The Enigmatic Roles of PPR-SMR Proteins in Plants

DEFECTIVE KERNEL 56 functions in mitochondrial RNA editing and maize seed development

Proper seed development is essential for achieving grain production, successful seed germination, and seedling establishment in maize (Zea mays). In the past few decades, pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) proteins have been proven to play an essential role in regulating the development of maize kernels through posttranscriptional RNA modification of mitochondrial genes. However, the underlying mechanisms remain largely unknown. Here, we characterized a mutant of DEFECTIVE KERNEL 56 (DEK56) with defective kernels that exhibited arrested development of both the embryo and endosperm. Accordingly, we isolated DEK56 through a map-based cloning strategy and found that it encoded an E subgroup PPR protein located in the mitochondria. Dysfunction of DEK56 resulted in altered cytidine (C)-to-uridine (U) editing efficiency at 48 editing sites across 21 mitochondrial transcripts. Notably, the editing efficiency of the maturase-related (matR)-1124 site was substantially reduced or abolished in the dek56 mutant. Furthermore, we found that the splicing efficiency of NADH dehydrogenase subunit 4 (nad4) Introns 1 and 3 was substantially reduced in dek56 kernels, which might be a consequence of the defective MatR function. Through a protein-protein interaction test, we hypothesized that DEK56 carries out its function by recruiting the PPR-DYW protein PPR motif, coiled-coil, and DYW domain-containing protein 1 (PCW1). This interaction is facilitated by Multiple Organellar RNA Editing Factors (ZmMORFs) and Glutamine-Rich Protein 23 (ZmGRP23). Based on these findings, we developed a working model of PPR-mediated mitochondrial processing that plays an essential role in the development of maize kernels. The present study will further broaden our understanding of PPR-mediated seed development and provide a theoretical basis for maize improvement.

Interaction of PALE CRESS with PAP2/pTAC2 and PAP3/pTAC10 affects the accumulation of plastid-encoded RNA polymerase complexes in Arabidopsis

The transcription of photosynthesis genes in chloroplasts is largely mediated by the plastid-encoded RNA polymerase (PEP), which resembles prokaryotic-type RNA polymerases, but with plant-specific accessory subunits known as plastid transcriptionally active chromosome proteins (pTACs) or PEP-associated proteins (PAPs). However, whether additional factors are involved in the biogenesis of PEP complexes remains unknown. Here, we investigated the function of an essential gene, PALE CRESS (PAC), in the accumulation of PEP complexes in chloroplasts. We established that an Arabidopsis leaf variegation mutant, variegated 6-1 (var6-1), is a hypomorphic allele of PAC. Unexpectedly, we revealed that a fraction of VAR6/PAC is associated with thylakoid membranes, where it interacts with PEP complexes. The accumulation of PEP complexes is defective in both var6-1 and the null allele var6-2. Further protein interaction assays confirmed that VAR6/PAC interacts directly with the PAP2/pTAC2 and PAP3/pTAC10 subunits of PEP complexes. Moreover, we generated viable hypomorphic alleles of the essential gene PAP2/pTAC2, and revealed a genetic interaction between PAC and PAP2/pTAC2 in photosynthesis gene expression and PEP complex accumulation. Our findings establish that VAR6/PAC affects PEP complex accumulation through interactions with PAP2/pTAC2 and PAP3/pTAC10, and provide new insights into the accumulation of PEP and chloroplast development.

Intronic microRNA-directed regulation of mitochondrial reactive oxygen species enhances plant stress tolerance in Arabidopsis

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) play crucial roles in regulating plant development and stress responses. However, the functions and mechanism of intronic miRNAs in plants are poorly understood. This study reports a stress-responsive RNA splicing mechanism for intronic miR400 production, whereby miR400 modulates reactive oxygen species (ROS) accumulation and improves plant tolerance by downregulating its target expression. To monitor the intron splicing events, we used an intronic miR400 splicing-dependent luciferase transgenic line. Luciferase activity was observed to decrease after high cadmium concentration treatment due to the retention of the miR400-containing intron, which inhibited the production of mature miR400. Furthermore, we demonstrated that under Cd treatments, Pentatricopeptide Repeat Protein 1 (PPR1), the target of miR400, acts as a positive regulator by inducing ROS accumulation. Ppr1 mutation affected the Complex III activity in the electron transport chain and RNA editing of the mitochondrial gene ccmB. This study illustrates intron splicing as a key step in intronic miR400 production and highlights the function of intronic miRNAs as a 'signal transducer' in enhancing plant stress tolerance.

