Embryonic limb bud organ culture in assessment of teratogenicity of environmental agents

Alternative Tests for Teratogenicity

Summary

The major features of the tests surveyed are shown in Table I. In a tier system of tests for teratogenicity, the Chernoff test is at a different level than the other assays described here. It is not appropriate for screening large numbers of chemicals, but may be useful for studies of smaller groups of agents, for example to confirm data from a prescreen. Although the test is certainly easier, cheaper and uses less than half the animals of a Segment II test, it is still much more expensive and time-consuming than most alternative tests.

Of the remaining alternatives, whole embryos or organs in culture encompass the widest range of mammalian developmental events and are invaluable in the study of teratogenic mechanisms. They are, however, also inappropriate for screening large numbers of chemicals. The methods are technically demanding, relatively expensive and use reasonably large numbers of pregnant mammals. To screen a group of, say, 20 chemicals involves a considerable investment of time and, in fact, no study of this size has been reported. In certain specific circumstances, they may be a useful adjunt to testing; for example, if treated human serum samples are freely available, if a drug has a unique action on rodent dams which confounds evaluation of the standard in vivo tests, or if human metabolism is important and can be mimicked in vitro.

Sub-mammalian and sub-vertebrate species offer considerable advantages; reduced cost, relative rapidity and no requirement for laboratory animals. FETAX provides some indication of teratogenicity in relation to embryotoxicity, while CHEST and the planarian and Drosophila assays measure only teratogenic potential, or more strictly speaking, embryotoxic potential, although it should be possible to derive some assessment of hazard with each of the latter systems. The Hydra system is cheap, quick and easy and is commercially available. It is the only assay specifically designed to estimate teratogenic hazard and may offer considerable advantages as an alternative screen.

The metabolic cooperation assay has not generated sufficient data to enable evaluation. The neural crest cell assay is not well developed as a routine screen, and objective endpoints which are not measures of general cytotoxicity must be devised. The viral morphogenesis and Drosophila embryo cell assays have both produced encouraging validation data. With further assessment, the viral system may be shown to be useful, but it is a relatively complex assay and its relevance to teratogenesis is obscure. The Drosophila system is easier, has been used with more chemicals and is developmentally relevant. However, it has not produced dose-response data to evaluate potency or hazard, and must be improved so that it can more clearly distinguish cytotoxicity. The measurement of endpoints in the neuroblastoma cell line assay requires further refinement, and contributions of growth inhibition or stimulation to effects on differentiation must be examined. In combination, tumour cell attachment and HEPM may prove valuable. Alone, HEPM appears to be an assay for cellular toxicity, not teratogenicity, and the attachment assay suffers from a high rate of false negatives because it measures only one cell phenomenon. Although micromass cultures use mammalian tissue, are not the cheapest assays and require some skill for full evaluation of the results obtained, they show considerable promise. Validation data are encouraging, the assay includes several developmental processes and the use of multiple endpoints permits specific developmental toxicities to be evaluated.

Implications for the Predictivity of Cell-Based Developmental Toxicity Assays Developed Two Decades Apart

Many in vitro developmental toxicity assays have been proposed over several decades. Since the late 1980s, we have made intermittent attempts to introduce in vitro assays as screening tests for developmental toxicity of in-house candidate products. Two cell-based assays which were developed two decades apart were intensively studied. One was an assay of inhibitory effects on mouse ascites tumor cell attachment to a concanavalin A-coated plastic sheet surface (MOT assay), which we studied in the early days of assay development. The other was an assay of inhibitory effects on the differentiation of mouse embryonic stem cell to beating heart cells (EST assay), which we assessed more recently. We evaluated the suitability of the assays for screening in-house candidates. The concordance rates with in vivo developmental toxicity were at the 60% level. The EST assay classified chemicals that inhibited cell proliferation as embryo-toxic. Both assays had a significant false positive rate. The assays were generally considered unsuitable for screening the developmental toxicity of our candidate compounds. Recent test systems adopt advanced technologies. Despite such evolution of materials and methods, the concordance rates of the EST and MOT systems were similar. This may suggest that the fundamental predictivity of in vitro developmental toxicity assays has remained basically unchanged for decades. To improve their predictivity, in vitro developmental toxicity assays should be strictly based on elucidated pathogenetic mechanisms of developmental toxicity.

