Two distinct mutations in a single dystrophin gene: identification of an altered splice-site as the primary Becker muscular dystrophy mutation

Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy Gene Therapy

Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies are allelic X-linked recessive neuromuscular diseases affecting both skeletal and cardiac muscles. Therefore, owing to their single X chromosome, the affected boys receive pathogenic gene mutations from their unknowing carrier mothers. Current pharmacological drugs are palliative that address the symptoms of the disease rather than the genetic cause imbedded in the Dystrophin gene DNA sequence. Therefore, alternative therapies like gene drugs that could address the genetic cause of the disease at its root are crucial, which include gene transfer/implantation, exon skipping, and gene editing. Presently, it is possible through genetic reprogramming to engineer AAV vectors to deliver certain therapeutic cargos specifically to muscle or other organs regardless of their serotype. Similarly, it is possible to direct the biogenesis of exosomes to carry gene editing constituents or certain therapeutic cargos to specific tissue or cell type like brain and muscle. While autologous exosomes are immunologically inert, it is possible to camouflage AAV capsids, and lipid nanoparticles to evade the immune system recognition. In this review, we highlight current opportunities for Duchenne muscular dystrophy gene therapy, which has been known thus far as an incurable genetic disease. This article is a part of Gene Therapy of Rare Genetic Diseases thematic issue.

EMQN best practice guidelines for genetic testing in dystrophinopathies

Dystrophinopathies are X-linked diseases, including Duchenne muscular dystrophy and Becker muscular dystrophy, due to DMD gene variants. In recent years, the application of new genetic technologies and the availability of new personalised drugs have influenced diagnostic genetic testing for dystrophinopathies. Therefore, these European best practice guidelines for genetic testing in dystrophinopathies have been produced to update previous guidelines published in 2010.These guidelines summarise current recommended technologies and methodologies for analysis of the DMD gene, including testing for deletions and duplications of one or more exons, small variant detection and RNA analysis. Genetic testing strategies for diagnosis, carrier testing and prenatal diagnosis (including non-invasive prenatal diagnosis) are then outlined. Guidelines for sequence variant annotation and interpretation are provided, followed by recommendations for reporting results of all categories of testing. Finally, atypical findings (such as non-contiguous deletions and dual DMD variants), implications for personalised medicine and clinical trials and incidental findings (identification of DMD gene variants in patients where a clinical diagnosis of dystrophinopathy has not been considered or suspected) are discussed.

Detection of pathogenic mutations and the mechanism of a rare chromosomal rearrangement in a Chinese family with Becker muscular dystrophy

OBJECTIVE

The objectives of this research are to genetically diagnose a family with Becker muscular dystrophy (BMD), to explore the molecular mechanism of the disease, and to predict the possibility of BMD development in two individuals who have not yet reached the age of onset (young individuals).

METHODS

The multiplex polymerase chain reaction was first employed to screen dystrophin (DMD) gene deletions, and the locations of deletion breakpoints were identified using the Sequenom platform and long-range PCR. Sanger sequencing was then performed for the undeleted exons.

RESULTS

All BMD patients and a young individual carry a deletion spanning exons 45 to 53 and an unreported missense mutation on exon 11 of the DMD gene. This point mutation was screened in 412 healthy individuals and heterozygous genotype was found in two females. Determination of deletion breakpoints demonstrated a 330-kb deletion and there was a 9-bp insertion between the breakpoints. This 9-bp could match a reference sequence located within the deleted region.

CONCLUSIONS

Two mutations of the DMD gene coexist in this family. One young child has a high disease risk. Pathogenic potential of the point mutation requires further investigation. The rare chromosomal rearrangement may be caused by short-nucleotide sequence capture or other unknown mechanisms.

[Family study allows more optimistic prognosis and genetic counselling in a child with a deletion of exons 50-51 of the dystrophin gene]

INTRODUCTION

In frame deletions of exons encoding the central rod domain of dystrophin have been associated with a highly variable phenotype, including asymptomatic individuals. The lack of family history impairs accurate genetic counselling.