Tetrapyrrole biosynthesis pathway regulates plastid-to-nucleus signaling by controlling plastid gene expression in plants

Plastid-to-nucleus retrograde signaling coordinates nuclear gene expression with chloroplast developmental status and is essential for the photoautotrophic lifestyle of plants. Previous studies have established that tetrapyrrole biosynthesis (TPB) and plastid gene expression (PGE) play essential roles in plastid retrograde signaling during early chloroplast biogenesis; however, their functional relationship remains unknown. In this study, we generated a series of rice TPB-related gun (genome uncoupled) mutants and systematically analyzed their effects on nuclear and plastid gene expression under normal conditions or when subjected to treatments with norflurazon (NF; a noncompetitive inhibitor of carotenoid biosynthesis) and/or lincomycin (Lin; a specific inhibitor of plastid translation). We show that under NF treatment, expression of plastid-encoded polymerase (PEP)-transcribed genes is significantly reduced in the wild type but is derepressed in the TPB-related gun mutants. We further demonstrate that the derepressed expression of PEP-transcribed genes may be caused by increased expression of the PEP core subunit and nuclear-encoded sigma factors and by elevated copy numbers of plastid genome per haploid genome. In addition, we show that expression of photosynthesis-associated nuclear genes (PhANGs) and PEP-transcribed genes is correlated in the rice TPB-related gun mutants, with or without NF or Lin treatment. A similar correlation between PhANGs and PGE is also observed in the Arabidopsis gun4 and gun5 mutants. Moreover, we show that increased expression of PEP-transcribed plastid genes is necessary for the gun phenotype in NF-treated TPB-related gun mutants. Further, we provide evidence that these TPB-related GUN genes act upstream of GUN1 in the regulation of retrograde signaling. Taken together, our results suggest that the TPB-related GUN genes control retrograde plastid signaling by regulating the PGE-dependent retrograde signaling pathway.

The PPR-Domain Protein SOAR1 Regulates Salt Tolerance in Rice

Previous studies in Arabidopsis reported that the PPR protein SOAR1 plays critical roles in plant response to salt stress. In this study, we reported that expression of the Arabidopsis SOAR1 (AtSOAR1) in rice significantly enhanced salt tolerance at seedling growth stage and promoted grain productivity under salt stress without affecting plant productivity under non-stressful conditions. The transgenic rice lines expressing AtSOAR1 exhibited increased ABA sensitivity in ABA-induced inhibition of seedling growth, and showed altered transcription and splicing of numerous genes associated with salt stress, which may explain salt tolerance of the transgenic plants. Further, we overexpressed the homologous gene of SOAR1 in rice, OsSOAR1, and showed that transgenic plants overexpressing OsSOAR1 enhanced salt tolerance at seedling growth stage. Five salt- and other abiotic stress-induced SOAR1-like PPRs were also identified. These data showed that the SOAR1-like PPR proteins are positively involved in plant response to salt stress and may be used for crop improvement in rice under salinity conditions through transgenic manipulation.