Organ culture of the fetal mouse palate for screening the developmental toxicity of chemicals: a validation study

Using in vitro organ culture of the fetal mouse palate in a chemically defined serumless medium, the toxicity of 24 chemical compounds was investigated. Explanted palates of day-12.5 mouse fetuses were exposed for 72 h in vitro to various concentrations of each chemical, and the fusion rate and growth parameters were compared between the experimental group and respective controls. The average rate of palate fusion was 84% in vehicle controls. For compounds that are teratogenic in experimental animals in vivo, the fusion rates of palatal shelves decreased as the concentration of the test chemicals increased, showing a dose-dependent relationship. Palate fusion was inhibited by 11 of the 15 in vivo teratogens, and the predictability of in vivo developmental toxicity in this culture system was 73%. Cyclophosphamide itself did not inhibit the growth and fusion of explanted palates, but supplementation of hepatic S-9 fraction and cofactors for a monooxygenase system converted it to a toxic substance, as was shown in other in vitro systems. The 50% inhibitory concentration (IC50) value calculated based on the fusion rate was also found to be a useful parameter for evaluating the developmental toxicity of drugs. The teratogenic risk in the human fetus could be assessed by comparing the minimal toxic concentrations of the test compound on cultured palates with the maximal plasma level in pregnant women under therapeutic conditions and with the plasma concentrations when its minimal teratogenic dose is given to pregnant mice. This organ culture system of the fetal palate should be useful for screening the developmental toxicity of drugs and other environmental agents, and its value should increase when it is used in combination with other battery test systems.

Chemically induced growth inhibition and cell cycle perturbations in cultures of differentiating rodent embryonic cells

Ethylnitrosourea (ENU) is a proven animal teratogen, although the mechanism of its developmental toxicity is unknown. The micromass rat embryo midbrain (CNS) and limb bud (LB) cultures were used in an effort to determine potential mechanisms by which ENU may exert its teratogenic effect. When cultured at high cell densities, both cell types undergo several rounds of replication while differentiating into discrete foci of neuronal cells and chondrocytes, respectively. Differentiation was monitored after 5 days by staining with hematoxylin (CNS) and alcian blue (LB). Our objectives were to (1) apply flow cytometry technology to the micromass cultures and (2) determine how ENU disrupts the normal growth, differentiation, and cell cycling of these cultures. Dose-dependent decreases in cell attachment and viability were observed in the first 24 hr after ENU exposure. Exposed cultures also exhibited dose-dependent growth inhibition over 5 days in culture as determined by cell counts. Flow cytometric cell cycle analysis of treated cultures revealed a dose-related accumulation of CNS cells in late G1/early S. Treated LB cells also displayed dose-related cell cycle changes with cells accumulating throughout the S phase. The concentration-dependent changes in both the CNS and the LB cell cycle profiles were observed in the attached cell populations which had greater than 94 +/- 3% viability at all ENU concentrations tested. This suggests that flow cytometric analysis allowed description of cellular alterations that would have been overlooked if only cell viability had been examined. Our examinations suggest that the effects of ENU on cell differentiation are related to its early effects on cell attachment, cell cycling, and cell proliferation.

Lung organoid culture

An organoid culture system for lung cells is described in which morphogenesis of lung histotypic structures and differentiation of both pneumocytes type II and mesenchyme occur. The principle of this technique is the culture of mouse fetal lung cells at high density on a membrane filter at the medium/air interface. In the course of cultivation, cell sorting-out, epithelial cell aggregation, formation of an alveolar-like lumen in the organoids and formation of a basal lamina occur. Epithelial differentiation culminates in the production of lamellar bodies, and the mesenchyme develops into mature connective tissue. Morphogenesis and differentiation depend on the stage of fetal development from which the lung cells were derived but appear independent of the formation of a basal lamina. Various drugs have been tested for their effects on morphogenesis and differentiation in this lung organoid culture: some of them inhibit differentiation or damage the mesenchyme, others stimulate surfactant production. Due to the quite complex morphogenetic and cellular events occurring in lung organoid culture, it may be an applicable tool for alternative in vitro screening methods.

Developmental effects of isotretinoin and 4-oxo-isotretinoin: the role of metabolism in teratogenicity

Previous observations have indicated that isotretinoin (IT), a drug in common use for therapy of cystic acne, is teratogenic in humans but possesses low embryotoxicity in pregnant mice, probably because of its shorter half-life and limited placental transfer in rodents. In human volunteers and patients, one major blood metabolite of IT is 4-oxo-isotretinoin (4-oxo-IT) which undergoes slower elimination than IT and may itself be a participant in teratogenesis. To investigate the problem of species differences displayed by IT and the role of its metabolism, embryotoxic effects of 4-oxo-IT were examined after its single or repeated intubations into pregnant ICR mice and compared with the effects of a similar regimen of IT. The two compounds were also tested for their relative ability to suppress chrondrogenesis in the in vitro cell and organ culture assays. We found that a single dose of 4-oxo-IT, 100 mg/kg, given on day 11 of gestation (plug day = day 0 of gestation) produced a moderate incidence of limb reduction defects and cleft palate (39% and 27% of surviving fetuses, respectively), while a dose of 150 mg/kg affected virtually every fetus. IT, on the other hand, produced no defects in fetuses exposed to similar dose levels. Repeated intubations with IT, however, resulted in increasing the frequencies of limb reduction defects and cleft palate to levels obtained after 4-oxo-IT administration. We found that a 3-hour interval between IT intubations was more effective in this regard than an 8-hour interval. Repeated IT intubations also uncovered sharper stage-dependency of limb and palatal defects than obtained otherwise.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Application of the preliminary developmental toxicity screen for chemical hazard identification under the Toxic Substances Control Act

