (P < 0.05) higher cytotoxic activity against autologous tumor cells and, on the contrary, lower cytotoxic activity against K562 than peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL). When cultured with SE-Ag, cytotoxicity of RLNL against autologous tumor cells was nearly equivalent to that of PBL. The blastogenesis of fresh PBL to SE-Ag was significantly (P < 0.05) augmented after the OK-432-combined AIT. Two patients showed complete response and 4 patients showed partial response among 19 patients who had evaluable lesions. Five patients whose liver metastases were resected were treated with OK-432-combined AIT as an adjuvant therapy. To date they are alive without recurrence in the liver.

Intermittent hepatic arterial or portal occlusion reduces liver tumor growth

The effect of repeated, intermittent hepatic vascular occlusion on liver tumor growth was studied in 32 rats. An adenocarcinoma was inoculated in the left liver lobe. After 8 days, the tumor size was measured and then, in three groups, the hepatic artery was occluded intermittently during 5 days for 15 min, 1 hr, or 2 hr daily, respectively. The tumor growth after 6 days in these groups was compared with that in a group where instead the portal vein was occluded intermittently during 5 days for 15 min, and with that in a group of sham-operated control rats. In the control rats, the tumor volume (mean +/- SEM) increased from 0.16 +/- 0.03 to 1.34 +/- 0.15 cm3 during the 6 days of experiment. It was found that repeated, intermittent occlusion of the hepatic artery or the portal vein, retarded the liver tumor growth to 30-60% of the growth rate in sham-operated controls (P less than or equal to 0.015). The 15-min daily hepatic artery or portal vein occlusion was found to reduce the tumor growth rate as much as daily hepatic artery occlusion for 2 hr. It is suggested that short, daily, intermittent hepatic vascular occlusions might be efficient in the palliative treatment of liver malignancy.

No treatment option for liver metastases from colorectal adenocarcinoma

After an explanation of alternative treatment modalities, 30 patients with unresectable liver metastases from colorectal adenocarcinoma chose to have no treatment. Fourteen patients (47 percent) had synchronous liver metastases and 16 (53 percent) had metachronous lesions. Thirteen of the 30 patients (43 percent) had histologic documentation of liver metastases, with the remaining 17 patients diagnosed by liver scan, ultrasonography, or computerized axial tomography. Twenty-four of 30 patients (80%) had less than 25 percent liver involvement (Stage I), 23 of 24 patients had alkaline phosphatase levels less than twice normal, and 20 of 24 patients were asymptomatic from their liver metastases. The remaining six patients had liver stages II or III at the time of diagnosis. Overall mean survival of the 30 reported patients with untreated metastatic colorectal cancer to liver is 16 months (range, 2 to 58 months; median survival, 12 months).

Regional treatment of hepatic metastases and hepatocellular carcinoma

Hepatic metastases represent a common site of dissemination for a number of primary malignancies related in part to the dual blood supply, large blood flow, and receptive environment of the hepatic parenchyma. Although this review focuses on regional therapy, we have included sections on systemic therapy to better interpret the results with intrahepatic therapy. We will also discuss the efficiency of hepatic arterial ligation, embolization, and radiotherapy of hepatic metastases. Primary gastrointestinal neoplasms are particularly prone to produce hepatic metastases. Because colorectal carcinoma metastasizes to the liver in up to 70% of patients with advanced disease, the treatment of hepatic metastases is a relevant topic. We will discuss the systemic and regional therapy of colorectal, gastric, and gallbladder cancers. Breast carcinoma and malignant melanoma frequently metastasize to the liver, and we have described systemic and regional treatments of these diseases. Because sarcomas are often treated by regional therapy, we have included a section on the treatment of hepatic sarcomas. Neuroendocrine tumors (carcinoid and islet cell), although often slow growing, frequently metastasize to the liver and then cause symptomatic problems. Much of the work done with embolization and hepatic ligation in the treatment of hepatic metastases has been performed in neuroendocrine tumors, and these studies, as well as the systemic and regional chemotherapy of hepatic metastases, will be described. The last section concerns the treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma. We have outlined the staging systems used. We then detail the results of systemic and intrahepatic therapy, embolization, and hepatic ligation in the treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma. Because hepatic metastases are a frequent problem, many patients are available for clinical investigation. It is hoped that newer strategies for the treatment of liver metastases will lead to higher response rates and perhaps control of local disease. These therapeutic approaches may also give us leads to the treatment of systemic disease.

Status of ischemic therapy for hepatic tumors

The use of hepatic artery ligation or permanent dearterialization as the sole procedure for the palliation of patients with malignant hepatic tumors has no proved value. The combination with cytotoxic drug administration via the portal route may offer some advantage. The use of transient dearterialization with one longer ischemic period has been successful in the treatment of metastatic carcinoid disease with carcinoid syndrome but ineffective in the treatment of other hepatic tumors. New knowledge of the effects of transient ischemia on the formation of arterial collaterals and the pathophysiologic mechanisms in cellular injury has led us to further refinement of this therapeutic principle. The first results of repeated short periods of ischemia are promising and give some hope for the future palliation of this group of tumor patients.