The small PPR protein SPR2 interacts with PPR-SMR1 to facilitate the splicing of introns in maize mitochondria

Splicing of plant mitochondrial introns is facilitated by numerous nucleus-encoded protein factors. Although some splicing factors have been identified in plants, the mechanism underlying mitochondrial intron splicing remains largely unclear. In this study, we identified a small P-type pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) protein containing merely four PPR repeats, small PPR protein 2 (SPR2), which is required for the splicing of more than half of the introns in maize (Zea mays) mitochondria. Null mutations of Spr2 severely impair the splicing of 15 out of the 22 mitochondrial Group II introns, resulting in substantially decreased mature transcripts, which abolished the assembly and activity of mitochondrial complex I. Consequently, embryogenesis and endosperm development were arrested in the spr2 mutants. Yeast two-hybrid, luciferase complementation imaging, bimolecular fluorescence complementation, and semi-in vivo pull-down analyses indicated that SPR2 interacts with small MutS-related domain protein PPR-SMR1, both of which are required for the splicing of 13 introns. In addition, SPR2 and/or PPR-SMR1 interact with other splicing factors, including PPR proteins EMPTY PERICARP16, PPR14, and chloroplast RNA splicing and ribosome maturation (CRM) protein Zm-mCSF1, which participate in the splicing of specific intron(s) of the 13 introns. These results prompt us to propose that SPR2/PPR-SMR1 serves as the core component of a splicing complex and possibly exerts the splicing function through a dynamic interaction with specific substrate recognizing PPR proteins in mitochondria.

An Overview of Pentatricopeptide Repeat (PPR) Proteins in the Moss Physcomitrium patens and Their Role in Organellar Gene Expression

Pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) proteins are one type of helical repeat protein that are widespread in eukaryotes. In particular, there are several hundred PPR members in flowering plants. The majority of PPR proteins are localized in the plastids and mitochondria, where they play a crucial role in various aspects of RNA metabolism at the post-transcriptional and translational steps during gene expression. Among the early land plants, the moss Physcomitrium (formerly Physcomitrella) patens has at least 107 PPR protein-encoding genes, but most of their functions remain unclear. To elucidate the functions of PPR proteins, a reverse-genetics approach has been applied to P. patens. To date, the molecular functions of 22 PPR proteins were identified as essential factors required for either mRNA processing and stabilization, RNA splicing, or RNA editing. This review examines the P. patens PPR gene family and their current functional characterization. Similarities and a diversity of functions of PPR proteins between P. patens and flowering plants and their roles in the post-transcriptional regulation of organellar gene expression are discussed.

Transcriptome of Endophyte-Positive and Endophyte-Free Tall Fescue Under Field Stresses

Tall fescue is one of the primary sources of forage for livestock. It grows well in the marginal soils of the temperate zones. It hosts a fungal endophyte (Epichloë coenophiala), which helps the plants to tolerate abiotic and biotic stresses. The genomic and transcriptomic resources of tall fescue are very limited, due to a complex genetic background and outbreeding modes of pollination. The aim of this study was to identify differentially expressed genes (DEGs) in two tissues (pseudostem and leaf blade) between novel endophyte positive (E+) and endophyte-free (E-) Texoma MaxQ II tall fescue genotypes. Samples were collected at three diurnal time points: morning (7:40-9:00 am), afternoon (1:15-2:15 pm), and evening (4:45-5:45 pm) in the field environment. By exploring the transcriptional landscape via RNA-seq, for the first time, we generated 226,054 and 224,376 transcripts from E+ and E- tall fescue, respectively through de novo assembly. The upregulated transcripts were detected fewer than the downregulated ones in both tissues (S: 803 up and 878 down; L: 783 up and 846 down) under the freezing temperatures (-3.0-0.5°C) in the morning. Gene Ontology enrichment analysis identified 3 out of top 10 significant GO terms only in the morning samples. Metabolic pathway and biosynthesis of secondary metabolite genes showed lowest number of DEGs under morning freezing stress and highest number in evening cold condition. The 1,085 DEGs were only expressed under morning stress condition and, more importantly, the eight candidate orthologous genes of rice identified under morning freezing temperatures, including orthologs of rice phytochrome A, phytochrome C, and ethylene receptor genes, might be the possible route underlying cold tolerance in tall fescue.