The Office of Toxic Substances (OTS) within the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is authorized to carry forth the mandates of the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA). Included among the provisions of TSCA are the development of requirements for testing of "new" and "existing" chemicals that may present an unreasonable risk of injury to health or the environment. There are over 63,000 "existing" chemicals on the TSCA inventory, and EPA in recent years has been receiving an average of over 1,300 submissions for "new" chemicals a year. Since it is illogical and unrealistic to expect that all of these chemicals should be subjected to detailed testing for all potential adverse health and environmental effects, OTS views screening assays as highly useful tools to assign priorities to chemicals for further testing according to standard methodologies. The Chernoff/Kavlock assay (preliminary developmental toxicity screen) was specifically developed to address the need for a developmental toxicity assay to prioritize for further testing the large number of "new" and "existing" chemicals. OTS has been involved in seeking the development of data through the preliminary developmental toxicity screen for purposes of validating the screen and to obtain critical data necessary for evaluating chemicals. OTS believes that the screen has a role in the risk assessment process and has developed a testing protocol, which is included along with other OTS test guidelines; has provided internal guidance on when the screen may be recommended; and has discussed how the data may be applied in prioritizing chemicals for further study.

An in vitro test for teratogens: its practical application

An in vitro test for teratogens has been used successfully for more than 3 years. The method involves exposing undifferentiated rat embryo midbrain and limb cells to test compounds and observing the effect on subsequent cell differentiation. Experience of using the test has confirmed the accuracy of prediction (greater than 90%) suggested by a blind trial. The test has been used at the early stages of pharmacological evaluation in the selection of non-teratogenic pharmaceuticals and 250 compounds are tested on average each year. Maternal metabolism is modelled by the inclusion of Aroclor 1254-induced rat liver homogenate plus cofactors (S-9 mix). The concentrations of S-9 mix (50-100 microliters/ml culture medium) conventionally used in the Ames bacterial mutagenicity test are toxic to rat embryo cells, but greatly reduced concentrations (3-5 microliters/ml) are not toxic but are still able to activate pro-teratogens such as cyclophosphamide. However, most potentially teratogenic compounds tested are toxic in the absence of active preparations of drug-metabolizing enzymes. The conclusion that most teratogens are direct acting may be premature, since evidence has been found for drug-metabolizing activity in the embryo cells themselves.

Xenobiotic influences on embryonic differentiation, growth and morphology in vitro

Direct in vitro exposure of post-implantation rat embryos to 18 known teratogens induced typical malformations in all cases. Of 21 non-teratogens in vivo, 20 induced, in vitro either no malformations at all, even at high concentrations, or abnormal development could only be observed at concentrations which affected growth and differentiation significantly. Responses of chemically induced exposed embryos in vitro occurred within wide concentration ranges. Actinomycin D, for example, affected embryonic development at a concentration as low as 3 X 10(-4) micrograms/ml, whereas other substances had no effect at concentrations up to 9 X 10(2) micrograms/ml.

[Progress report. Possibilities and limitations of the in vitro technic for prenatal toxicologic studies]

Considering the variety of problems of the prenatal toxicity test the in vitro methods hitherto existing in this field are discussed according to their degree of complexity (cell culture, mass culture of dispersed cells, organ culture, whole embryo culture) within their limitations and possibilities. In this connection special attention is focussed to the use of human tissue for testing basic mechanisms of the developmental biology and for toxicity tests.

Toxic and teratogenic effects of chemical class fractions of a coal-gasification electrostatic precipitator tar

Dimethyl sulfoxide slurries of a coal gasifier electrostatic precipitator tar and its chemical class fractions were assayed for their toxicity and teratogenicity using early embryos of the frog Xenopus laevis. Of the 5 tar fractions the ether-soluble base and polyaromatic were found to be the most teratogenic and the ether-soluble acid and ether-soluble base were the most toxic. The teratogenic effects of the raw tar suggest synergism. The toxic effects to newly metamorphosed froglets is 1-2 orders of magnitude less than those observed for embryos. Chemical analysis shows dihydroxybenzenes and organonitrogen compounds to be the major components of the acid and base fractions, respectively. The neutral fractions contain mainly alkyl-substituted two-ring hydrocarbons.