Late relapse with nodular lymphoma after treatment for diffuse non-Hodgkin's lymphoma

Clinical Characteristics and Risk of Relapse for Patients with Stage I-II Diffuse Large B-cell Lymphoma Treated in First Line with Immunochemotherapy

Diffuse large b-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) is an aggressive and potentially curable lymphoma that presents itself as stage I–II in 30% of all cases. It is known that in these localized stages, 15–20% of patients treated without rituximab eventually relapse, but less data exist regarding rituximab era. We have analyzed clinico-pathological features and risk of relapse in 98 patients with I–II stage DLBCL in complete response (CR) or unconfirmed CR (CRu) after first-line treatment consisting of immunochemotherapy. Twelve patients (12.2%) eventually relapsed. Late relapse, more than two years after diagnosis, occurred in three patients, and early relapse, less than two years after diagnosis, was documented in nine patients. Median time from diagnosis to relapse was 0.61 years for patients with early relapse and 3.66 years for patients with late relapse. The second CR rate obtained was similar in the late and in early relapsing patients, being 33% versus 44% (p = 0.072), respectively. Three-year overall survival (OS) was 22% for early relapsing patients and 33% for late relapsing patients (p = 0.65). In conclusion, patients who are diagnosed with stage I-II DLBCL and achieve a CR/CRu with first line immunochemotherapy have a good prognosis. However, a proportion of patients relapse, and this is less frequent in patients treated with first line with immunochemotherapy. These patients have a poor prognosis.

Lymphoma recurrence 5 years or later following diffuse large B-cell lymphoma: clinical characteristics and outcome

PURPOSE Patients with diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL) usually relapse early following diagnosis but some relapses happen at 5 years or later. Few data exist regarding clinical characteristics and outcome of these patients. PATIENTS AND METHODS We performed a retrospective analysis of all patients from two centers in Lyon, France, between 1985 and 2003 who had a biopsy-proven relapse 5 years or later following diagnosis of DLBCL. All available biopsies were reviewed and immunohistochemistry was completed. Results Among 1,492 patients with DLBCL, 54 were eligible. At diagnosis, 63% of patients had stage I-II, 82% had low/low-intermediate International Prognostic Index (IPI) score, 65% had extranodal involvement, 24% had an indolent component associated with DLBCL, 57% had germinal center phenotype, and 43% had non-germinal center phenotype. Median time from diagnosis to relapse was 7.4 years (range, 5 to 20.5 years). At time of relapse, 83% had DLBCL histology, and 17% had indolent histology. Having an indolent component at diagnosis was associated with indolent histology at relapse (P = .028). Five-year event free-survival (EFS) was 17% for patients with DLBCL relapse and 61% for patients with indolent relapse (P = .027). Five-year overall survival was 27% for patients with DLBCL and 75% for patients with indolent relapse (P = .029). For DLBCL relapse, 3-year EFS was 56% versus 18% with autologous stem-cell transplantation or not, respectively (P = .0661). CONCLUSION Patients with DLBCL who had a late relapse usually had localized stage, favorable IPI score, and extranodal involvement at diagnosis. The outcome of patients with DLBCL at time of relapse remains poor, and aggressive treatment such as autologous stem-cell transplantation should be pursued whenever possible. Biopsy at relapse is essential because some patients relapse with indolent histology.

Risk of relapse and clinico-pathological features in 103 patients with diffuse large-cell lymphoma in complete response after first-line treatment

Patients with diffuse large-cell lymphoma (DLCL) achieve a complete response (CR) in most cases, but at least one-third of them eventually relapse. Such an event occurs most frequently within 2 yr from CR achievement. The aim of the present study was to analyse the risk and pattern of relapse of patients with DLCL in CR. One hundred and three patients with DLCL (53 male/50 female; median age: 55 yr) in CR after doxorubicin-containing first-line treatments were included in the study. Main clinicobiological characteristics at diagnosis and at relapse were analysed. Uni- and multivariate studies were performed. Forty-one patients (40%) eventually relapsed, in 27 cases within 2 yr from CR and 14 thereafter. Histological subtype was the same at diagnosis and at relapse in all the early relapsing patients and in 8 of 10 late relapsing patients with available biopsy. The most important variables at diagnosis for predicting relapse were advanced stage (p<0.01) and bone marrow infiltration (p=0.05), with stage (I-II vs. III-IV) (p=0.009; relative risk=2.28) being the only predictive variable in the multivariate analysis. No differences were found according to the treatment given. The second CR rate obtained in the late relapsing patients after salvage therapies was higher that in early relapsing (50% vs. 37%). Median survival from relapse was 1.4 yr for patients early relapsing and it was not achieved for those with late relapses (p=0.09). Late relapse is a quite common event in DLCL lymphomas, with those patients achieving more frequently a second CR and having better survival than early relapsed patients.

Advanced diffuse large-cell lymphoma treated with 12-week combination chemotherapy: natural history of relapse after initial complete response and prognostic variables defining outcome after relapse

PURPOSE

To define both the natural history of and prognostic factors affecting outcome post relapse from a complete response in advanced stage diffuse large-cell lymphoma.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A total of 468 patients aged 17-74 years received the 12-week duration chemotherapy regimens MACOP-B, VACOP-B and ACOP-12 between 1 April 1981 and 31 December 1995 for advanced stage diffuse large, mixed or immunoblastic lymphoma. Of these 402 entered a complete remission, 97 (24%) of whom subsequently relapsed. Initial staging data, follow-up, and relapse information were analyzed to define the natural history of relapse and also subjected to univariate and multivariate correlation with overall (OS) and failure free survival (FFS).

RESULTS

Eleven percent of the relapses were low grade. All other relapses were of intermediate grade with 75% occurring within the first two years, the remainder up until the eleventh year. Median and five-year OS from the time of relapse for intermediate grade relapse were 12 months and 20%; for FFS they were eight months and 18% respectively. Adverse independent factors, for both OS and FFS were: less than one year to relapse, decreasing performance status at relapse, and more than three nodal sites at relapse.

CONCLUSIONS

Low-grade relapse is not uncommon in patients who initially presented with diffuse large cell lymphoma. As the management of low- and intermediate grade disease is so different biopsy proof of the nature of the relapse is of value. The prognostic factors identified need to be taken into consideration when analyzing results from trials of secondary treatment so as to avoid erroneous conclusions about comparative treatment efficacy.