Discordance of muscular dystrophy in monozygotic female twins: evidence supporting asymmetric splitting of the inner cell mass in a manifesting carrier of Duchenne dystrophy

TCEAL1 loss-of-function results in an X-linked dominant neurodevelopmental syndrome and drives the neurological disease trait in Xq22.2 deletions

An Xq22.2 region upstream of PLP1 has been proposed to underly a neurological disease trait when deleted in 46,XX females. Deletion mapping revealed that heterozygous deletions encompassing the smallest region of overlap (SRO) spanning six Xq22.2 genes (BEX3, RAB40A, TCEAL4, TCEAL3, TCEAL1, and MORF4L2) associate with an early-onset neurological disease trait (EONDT) consisting of hypotonia, intellectual disability, neurobehavioral abnormalities, and dysmorphic facial features. None of the genes within the SRO have been associated with monogenic disease in OMIM. Through local and international collaborations facilitated by GeneMatcher and Matchmaker Exchange, we have identified and herein report seven de novo variants involving TCEAL1 in seven unrelated families: three hemizygous truncating alleles; one hemizygous missense allele; one heterozygous TCEAL1 full gene deletion; one heterozygous contiguous deletion of TCEAL1, TCEAL3, and TCEAL4; and one heterozygous frameshift variant allele. Variants were identified through exome or genome sequencing with trio analysis or through chromosomal microarray. Comparison with previously reported Xq22 deletions encompassing TCEAL1 identified a more-defined syndrome consisting of hypotonia, abnormal gait, developmental delay/intellectual disability especially affecting expressive language, autistic-like behavior, and mildly dysmorphic facial features. Additional features include strabismus, refractive errors, variable nystagmus, gastroesophageal reflux, constipation, dysmotility, recurrent infections, seizures, and structural brain anomalies. An additional maternally inherited hemizygous missense allele of uncertain significance was identified in a male with hypertonia and spasticity without syndromic features. These data provide evidence that TCEAL1 loss of function causes a neurological rare disease trait involving significant neurological impairment with features overlapping the EONDT phenotype in females with the Xq22 deletion.

X-Chromosome Inactivation and Related Diseases

X-chromosome inactivation (XCI) is the form of dosage compensation in mammalian female cells to balance X-linked gene expression levels of the two sexes. Many diseases are related to XCI due to inactivation escape and skewing, and the symptoms and severity of these diseases also largely depend on the status of XCI. They can be divided into 3 types: X-linked diseases, diseases that are affected by XCI escape, and X-chromosome aneuploidy. Here, we review representative diseases in terms of their definition, symptoms, and XCI’s role in the pathogenesis of these diseases.

Mechanisms of Choice in X-Chromosome Inactivation

Early in development, placental and marsupial mammals harbouring at least two X chromosomes per nucleus are faced with a choice that affects the rest of their lives: which of those X chromosomes to transcriptionally inactivate. This choice underlies phenotypical diversity in the composition of tissues and organs and in their response to the environment, and can determine whether an individual will be healthy or affected by an X-linked disease. Here, we review our current understanding of the process of choice during X-chromosome inactivation and its implications, focusing on the strategies evolved by different mammalian lineages and on the known and unknown molecular mechanisms and players involved.

Molecular Mechanisms of Skewed X-Chromosome Inactivation in Female Hemophilia Patients-Lessons from Wide Genome Analyses

Introduction: Hemophilia A (HA) is an X-linked bleeding disorder caused by factor VIII (FVIII) deficiency or dysfunction due to F8 gene mutations. HA carriers are usually asymptomatic because their FVIII levels correspond to approximately half of the concentration found in healthy individuals. However, in rare cases, a carrier may exhibit symptoms of moderate to severe HA primarily due to skewed inactivation of her non-hemophilic X chromosome. Aim: The aim of the study was to investigate X-chromosome inactivation (XCI) patterns in HA carriers, with special emphasis on three karyotypically normal HA carriers presenting with moderate to severe HA phenotype due to skewed XCI, in an attempt to elucidate the molecular mechanism underlying skewed XCI in these symptomatic HA carriers. The study was based on the hypothesis that the presence of a pathogenic mutation on the non-hemophilic X chromosome is the cause of extreme inactivation of that X chromosome. Methods: XCI patterns were studied by PCR analysis of the CAG repeat region in the HUMARA gene. HA carriers that demonstrated skewed XCI were further studied by whole-exome sequencing (WES) followed by X chromosome-targeted bioinformatic analysis. Results: All three HA carriers presenting with the moderate to severe HA phenotype due to skewed XCI were found to carry pathogenic mutations on their non-hemophilic X chromosomes. Patient 1 was diagnosed with a frameshift mutation in the PGK1 gene that was associated with familial XCI skewing in three generations. Patient 2 was diagnosed with a missense mutation in the SYTL4 gene that was associated with familial XCI skewing in two generations. Patient 3 was diagnosed with a nonsense mutation in the NKAP gene that was associated with familial XCI skewing in two generations. Conclusion: Our results indicate that the main reason for skewed XCI in our female HA patients was negative selection against cells with a disadvantage caused by an additional deleterious mutation on the silenced X chromosome, thus complicating the phenotype of a monogenic X-linked disease. Based on our study, we are currently offering the X inactivation test to symptomatic hemophilia carriers and plan to expand this approach to symptomatic carriers of other X-linked diseases, which can be further used in pregnancy planning.

