Immobilization of actively thromboresistant assemblies on sterile blood-contacting surfaces

A rechargeable anti-thrombotic coating for blood-contacting devices

Despite the potential of anti-thrombogenic coatings, including heparinized surfaces, to improve the performance of blood-contacting devices, the inevitable deterioration of bioactivity remains an important factor in device failure and related thrombotic complications. As a consequence, the ability to restore the bioactivity of a surface coating after implantation of a blood-contacting device provides a potentially important strategy to enhance its clinical performance. Here, we report the regeneration of a multicomponent anti-thrombogenic coating through use of an evolved sortase A to mediate reversible transpeptidation. Both recombinant thrombomodulin and a chemoenzymatically synthesized ultra-low molecular weight heparin were repeatedly and selectively immobilized or removed in a sequential, alternating, or simultaneous manner. The generation of activated protein C (aPC) and inhibition of activated factor X (FXa) was consistent with the molecular composition of the surface. The fabrication of a rechargeable anti-thrombogenic surface was demonstrated on an expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) vascular graft with reconstitution of the surface bound coating 4 weeks after in vivo implantation in a rat model.

A dynamic remodeling bio-mimic extracellular matrix to reduce thrombotic and inflammatory complications of vascular implants

Thrombotic and inflammatory complications induced by vascular implants remain a challenge to treat cardiovascular disease due to the lack of self-adaption and functional integrity of implants. Inspired by the dynamic remodeling of the extracellular matrix (ECM), we constructed a bio-mimic ECM with a dual-layer nano-architecture on the implant surface to render the surface adaptive to inflammatory stimuli and remodelable possessing long-term anti-inflammatory and anti-thrombotic capability. The inner layer consists of PCL-PEG-PCL [triblock copolymer of polyethylene glycol and poly(ε-caprolactone)]/Au-heparin electrospun fibers encapsulated with indomethacin while the outer layer is composed of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) and ROS-responsive poly(2-(4-((2,6-dimethoxy-4-methylphenoxy)methyl)phenyl)-4,4,5,5-tetramethyl-1,3,2-dioxaborolane) (PBA) fibers. In response to acute inflammation after vascular injury, the outer layer reduces ROS rapidly by PBA degradation for inflammation suppression. The degraded outer layer facilitates inner layer reconstruction with enhanced hemocompatibility through the H-bond between PVA and PCL-PEG-PCL. Furthermore, chronic inflammation is effectively depressed with the sustained release of indomethacin from the inner layer. The substantial enhancement of the functional integrity of implants and reduction of thrombotic and inflammatory complications with the self-adaptive ECM are demonstrated both in vitro and in vivo. Our work paves a new way to develop long-term anti-thrombotic and anti-inflammatory implants with self-adaption and self-regulation properties.

Single and multi-functional coating strategies for enhancing the biocompatibility and tissue integration of blood-contacting medical implants

Device-associated clot formation and poor tissue integration are ongoing problems with permanent and temporary implantable medical devices. These complications lead to increased rates of mortality and morbidity and impose a burden on healthcare systems. In this review, we outline the current approaches for developing single and multi-functional surface coating techniques that aim to circumvent the limitations associated with existing blood-contacting medical devices. We focus on surface coatings that possess dual hemocompatibility and biofunctionality features and discuss their advantages and shortcomings to providing a biocompatible and biodynamic interface between the medical implant and blood. Lastly, we outline the newly developed surface modification techniques that use lubricant-infused coatings and discuss their unique potential and limitations in mitigating medical device-associated complications.

Regenerating Antithrombotic Surfaces through Nucleic Acid Displacement

Blood-contacting devices are commonly coated with antithrombotic agents to prevent clot formation and to extend the lifespan of the device. However, in vivo degradation of these bioactive surface agents ultimately limits device efficacy and longevity. Here, a regenerative antithrombotic catheter surface treatment is developed using oligodeoxynucleotide (ODN) toehold exchange. ODN strands modified to carry antithrombotic payloads can inhibit the thrombin enzyme when bound to a surface and exchange with rapid kinetics over multiple cycles, even while carrying large payloads. The surface-bound ODNs inhibit thrombin activity to significantly reduce fibrinogen cleavage and fibrin formation, and this effect is sustained after ODN exchange of the surface-bound strands with a fresh antithrombotic payload. This study presents a unique strategy for achieving a continuous antithrombotic state for blood-contacting devices using an ODN-based regeneration method.