OBSERVATION

We report on a 4-year-old child suffering from transient episodes of limping at the age of 2 and several episodes of fall since the age of 3. Clinical examination did not show muscle weakness. CPK levels were increased (1300 UI). EMG was normal. Muscle histology showed a rhabdomyolysis without features of muscular dystrophy. Immunolabelling for dystrophin, merosin and dysferlin were normal. Western blot analysis of muscular proteins showed reduced-size dystrophin bands and a slightly reduced intensity for dystrophin, alpha and gamma-sarcoglycan. Multiplex PCR of the dystrophin gene showed an in-frame deletion of exons 50-51, predicted to be associated to a Becker type of dystrophinopathy. Intragenic markers and quantitative PCR suggested maternal inheritance. This was confirmed by testing the maternal grand-parents, revealing that the asymptomatic 69-year-old grand father was a carrier. Three additional healthy males, whose ages ranged from 28 to 55 years and who were asymptomatic, also carried the mutation. The proband became spontaneously asymptomatic and cardiac echography was normal. In light of these data, genetic counselling was more reassuring and the mutation carrier maternal aunt, who was pregnant, decided to continue the pregnancy.

CONCLUSION

This case report emphasizes the importance of family molecular analysis, especially in males from the maternal lineage, for genetic counselling of dystrophinopathies associated to atypical features or to an isolate increase of muscular enzymes level in a young boy with no positive family history.

Mutation analysis in the FKRP gene provides an explanation for a rare cause of intrafamilial clinical variability in LGMD2I

We report a limb-girdle muscular dystrophy 2I family with three affected sisters and a highly variable clinical course. FKRP gene sequencing showed that all three sisters carried a nonsense paternal mutation (W225X). The two oldest sisters with a severe phenotype carried two maternal mutations V79M and P89A. However, the youngest sister with a milder course carried the paternal and only the V79M maternal mutation, due to an intragenic recombination.

Redirecting Splicing to Address Dystrophin Mutations: Molecular By-pass Surgery

Mutations in the dystrophin gene that prevent synthesis of a functional protein lead to Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), the most common serious childhood muscular dystrophy. The major isoform is produced in skeletal muscle and the size of the dystrophin gene and complexity of expression have posed great challenges to the development of a therapy for DMD. Considerable progress has been made in the areas of gene and cell replacement, yet it appears that any potential therapy for DMD is still some years away. Other approaches are being considered, and one that has generated substantial interest over the last few years is induced exon skipping. Antisense oligonucleotides have been used to block abnormal splice sites and force pre-mRNA processing back to the normal patterns. This approach is re-interpreted to address the more common dystrophin mutations, where normal splice sites are targeted to induce abnormal splicing, resulting in specific exon exclusion. Selected exon removal during processing of the dystrophin pre-mRNA can by-pass nonsense mutations or restore a disrupted reading frame arising from genomic deletions or duplications. Attributes of the dystrophin gene that have hampered gene replacement therapy may be regarded as positive features for induced exon skipping, which may be regarded as a form of by-pass surgery at the molecular level. In humans, antisense oligonucleotides have been more generally applied to down-regulate specific gene expression, for the treatment of acquired conditions such as malignancies and viral infections. From interesting in vitro experiments several years ago, the dystrophin exon-skipping field has progressed to the stage of planning for clinical trials.

P-15 cell-binding domain derived from collagen: analysis of MG63 osteoblastic-cell response by means of a microarray technology

BACKGROUND

P-15 is an analog of the cell-binding domain of collagen. P-15 has been shown to facilitate physiological processes in a way similar to collagen; to serve as an anchorage for cells; and to promote the binding, migration, and differentiation of cells.

METHODS

Expression profiling by DNA microarray is a molecular technology that allows the analysis of gene expression in a cell system. By using DNA microarrays containing 19,200 genes, we identified in osteoblast-like cell line (MG-63) cultured with P-15 several genes whose expression was significantly up- or downregulated.