X Chromosome Inactivation in Carriers of Fabry Disease: Review and Meta-Analysis

Anderson-Fabry disease is an X-linked inborn error of glycosphingolipid catabolism caused by a deficiency of α-galactosidase A. The incidence ranges between 1: 40,000 and 1:117,000 of live male births. In Italy, an estimate of incidence is available only for the north-western Italy, where it is of approximately 1:4000. Clinical symptoms include angiokeratomas, corneal dystrophy, and neurological, cardiac and kidney involvement. The prevalence of symptomatic female carriers is about 70%, and in some cases, they can exhibit a severe phenotype. Previous studies suggest a correlation between skewed X chromosome inactivation and symptoms in carriers of X-linked disease, including Fabry disease. In this review, we briefly summarize the disease, focusing on the clinical symptoms of carriers and analysis of the studies so far published in regards to X chromosome inactivation pattern, and manifesting Fabry carriers. Out of 151 records identified, only five reported the correlation between the analysis of XCI in leukocytes and the related phenotype in Fabry carriers, in particular evaluating the Mainz Severity Score Index or cardiac involvement. The meta-analysis did not show any correlation between MSSI or cardiac involvement and skewed XCI, likely because the analysis of XCI in leukocytes is not useful for predicting the phenotype in Fabry carriers.

Whole genome miRNA profiling revealed miR-199a as potential placental pathogenesis of selective fetal growth restriction in monochorionic twin pregnancies

INTRODUCTION

Placental-related mechanism of fetal growth restriction (FGR) is still unknown. Here we aimed to profile whole-genome miRNA between selective FGR twin (sFGR-T) and normally larger co-twin (sL-T) in monochorionic (MC) twin pregnancies and to further investigate effect of the miRNA on placental pathogenesis, including angiogenesis and mitochondrial functions.

METHODS

MC twin pregnancies with or without sFGR were recruited, and their placental miRNAs were profiled (n = 3 vs 5). Ratio of placental miRNAs in the sFGR twin pairs (sFGR-T/sL-T) were calculated and compared to that in the control twin pairs (cS-T/cL-T). Differentially expressed miRNAs and associated markers were validated qRT-PCR, immunohistochemistry staining (n = 8 vs 13) and electron microscopy (n = 3 vs 3).

RESULTS

Placental miR-199a-5p was significantly upregulated in sFGR-T (p = 0.004), which was validated by qRT-PCR (1.03 vs 0.56; p = 0.020). Compared to control twin pairs, ratio of CD31-positive vessels and volume density of vessels in sFGR twin pairs was lower (0.65 vs 0.92 and 18.7% vs 36.3%; both p < 0.001), while that of cyclooxygenase 2 (COX2)-positive trophoblast cells was higher (3.50 vs 2.22; p = 0.001), indicating an impaired angiogenesis and oxidative stress in the sFGR placenta. In addition, ratio of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) mitochondrial encoded NADH dehydrogenase 1 (MTND1) copy numbers (2.10 vs 0.90; p = 0.013), H-score ratios of mitochondrial markers citrate synthase (CS) and cytochrome c oxidase subunit 4 isoform 1 (COX4, 0.53 vs 0.95, p < 0.001; 0.29 vs 1.06, p < 0.001) in trophoblast cells of sFGR twin pairs were also altered significantly and correlated with angiogenesis. Furthermore, ratio of mitochondrial numbers per trophoblasts (8.67 vs 18.67; p = 0.006) and percentage of swollen mitochondria (84.33 vs 11.33; p = 0.003) were converted significantly, indicating mitochondrial damage.

DISCUSSION

Our results suggested miR-199a-5p may play a role in the placental angiogenesis, oxidative stress and mitochondrial damage and dysfunction as an underlying pathogenesis of sFGR.

Rapidly Progressive Heart Failure in a Female Carrier of Becker Muscular Dystrophy with No Skeletal Muscle Symptoms

Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) carriers are at risk to developing cardiac dysfunction. The prevalence of female BMD carriers remains underestimated, and the disease progression varies. We herein report the case of a young female BMD carrier who developed dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) and heart failure without any skeletal muscle signs. Her cardiac dysfunction progressed over a mere two months, resulting in the need for left ventricular assist device implantation. Her case demonstrates that progressive cardiomyopathy can be the only clinical manifestation in some BMD carriers, suggesting the need for a more aggressive implementation of genetic testing in female DCM patients.

Skewed X-chromosome inactivation plays a crucial role in the onset of symptoms in carriers of Becker muscular dystrophy

BACKGROUND

Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD) is an X-linked recessive disorder affecting approximately 1: 18.000 male births. Female carriers are usually asymptomatic, although 2.5-18% may present muscle or heart symptoms. In the present study, the role of the X chromosome inactivation (XCI) on the onset of symptoms in BMD carriers was analysed and compared with the pattern observed in Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) carriers.

METHODS

XCI was determined on the lymphocytes of 36 BMD carriers (both symptomatic and not symptomatic) from 11 families requiring genetic advice at the Cardiomyology and Medical Genetics of the Second University of Naples, using the AR methylation-based assay. Carriers were subdivided into two groups, according to age above or below 50 years. Seven females from the same families known as noncarriers were used as controls. A Student's t-test for nonpaired data was performed to evaluate the differences observed in the XCI values between asymptomatic and symptomatic carriers, and carriers aged above or below 50 years. A Pearson correlation test was used to evaluate the inheritance of the XCI pattern in 19 mother-daughter pairs.

RESULTS

The results showed that symptomatic BMD carriers had a skewed XCI with a preferential inactivation of the X chromosome carrying the normal allele, whereas the asymptomatic carriers and controls showed a random XCI. No concordance concerning the XCI pattern was observed between mothers and related daughters.

CONCLUSIONS

The data obtained in the present study suggest that the onset of symptoms in BMD carriers is related to a skewed XCI, as observed in DMD carriers. Furthermore, they showed no concordance in the XCI pattern inheritance.