The blood compatibility challenge. Part 4: Surface modification for hemocompatible materials: Passive and active approaches to guide blood-material interactions

Biomedical devices in the blood flow disturb the fine-tuned balance of pro- and anti-coagulant factors in blood and vessel wall. Numerous technologies have been suggested to reduce coagulant and inflammatory responses of the body towards the device material, ranging from camouflage effects to permanent activity and further to a responsive interaction with the host systems. However, not all types of modification are suitable for all types of medical products. This review has a focus on application-oriented considerations of hemocompatible surface fittings. Thus, passive versus bioactive modifications are discussed along with the control of protein adsorption, stability of the immobilization, and the type of bioactive substance, biological or synthetic. Further considerations are related to the target system, whether enzymes or cells should be addressed in arterial or venous system, or whether the blood vessel wall is addressed. Recent developments like feedback controlled or self-renewing systems for drug release or addressing cellular regulation pathways of blood platelets and endothelial cells are paradigms for a generation of blood contacting devices, which are hemocompatible by cooperation with the host system. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: This paper is part 4 of a series of 4 reviews discussing the problem of biomaterial associated thrombogenicity. The objective was to highlight features of broad agreement and provide commentary on those aspects of the problem that were subject to dispute. We hope that future investigators will update these reviews as new scholarship resolves the uncertainties of today.

Broadening the scope of sortagging

Sortases are enzymes occurring in the cell wall of Gram-positive bacteria. Sortase A (SrtA), the best studied sortase class, plays a key role in anchoring surface proteins with the recognition sequence LPXTG covalently to oligoglycine units of the bacterial cell wall. This unique transpeptidase activity renders SrtA attractive for various purposes and motivated researchers to study multiple in vivo and in vitro ligations in the last decades. This ligation technique is known as sortase-mediated ligation (SML) or sortagging and developed to a frequently used method in basic research. The advantages are manifold: extremely high substrate specificity, simple access to substrates and enzyme, robust nature and easy handling of sortase A. In addition to the ligation of two proteins or peptides, early studies already included at least one artificial (peptide equipped) substrate into sortagging reactions - which demonstrates the versatility and broad applicability of SML. Thus, SML is not only a biology-related technique, but has found prominence as a major interdisciplinary research tool. In this review, we provide an overview about the use of sortase A in interdisciplinary research, mainly for protein modification, synthesis of protein-polymer conjugates and immobilization of proteins on surfaces.

Animal models of cardiovascular disease as test beds of bioengineered vascular grafts

The last two decades have seen many advances in regenerative medicine, including the development of tissue engineered vessels (TEVs) for replacement of damaged or diseased arteries or veins. Biomaterials from natural sources as well as synthetic polymeric materials have been employed in engineering vascular grafts. Recently, cell-free grafts have become available opening new possibilities for the next generation, off-the-shelf products. These TEVs are first tested in small or large animal models, which are usually young and healthy. However, the majority of patients in need of vascular grafts are elderly and suffer from comorbidities that may complicate their response to the implants. Therefore, it is important to evaluate TEVs in animal models of vascular disease in order to increase their predictive value and learn how the disease microenvironment may affect the patency and remodeling of vascular grafts. Small animals with various disease phenotypes are readily available due to the availability of transgenic or gene knockout technologies and can be used to address mechanistic questions related to vascular grafting. On the other hand, large animal models with similar anatomy, hematology and thrombotic responses to humans have been utilized in a preclinical setting. We propose that large animal models with certain pathologies or age range may provide more clinically relevant platforms for testing TEVs and facilitate the clinical translation of tissue engineering technologies by increasing the likelihood of success in clinical trials.

Device thrombosis and pre-clinical blood flow models for assessing antithrombogenic efficacy of drug-device combinations

Thrombosis associated with blood-contacting devices is a complex process involving several component interactions that have eluded precise definition. Extensive investigations of individual biological modules such as protein adsorption, coagulation cascade activation and platelet activation/adhesion/aggregation have provided an initial foundation for developing biomaterials for blood-contacting devices, but a material that is intrinsically non-thrombogenic is yet to be developed. The well-recognized association between fluid dynamics parameters such as shear stress, vortices, stagnation and thrombotic processes such as platelet aggregation and coagulation aggravate thrombosis on most device geometries that elicit these flow disturbances. Thus, antithrombotic drugs that were developed to treat thrombosis associated with vascular diseases such as atherosclerosis have also been adapted to mitigate the risk of device thrombosis. However, balancing the risk of bleeding with the antithrombotic efficacy of these drugs continues to be a challenge, and surface modification of devices with these drug molecules to mitigate device thrombosis locally has been explored. Pre-clinical blood flow models to test the effectiveness of these drug-device combinations have also evolved and several in-vitro, ex-vivo, and in-vivo test configurations are available with their attendant merits and limitations. Despite considerable efforts toward iterative design and testing of blood contacting devices and antithrombogenic surface modifications, device thrombosis remains an unsolved problem.

