A review and case report of aprosencephaly and the XK aprosencephaly syndrome

Cyclopia, aprosencephaly, and acardiac twinning: Is hypoxia-ischemia a unifying mechanism?

In a recent case of monochorionic diamniotic twinning we observed one twin with acardia, cyclopia, and aprosencephaly, an association not reported previously. In most cases of acardia, the development of tissues in superior regions of the body is disrupted severely, while inferior structures develop more normally. A common explanation for this disruption is hypoxia-ischemia due to twin reversed arterial perfusion (TRAP). In this condition, arterial-arterial and venous-venous anastomoses in the placenta permit twin-twin transfusion and reversal of blood flow in the umbilical vessels and aorta of the recipient twin. The heart is absent or severely deficient, either by secondary atrophy or possibly a more primary, though currently unknown, mechanism. As a result, cranial tissues are less likely to be perfused with oxygenated blood than caudal tissues. A host of craniocerebral anomalies are observed in acardia, including total absence of the head and brain, rudimentary brain, anencephaly, holoprosencephaly, neuronal migration defects, and near-normal brain. Hypoxia-ischemia could be an important factor in the disruption of tissues in the present case, although a more generalized process affecting heart, head, and brain cannot be excluded. The findings suggest that hypoxia-ischemia may play a role in the pathogenesis of some cases of holoprosencephaly and aprosencephaly. This mechanism has been underreported and requires additional investigation.

XK-aprosencephaly and related entities

We offer further biological characterization of the XK atelen/aprosencephaly syndrome in two infants, one with prolonged survival, the other presenting prenatally with apparent hydranencephaly and an orbital tumor (OS). Familial occurrence in the former born to presumably nonconsanguineous Lybian parents may represent parental germinal mosaicism or autosomal recessive inheritance. Both had apparently normal chromosomes; however, the Lybian infant had slightly increased induced chromosome breakage suggesting that this rare multiple congenital anomalies syndrome may involve a DNA repair defect. Virtual absence of atelen/aprosencephalic structures may lead to an arthrogryposis-like prenatal movement disorder. The orbital tumor in the Utah infant consisted of dystopic neural tissue compressing a rudimentary globe and was connected by a thin bridge of neural tissue to the small mass of disorganized brain tissue usually found in atelen/aprosencephalic infants and fetuses. No evidence of an encephaloclastic process was found in the autopsied Utah infant.

Anomalies of the forebrain with radial limb defects: Garcia-Lurie-Steinfeld syndrome?

BACKGROUND

Severe anomalies of the forebrain together with radial limb anomalies have been reported in Steinfeld syndrome, XK aprosencephaly, and partial monosomy 13q. Steinfeld syndrome is an extremely variable autosomal dominant condition that, in severe cases, is characterized by holoprosencephaly, radial limb defects, and renal and/or cardiac defects. In mild cases there may be only thumb hypoplasia, ocular coloboma, or oral clefts. XK aprosencephaly, also called Garcia-Lurie syndrome (GLS), is a usually sporadic disorder with radial limb defects and aprosencephaly/atelencephaly. Based on two atypical sibships, autosomal recessive inheritance has been suggested. Two patients with variations of monosomy 13q have been described with atelencephaly but, generally, Steinfeld and XK aprosencephaly patients are chromosomally normal. Holoprosencephaly in 13q deletion patients appears to be due to ZIC2 mutations, but ZIC2 has not been previously tested in Steinfeld syndrome or GLS patients.

CASES

We report three sporadic cases with clinical features intermediate between Steinfeld and GLS, including severe forebrain malformations and radial limb defects. All had normal karyotypes, and mutations in ZIC2 were absent in the two cases tested.

CONCLUSIONS

In our cases and in the literature there is significant clinical overlap between Steinfeld syndrome and GLS. We propose these conditions may not be nosologically or etiologically distinct. The spectrum of severe forebrain anomalies in these conditions is broader than previously thought and may include some neural tube defects. Mild cases are difficult to identify and the full range of expression remains unknown. Autosomal dominant inheritance with incomplete penetrance and frequent new mutations is postulated. Thorough clinical evaluation is recommended for children with severe forebrain and radial limb defects.