RESULTS

The differentially expressed genes cover a broad range of functional activities: 1) signaling transduction, 2) differentiation, 3) apoptosis, and 4) cell-cycle regulation. It was also possible to detect some genes whose function is unknown.

CONCLUSIONS

The data reported are, to our knowledge, the first genetic portrait of P-15 effects. They can help us to better understand the molecular mechanism of osteogenesis and can serve as a model for comparing different cell cultures and/or other materials with similar effect.

Antisense-induced exon skipping and synthesis of dystrophin in the mdx mouse

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a severe muscle wasting disease arising from defects in the dystrophin gene, typically nonsense or frameshift mutations, that preclude the synthesis of a functional protein. A milder, allelic version of the disease, Becker muscular dystrophy, generally arises from in-frame deletions that allow synthesis of a shorter but still semifunctional protein. Therapies to introduce functional dystrophin into dystrophic tissue through either cell or gene replacement have not been successful to date. We report an alternative approach where 2'-O-methyl antisense oligoribonucleotides have been used to modify processing of the dystrophin pre-mRNA in the mdx mouse model of DMD. By targeting 2'-O-methyl antisense oligoribonucleotides to block motifs involved in normal dystrophin pre-mRNA splicing, we induced excision of exon 23, and the mdx nonsense mutation, without disrupting the reading frame. Exon 23 skipping was first optimized in vitro in transfected H-2K(b)-tsA58 mdx myoblasts and then induced in vivo. Immunohistochemical staining demonstrated the synthesis and correct subsarcolemmal localization of dystrophin and gamma-sarcoglycan in the mdx mouse after intramuscular delivery of antisense oligoribonucleotide:liposome complexes. This approach should reduce the severity of DMD by allowing a dystrophic gene transcript to be modified, such that it can be translated into a Becker-dystrophin-like protein.

Antisense-induced exon skipping and synthesis of dystrophin in the mdx mouse

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a severe muscle wasting disease arising from defects in the dystrophin gene, typically nonsense or frameshift mutations, that preclude the synthesis of a functional protein. A milder, allelic version of the disease, Becker muscular dystrophy, generally arises from in-frame deletions that allow synthesis of a shorter but still semifunctional protein. Therapies to introduce functional dystrophin into dystrophic tissue through either cell or gene replacement have not been successful to date. We report an alternative approach where 2'-O-methyl antisense oligoribonucleotides have been used to modify processing of the dystrophin pre-mRNA in the mdx mouse model of DMD. By targeting 2'-O-methyl antisense oligoribonucleotides to block motifs involved in normal dystrophin pre-mRNA splicing, we induced excision of exon 23, and the mdx nonsense mutation, without disrupting the reading frame. Exon 23 skipping was first optimized in vitro in transfected H-2K(b)-tsA58 mdx myoblasts and then induced in vivo. Immunohistochemical staining demonstrated the synthesis and correct subsarcolemmal localization of dystrophin and gamma-sarcoglycan in the mdx mouse after intramuscular delivery of antisense oligoribonucleotide:liposome complexes. This approach should reduce the severity of DMD by allowing a dystrophic gene transcript to be modified, such that it can be translated into a Becker-dystrophin-like protein.

Novel point mutations in the dystrophin gene

Duchenne (DMD) and Becker (BMD) type muscular dystrophies are allelic X-linked recessive disorders caused by mutations in the gene encoding dystrophin. About 65% of the cases are caused by deletions, while 5-10% are duplications. The remaining 30% of affected individuals may have smaller mutations (point mutations or small deletions/insertions) which cannot be identified by current diagnostic screening strategies. In order to look for pathogenic small mutations in the dystrophin gene, we have screened the 18 exons located in the hot spot region of this gene through two different single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) conditions. Five different pathogenic mutations were identified in 6 out of 192 DMD/BMD patients without detectable deletions: 2 nonsense, 1 bp insertion, 1 bp deletion and 1 intronic. Except for the intronic change, which alters a splice site, all the others cause a premature stop codon. In addition, 8 apparently neutral changes were identified. However, interestingly, one of them was not identified in 195 normal chromosomes, although it was previously described in a DMD patient from a different population. The possibility that this mutation may be pathogenic is discussed. Except for two neutral changes, all the others are apparently here described for the first time.