CAF Proteins Help SOT1 Regulate the Stability of Chloroplast ndhA Transcripts

Protein-mediated RNA stabilization plays profound roles in chloroplast gene expression. Genetic studies have indicated that chloroplast ndhA transcripts, encoding a key subunit of the NADH dehydrogenase-like complex that mediates photosystem I cyclic electron transport and facilitates chlororespiration, are stabilized by PPR53 and its orthologs, but the underlying mechanisms are unclear. Here, we report that CHLOROPLAST RNA SPLICING 2 (CRS2)-ASSOCIATED FACTOR (CAF) proteins activate SUPPRESSOR OF THYLAKOID FORMATION 1 (SOT1), an ortholog of PPR53 in Arabidopsis thaliana, enhancing their affinity for the 5' ends of ndhA transcripts to stabilize these molecules while inhibiting the RNA endonuclease activity of the SOT1 C-terminal SMR domain. In addition, we established that SOT1 improves the splicing efficiency of ndhA by facilitating the association of CAF2 with the ndhA intron, which may be due to the SOT1-mediated stability of the ndhA transcripts. Our findings shed light on the importance of PPR protein interaction partners in moderating RNA metabolism.

Moss PPR-SMR protein PpPPR_64 influences the expression of a psaA-psaB-rps14 gene cluster and processing of the 23S-4.5S rRNA precursor in chloroplasts

Moss PPR-SMR protein PpPPR_64 is a pTAC2 homolog but is functionally distinct from pTAC2. PpPPR_64 is required for psaA gene expression and its function may have evolved in mosses. The pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) proteins are key regulatory factors responsible for the control of plant organellar gene expression. A small subset of PPR proteins possess a C-terminal small MutS-related (SMR) domain and have diverse roles in plant organellar biogenesis. However, the function of PPR-SMR proteins is not fully understood. Here, we report the function of PPR-SMR protein PpPPR_64 in the moss Physcomitrium patens. Phylogenetic analysis indicated that PpPPR_64 belongs to the same clade as the Arabidopsis PPR-SMR protein pTAC2. PpPPR_64 knockout (KO) mutants grew autotrophically but with reduced protonemata growth and the poor formation of photosystems' antenna complexes. Quantitative reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction and RNA gel blot hybridization analyses revealed a significant reduction in transcript levels of the psaA-psaB-rps14 gene cluster but no alteration to transcript levels of most photosynthesis- and non-photosynthesis-related genes. In addition, RNA processing of 23S-4.5S rRNA precursor was impaired in the PpPPR_64 KO mutants. This suggests that PpPPR_64 is specifically involved in the expression level of the psaA-psaB-rps14 gene and in processing of the 23S-4.5S rRNA precursor. Our results indicate that PpPPR_64 is functionally distinct from pTAC2 and is a novel PPR-SMR protein required for proper chloroplast biogenesis in P. patens.

A PPR Protein ACM1 Is Involved in Chloroplast Gene Expression and Early Plastid Development in Arabidopsis

Chloroplasts cannot develop normally without the coordinated action of various proteins and signaling connections between the nucleus and the chloroplast genome. Many questions regarding these processes remain unanswered. Here, we report a novel P-type pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) factor, named Albino Cotyledon Mutant1 (ACM1), which is encoded by a nuclear gene and involved in chloroplast development. Knock-down of ACM1 transgenic plants displayed albino cotyledons but normal true leaves, while knock-out of the ACM1 gene in seedlings was lethal. Fluorescent protein analysis showed that ACM1 was specifically localized within chloroplasts. PEP-dependent plastid transcript levels and splicing efficiency of several group II introns were seriously affected in cotyledons in the RNAi line. Furthermore, denaturing gel electrophoresis and Western blot experiments showed that the accumulation of chloroplast ribosomes was probably damaged. Collectively, our results indicate ACM1 is indispensable in early chloroplast development in Arabidopsis cotyledons.

