A 137-kb deletion within the Potocki-Shaffer syndrome interval on chromosome 11p11.2 associated with developmental delay and hypotonia

De novo variants in PHF21A cause intellectual developmental disorder with behavioral abnormalities and craniofacial dysmorphism with or without seizures: A case report and literature review

PURPOSE

PHF21A has been associated with intellectual developmental disorder with behavioral abnormalities and craniofacial dysmorphism with or without seizures (IDDBCS). Here, we report a new patient with IDDBCS and review previously reported patients.

METHODS

We reviewed the phenotypic and genetic spectrum of the newly diagnosed patient and previously reported patients with IDDBCS.

RESULTS

Among 12 patients (11 whose cases were previously reported and the patient whose case we report here), all patients (100%) had intellectual disability (ID) and motor development delay. Three of 8 patients (37.5%) for whom information on cognition was available had severe ID; ID was moderate in two patients (25%) and mild in three patients (37.5%). Seven of the 12 patients (58.33%) had an epileptic phenotype, and the majority (5/7, 71.42%) of affected individuals developed developmental and epileptic encephalopathy (DEE). Of the 5 patients with DEE, three developed infantile epileptic spasm syndrome (IESS). The seizures of 2 patients (2/5, 40%) were controlled by antiseizure medications. Overgrowth, ADHD, hypotonia, ASD, and sleep disorders were observed in 100%, 77.78%, 70%, 50%, and 33.33% of patients, respectively. All of the variants (100%) were de novo heterozygous variants. Three of the 12 patients (25%) had the same variant (p.Arg580*). The most common types of variants were frameshift variants (7/12, 58.33%), followed by nonsense variants (4/12, 33.33%) and missense variants (1/12, 8.33%). Genotype-phenotype relationships for IDDBCS were uncertain, as phenotypic variability was observed among patients with the same variant (p.Arg580*). The patient whose case we report here had a novel PHF21A gene variant (p.Gln97fs*20), which caused neurodevelopmental delay, macrocephaly, and IESS.

CONCLUSION

The core phenotypes of IDDBCS include neurodevelopmental delay (intellectual disability and impaired motor skills), craniofacial abnormalities, and overgrowth. ADHD, hypotonia, epilepsy, ASD, and sleep disorders are common symptoms of IDDBCS. Notably, DEE is the dominant phenotype of epilepsy, especially IESS. PHF21A may be a candidate gene for DEE. De novo variants are the main mode of inheritance. The most common types of variants are frameshift variants, and the variant p.Arg580* in PHF21A is located at a mutation hot spot.

The PHF21A neurodevelopmental disorder: an evaluation of clinical data from 13 patients

Potocki-Shaffer syndrome (PSS) is a rare neurodevelopmental disorder caused by deletions involving the 11p11.2-p12 region, encompassing the plant homeodomain finger protein 21A (PHF21A) gene. PHF21A has an important role in epigenetic regulation and PHF21A variants have previously been associated with a specific disorder that, whilst sharing some features of PSS, has notable differences. This study aims to expand the phenotype, particularly in relation to overgrowth, associated with PHF21A variants. Analysis of phenotypic data was undertaken on 13 individuals with PHF21A constitutional variants including four individuals described in the current series. Of those individuals where data were recorded, postnatal overgrowth was reported in 5/6 (83%). In addition, all had both an intellectual disability and behavioural issues. Frequent associations included postnatal hypotonia (7/11, 64%); and at least one afebrile seizure episode (6/12, 50%). Although a recognizable facial gestalt was not associated, subtle dysmorphic features were shared amongst some individuals and included a tall broad forehead, broad nasal tip, anteverted nares and full cheeks. We provide further insight into the emerging neurodevelopmental syndrome associated with PHF21A disruption. We present some evidence that PHF21A might be considered a new member of the overgrowth-intellectual disability syndrome (OGID) family.

PHF21A Related Disorder: Description of a New Case

PHF21A (PHD finger protein 21A) gene, located in the short arm of chromosome 11, encodes for BHC80, a component of the Lysine Specific Demethylase 1, Corepressor of REST (LSD1-CoREST) complex. BHC80 is mainly expressed in the human fetal brain and skeletal muscle and acts as a modulator of several neuronal genes during embryogenesis. Data from literature relates PHF21A variants with Potocki-Shaffer Syndrome (PSS), a contiguous gene deletion disorder caused by the haploinsufficiency of PHF21A, ALX4, and EXT2 genes. Clinical cardinal features of PSS syndrome are multiple exostoses (due to the EXT2 involvement), biparietal foramina (due to the ALX4 involvement), intellectual disability, and craniofacial anomalies (due to the PHF21A involvement). To date, to the best of our knowledge, a detailed description of PHF21A-related disorder clinical phenotype is not described in the literature; in fact, only 14 subjects with microdeletion frameshift or nonsense variants concerning only PHF21A gene have been reported. All reported cases did not present ALX4 or EXT2 variants, and their clinical features did not fit with PSS diagnosis. Herein, by using Exome sequencing, and Sanger sequencing of the region of interest, we describe a case of a child with a paternally inherited (mosaicism of 5%) truncating variant of the PHF21A gene (c.649_650del; p.Gln217ValfsTer6), and discuss the new evidence. In conclusion, these patients showed varied clinical expressions, mainly including the presence of intellectual disability, epilepsy, hypotonia, and dysmorphic features. Our study contributes to describing the genotype-phenotype spectrum of patients with PHF21A-related disorder; however, the limited data in the literature have been unable to provide a precise diagnostic protocol for patients with PHF21A-related disorder.