Recent advances in covalent, site-specific protein immobilization

The properties of biosensors, biomedical implants, and other materials based on immobilized proteins greatly depend on the method employed to couple the protein molecules to their solid support. Covalent, site-specific immobilization strategies are robust and can provide the level of control that is desired in this kind of application. Recent advances include the use of enzymes, such as sortase A, to couple proteins in a site-specific manner to materials such as microbeads, glass, and hydrogels. Also, self-labeling tags such as the SNAP-tag can be employed. Last but not least, chemical approaches based on bioorthogonal reactions, like the azide-alkyne cycloaddition, have proven to be powerful tools. The lack of comparative studies and quantitative analysis of these immobilization methods hampers the selection process of the optimal strategy for a given application. However, besides immobilization efficiency, the freedom in selecting the site of conjugation and the size of the conjugation tag and the researcher's expertise regarding molecular biology and/or chemical techniques will be determining factors in this regard.

Enhancing the efficiency of sortase-mediated ligations through nickel-peptide complex formation

A modified sortase A recognition motif containing a masked Ni(2+)-binding peptide was employed to boost the efficiency of sortase-catalyzed ligation reactions. Deactivation of the Ni(2+)-binding peptide using a Ni(2+) additive improved reaction performance at low to equimolar ratios of the glycine amine nucleophile and sortase substrate. The success of this approach was demonstrated with both peptide and protein substrates.

In situ regeneration of bioactive coatings enabled by an evolved Staphylococcus aureus sortase A

Surface immobilization of bioactive molecules is a central paradigm in the design of implantable devices and biosensors with improved clinical performance capabilities. However, in vivo degradation or denaturation of surface constituents often limits the long-term performance of bioactive films. Here we demonstrate the capacity to repeatedly regenerate a covalently immobilized monomolecular thin film of bioactive molecules through a two-step stripping and recharging cycle. Reversible transpeptidation by a laboratory evolved Staphylococcus aureus sortase A (eSrtA) enabled the rapid immobilization of an anti-thrombogenic film in the presence of whole blood and permitted multiple cycles of film regeneration in vitro that preserved its biological activity. Moreover, eSrtA transpeptidation facilitated surface re-engineering of medical devices in situ after in vivo implantation through removal and restoration film constituents. These studies establish a rapid, orthogonal and reversible biochemical scheme to regenerate selective molecular constituents with the potential to extend the lifetime of bioactive films.

Bioactive coatings offer a strategy to modulate host response to implants, but their translation to the clinic is hampered by their fast in vivo degradation. Here, the authors use an engineered bacterial protein to regenerate an anti-thrombogenic film in vitro and in situ after device implantation.

Preparation of chain-end clickable recombinant protein and its bio-orthogonal modification

Introducing unique functional group into protein is an attractive approach for site-selective protein modification applications. In this report, we systemically investigated four site-selective strategies to introduce azide functionality into recombinant thrombomodulin (TM456), via direct recombinant expression with unnatural amino acid, chemical, and enzymatic modification for its bio-orthogonal modification application. First, a straightforward recombinant method to express TM456 with azide functionality near C-terminus by replacing methionine with azidohomoanlanine from methionine auxotroph Escherichia coli cell was investigated. Next, a sortase-mediated ligation (SML) method to incorporate azide functionality into the C-terminus of recombinant TM456 was demonstrated. The third is to add azide functionality to the N-terminal amine of recombinant TM456via amidation chemistry, and the fourth is tyrosine selective three-component Mannich reaction to introduce azide functionality to recombinant TM456. Overall, SML of recombinant protein affords the highest overall yield for incorporating azide functionality into the C-terminus recombinant TM456 since the key protein expression step uses natural amino acids. Also, single site modification facilitates the highest TM456 activity.

In vitro and ex vivo hemocompatibility of off-the-shelf modified poly(vinyl alcohol) vascular grafts

Synthetic small diameter vascular grafts with mechanical properties of native arteries, resistance to thrombosis and capacity to stimulate in situ endothelialization are an unmet clinical need. Poly(vinyl alcohol) hydrogel (PVA) is an excellent candidate as a vascular graft due to its tunable mechanical properties. However, the hydrophilicity and bio-inertness of PVA prevents endothelialization in vivo. We hypothesize that the modification of PVA with biomolecules and topographies creates a hemocompatible environment that also enhances bioactivity. PVA modified with fibronectin, RGDS peptide, cyclicRGD (cRGD) peptide, or heparin provided cell-adhesion motifs, which were confirmed by detection of nitrogen through X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. Protein- and peptide-modified surfaces showed a slight increase in human vascular endothelial cell proliferation over unmodified PVA. With the exception of fibronectin modification, modified surfaces showed in vitro hemocompatibility comparable with unmodified PVA. To further improve bioactivity, cRGD-PVA was combined with gratings and microlens topographies. Combined modifications of 2 μm gratings or convex topography and cRGD significantly improved human vascular endothelial cell viability on PVA. In vitro hemocompatibility testing showed that topography on cRGD-PVA did not significantly trigger an increase of platelet adhesion or activation compared with unpatterned PVA. Using the more physiologically relevant ex vivo hemocompatibility testing, all PVA grafts tested showed similar platelet adhesion to ePTFE and significantly lower platelet accumulation compared to collagen-coated ePTFE grafts. The biochemical and topographical modification of PVA demonstrates excellent hemocompatibility with enhanced bioactivity of PVA, thus highlighting its potential as a vascular graft.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