Interspecific Hybrids Between Pelargonium × hortorum and Species From P. Section Ciconium Reveal Biparental Plastid Inheritance and Multi-Locus Cyto-Nuclear Incompatibility

The genetics underlying Cyto-Nuclear Incompatibility (CNI) was studied in Pelargonium interspecific hybrids. We created hybrids of 12 closely related crop wild relatives (CWR) with the ornamental P. × hortorum. Ten of the resulting 12 (F₁) interspecific hybrids segregate for chlorosis suggesting biparental plastid inheritance. The segregation ratios of the interspecific F₂ populations show nuclear interactions of one, two, or three nuclear genes regulating plastid function dependent on the parents. We further validated that biparental inheritance of plastids is common in section Ciconium, using diagnostic PCR primers. Our results pave the way for using the diverse species from section Ciconium, each with its own set of characteristics, as novel sources of desired breeding traits for P. × hortorum cultivars.

The novel E-subgroup pentatricopeptide repeat protein DEK55 is responsible for RNA editing at multiple sites and for the splicing of nad1 and nad4 in maize

BACKGROUND

Pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) proteins compose a large protein family whose members are involved in both RNA processing in organelles and plant growth. Previous reports have shown that E-subgroup PPR proteins are involved in RNA editing. However, the additional functions and roles of the E-subgroup PPR proteins are unknown.

RESULTS

In this study, we developed and identified a new maize kernel mutant with arrested embryo and endosperm development, i.e., defective kernel (dek) 55 (dek55). Genetic and molecular evidence suggested that the defective kernels resulted from a mononucleotide alteration (C to T) at + 449 bp within the open reading frame (ORF) of Zm00001d014471 (hereafter referred to as DEK55). DEK55 encodes an E-subgroup PPR protein within the mitochondria. Molecular analyses showed that the editing percentage of 24 RNA editing sites decreased and that of seven RNA editing sites increased in dek55 kernels, the sites of which were distributed across 14 mitochondrial gene transcripts. Moreover, the splicing efficiency of nad1 introns 1 and 4 and nad4 intron 1 significantly decreased in dek55 compared with the wild type (WT). These results indicate that DEK55 plays a crucial role in RNA editing at multiple sites as well as in the splicing of nad1 and nad4 introns. Mutation in the DEK55 gene led to the dysfunction of mitochondrial complex I. Moreover, yeast two-hybrid assays showed that DEK55 interacts with two multiple organellar RNA-editing factors (MORFs), i.e., ZmMORF1 (Zm00001d049043) and ZmMORF8 (Zm00001d048291).

CONCLUSIONS

Our results demonstrated that a mutation in the DEK55 gene affects the mitochondrial function essential for maize kernel development. Our results also provide novel insight into the molecular functions of E-subgroup PPR proteins involved in plant organellar RNA processing.

The PPR-SMR Protein ATP4 Is Required for Editing the Chloroplast rps8 mRNA in Rice and Maize

Chloroplast gene expression involves the participation of hundreds of pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) RNA binding proteins, and proteins in the PLS subfamily typically specify sites of RNA editing, whereas those in the P-subfamily typically stabilize RNA, activate translation, or promote intron splicing. Several P-type PPR proteins include a small MutS-related (SMR) domain, but the biochemical contribution of the SMR domain remains enigmatic. Here, we describe a rice (Oryza sativa) mutant, osatp4, lacking the ortholog of ATP4, a PPR-SMR protein in maize (Zea mays). osatp4 mutants were chlorotic and had a plastid-ribosome deficiency when grown in the cold. Like maize ATP4, OsATP4 was required for the accumulation of dicistronic rpl16-rpl14 transcripts. Surprisingly, OsATP4 was also required for the editing of a specific nucleotide in the ribosomal protein S8 transcripts, rps8, and this function was conserved in maize. By contrast, rps8 RNA was edited normally in the maize PROTON gradient regulation3 mutant, pgr3, which also lacks rpl16-rpl14 transcripts, indicating that the editing defect in atp4 mutants is not a secondary effect of altered rpl16-rpl14 RNA metabolism. Expression of the edited rps8 isoform in transgenic osatp4 mutants complemented the cold-sensitive phenotype, indicating that a rps8 expression defect accounts for the cold-sensitivity. We suggest that ATP4 stimulates rps8 editing by facilitating access of a previously characterized PLS-type RNA editing factor to its cognate cis-element upstream of the edited nucleotide.