Determining the role of skewed X-chromosome inactivation in developing muscle symptoms in carriers of Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Duchenne and Becker dystrophinopathies (DMD and BMD) are X-linked recessive disorders caused by mutations in the dystrophin gene that lead to absent or reduced expression of dystrophin in both skeletal and heart muscles. DMD/BMD female carriers are usually asymptomatic, although about 8 % may exhibit muscle or cardiac symptoms. Several mechanisms leading to a reduced dystrophin have been hypothesized to explain the clinical manifestations and, in particular, the role of the skewed XCI is questioned. In this review, the mechanism of XCI and its involvement in the phenotype of BMD/DMD carriers with both a normal karyotype or with X;autosome translocations with breakpoints at Xp21 (locus of the DMD gene) will be analyzed. We have previously observed that DMD carriers with moderate/severe muscle involvement, exhibit a moderate or extremely skewed XCI, in particular if presenting with an early onset of symptoms, while DMD carriers with mild muscle involvement present a random XCI. Moreover, we found that among 87.1 % of the carriers with X;autosome translocations involving the locus Xp21 who developed signs and symptoms of dystrophinopathy such as proximal muscle weakness, difficulty to run, jump and climb stairs, 95.2 % had a skewed XCI pattern in lymphocytes. These data support the hypothesis that skewed XCI is involved in the onset of phenotype in DMD carriers, the X chromosome carrying the normal DMD gene being preferentially inactivated and leading to a moderate-severe muscle involvement.

Menkes disease with discordant phenotype in female monozygotic twins

Menkes disease (MD) is a rare X-linked recessive disorder caused by mutations in the ATP7A gene. This neurodegenerative disorder typically affects males and is characterized by impaired copper distribution and the malfunction of several copper-dependent enzymes. We report clinically discordant female monozygotic twins (MZT) with a heterozygous ATP7A mutation. One twin girl is healthy at the current age of 4 years, whereas the other twin girl developed classical MD, showed disease stabilization under copper histidine treatment but died at the age of 3 years. Presumably, the affected girl developed MD due to skewed X inactivation, although this could not be demonstrated in two tissues (blood, buccal mucosa). This case is a rare example of an affected girl with MD and shows the possibility of a discordant phenotype in MZT girls. As speculated in other X-linked diseases, the process of monozygotic twinning may be associated with skewed X inactivation leading to a discordant phenotype.

Nonrandom X chromosome inactivation detection

X chromosome inactivation patterns may be clinically useful in assessing tumor clonality, determining carrier status for certain X-linked disorders and evaluating the pathogenicity of a genetic variant identified in an X-linked gene. The protocols in this unit utilize the highly polymorphic trinucleotide repeat within the first exon of the human androgen receptor gene (AR) and the methylation-sensitive restriction enzyme HpaII to distinguish between the maternal and paternal alleles and simultaneously determine their methylation status. The data obtained from these protocols can be used to calculate the ratio of inactivation between the two alleles that ultimately reflects whether a female has a random or nonrandom pattern of X chromosome inactivation.

Genetic and clinical specificity of 26 symptomatic carriers for dystrophinopathies at pediatric age

The molecular basis underlying the clinical variability in symptomatic Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) carriers are still to be precised. We report 26 cases of early symptomatic DMD carriers followed in the French neuromuscular network. Clinical presentation, muscular histological analysis and type of gene mutation, as well as X-chromosome inactivation (XCI) patterns using DNA extracted from peripheral blood or muscle are detailed. The initial symptoms were significant weakness (88%) or exercise intolerance (27%). Clinical severity varied from a Duchenne-like progression to a very mild Becker-like phenotype. Cardiac dysfunction was present in 19% of the cases. Cognitive impairment was worthy of notice, as 27% of the carriers are concerned. The muscular analysis was always contributive, revealing muscular dystrophy (83%), mosaic in immunostaining (81%) and dystrophin abnormalities in western blot analysis (84%). In all, 73% had exonic deletions or duplications and 27% had point mutations. XCI pattern was biased in 62% of the cases. In conclusion, we report the largest series of manifesting DMD carriers at pediatric age and show that exercise intolerance and cognitive impairment may reveal symptomatic DMD carriers. The complete histological and immunohistological study of the muscle is the key of the diagnosis leading to the dystrophin gene analysis. Our study shows also that cognitive impairment in symptomatic DMD carriers is associated with mutations in the distal part of the DMD gene. XCI study does not fully explain the mechanisms as well as the wide spectrum of clinical phenotype, though a clear correlation between the severity of the phenotype and inactivation bias was observed.

The effects of low levels of dystrophin on mouse muscle function and pathology

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a severe progressive muscular disorder caused by reading frame disrupting mutations in the DMD gene, preventing the synthesis of functional dystrophin. As dystrophin provides muscle fiber stability during contractions, dystrophin negative fibers are prone to exercise-induced damage. Upon exhaustion of the regenerative capacity, fibers will be replaced by fibrotic and fat tissue resulting in a progressive loss of function eventually leading to death in the early thirties. With several promising approaches for the treatment of DMD aiming at dystrophin restoration in clinical trials, there is an increasing need to determine more precisely which dystrophin levels are sufficient to restore muscle fiber integrity, protect against muscle damage and improve muscle function.

To address this we generated a new mouse model (mdx-Xist^Δhs) with varying, low dystrophin levels (3–47%, mean 22.7%, stdev 12.1, n = 24) due to skewed X-inactivation. Longitudinal sections revealed that within individual fibers, some nuclei did and some did not express dystrophin, resulting in a random, mosaic pattern of dystrophin expression within fibers.

Mdx-Xist^Δhs, mdx and wild type females underwent a 12 week functional test regime consisting of different tests to assess muscle function at base line, or after chronic treadmill running exercise. Overall, mdx-Xist^Δhs mice with 3–14% dystrophin outperformed mdx mice in the functional tests. Improved histopathology was observed in mice with 15–29% dystrophin and these levels also resulted in normalized expression of pro-inflammatory biomarker genes, while for other parameters >30% of dystrophin was needed. Chronic exercise clearly worsened pathology, which needed dystrophin levels >20% for protection. Based on these findings, we conclude that while even dystrophin levels below 15% can improve pathology and performance, levels of >20% are needed to fully protect muscle fibers from exercise-induced damage.