Effect on liver tumor growth in rats of allopurinol and 5-fluorouracil in combination with hepatic artery ligation

Rats with an experimental solitary liver tumor of a nitrosoguanidine-induced colonic adenocarcinoma were subjected to hepatic artery ligation (HAL) alone or in combination with 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) in three different doses, with or without the addition of allopurinol. The drugs were injected i.p. on 3 consecutive days before or after the HAL procedure. HAL alone significantly reduced the tumor growth compared with the control procedure (P less than 0.001). This observation was correlated with a significantly prolonged survival for the ligated animals (P less than 0.01). The administration of a low dose of 5-FU (15 mg/kg per day) in combination with allopurinol (100 mg/kg per day) enhanced tumor growth compared with that in animals treated with 5-FU only (P less than 0.01) or nontreated animals (P less than 0.05). A significant increase in survival was observed in animals given a high dose of 5-FU (60 mg/kg per day) after HAL compared with non-treated animals (P less than 0.001) as well as animals subjected to HAL alone (P less than 0.02). All animals receiving more than 15 mg/kg per day 5-FU before HAL succumbed within 10 days. The addition of allopurinol did not protect the animals against this mortality. These observations indicate that the effect of HAL followed by 5-FU is dose-dependent and that, at least in this treatment modality, allopurinol does not modulate the toxicity of 5-FU.

Regional chemotherapy of liver metastases from colorectal carcinoma: hepatic artery or portal vein infusion?

Hepatic artery infusion (HAI) chemotherapy has been well developed and is commonly used in the treatment of unresectable hepatic colorectal metastases. However, several important questions are unanswered, such as survival advantage over conventional systemic intravenous chemotherapy, long-term effects on the liver function, and prevention of complications, in particular cholangiosclerosis. Recent investigation into the blood supply of liver tumors challenges the adage that arterial flow is dominant. This review of the merits of regional HAI compared with portal venous infusion (PVI) chemotherapy shows a lack of conclusive data to favor either treatment modality, although a larger experience exists for HAI. Further studies need to be conducted.

Hepatic arterial infusion (HAI) chemotherapy proves to be advantageous in the treatment of experimental liver tumors

To evaluate the best locoregional approach in the treatment of hepatic tumors we investigated four different treatment modalities. Sixty female Sprague-Dawley rats were randomized to the following treatment groups: (1) untreated control; (2) hepatic artery ligation; (3) hepatic artery ligation plus portal 5-FU chemotherapy; (4) arterial 5-FU chemotherapy; (5) portal 5-FU chemotherapy. All animals received Novikoff hepatoma cells inoculated in the median liver lobe. After tumor inoculation animals were treated according to their randomization and surgery was performed for repeated tumor size measurements. Through hepatic artery ligation, hepatic artery ligation plus portal 5-FU infusion as well as through arterial 5-FU infusion a significant tumor growth inhibition compared to the untreated control could be achieved. The portal infusion group even showed an accelerated tumor growth; however, this effect was not significant. We conclude that the intraarterial application in terms of clinical feasibility and duration of response should be the preferred approach in locoregional therapy of liver malignancies.

Perfusion of colorectal hepatic metastases. Relative distribution of flow from the hepatic artery and portal vein

The importance of portal circulation in the delivery of drugs and nutrients to colorectal hepatic metastases is controversial. Using 13N (nitrogen 13) amino acids and ammonia with dynamic gamma camera imaging, we demonstrate, for the first time in human beings, a quantitative advantage of hepatic artery compared with portal vein infusion. Eleven patients were studied by hepatic artery injection, five patients were studied by portal vein injection, and two patients had injections through both routes. Data collected from the liver for 10 minutes after rapid bolus injection of 13N L-glutamate, L-glutamine, or ammonia were compared with 99mTc (technetium) macroaggregated albumin (MAA) images produced after injection through the hepatic artery or portal vein at the same session. Tumor regions defined from 99mTc sulfur colloid scans were compared with nearby liver areas of similar thickness. For the 13N compounds, the area-normalized count rate at first pass maximum (Qmax) and the tissue extraction efficiency were computed. The tumor/liver Qmax ratios for MAA and 13N compounds were highly correlated. Both tumor and liver extracted more than 70% of the nitrogenous compounds. The tumor/liver Qmax ratios reflect the relative delivery of injected tracer per unit volume of tissue. After hepatic artery injection the Qmax ratio was 1.03 +/- 0.33 (mean +/- SD), significantly exceeding the Qmax ratio of 0.50 +/- 0.34 after portal vein injection (P less than 0.003). Therefore, more than twice as much of a nutrient substrate is delivered per volume of tumor relative to liver by the hepatic artery as by the portal vein; the high extraction efficiency demonstrates that the hepatic artery flow is nutritive; and the delivery of substance in solution (such as nutrients or drugs) to tumor and liver tissue correlates with the distribution of colloids such as macroaggregated albumin after hepatic arterial and portal venous injection.