Paternal inheritance or different mutations in maternally related patients occur in about 3% of Duchenne familial cases

Duchenne dystrophy (DMD) is an X-linked lethal condition which affects 1 in 3,500 boys. The DMD gene is deleted in about 60-65% of patients while in the remaining 35-40% the condition is caused by point mutations, small insertions, or duplications. We have ascertained 967 DMD families (680 isolated and 287 familial cases). Screening for deletions showed a molecular deletion in 383 among 615 (62.3%) analyzed cases. However, 10 families were unusual: In 7 of them, 2 or more DMD patients were related through paternal lines while in 3 others, affected boys related through maternal lines carried different mutations or originated through independent new mutation events. The finding of 10 atypical genealogies, which represent about 1% of the sample (10/967) or about 3% of familial cases (10/287) is higher than we would expect by chance. Even so, it is an underestimate because screening of mutations in all the affected DMD relatives from each genealogy is not done in many of the familial cases. It suggests that other mechanisms (such as transposon-like elements, for example) could be responsible for a higher genomic instability leading to novel mutations as reported previously by us and others in DMD and in other genetic disorders such as hemophilia and inherited peripheral neuropathies. On the other hand, it shows the importance of testing all affected patients within each genealogy to prevent possible mistakes in carrier detection, genetic counseling, and prenatal diagnosis.

Elevation of serum creatine kinase as the only manifestation of an intragenic deletion of the dystrophin gene in three unrelated families

This study reports three children from three unrelated families, aged from 9 to 12 years, who were investigated because of the incidental finding of elevated serum creatine kinase (CK) levels and were found to have a dystrophinopathy. The molecular defect consisted of a deletion of variable extent within the central rod domain of the dystrophin gene, involving either exons 32-44 or 48-51 or 48-53. In each family we found the same deletion in at least one adult male relative aged from 40 to 77 years, who was either completely asymptomatic or had very mild muscle involvement (thin muscles and/or mild scoliosis), with normal or borderline CK levels. This study suggests once again that deletions of the central rod domain of dystrophin may be associated with elevation of serum CK as the only manifestation and that prediction of the clinical severity based solely on the molecular findings should be interpreted with caution.

Dystrophin gene transcripts skipping the mdx mutation

The mdx mouse, an animal model used to study Duchenne muscular dystrophy, has a nonsense mutation in exon 23 of the dystrophin gene which should result in a truncated protein that cannot be correctly localized at the sarcolemma of the muscle fibers. Immunohistochemical staining with antidystrophin antibodies has shown that while most of the muscle tissue is dystrophin-negative, a small percentage of muscle fibers is clearly dystrophin-positive and has somehow bypassed the primary nonsense mutation. A sensitive nested polymerase chain reaction-based examination of dystrophin gene transcripts around the mdx mutation has revealed several alternatively processed transcripts. Four mRNA species skipped the mutation in exon 23, were in-frame, and could be translated into a shorter but still functional dystrophin protein. Specific tests for these transcripts demonstrated these were also present in normal mouse muscle tissue.