Aprosencephaly and cerebellar dysgenesis in sibs

Aprosencephaly is a rare, lethal malformation sequence of the central nervous system that has been attributed to a postneuralation encephaloclastic process. We describe autopsy findings consistent with aprosencephaly in 2 fetuses conceived from a consanguineous mating (first cousins). Both showed anencephalic manifestations; however, the crania were intact, with fused sutures. The neuropathologic findings were essentially identical. Each fetus had complete absence of the telecephalon and pyramidal tracts, rudimentary diencephalic and mesencephalic structures, primitive cerebellar hemispheres, posterolateral clusters of primitive neural cells in the medullas suggesting an abnormality of neural migration, a normally-formed spinal cord, and retinal dysplasia within normally-formed globes. In addition, both fetuses manifested a peculiar perivascular mesenchymal proliferation seen only within the central nervous system. The similarity of these cases, coupled with parental consanguinity, suggests a primary malformation in brain development due to the homozygous representation of a mutant allele. We hypothesize that these patients may represent a defect in a gene important in brain development, the nature of which has yet to be elucidated.

Atelencephalic aprosencephaly

Absence of the telencephalon and diencephalon characterizes the syndrome of aprosencephaly, while in atelencephaly, only the telencephalon is absent. Atelencephalic aprosencephaly is characterized by the presence of at least a rudimentary diencephalon. Embryologically, aprosencephaly is thought to occur after the optic vesicles form but before the cerebral vesicles appear. The syndrome is quite rare, with only 10 cases previously reported. We describe two fetuses with atelencephalic aprosencephaly. A 25-week estimated gestational age fetus was born to first-cousin parents and had a prenatal ultrasonographic diagnosis of anencephaly. The second, a 19-week estimated gestational age fetus, was thought to have semilobar holoprosencephaly by prenatal ultrasound. At autopsy, neuropathologic examination in both cases showed virtual absence of the cerebral hemispheres with an incomplete diencephalon. Microscopic examination in one case revealed disorganized neuropil with a proliferative vasculopathy. The optic globes were completely formed and attached to hypoplastic optic nerves, but retinal dysplasia was apparent histologically in both cases, and bilateral colobomata were present in one case. The findings in these cases demonstrate a spectrum of congenital variations that lie between the syndromes of atelencephaly and aprosencephaly, underscoring the complexity of the congenital anomalies.

Mosaic r(13) in an infant with aprosencephaly

We report on a stillborn male infant with a mosaic ring 13 karyotype (45,XY,-13/46,XY,-13,+r(13)) with apparent aprosencephaly and clinical findings similar to those reported previously in the XK-aprosencephaly syndrome. Findings of patients with r(13) are often similar to those seen in individuals with del(13q). This case was unusual because of the presence of aprosencephaly, although brain malformations such as arhinencephaly and cerebellar hypoplasia are present in at least one-half of reported patients with 13q-. The overlap between these syndromes suggests a possible chromosomal model of the XK-aprosencephaly syndrome.

Aprosencephaly: review of the literature and report of a case with cerebellar hypoplasia, pigmented epithelial cyst and Rathke's cleft cyst

Aprosencephaly is a very rare brain malformation that occurs in isolated and sydromatic forms. The syndromatic form has been named "XK-aprosencephaly", and is characterized by near total absence of prosencephalon with a midline oculofacial defect similar to the most severe forms of holoprosencephaly, in association with limb and genital anomalies. We present a case of syndromatic aprosencephaly with absence of thumb and abnormal external genitalia. A previously undescribed finding was a Rathke's cleft cyst. Two other cystic structure were also identified--an ependymal cyst, which may represent a dorsal cyst as in holoprosencephaly, and a pigmented epithelial cyst, which may represent a rudimentary eye. Additional findings were extensive calcific vasculopathy in the rudimentary prosencephalon, absence of pituitary gland, forking of the aqueduct of Sylvius and marked cerebellar hypoplasia. Since calcific vasculopathy is a common accompaniment of other inflammatory diseases of the central nervous system, its presence in this case suggests that destructive processes may be involved in the genesis of some cases of aprosencephaly.