Identical but not the same: the value of discordant monozygotic twins in genetic research

Monozygotic (MZ) twins show remarkable resemblance in many aspects of behavior, health, and disease. Until recently, MZ twins were usually called "genetically identical"; however, evidence for genetic and epigenetic differences within rare MZ twin pairs has accumulated. Here, we summarize the literature on MZ twins discordant for Mendelian inherited disorders and chromosomal abnormalities. A systematic literature search for English articles on discordant MZ twin pairs was performed in Web of Science and PubMed. A total number of 2,016 publications were retrieved and reviewed and 439 reports were retained. Discordant MZ twin pairs are informative in respect to variability of phenotypic expression, pathogenetic mechanisms, epigenetics, and post-zygotic mutagenesis and may serve as a model for research on genetic defects. The analysis of single discordant MZ twin pairs may represent an elegant approach to identify genes in inherited disorders.

Expression of the disease on female carriers of X-linked lysosomal disorders: a brief review

Most lysosomal diseases (LD) are inherited as autosomal recessive traits, but two important conditions have X-linked inheritance: Fabry disease and Mucopolysaccharidosis II (MPS II). These two diseases show a very different pattern regarding expression on heterozygotes, which does not seem to be explained by the X-inactivation mechanism only. While MPS II heterozygotes are asymptomatic in most instances, in Fabry disease most of female carriers show some disease manifestation, which is sometimes severe. It is known that there is a major difference among X-linked diseases depending on the cell autonomy of the gene product involved and, therefore, on the occurrence of cross-correction. Since lysosomal enzymes are usually secreted and uptaken by neighbor cells, the different findings between MPS II and Fabry disease heterozygotes can also be due to different efficiency of cross-correction (higher in MPS II and lower in Fabry disease). In this paper, we review these two X-linked LD in order to discuss the mechanisms that could explain the different rates of penetrance and expressivity observed in the heterozygotes; this could be helpful to better understand the expression of X-linked traits.

X chromosome inactivation in clinical practice

X chromosome inactivation (XCI) is the transcriptional silencing of the majority of genes on one of the two X chromosomes in mammalian females. Females are, therefore, mosaics for two cell lines, one with the maternal X and one with the paternal X as the active chromosome. The relative proportion of the two cell lines, the X inactivation pattern, may be analyzed by simple assays in DNA from available tissues. This review focuses on medical issues related to XCI in X-linked disorders, and on the value of X inactivation analysis in clinical practice.

Detection of nonrandom X chromosome inactivation

This unit describes a PCR-based assay for distinguishing between the two X chromosomes in female cells and assessing the percentage of cells having each parental X chromosome active. Methylation of CpG residues in gene promoters is a major mechanism of transcriptional silencing. In mammalian female cells, hypermethylation is the way in which one X chromosome is inactivated. The X-inactivation assay described in the Basic Protocol relies on methylation sensitivity. In this unit, the highly polymorphic and therefore typically heterozygous (CAG)n region of the 5 end of the coding region of the human androgen receptor gene (HUMARA), at Xq11.2, is used to distinguish and compare the methylation activity of the X chromosomes.

Lesch-Nyhan disease in a female with a clinically normal monozygotic twin

Lesch-Nyhan disease (LND) is an inborn error of purine metabolism caused by defective activity of the enzyme hypoxanthine guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HPRT, EC 2.4.2.8), resulting from mutation in the corresponding gene on the long arm of the X chromosome (Xq26). The classic phenotype occurs almost exclusively in males and is characterized by hyperuricemia, mental retardation, severe dystonia, and self-injurious behavior. Heterozygous carrier females are usually clinically normal. However, a small number of clinically affected females have been described. In all previous cases there was a mutation in one HPRT allele and non-random inactivation of the X chromosome carrying the normal HPRT gene. We have analyzed a female MZ twin pair discordant for Lesch-Nyhan disease. The mother and both twins are heterozygous carriers of a HPRT splicing mutation (IVS8 + 4A > G; c.609 + 4A > G) and all three express the mutant allele at similar frequencies in peripheral blood T cells. The mother and one sister are clinically normal. In the affected twin, the clinical phenotype is classical for Lesch-Nyhan disease, despite the fact that HPRT activity in the blood was also normal. X inactivation analysis showed a skewed pattern in the fibroblasts of the affected twin sister, with the X chromosome carrying the normal HPRT allele preferentially inactivated. As in many other reported cases of X-linked diseases, the discordant phenotype of the two monozygous twin sisters suggests that the process responsible for monozygotic twinning can trigger skewed X inactivation.

Conjoined twins in a monozygotic triplet pregnancy: prenatal diagnosis and X-inactivation

BACKGROUND

The etiology of monozygotic twinning is not known. Some investigators have implicated abnormal X-inactivation, which could also be related to the increased female:male ratio in higher order multiple gestations in general, and in monozygotic and conjoined twins (CTS) in particular. CTS are rare, and even more unusual when part of a triplet pregnancy.

METHODS

DNA polymorphism analysis using 13 markers in the buccal cells of the triplets and the lymphocytes of the parents were used to evaluate zygosity. We investigated the X-inactivation pattern of the triplets by analyzing methylation at the androgen receptor gene.

RESULTS

We found a female triplet gestation consisting of CTS and a normal singleton. The thoracopagus CTS were joined from the clavicles to the umbilicus. Congenital heart disease was suspected antenatally, but the precise delineation of the heart defects required extensive postnatal evaluation. There was a single placental mass with a thin dividing membrane. Cesarean section was carried out at 32 weeks after the onset of labor. Histologically, the placenta was diamniotic monochorionic. The normal singleton did well after delivery; the CTS died at 35 days from cardiopulmonary collapse. The babies were monozygotic (>99.99% probability). Each baby in this triplet set exhibited a random and symmetric X-inactivation pattern. The degree of X-inactivation skewing fell in the range of 50-65%.

