No evidence of SALL4-mutations in isolated sporadic duane retraction ?syndrome? (DURS)

Exotropic Duane syndrome with synergistic divergence and no mutations in COL25A1

Typical Duane retraction syndrome, a common form of congenital cranial dysinnervation disorder (CCDD), is rarely due to a monogenic mutation. However, the unusual form of exotropic Duane syndrome with synergistic divergence was recently associated with bi-allelic mutations in the gene COL25A1, raising the possibility that this particular Duane syndrome phenotype could be a monogenic recessive CCDD. To explore this possibility, we tested 4 consecutive unrelated subjects with the diagnosis for COL25A1 mutations. None harbored pathogenic variants, evidence that exotropic Duane syndrome with synergistic divergence is notspecifically caused by mutations in the gene.

The genetics of nonsyndromic bilateral Duane retraction syndrome

PURPOSE

To assess the importance of monogenic mutations and chromosomal copy number variants (CNVs) in the occurrence of nonsyndromic bilateral Duane retraction syndrome (bilateral nsDRS).

METHODS

The medical records of 12 patients with bilateral nsDRS were reviewed. Genes associated with DRS and associated congenital cranial dysinnervation disorders (SALL4, CHN1, HOXA1, TUBB3, and KIF21A) were sequenced in the standard fashion in each patient. Array comparative genomic hybridization (array CGH) was performed using Affymetrix Cytogenetics Whole-Genome 2.7M array, and the results were analyzed using Affymetrix Chromosome Analysis Suite v1.2. CNVs were assessed as unlikely to be pathologic if they were also present in the Database of Genomic Variants (DGV) or our local database of array CGH results in 150 normal individuals of Middle Eastern ethnicity.

RESULTS

No patient had a sequence mutation in SALL4, CHN1, HOXA1, TUBB3, or KIF21A. These 12 patients each had 36-42 chromosomal deletions and/or duplications (mean with standard deviation, 26.25 ± 6.77), but all of these CNVs were present either in the DGV or in our local database of normal individuals of similar ethnicity and, therefore, are considered nonpathogenic.

CONCLUSIONS

The results reported here suggest that bilateral nsDRS is not usually associated with mutations in these genes or with chromosomal CNVs. Current evidence suggests other factors such as epigenetic and/or teratogenic abnormalities may be a potential cause of bilateral nsDRS.

Strabismus genetics across a spectrum of eye misalignment disorders

Eye misalignment, called strabismus, is amongst the most common phenotypes observed, occurring in up to 5% of individuals in a studied population. While misalignment is frequently observed in rare complex syndromes, the majority of strabismus cases are non-syndromic. Over the past decade, genes and pathways associated with syndromic forms of strabismus have emerged, but the genes contributing to non-syndromic strabismus remain elusive. Genetic testing for strabismus risk may allow for earlier diagnosis and treatment, as well as decreased frequency of surgery. We review human and model organism literature describing non-syndromic strabismus, including family, twin, linkage, and gene expression studies. Recent advances in the genetics of Duane retraction syndrome are considered, as relatives of those impacted show elevated familial rates of non-syndromic strabismus. As whole genome sequencing efforts are advancing for the discovery of the elusive strabismus genes, this overview is intended to support the interpretation of the new findings.

Analysis of the SALL4 gene in patients with Duane retraction syndrome in a South Indian population

Duane retraction syndrome (DRS) is a congenital eye movement disorder characterized most typically by partial or complete failure of abduction and narrowing of palpebral fissure with globe retraction on adduction. Recently mutations of the SALL4 gene on chromosome 20 have been linked to DRS associated with radial forearm malformations (Okihiro syndrome). In this prospective, non-interventional study we screened for SALL4 mutations in 72 patients clinically diagnosed as having isolated DRS or DRS associated syndromes. All four exonic and the neighboring intronic regions of SALL4 gene were amplified by sixteen sets of primers using polymerase chain reaction and were subjected to bi-directional sequencing and BLAST analysis. No genetic variations were detected in the coding region and in the neighboring intronic regions of the SALL4 gene suggesting an alternative mechanism in the pathogenesis of these disorders in the South Indian population.

Magnetic resonance imaging of innervational and extraocular muscle abnormalities in Duane-radial ray syndrome

PURPOSE

The authors used magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to study extraocular muscles (EOMs) and nerves in Duane-radial ray (Okihiro) syndrome (DRRS) caused by mutations in the transcription factor SALL4.

