Artificial corneas versus donor corneas for repeat corneal transplants

Boston type I keratoprosthesis versus penetrating keratoplasty following a single failed corneal graft

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES

To compare long-term outcomes of the Boston type 1 keratoprosthesis (KPro) with penetrating keratoplasty (PKP) in patients with a failed first PKP.

SUBJECTS/METHODS

In this retrospective comparative case series, 48 eyes of 48 patients who underwent a second corneal replacement procedure after a first failed PKP at the Centre Hospitalier de l'Université de Montréal from 2008 to 2020 were included. Minimum follow-up duration was 5 years, and patients with keratoconus were excluded since such subjects are not candidates for KPro. Main outcome measures included best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA), postoperative complications, graft survival and subsequent interventions.

RESULTS

Mean follow-up was 6.4 years for PKP and 9.6 years for KPro (p < 0.001). Preoperative BCVA was better in PKP patients (means 1.67 vs 2.13, p = 0.041). Visual outcomes were similar between groups. KPro patients developed 0.263 complication per patient-year (ppy) compared to 0.245 ppy or PKP. The most common complications for PKP were corneal complications (0.088 ppy) and glaucoma worsening (0.041 ppy). In KPro, glaucoma worsening (0.046 ppy), vitreoretinal complications (0.042 ppy) and retroprosthetic membrane (0.042 ppy) were the most frequent. Graft failure (69.6 vs 20.0%, p < 0.001) and reoperation rates (56.5 vs 12.0%, p = 0.001) were significantly higher for PKP. Failure mainly resulted from decompensation or rejection in PKP, while all five failures in KPro were caused by melt and/or extrusion.

CONCLUSIONS

Both interventions showed similar visual outcomes. Complication profiles were different, with more posterior segment complications in the KPro group, and more corneal complications in the PKP group, often necessitating regraft.

Overview of Corneal Transplantation for the Nonophthalmologist

Corneal transplant is a procedure that aims to replace dysfunctional corneal tissue with a transparent graft and is one of the most widely performed transplant surgeries, but its public and professional awareness is low outside of ophthalmology. Corneal tissue consists of 5 major layers that serve to maintain its structural integrity and refractive shape: the epithelium, Bowman's layer, the stroma, Descemet's membrane, and the endothelium. Failure or irreversible damage to any layer of the cornea may be an indication for corneal transplant, and variants of this procedure may be full thickness or selectively lamellar. Complications related to corneal transplantation may occur anywhere from during surgery to years afterward, including rejection, dehiscence, cataract, and glaucoma. Complications should be managed by an ophthalmologist, but other physicians should be aware of prophylactic medications. Topical immunosuppressants and steroids are effective for preventing and treating rejection episodes, whereas there is little evidence to support the use of systemic immunosuppression. Eye protection is recommended for any corneal transplant recipient. Physicians should counsel patients on corneal donation, especially if outside the United States, where donor tissue is in short supply.

The treatment of end-stage corneal disease: penetrating keratoplasty compared with Boston type 1 keratoprosthesis

Penetrating keratoplasty (PKP) yields excellent results for restoring vision in end-stage corneal diseases. However, its success is limited to high-risk diseases such as aniridia, chemical burns, autoimmune corneal diseases, and herpetic eye disease. Boston type 1 keratoprosthesis (BKPro) offers another option to these patients. Since 1992, improvements in perioperative management and device construction have significantly increased the use of BKPro worldwide and challenged the therapeutic role of PKP in these patients. This review aims to evaluate BKPro's place in the treatment algorithm of these high-risk patients to assist surgeons' decision-making. PKP and BKPro are compared in three outcome categories: visual acuity, graft retention and failure, and complications profile. Special attention is given to comparing secondary BKPro versus repeated PKP as well as primary BKPro versus primary PKP. We conclude that secondary BKPro bears a better prognosis than repeated PKP in most high-risk patients. Similarly, primary BKPro likely confers improved outcomes over primary PKP in most high-risk recipients. However, current evidence is based on retrospective designs, and controlled prospective randomized trials are required to validate these conclusions.

Artificial Cornea: Past, Current, and Future Directions

Corneal diseases are a leading cause of blindness with an estimated 10 million patients diagnosed with bilateral corneal blindness worldwide. Corneal transplantation is highly successful in low-risk patients with corneal blindness but often fails those with high-risk indications such as recurrent or chronic inflammatory disorders, history of glaucoma and herpetic infections, and those with neovascularisation of the host bed. Moreover, the need for donor corneas greatly exceeds the supply, especially in disadvantaged countries. Therefore, artificial and bio-mimetic corneas have been investigated for patients with indications that result in keratoplasty failure. Two long-lasting keratoprostheses with different indications, the Boston type-1 keratoprostheses and osteo-odonto-keratoprostheses have been adapted to minimise complications that have arisen over time. However, both utilise either autologous tissue or an allograft cornea to increase biointegration. To step away from the need for donor material, synthetic keratoprostheses with soft skirts have been introduced to increase biointegration between the device and native tissue. The AlphaCor™, a synthetic polymer (PHEMA) hydrogel, addressed certain complications of the previous versions of keratoprostheses but resulted in stromal melting and optic deposition. Efforts are being made towards creating synthetic keratoprostheses that emulate native corneas by the inclusion of biomolecules that support enhanced biointegration of the implant while reducing stromal melting and optic deposition. The field continues to shift towards more advanced bioengineering approaches to form replacement corneas. Certain biomolecules such as collagen are being investigated to create corneal substitutes, which can be used as the basis for bio-inks in 3D corneal bioprinting. Alternatively, decellularised corneas from mammalian sources have shown potential in replicating both the corneal composition and fibril architecture. This review will discuss the limitations of keratoplasty, milestones in the history of artificial corneal development, advancements in current artificial corneas, and future possibilities in this field.

Preliminary Study on Fish Scale Collagen Lamellar Matrix as Artificial Cornea

To construct a novel artificial cornea biomaterial, a method to prepare collagen lamellar matrix was developed in this study using grass carp scales as raw materials. The relationship between the structure of fish scale collagen lamellar matrix and the optical and mechanical properties was analyzed, and co-culture of it and rat bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) was performed to preliminarily analyze the cellular compatibility of fish scale collagen lamellar matrix. The results show that the grass carp scales could be divided into base region, lateral region and parietal region according to the surface morphology. The inorganic calcium in the surface layer could be effectively removed by decalcification, and the decalcification rate could reach 99%. After etching treatment, homogeneous collagen lamellar matrix could be obtained. With the decalcification and etching treatment, the water content of the sample increased gradually, but the cross-linking treatment had no obvious effect on the water content of fish scale collagen lamellar matrix. Fish scale collagen lamellar matrix has good transparency, refractive index, mechanical properties and cellular compatibility, which may represent a prospect for the construction of cornea tissue engineering products.