Hemoglobin Loves Park [beta68 (E12) Leu-->Phe]: report of five cases including one originating from a de novo mutation

Non-S Sickling Hemoglobin Variants: Historical, Genetic, Diagnostic, and Clinical Perspectives

Apart from hemoglobin-S (HbS), there are other Hb variants (non-S sickling Hb variants) that cause sickle cell disease. However, the profiles of these non-S sickling Hb variants have neither been collated nor harmonized. A literature search revealed 14 non-S sickling Hb variants (HbC-Harlem, HbC-Ziguinchor, HbS-Travis, HbS-Antilles, HbS-Providence, HbS-Oman, HbS-Cameroon, HbS-South End, Hb Jamaica Plain, HbC-Ndjamena, HbS-Clichy, HbS-San Martin, HbS-Wake, and HbS-São Paulo). Generally, the non-S sickling Hb variants are double mutants with the HbS mutation (GAG>GTG: βGlu6Val) and additional β-chain mutations. Consequently, non-S sickling Hb variants give positive solubility and sickling tests, but they differ from HbS with respect to stability, oxygen affinity, and electro-chromatographic characteristics. Similarities and discrepancies between HbS and non-S sickling Hb variants create diagnostic pitfalls that can only be resolved by elaborate electro-chromatographic and/or genetic tests. It is therefore imperative that tropical hematologists should have a thorough understanding of these atypical sickling Hb variants. Collated and harmonized appraisal of the non-S sickling Hb variants have not been previously undertaken. Hence, this paper aims to provide a comprehensive but concise historical, genetic, comparative, diagnostic, and clinical overview of non-S sickling Hb variants. The elaborate techniques often required for precise diagnosis of non-S sickling Hb variants are regrettably not readily available in low resource tropical countries, which paradoxically carry the heaviest burden of sickling disorders. We strongly recommend that tropical countries should upgrade their diagnostic laboratory facilities to avoid misdiagnosis of these atypical Hb mutants.