METHODS

The authors examined four male and two female affected members of a pedigree previously reported to cosegregate DRRS and a heterozygous SALL4 mutation. Coronal T1-weighted magnetic resonance images of the orbits and heavily T2-weighted images in the plane of the cranial nerves were obtained in four subjects. MRI findings were correlated with motility examinations and published norms obtained using identical technique.

RESULTS

Five of the six subjects with DRRS had radial ray abnormalities including thumb, radial artery, radial bone, and pectoral muscle hypoplasia. Three had bilateral and three had unilateral ocular involvement. Seven eyes had limitation of both abduction and adduction, whereas two had limitations only of abduction. Most affected eyes had lid fissure narrowing and retraction in adduction. Intraorbital and intracranial abducens nerves (CN6) were small to absent, particularly ipsilateral to abduction deficiency. All subjects undergoing MRI had normal intracranial oculomotor nerves (CN3). Optic nerve (ON) cross-section findings were similar to normal. EOMs and pulleys were structurally normal in most subjects. In some affected orbits, a branch of CN3 closely approximated and presumably innervated the LR.

CONCLUSIONS

DRRS encompasses a Duane syndrome phenotype, with a variable and asymmetric endophenotype including marked CN6 hypoplasia and probable innervation or coinnervation of the LR by CN3. This endophenotype is more limited than reported in DURS2-linked Duane syndrome (On-line Mendelian Inheritance in Man, OMIM 604356) and CFEOM1 (OMIM 135700), which are clinically similar congenital cranial dysinnervation disorders that also feature CN3 hypoplasia and more widespread EOM abnormalities.

Two pedigrees segregating Duane's retraction syndrome as a dominant trait map to the DURS2 genetic locus

PURPOSE

The genetic bases of Duane's retraction syndrome (DRS) were investigated to determine its molecular etiologies. In prior studies, the transcription factors SALL4 and HOXA1 were identified as the genes mutated in DRS with radial anomalies, and in DRS with deafness, vascular anomalies, and cognitive deficits, respectively. Less is known, however, about the genetic etiology of DRS when it occurs in isolation, and only one genetic locus for isolated DRS, the DURS2 locus on chromosome 2, has been mapped to date. Toward the goal of identifying the DURS2 gene, two pedigrees have been ascertained that segregate DRS as a dominant trait.

METHODS

Members of two large dominant DRS pedigrees were enrolled in an ongoing study of the genetic basis of the congenital cranial dysinnervation disorders, and linkage analysis was conducted to determine whether their DRS phenotype maps to the DURS2 locus.

RESULTS

By haplotype analysis, the DRS phenotype in each family cosegregates with markers spanning the DURS2 region. Linkage analysis reveals maximum lod scores >2, establishing that the DRS phenotype in these two pedigrees maps to the DURS2 locus.

CONCLUSIONS

These two pedigrees double the published pedigrees known to map to the DURS2 locus and can thus contribute toward the search for the DURS2 gene. The affected members represent a genetically defined population of DURS2-linked DRS individuals, and hence studies of their clinical and structural features can enhance understanding of the DURS2 phenotype, as described in the companion paper.

A family with features overlapping Okihiro syndrome, hemifacial microsomia and isolated Duane anomaly caused by a novelSALL4 mutation

The SALL4 gene encodes a putative zinc finger transcription factor and is located on chromosome 20q13.13-13.2. Mutations in SALL4 have been identified in patients with Okihiro syndrome, which is characterized by radial ray anomalies associated with a Duane anomaly. Here, we report an unusual family in which affected persons show an extremely variable phenotype consistent with either Okihiro syndrome, hemifacial microsomia, or isolated Duane anomaly. A novel nonsense mutation in the SALL4 gene was detected in all affected family members and obligate carriers. This mutation is located in exon 3, only 29 bp 5' of the most 3' intron, and would therefore be expected to escape the nonsense mediated mRNA decay pathway, which might explain the phenotypic variability and mild degree of limb involvement.

A family with Duane anomaly and distal limb abnormalities: A further family with the arthrogryposis-ophthalmoplegia syndrome

A two-generation family is reported in which three members have Duane anomaly and distal limb abnormalities. All three affected have photopic electroretinogram responses that are abnormal or at the lower limit of the normal range with normal scotopic responses. Two affected family members also have hearing loss. The likeliest diagnosis is the syndrome listed as "arthrogryposis-ophthalmoplegia syndrome" on the London Dysmorphology Database or as "arthrogryposis with oculomotor limitation and electroretinal abnormalities" or "oculomelic aplasia" in OMIM [MIM 108145]. In view of the similarities with Okihiro syndrome, a search for mutations within the SALL4 gene was undertaken, but none were identified.