CONCLUSION

Genetic or environmental factors other than abnormal X-inactivation must be involved in causing monozygous multiple gestation or CTS. Despite prenatal diagnosis, shared myocardium or cardiac anomalies in CTS often determine the prognosis.

Skewed X-chromosome inactivation in monochorionic diamniotic twin sisters results in severe and mild hemophilia A

This study describes the genetic mechanisms responsible for the de novo occurrence of severe and mild hemophilia A in monozygotic twin females. Both twins were found to carry a previously known factor VIII mutation (Tyr16Cys) in the heterozygous state which most probably arose in the paternal germ line. Both twins showed concordant skewing of X inactivation toward the maternally derived normal X chromosome, the most severely affected twin exhibiting a higher percentage of inactivation of the normal X chromosome. The degree of skewing of X inactivation closely correlated with both the coagulation parameters and the clinical phenotype of the twins. Since these twins were monochorionic, such results suggest that the twinning event in this case has occurred after the onset of the X-inactivation period.

Associations between MeCP2 mutations, X-chromosome inactivation, and phenotype

Rett syndrome is a neurodevelopmental disorder of early postnatal brain growth in girls. Patients show a normal neonatal period with subsequent developmental regression and a loss of acquired skills (communication and motor skills), deceleration of head growth, and development of typical hand stereotypies. Recent studies have shown that mutations in the X-linked methyl CpG binding protein 2 gene (MeCP2) cause most typical cases of Rett syndrome. The MeCP2 gene encodes a protein that binds methylated cytosine residues of CpG dinucleotides and mediates, with histone deacetylases and transcriptional repressors, the transcription "silencing" of other genes. Girls with Rett syndrome exhibit mosaic expression for the MeCP2 defect at the cellular level, with most patients showing random X-inactivation and approximately equal numbers of cells expressing the normal MeCP2 gene and the mutated MeCP2 gene. In rare cases, females with a MeCP2 mutation escape phenotypic expression of the disorder because of nonrandom X-inactivation and the preferential inactivation of the mutated MeCP2 allele. Nonrandom patterns of X-inactivation may also contribute to the clinical variability often seen in girls with Rett syndrome. The spectrum of clinical phenotype caused by MeCP2 mutations is wide, including milder "preserved speech" variants, the severe congenital Rett variant, and a subset of X-linked recessive mental retardation in boys. Studies have shown that atypical and classical Rett syndrome can caused by the same MeCP2 mutations, indicating clinical phenotype is variable even among girls with the same MeCP2 mutation. The relationship between type of MeCP2 mutation, X-inactivation status, and clinical phenotype of Rett syndrome is complex and likely involves other environmental and polygenic modifiers.

Phenotypic variation in Melnick-Needles syndrome is not reflected in X inactivation patterns from blood or buccal smear

Melnick-Needles syndrome is a rare putative X-linked dominant bone dysplasia. The patients have short stature, characteristic facial features, and a normal intelligence. The skeletal dysplasia includes S-shaped curvature of tubular bones and sclerosis of the base of the skull. The phenotype of affected individuals varies, even within families. This could be related to X chromosome inactivation. We report here on a very mildly affected mother and her two severely affected daughters with characteristic features of Melnick-Needles syndrome. In addition, the two daughters had very similar pigmented nevi on their back. X chromosome inactivation analysis of blood DNA revealed a skewed X inactivation pattern in all three affected females, with the normal X chromosome as the predominating active X chromosome. The X inactivation pattern was similar in buccal smear and blood DNA in the mother and one of the daughters, whereas the other daughter had a skewed pattern in blood only. X chromosome inactivation in blood and buccal smear DNA therefore does not explain the phenotypic variation in this family. The skewed X chromosome inactivation is in agreement with X-linked inheritance of Melnick-Needles syndrome and suggests a critical role of the Melnick-Needles gene in hematopoietic cell proliferation. Clinical evidence indicates that Melnick-Needles syndrome is allelic to the otopalatodigital syndromes, which have been assigned to Xq26-28. Haplotype analysis of the X chromosomes in this family was in agreement with the localization of the gene for Melnick-Needles syndrome to Xq25-qtel.

Mechanisms for differences in monozygous twins

Monozygous (MZ) twins are often described as being physically and genetically identical. Clinical determination of zygosity relies on the assumption that any physical differences between a pair of twins imply they are dizygous. Most twin research relies on the assumption that dizygous twins share approximately 50% of the same genes, whereas monozygous twins share 100%. There is, however, increasing evidence to challenge both these assumptions. In this review, we describe a number of intrauterine effects and genetic mechanisms that may result in phenotypic, genotypic, and epigenetic differences between monozygous twins. Newer molecular techniques are resulting in such differences being increasingly commonly recognised. The potential for differences in monozygotic twin pairs is an important consideration for both clinicians and researchers involved in twin work.

Commitment to X inactivation precedes the twinning event in monochorionic MZ twins

To gain insight into the timing of twinning, we have examined a closely related event, X-chromosome inactivation, in female MZ twin pairs. X-inactivation patterns in peripheral blood and buccal mucosa were compared between monochorionic MZ (MC-MZ) and dichorionic MZ (DC-MZ) twins. Overall, the MC-MZ twins displayed highly similar X-inactivation patterns, whereas DC-MZ twins frequently differed in their X-inactivation patterns, when both tissues were tested. Previous experimental data suggest that commitment to X inactivation occurs when there are 10-20 cells in the embryo. Simulation of embryo splitting after commitment to X inactivation suggests that MC-MZ twinning occurs three or four rounds of replication after X inactivation, whereas a DC-MZ twinning event occurs earlier, before or around the time of X inactivation. Finally, the overall degree of skewing in the MZ twins was not significantly different from that observed in singletons. This indicates that X inactivation does not play a direct role in the twinning process, and it further suggests that extreme unequal splitting is not a common mechanism of twin formation.