New synthetic small diameter vascular grafts with mechanical properties, blood-clot resistance and endothelial lining mimicking native arteries remains an unresolved critical clinical need. We aim to achieve this by modifying the mechanically-tunable poly(vinyl alcohol) hydrogel (PVA) vascular graft with both biochemical and biophysical cues in the lumenal surface. PVA modified with cyclic RGD peptide and ordered micrometer-sized topography showed low platelet adhesion in both a rabbit in vitro and baboon ex vivo blood compatibility assay. Modified PVA also exhibited significant enhancement of human vascular endothelial cell viability and proliferation in vitro. The readily available, modified PVA grafts are the first to show biophysical and biochemical modification in a three-dimensional scaffold with hemocompatibility, biofunctionality and excellent potential for clinical application.

Biomolecular strategies to modulate the macrophage response to implanted materials

The material-induced foreign body response is a major challenge for implanted medical devices. This review highlights recent developments in biomimetic approaches to create biomaterials that mitigate the host response to biomaterials. Specifically, we will describe strategies in which biomaterials are decorated with endogenously expressed biomolecules that naturally modulate the function of immune cells. These include molecules that directly bind to and interact with immune cells, as well as molecules that control complement activation or thrombosis and indirectly modulate immune cell function. We provide perspective on how these approaches may impact the design of materials for medical devices and tissue engineering.

Simulated Thrombin Generation in the Presence of Surface-Bound Heparin and Circulating Tissue Factor

An expanded computational model of surface induced thrombin generation was developed that includes hemodynamic effects, 22 biochemical reactions and 44 distinct chemical species. Surface binding of factors V, VIII, IX, and X was included in order to more accurately simulate the formation of the surface complexes tenase and prothrombinase. In order to model these reactions, the non-activated, activated and inactivated forms were all considered. This model was used to investigate the impact of surface bound heparin on thrombin generation with and without the additive effects of thrombomodulin (TM). In total, 104 heparin/TM pairings were evaluated (52 under venous conditions, 52 under arterial conditions), the results demonstrating the synergistic ability of heparin and TM to reduce thrombin generation. Additionally, the role of circulating tissue factor (TF(p)) was investigated and compared to that of surface-bound tissue factor (TF(s)). The numerical results suggest that circulating TF has the power to amplify thrombin generation once the coagulation cascade is already initiated by surface-bound TF. TF(p) concentrations as low as 0.01 nM were found to have a significant impact on total thrombin generation.

Methods for the directed evolution of proteins

Directed evolution has proved to be an effective strategy for improving or altering the activity of biomolecules for industrial, research and therapeutic applications. The evolution of proteins in the laboratory requires methods for generating genetic diversity and for identifying protein variants with desired properties. This Review describes some of the tools used to diversify genes, as well as informative examples of screening and selection methods that identify or isolate evolved proteins. We highlight recent cases in which directed evolution generated enzymatic activities and substrate specificities not known to exist in nature.

Engineering biomaterials surfaces to modulate the host response

Undesirable host response is responsible for the surface induced thrombus generation, activation of the complement system and the inflammatory reactions by the blood-contacting biomaterials. The surface interaction of biomaterials with different blood components is thought to be the critical factor that dictates the host response to biomaterials. Surface engineering can be utilized as a method to enhance the biocompatibility and tailor the biological response to biomaterials. This review provides a brief account of various polymer brush based approaches used for biomaterials surface modification, both passive and bioactive, to make the material surfaces biocompatible and antibacterial. Initially we discuss the utilization of polymer brushes with different structure and chemistry as a novel strategy to design the surface non-fouling that passively prevent the subsequent biological responses. Further we explore the utility of different bioactive agents including peptides, carbohydrates and proteins which can be conjugated the polymer brush to make the surface actively interact with the body and modulate the host response. A number of such avenues have also been explored in this review.

Flow-based enzymatic ligation by sortase A

Sortase-mediated ligation (sortagging) is a versatile, powerful strategy for protein modification. Because the sortase reaction reaches equilibrium, a large excess of polyglycine nucleophile is often employed to drive the reaction forward and suppress sortase-mediated side reactions. A flow-based sortagging platform employing immobilized sortase A within a microreactor was developed that permits efficient sortagging at low nucleophile concentrations. The platform was tested with several reaction partners and used to generate a protein bioconjugate inaccessible by solution-phase batch sortagging.