Pentatricopeptide repeat protein PHOTOSYSTEM I BIOGENESIS FACTOR2 is required for splicing of ycf3

To gain a better understanding of the molecular mechanisms of photosystem I (PSI) biogenesis, we characterized the Arabidopsis thaliana photosystem I biogenesis factor 2 (pbf2) mutant, which lacks PSI complex. PBF2 encodes a P-class pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) protein. In the pbf2 mutants, we observed a striking decrease in the transcript level of only one gene, the chloroplast gene ycf3, which is essential for PSI assembly. Further analysis of ycf3 transcripts showed that PBF2 is specifically required for the splicing of ycf3 intron 1. Computational prediction of binding sequences and electrophoretic mobility shift assays reveal that PBF2 specifically binds to a sequence in ycf3 intron 1. Moreover, we found that PBF2 interacted with two general factors for group II intron splicing CHLOROPLAST RNA SPLICING2-ASSOCIATED FACTOR1 (CAF1) and CAF2, and facilitated the association of these two factors with ycf3 intron 1. Our results suggest that PBF2 is specifically required for the splicing of ycf3 intron 1 through cooperating with CAF1 and CAF2. Our results also suggest that additional proteins are required to contribute to the specificity of CAF-dependent group II intron splicing.

The Role of Chloroplast Gene Expression in Plant Responses to Environmental Stress

Chloroplasts are plant organelles that carry out photosynthesis, produce various metabolites, and sense changes in the external environment. Given their endosymbiotic origin, chloroplasts have retained independent genomes and gene-expression machinery. Most genes from the prokaryotic ancestors of chloroplasts were transferred into the nucleus over the course of evolution. However, the importance of chloroplast gene expression in environmental stress responses have recently become more apparent. Here, we discuss the emerging roles of the distinct chloroplast gene expression processes in plant responses to environmental stresses. For example, the transcription and translation of psbA play an important role in high-light stress responses. A better understanding of the connection between chloroplast gene expression and environmental stress responses is crucial for breeding stress-tolerant crops better able to cope with the rapidly changing environment.

Organellar and Secretory Ribonucleases: Major Players in Plant RNA Homeostasis

Organellar and secretory RNases, associated with different cellular compartments, are essential to maintain cellular homeostasis during development and in stress responses.

Mitochondrial Pentatricopeptide Repeat Protein, EMB2794, Plays a Pivotal Role in NADH Dehydrogenase Subunit nad2 mRNA Maturation in Arabidopsis thaliana

The Arabidopsis genome encodes >450 proteins containing the pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) motif. The PPR proteins are classified into two groups, termed as P and P Long-Short (PLS) classes. Typically, the PLS subclass proteins are mainly involved in the RNA editing of mitochondrial and chloroplast transcripts, whereas most of the analyzed P subclass proteins have been mainly implicated in RNA metabolism, such as 5' or 3' transcript stabilization and processing, splicing and translation. Mutations of PPR genes often result in embryogenesis and altered seedling developmental defect phenotypes, but only a limited number of ppr mutants have been characterized in detail. In this report, we show that null mutations in the EMB2794 gene result in embryo arrest, due to altered splicing of nad2 transcripts in the Arabidopsis mitochondria. In angiosperms, nad2 has five exons that are transcribed individually from two mitochondrial DNA regions. Biochemical and in vivo analyses further indicate that recombinant or transgenic EMB2794 proteins bind to the nad2 pre-mRNAs in vitro as well as in vivo, suggesting a role for this protein in trans-splicing of nad2 intron 2 and possibly in the stability of the second pre-mRNA of nad2. Homozygous emb2794 lines, showing embryo-defective phenotypes, can be partially rescued by the addition of sucrose to the growth medium. Mitochondria of rescued homozygous mutant plants contain only traces of respiratory complex I, which lack the NADH-dehydrogenase activity.