X-chromosome inactivation in mammals

The inactive X chromosome differs from the active X in a number of ways; some of these, such as allocyclic replication and altered histone acetylation, are associated with all types of epigenetic silencing, whereas others, such as DNA methylation, are of more restricted use. These features are acquired progressively by the inactive X after onset of initiation. Initiation of X-inactivation is controlled by the X-inactivation center (Xic) and influenced by the X chromosome controlling element (Xce), which causes primary nonrandom X-inactivation. Other examples of nonrandom X-inactivation are also presented in this review. The definition of a major role for Xist, a noncoding RNA, in X-inactivation has enabled investigation of the mechanism leading to establishment of the heterochromatinized X-chromosome and also of the interactions between X-inactivation and imprinting as well as between X-inactivation and developmental processes in the early embryo.

X-chromosome inactivation is mostly random in placental tissues of female monozygotic twins and triplets

Patterns of X-chromosome inactivation in chorion, amnion, and cord from 79 pairs of twins were examined. Seven sets of triplets were included in the analysis, both as twin pairs and triplets. Twins were stratified as dizygotic (DZ), monozygotic (MZ), monochorionic, and dichorionic and were selected for birth weight discordance, discordance for congenital anomalies, twin-twin transfusion syndrome, and various patterns of vascular anastomosis. X-inactivation was predominantly symmetric. Chorion was the most likely tissue to show asymmetric X-inactivation and was found most frequently in MZ dichorionic twins. There was no correlation of X-inactivation pattern with the selected clinical criteria. This study does not confirm that asymmetric X-inactivation in embryonic tissues is a common phenomenon in female twins, including monozygotic twins.

Some causes of genotypic and phenotypic discordance in monozygotic twin pairs

The use of the adjective "identical" rather than monozygotic leads to misunderstandings about the biology of monozygotic twinning. Most monozygotic twin pairs are not identical; there may be major discordance for birth weight, genetic disease, and congenital anomalies. These indicate that postzygotic events may lead to the formation of two or more cell clones in the inner cell mass and early embryo that actually stimulate the monozygotic twinning event. There is also evidence that there may be unequal allocation of numbers of cells to the monozygotic twins; this may have widespread implications for the cascade of developmental events during embryogenesis, formation, and vascularization of the placenta. Large-scale zygosity testing at birth could be the template for analysis of twin outcomes and their biologic causes.

Monozygotic twins discordant for the Russell-Silver syndrome

Russell-Silver syndrome (RSS) is a pattern of malformation characterized by intrauterine and postnatal growth retardation, limb asymmetry, triangular face, and hypospadias. We report on a patient, from a triplet pregnancy, who was one of identical male twins discordant for RSS. R.B. was a 710-g male born at 33 weeks of gestation, with hypospadias, chordee, and undescended testes. He had a normal 46,XY karyotype and no renal abnormalities. Female triplet A weighed 1,843 g, and male triplet B weighed 1,920 g. Both had normal physical findings and neonatal period. R.B. was first seen by us at age 6 7/12 years with short stature, triangular and asymmetric face, lower limb length discrepancy, and surgically repaired genital anomalies. Growth hormone testing results were normal. At age 8 7/12 years the brothers appeared physically identical except for size, with a height differential of 114.25 vs. 121.5 cm. Testing to establish biological zygosity was performed using VNTR (variable number tandem repeat) DNA probes YNH24 (D2S44), CMM101 (D14S13), EFD52 (D17S26), TBQ7 (D10S28), and 3'HVR (D16S85), PCR loci MCT118 (D1S80), and HLA-DQ alpha. These data indicate a > 99.99% probability of triplets B and C being monozygotic twins. While most occurrences of RSS are sporadic, familial cases suggesting autosomal dominance have been reported. Three other cases of probable monozygotic twins with RSS have been described. The significance of this confirmation of discordance in determining the cause of RSS is discussed.

X-chromosome methylation in manifesting and healthy carriers of dystrophinopathies: concordance of activation ratios among first degree female relatives and skewed inactivation as cause of the affected phenotypes

The X-chromosome activity states of 11 manifesting carriers of dystrophinopathies, all with normal karyotypes, were estimated by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP)-methylation analysis with the probes M27 beta (DXS255), p2-19(DXS605) and pSPT/PGK (PGK1) to test the role of skewed X-inactivation ratios as the cause of their affected phenotypes. In eight cases preferential inactivation of the putative X chromosome carrying the normal dystrophin allele in > or = 90% of their peripheral lymphocytes was observed, two cases showed non-apparent deviant ratios (60:40 and 70:30) from the theoretically expected values around the mean of 50% and in one case the three markers employed yielded no information. The analysis of the X-inactivation ratio in six mother-daughter pairs, all non-manifesting Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) carriers, and in the close female relatives of the patients showed: (a) neither of the two X chromosomes was preferentially inactivated with respect to their parental origin; (b) a high concordance among the activation ratios of mothers and daughters, a result difficult to explain just in terms of random X-chromosome inactivation.