Splicing mutations in DMD/BMD detected by RT-PCR/PTT: detection of a 19AA insertion in the cysteine rich domain of dystrophin compatible with BMD

We have used an RNA based mutation detection method to screen the total coding region of the dystrophin gene of a Duchenne and a Becker muscular dystrophy patient in whom DNA based mutation detection methods have so far failed to detect mutations. By RT-PCR and the protein truncation test (PTT) we could identify point mutations in both cases. DMD patient DL184.3 has a T-->A mutation in intron 59 at position -9, creating a novel splice acceptor site for exon 60. As a result seven intronic bases are spliced into the mRNA, causing a frameshift and premature translation termination 20 codons downstream. Since this patient had died and only fibroblasts were available, we applied MyoD induced myodifferentiation of stored fibroblasts to enhance muscle specific gene expression. With the results of this mutation analysis, prenatal diagnosis could subsequently be performed in this family. BMD patient BL207.1 carries a G-->C mutation at position +5 of intron 64, disrupting the splice donor consensus sequence and activating a cryptic splice donor site 57bp downstream. The inclusion of these 57 intronic bases in the mRNA leaves the reading frame open and results in the insertion of 19 amino acids into the cysteine rich domain of dystrophin. Interestingly, this insertion in a part of the dystrophin considered to interact with the dystrophin binding complex of the sarcolemma is apparently compatible with mild BMD-like clinical features. Both mutations reported are missed by analysis of multiplex PCR products designed for deletion screening of the coding region. Extrapolation from existing point mutation detection efficiencies by DNA and RNA based methods emphasises that RNA based methods are more sensitive and that most of the remaining undetected mutations may affect splice or branch sites or create cryptic splice sites.

A novel splice site mutation in a Becker muscular dystrophy patient

A Becker muscular dystrophy patient was found to have a single base substitution at the 5' end of intron 54. This single base substitution disrupts the invariant GT dinucleotide within the 5' donor splice site and was shown to cause an out of frame deletion of exon 54 during mRNA processing. This is predicted to produce a truncated dystrophin protein which is more consistent with a DMD phenotype. However, small quantities of normal mRNA are also transcribed and these are sufficient to produce a reduced amount of normal molecular weight dystrophin and give rise to a milder BMD phenotype. This indicates that a single base substitution at an invariant dinucleotide of the splice site consensus sequence may still allow read through of the message and allow the production of some normal protein. This shows that there are a greater number of possible intronic mutations that can lead to a mild phenotype and it also underlines the importance of performing cDNA analysis when screening for small gene alterations in the BMD patient population.

Investigation of muscle disease

Images

DMD and BMD in the same family due to distinct mutations

We report on a family with a boy affected by Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) and an asymptomatic cousin with a Becker-type dystrophin abnormality, diagnosed by chance. Dystrophin gene analysis showed that these conditions were caused by two distinct deletions with breakpoints in different exons. In Xp21 families, DNA analysis and dystrophin testing of asymptomatic males with high CK plasma levels might detect different dystrophin mutations in separate haplotypes as in our family, although we stress there should be clear clinical or familial indications for such testing.

Characterization of genetic deletions in Becker muscular dystrophy using monoclonal antibodies against a deletion-prone region of dystrophin

We have produced a new panel of 20 monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) against a region of the dystrophin protein corresponding to a deletion-prone region of the Duchenne muscular dystrophy gene (exons 45-50). We show that immuno-histochemistry or Western blotting with these "exon-specific" mAbs can provide a valuable addition to Southern blotting or PCR methods for the accurate identification of genetic deletions in Becker muscular dystrophy patients. The antibodies were mapped to the following exons: exon 45 (2 mAbs), exon 46 (6), exon 47 (1), exons 47/48 (4), exons 48-50 (6), and exon 50 (1). PCR amplification of single exons or groups of exons was used both to produce specific dystrophin immunogens and to map the mAbs obtained. PCR-mediated mutagenesis was also used to identify regions of dystrophin important for mAb binding. Because the mAbs can be used to characterize the dystrophin produced by individual muscle fibres, they will also be useful for studying "revertant" fibres in Duchenne muscle and for monitoring the results of myoblast therapy trials in MD patients with deletions in this region of the dystrophin gene.