Perspectives on holoprosencephaly: Part III. Spectra, distinctions, continuities, and discontinuities

This paper attempts to balance our knowledge of holoprosencephalic spectra and continuities with important distinctions and discontinuities. Prevalence studies and syndrome delineation are briefly reviewed. The following topics receive detailed coverage: human teratogens, special aspects of forebrain and hindbrain malformations, aprosencephaly/atelencephaly, association with neural tube defects, current assessment of "facial principles," and endocrine abnormalities.

XK aprosencephaly and anencephaly in sibs

Recent studies have suggested a causal and pathogenetic relationship between holoprosencephaly and anencephaly. In support of the proposed relationship we report a sibship that includes anencephalic male twins and a female infant with a severe form of alobar holoprosencephaly, radial aplasia, and oligodactyly. The upper limb and brain malformations are considered to represent aprosencephaly syndrome. The coexistence of anencephaly and aprosencephaly within a sibship suggests that XK aprosencephaly syndrome may be an autosomal recessive disorder.

Atelencephalic microcephaly: craniofacial anatomy and morphologic comparisons with holoprosencephaly and anencephaly

This is the first detailed report of the craniofacial anatomy of atelencephaly. Comparisons were made with a control specimen and others with holoprosencephaly, anencephaly, and anencephaly with holoprosencephalic facial features. In the atelencephalic fetus, severe microcephaly, flattened calvaria, and partial synostosis of the metopic suture were apparent. The cranial fossae were much smaller than usual; lesser wings of the sphenoid were folded into a rounded basal mass. Facial features were pronounced, and orbits were hyperteloric, lowset, and rounded. Ethmoidal cartilages, nasal bones, and maxillary structures were distorted and elongated. The secondary palate was displaced inferiorly and cleft. Because major components of the craniofacial complex were generally present, although misshapen, changes in the atelencephalic skull seem to be deformations rather than malformations. Differences in the cranial morphology of associated disorders--holoprosencephaly and anencephaly--can be construed as aberrations of separate developmental fields. Relationships between atelencephaly and these fields are unclear.

Atelencephalic microcephaly in a 21-week human fetus

Atelencephalic microcephaly, a rare and extreme disorder, is known morphologically by only six cases. Derivatives of the telencephalon are absent or dysplastic, while more caudal structures are normal or mildly deformed. A more extensive form, aprosencephaly, involves structures of the diencephalon and may be associated with holoprosencephalic facies. Extracranial anomalies may be present in both atelencephaly and aprosencephaly. We describe the seventh and youngest specimen, a 21-week female with atelencephaly. Maternal and gestational histories were unremarkable; the fetus was obtained by therapeutic abortion following diagnosis of a severe cranial malformation by ultrasound. A small and depressed, but intact, calvarium covered the brain. The forebrain was rounded and showed fused hemispheres, absent gyri, olfactory bulbs, and tracts. Caudal structures were mildly deformed. An oval mass of bone filled much of the middle cranial fossa. By light microscopy, several dysplastic changes were apparent in the forebrain. Ventricles were not present; small round cells resembling those of the germinal matrix were prominent in the forebrain. Pyramidal tracts were absent at all levels. The process responsible for these changes cannot be established with certainty; the changes are, however, in keeping with previous damage, such as that accepted for other encephaloclastic disorders. The insult in atelencephaly presumably occurs after closure of the rostral neuropore; earlier damage, with more widespread consequences, is possible for aprosencephaly. As with other destructive processes, etiology in atelencephaly and aprosencephaly is most likely heterogeneous.

Further comments on the lissencephaly syndromes

Detailed clinical, pathological, and cytogenetic investigations of patients with lissencephaly over the past several years have demonstrated the existence of at least eight distinct conditions with variable genetic implications. In several of these disorders, especially chromosomally normal MDS, ILS, and CCL, too few patients have been reported to permit citation of accurate recurrence risk figures. Accordingly, we wish to begin a registry of patients with lissencephaly of all types for the purpose of developing such risk figures and request that any available information be sent to one of us (W.B.D. or J.M.O.).