The Implementation of a Return-to-Play Protocol with Standardized Physical Therapy Referrals in a Collegiate Football Program: PT's Role in Return-to-Play, A Clinical Commentary

Sport-related concussions (SRCs) are multi-faceted injuries requiring coordinated care for return-to-play (RTP). Although the number of concussions in collegiate football is increasing annually, there is poor standardization among RTP protocols. Recent evidence suggests there is an increased risk of lower extremity injury, neuropsychiatric consequences, and re-injury after SRC, and risk factors for a prolonged recovery from SRC have also been identified. Evidence demonstrates a faster RTP and improved outcomes with early physical therapy intervention; however, this is not yet common practice in the treatment of acute SRC. There is little guidance available on the development and implementation of a multidisciplinary RTP rehabilitation protocol for SRC that incorporates standardized physical therapy. By describing an evidence-based RTP protocol with standardized physical therapy management, and measures taken to implement this protocol, this clinical commentary aims to identify steps in treating SRC that can be used to improve recovery. The purpose of this commentary is to: a) survey the current state of standardization of RTP protocols in collegiate football; b) highlight the development and implementation of a RTP protocol with standardized physical therapy referral and management in an NCAA Division II collegiate football program; and c) describe results of a full-season pilot study, including time to evaluation, time to RTP, rate of re-injury or lower extremity injury, and the clinical significance of protocol implementation.

Level of Evidence

Level V.

Effects of two different dual-task training protocols on gait, balance, and cognitive function in community-dwelling older adults: a 24-week randomized controlled trial

Background

Although alternating dual-task (ADT) training is functionally easier for older adults, a large part of the motor and cognitive tasks is simultaneously performed, especially during activities of daily living that require maintaining body balance.

Objective

To evaluate the effects of mixed dual-task training on mobility, cognitive function, and balance in community-dwelling older adults.

Methods

Sixty participants were randomly allocated at a 1:1 ratio into the experimental group-single motor task (SMT) and simultaneous dual task (SDT) interchangeably in stage 1 (for 12 weeks) and after strictly with SDT in stage 2 (the last 12 weeks)-or into the control group-only SMT and SDT interchangeably in stages 1 and 2. Gait parameters were acquired by two inertial sensors. Physical and cognitive performance were acquired by specific questionnaires. Generalized linear mixed models were used for analyzing interaction and main effects.

Results

No between-group difference was observed for gait performance. Both protocols improved mobility (mean change ((MC) = 0.74)), dual-task effect (MC = -13.50), lower limb function (MC = 4.44), static (MC = -0.61), and dynamic balance (MC = -0.23), body sway (MC = 4.80), and cognitive function (MC = 41.69).

Conclusion

Both dual-task training protocols improved these outcomes.

Portable Electromyogram-sensitive System for Assessment of Fear of Fall: Relevance of Gait Phases for Post-Stroke Patients

Post-stroke patients often suffer from gait deficits along with Fear of Fall (FoF) that adversely affect their ambulation. The FoF has been reported to be negatively correlated with one's performance in daily life. Clinical scales, e.g., Falls Efficacy Scale are often used to assess one's FoF. Though powerful, it can suffer from subjectivity. Thus, it is important to have reliable assessment of FoF. Motivated by this, we used one's lower limb muscle activation during specific gait phases to assess one's FoF. For this, we developed a portable electromyogram-sensitive system that can synchronously measure one's muscle activation along with gait phases. We conducted an experimental study with post-stroke patients and age-matched healthy controls who walked under Dual-Task condition. We investigated the lower limb muscle (Gastrocnemius Lateralis (GM) and Tibialis Anterior (TA)) activation during Loading Response, Terminal Stance and Initial Swing phases of gait, associated with slips contributing to FoF. Results show that our system could quantify the disparity (∆) in muscle activation between the affected and unaffected sides of patients (∆ =  ∼ 84% during Loading response for both GM and TA, ~32%for GM during Terminal Stance and TA during Initial Swing) which was considerably higher than that between dominant and non-dominant sides of healthy controls. This might infer reduced dynamic stability of patients leading to their FoF. Also, muscle activation could classify patients from healthy controls with 90% accuracy during Loading Response and Initial Swing phases with clinical relevance in diagnostics and monitoring rehabilitation outcomes. Clinical Relevance- This study indicated that our system has potential to be utilized as a tool for diagnostic and monitoring rehabilitation outcomes as it can quantify the residual muscle ability of the post-stroke patients during gait.