Non-random X chromosome inactivation in an affected twin in a monozygotic twin pair discordant for Wiedemann-Beckwith syndrome

Wiedemann-Beckwith syndrome (WBS) is a syndrome including exomphalos, macroglossia, and generalized overgrowth. The locus has been assigned to 11p15.5, and genomic imprinting may play a part in the expression of one or more genes involved. Most cases are sporadic. An excess of female monozygotic twins discordant for WBS have been reported, and it has been proposed that this excess could be related to the process of X chromosome inactivation. We have therefore studied X chromosome inactivation in 13-year-old monozygotic twin girls who were discordant for WBS. In addition, both twins had Tourette syndrome. The twins were monochorionic and therefore the result of a late twinning process. This has also been the case in previously reported discordant twin pairs with information on placentation. X chromosome inactivation was determined in DNA from peripheral blood cells by PCR analysis at the androgen receptor locus. The affected twin had a completely skewed X inactivation, where the paternal allele was on the active X chromosome in all cells. The unaffected twin had a moderately skewed X inactivation in the same direction, whereas the mother had a random pattern. Further studies are necessary to establish a possible association between the expression of WBS and X chromosome inactivation.

MZ female twins discordant for X-linked diseases: a review

The 20 reported cases of MZ female twins discordant for X-linked diseases are reviewed. In such twins the X-inactivation pattern is opposite skewing (abnormal allele inactivated in most cells of the normal twin, and normal allele inactivated in most cells of the affected twin) or skewing in one twin and random in the cotwin. The diseases involved map in two specific regions: Xq27-28 and Xp21. The only exceptions are Fabry's disease and Aicardi's syndrome, which map in Xq22 and Xp22 respectively. No concordant MZ female carrier twins, either normal or affected, have been described. Three main hypotheses have been proposed to explain such characteristics [2, 5, 14], but none is completely satisfactory. The constant discordance for X-linked diseases in MZ female twins has important consequences for genetic counselling.

X inactivation patterns in female monozygotic twins and their families

X inactivation studies have been carried out on 22 pairs of female monozygotic twins, one set of female monozygotic triplets, and their mothers and singleton sisters, using the probe M27 beta. Forty-eight per cent of the twins, 55% of their mothers, and 42% of their singleton sisters showed skewed X inactivation. Two of the triplets and their mother had random X inactivation, while the third triplet showed skewed X inactivation. Their singleton sister was homozygous with M27 beta. Of the twins, six pairs showed skewed X inactivation in favour of the same X chromosome, one pair showed skewed X inactivation favouring opposite X chromosomes, in seven pairs one twin showed skewed X inactivation while her co-twin showed random X inactivation, and in eight pairs both twins were random. A higher frequency of skewed pattern of X inactivation was not observed in the monozygotic twins when compared to a series of non-twin females (mothers and singleton sisters) and, so, the results in this study do not lend support to the theory that skewed X inactivation predisposes to the twinning process.

Additional case of female monozygotic twins discordant for the clinical manifestations of Duchenne muscular dystrophy due to opposite X-chromosome inactivation

A pair of female monozygotic (MZ) twins, heterozygous carriers for a deletion in the DMD gene and discordant for the clinical manifestations of Duchenne muscular dystrophy, were analyzed by molecular studies, in situ hybridization, and methylation pattern of X chromosomes to search for opposite X inactivation as an explanation of their clinical discordance. Results in lymphocytes and skin fibroblast cell lines suggest a partial mirror inactivation with the normal X chromosome preferentially active in the unaffected twin, and the maternal deleted X chromosome preferentially active in the affected twin. A review shows that MZ female twins discordant for X-linked diseases are not uncommon. Twinning and X inactivation may be interrelated and could explain the female twins discordant for X-linked traits.

Mirror-image dental fusion and discordance in monozygotic twins

A pair of monozygotic twins had similar but not identical dental anomalies. One twin had fusion of deciduous mandibular lateral incisor and canine on the left, with normal dentition on the right; the co-twin had right mandibular incisor/canine fusion, with aplasia of the lateral incisor on the left. These findings are discussed in the context of the related phenomena of situs inversus, mirror-imaging in twins, and gradients of severity of anomalies in the four copies of the mandibular developmental dental field.

Clefts of the lip and palate in twins: use of DNA fingerprinting for zygosity determination

The study of twins is a well-established method for evaluating the relative roles of heredity and environmental factors in the etiology of diseases. Conclusions depend on zygosity determination and on the classification of minor forms of diseases. This paper reports on ten (5 mono- and 5 dizygotic) out of thirteen twin pairs among 1039 patients with cleft lip and palate (n = 677) or cleft palate (n = 362). Zygosity was determined using "DNA fingerprinting" on blood samples in all 10 pairs and on cleft-associated tissue in one pair. Including minor forms of clefting, two of five pairs of monozygotic and two of five pairs of dizygotic twins of the same sex showed concordance. "DNA fingerprinting" should be established as a definitive method for zygosity determination, and the calculation of concordance rates should always include minor forms of diseases.

In utero fetal muscle biopsy for the diagnosis of Duchenne muscular dystrophy in a female fetus "suddenly at risk"

DNA methods to diagnose Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) are not always informative, and we have published previously the first instance of in utero muscle biopsy to assess dystrophin in a male fetus having the same "X" as an affected sib. We present here a female fetus with a de novo X,1 translocation with breakpoint at Xp21, detected on amniocentesis for advanced maternal age. The translocation breakpoint placed her at high risk for DMD. In utero muscle biopsy at 20 weeks of gestation produced a specimen positive for dystrophin immunofluorescence indicating a likely normal fetus. The pregnancy was continued, and at term the baby girl was found to have normal serum creatine kinase levels, and was therefore unaffected with DMD. Our experiences add de novo Xp21 translocation to the indications for in utero muscle biopsy for diagnosis of DMD.