A mutation in the alpha tropomyosin gene TPM3 associated with autosomal dominant nemaline myopathy

Nemaline myopathies are diseases characterized by the presence in muscle fibres of pathognomonic rod bodies. These are composed largely of alpha-actinin and actin. We have identified a missense mutation in the alpha-tropomyosin gene, TPM3, which segregates completely with the disease in a family whose autosomal dominant nemaline myopathy we had previously localized to chromosome 1p13-q25. The mutation substitutes an arginine residue for a highly conserved methionine in a putative actin-binding site near the N terminus of the alpha-tropomyosin. The mutation may strengthen tropomyosin - actin binding, leading to rod body formation, by adding a further basic residue to the postulated actin-binding motif.

Some unanswered questions in Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Though the molecular and biochemical bases of Duchenne muscular dystrophy are known, many questions still remain unanswered. They range from the nature and cause of gene deletions to the relationship between dystrophin defects and the clinical phenotype, both in affected males and female carriers. These questions are discussed in the light of recent developments.

A possible missense mutation detected in the dystrophin gene by Double-Strand Conformation Analysis (DSCA)

A new and simple method for detecting point mutations is presented. The method, based on Double-Strand Conformation Analysis (DSCA) of PCR amplification products in polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, was applied to 78 unrelated subjects affected with Duchenne or Becker muscular dystrophy and to 9 subjects suspected to be affected with an atypical dystrophinopathy. An A-->G substitution in the nucleotide 2525, which changes the codon for lysine to a codon for glutamic acid was detected in an 8-year-old boy, with normal neurological examination, but showing increased CK level and an abnormal EMG. The muscle biopsy was normal, without features of necrosis or regeneration. Immunoreactions with anti-dystrophin antibodies showed a normal distribution and intensity of the staining. A review of the dystrophin mutations detected so far is included.

Searching for the 1 in 2,400,000: a review of dystrophin gene point mutations

The past few years have seen a rapid increase in our knowledge of naturally occurring mutations in the dystrophin gene. Although earlier studies were limited to gross rearrangement mutations, we are now in a position to draw lessons on the molecular etiology of the remaining one-third of cases of Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy (DMD, BMD) which are associated with small mutations. This paper reviews 70 published and unpublished small mutations in the dystrophin gene and asks what we can learn about their nature, their distribution, and approaches to their characterisation. Strikingly for such a well-conserved gene, missense mutations are extremely rare, and the vast majority of DMD point mutations, like the gross rearrangements, result in premature translational termination. It seems increasingly likely that almost all cases of DMD arise solely as a result of a reduction in the level of dystrophin transcripts, and we argue that > 95% of DMD mutations contribute nothing to the functional dissection of the dystrophin protein. Most of the few BMD point mutations presented here are missense mutations in the N-terminal or C-terminal domains or are splice-site mutations that probably act, like BMD deletions, via the production of in-frame, interstitially deleted transcripts.

Identification of a point mutation and germinal mosaicism in a Duchenne muscular dystrophy family

Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies (DMD and BMD) are allelic X-linked disorders arising from mutations in the (2.4 Mb) dystrophin gene at Xp21. We have applied the reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) to identify a larger than normal dystrophin mRNA from a male with Duchenne muscular dystrophy and his younger affected brother. The increased size of the dystrophin mRNA was due to a splice-site mutation at the exon 26:intron 26 junction where a T to G substitution prevented normal RNA processing. A cryptic splice-site, downstream of the mutation, was activated during processing, resulting in the inclusion of 117 bases of intron 26. This insertion introduced an in-frame stop codon into the mature dystrophin mRNA. An allele-specific test was developed to identify the mutation and was applied to this family. Interestingly, the mother of the two affected boys did not carry the mutation, as determined by allele-specific amplification and direct DNA sequence analysis, indicating gonadal mosaicism. Her eldest daughter, designated as a carrier based upon conventional testing and haplotype analysis, also did not carry the family mutation. Initial haplotyping of the family appeared to be straightforward with gonadal mosaicism becoming evident only after allele-specific analysis. The application of linked markers to identify the disease allele for conventional genetic counselling would have been erroneous in this family and highlights the diagnostic power of precise identification of the disease-causing mutation.