Charcot-Marie-Tooth type 1A duplication appears to arise from recombination at repeat sequences flanking the 1.5 Mb monomer unit

We have constructed a 3.1 megabase (Mb) physical map of chromosome 17p11.2-p12, which contains a submicroscopic duplication in patients with Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 1A (CMT1A). We find that the CMT1A duplication is a tandem repeat of 1.5 Mb of DNA. A YAC contig encompassing the CMT1A duplication and spanning the endpoints was also developed. Several low copy repeats in 17p11.2-p12 were identified including the large (> 17 kb) CMT1A-REP unit which may be part of a mosaic repeat. CMT1A-REP flanks the 1.5 Mb CMT1A monomer unit on normal chromosome 17 and is present in an additional copy on the CMT1A duplicated chromosome. We propose that the de novo CMT1A duplication arises from unequal crossing over due to misalignment at these CMT1A-REP repeat sequences during meiosis.

Female twin with Hunter disease due to nonrandom inactivation of the X-chromosome: a consequence of twinning

We report the occurrence of Hunter disease (mucopolysaccharidosis type II) in a karyotypically normal girl who was one of identical twins. Molecular studies showed nonrandom X-inactivation in both her fibroblasts and lymphocytes, while her normal twin showed equal usage of both X chromosomes. In view of previous reports of 7 pairs of identical female twins in which one had Duchenne muscular dystrophy, it seems that twinning may be strongly associated with nonrandom X-inactivation, and is not specific to the properties of the disease causing gene.

X inactivation and dystrophin studies in a t(X;12) female: evidence for biochemical normalization in Duchenne muscular dystrophy carriers

A 4-year-old girl was identified with high creatine kinase (CK) values, and mild muscle weakness in a limb-girdle distribution. Results of dystrophin analysis of the muscle biopsy were consistent with a manifesting heterozygote for Duchenne muscular dystrophy. In peripheral lymphocytes she had a t(X;12) (p21.2;q24.33). Late DNA replication studies demonstrated inactivation of the normal X chromosome in 99.4% of cells. Dystrophin immunofluorescence showed 64% dystrophin-negative muscle fibers. Dystrophin content of muscle by immunoblot was approximately 5% of normal. The discordance between the percent of normal X inactivation and percent of dystrophin-negative cells may be explained by compensatory protection of dystrophin by rare nuclei with the normal X active in multi-nucleated muscle fibers with shared cytoplasm.

The first decade of molecular genetics in neurology: changing clinical thought and practice

Molecular genetics has had a powerful impact on clinical neurology. Definitions of disease are changing from clinical criteria to DNA analysis, resolving questions about the nature of clinically similar but not identical diseases. Genetic counseling is more reliable. Concepts of mendelian inheritance are being tested and new forms of mutation have been discovered to explain anticipation. Nonmendelian forms of inheritance have emerged; concepts of pathogenesis are on a more secure footing; and novel treatments are being explored.

Dystrophin deficiency causes lethal muscle hypertrophy in cats

Two 5-month-old male Domestic Shorthair littermates showed general skeletal muscle hypertrophy, multifocal submucosal lingual calcification with lingual enlargement, and excessive salivation. Both cats had a reduced level of activity, walked with a stiff gait, and tended to "bunny hop" when they ran. These clinical features were similar to those of previously reported dystrophin-deficient cats. Using multiple dystrophin antibodies, we found that the cats described in this report also showed marked dystrophin deficiency. The histopathology was remarkable for hypertrophy and splitting of fibers, and progressive accumulation of calcium deposits within the muscle. There was little or no endomysial fibrosis at 2 years of age. The natural history of dystrophin-deficiency in cats has not been described: both previous cats had been euthanized at 2 years of age prior to experiencing any life-threatening problems. At 6 months of age, one of the new cats developed megaesophagus because of severe progressive hypertrophy of the diaphragmatic muscles. The diaphragm completely occluded the esophagus, and the cat was euthanized for humane reasons. The second cat remained in good condition until age 18 months when it developed acute renal failure attributed to severe prolonged dehydration and hyperosmolality. The cat recovered after receiving supportive treatment but was unable to maintain fluid homeostasis. The insufficient water intake was attributed to glossal hypertrophy and dysfunction. At age 2 years, the cat received regular subcutaneous injections of low-sodium fluids to maintain proper hydration. The clinical consequence of dystrophin deficiency in cats is lethal muscle hypertrophy. We have called the feline disease "hypertrophic feline muscular dystrophy" (HFMD).

Molecular detection of altered X-inactivation patterns in the diagnosis of genetic disease

It is widely assumed that when a female carrier of a genetic disorder exhibits clinical signs of the disorder it is due to chance non-random X-inactivation in particular tissues. Recently molecular methods have become available for the analysis of X-chromosome inactivation status. These are based either on the methylation patterns of DNA from the active and inactive chromosomes or on the rescue of active X chromosomes in somatic cell hybrids. As a consequence of the molecular studies, it has become obvious that there are some special cases of non-random X-inactivation patterns. These include females carrying X-linked immunodeficiencies and, sometimes, one of a pair of identical female twins.

Recent advances in dystrophin research

Evidence suggesting that dystrophin is a component of the membrane cytoskeleton of excitable cells continues to accumulate. Whereas the specific mechanisms leading to muscle pathology in Duchenne muscular dystrophy are still being debated it is apparent that the progressive weakness that occurs in this disease is the result of a chronic process that is initiated by dystrophin deficiency.

Dystrophin and disease

Recent advances concerning the genetic and biochemical basis of Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies have resulted in a good understanding of the etiology of these common dystrophies. An important secondary consequence of the genetic and biochemical research has been the generation of gene-based and protein-based diagnostic tools which enable a 'molecular diagnosis' for patients and their families. This review summarizes our current understanding of the genetics, biochemistry, and pathophysiology of Duchenne dystrophy, and gives an overview of the molecular diagnostic tools and their applications. Recent correlations of clinical, genetic and biochemical data have indicated that dystrophinopathies can present with a wide range of neuromuscular symptoms, and that neither male sex nor proximal weakness are diagnostic prerequisites for consideration of an underlying dystrophin abnormality.