New Insights into Potocki-Shaffer Syndrome: Report of Two Novel Cases and Literature Review

Potocki-Shaffer syndrome (PSS) is a rare non-recurrent contiguous gene deletion syndrome involving chromosome 11p11.2. Current literature implies a minimal region with haploinsufficiency of three genes, ALX4 (parietal foramina), EXT2 (multiple exostoses), and PHF21A (craniofacial anomalies, and intellectual disability). The rest of the PSS phenotype is still not associated with a specific gene. We report a systematic review of the literature and included two novel cases. Because deletions are highly variable in size, we defined three groups of patients considering the PSS-genes involved. We found 23 full PSS cases (ALX4, EXT2, and PHF21A), 14 cases with EXT2-ALX4, and three with PHF21A only. Among the latter, we describe a novel male child showing developmental delay, café-au-lait spots, liner postnatal overgrowth and West-like epileptic encephalopathy. We suggest PSS cases may have epileptic spasms early in life, and PHF21A is likely to be the causative gene. Given their subtle presentation these may be overlooked and if left untreated could lead to a severe type or deterioration in the developmental plateau. If our hypothesis is correct, a timely therapy may ameliorate PSS phenotype and improve patients’ outcomes. Our analysis also shows PHF21A is a candidate for the overgrowth phenotype.

Disruption of PHF21A causes syndromic intellectual disability with craniofacial anomalies, epilepsy, hypotonia, and neurobehavioral problems including autism

Background

PHF21A has been associated with intellectual disability and craniofacial anomalies based on its deletion in the Potocki-Shaffer syndrome region at 11p11.2 and its disruption in three patients with balanced translocations. In addition, three patients with de novo truncating mutations in PHF21A were reported recently. Here, we analyze genomic data from seven unrelated individuals with mutations in PHF21A and provide detailed clinical descriptions, further expanding the phenotype associated with PHF21A haploinsufficiency.

Methods

Diagnostic trio whole exome sequencing, Sanger sequencing, use of GeneMatcher, targeted gene panel sequencing, and MiSeq sequencing techniques were used to identify and confirm variants. RT-qPCR was used to measure the normal expression pattern of PHF21A in multiple human tissues including 13 different brain tissues. Protein-DNA modeling was performed to substantiate the pathogenicity of the missense mutation.

Results

We have identified seven heterozygous coding mutations, among which six are de novo (not maternal in one). Mutations include four frameshifts, one nonsense mutation in two patients, and one heterozygous missense mutation in the AT Hook domain, predicted to be deleterious and likely to cause loss of PHF21A function. We also found a new C-terminal domain composed of an intrinsically disordered region. This domain is truncated in six patients and thus likely to play an important role in the function of PHF21A, suggesting that haploinsufficiency is the likely underlying mechanism in the phenotype of seven patients. Our results extend the phenotypic spectrum of PHF21A mutations by adding autism spectrum disorder, epilepsy, hypotonia, and neurobehavioral problems. Furthermore, PHF21A is highly expressed in the human fetal brain, which is consistent with the neurodevelopmental phenotype.

Conclusion

Deleterious nonsense, frameshift, and missense mutations disrupting the AT Hook domain and/or an intrinsically disordered region in PHF21A were found to be associated with autism spectrum disorder, epilepsy, hypotonia, neurobehavioral problems, tapering fingers, clinodactyly, and syndactyly, in addition to intellectual disability and craniofacial anomalies. This suggests that PHF21A is involved in autism spectrum disorder and intellectual disability, and its haploinsufficiency causes a diverse neurological phenotype.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s13229-019-0286-0) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

De novo truncating variants in PHF21A cause intellectual disability and craniofacial anomalies

Potocki-Shaffer syndrome (PSS) is a contiguous gene syndrome caused by 11p11.2 deletions. PSS is clinically characterized by intellectual disability, craniofacial anomalies, enlarged parietal foramina, and multiple exostoses. PSS occasionally shows autism spectrum disorder, epilepsy, and overgrowth. Some of the clinical features are thought to be associated with haploinsufficiency of two genes in the 11p11.2 region; variants affecting the function of ALX4 cause enlarged parietal foramina and EXT2 lead to multiple exostoses. However, the remaining clinical features were still yet to be linked to specific genetic alterations. In this study, we identified de novo truncating variants in an 11p11.2 gene, PHF21A, in three cases with intellectual disability and craniofacial anomalies. Among these three cases, autism spectrum disorder was recognized in one case, epilepsy in one case, and overgrowth in two cases. This study shows that PHF21A haploinsufficiency results in intellectual disability and craniofacial anomalies and possibly contributes to susceptibility to autism spectrum disorder, epilepsy, and overgrowth, all of which are PSS features.

Functional convergence of histone methyltransferases EHMT1 and KMT2C involved in intellectual disability and autism spectrum disorder

Kleefstra syndrome, caused by haploinsufficiency of euchromatin histone methyltransferase 1 (EHMT1), is characterized by intellectual disability (ID), autism spectrum disorder (ASD), characteristic facial dysmorphisms, and other variable clinical features. In addition to EHMT1 mutations, de novo variants were reported in four additional genes (MBD5, SMARCB1, NR1I3, and KMT2C), in single individuals with clinical characteristics overlapping Kleefstra syndrome. Here, we present a novel cohort of five patients with de novo loss of function mutations affecting the histone methyltransferase KMT2C. Our clinical data delineates the KMT2C phenotypic spectrum and reinforces the phenotypic overlap with Kleefstra syndrome and other related ID disorders. To elucidate the common molecular basis of the neuropathology associated with mutations in KMT2C and EHMT1, we characterized the role of the Drosophila KMT2C ortholog, trithorax related (trr), in the nervous system. Similar to the Drosophila EHMT1 ortholog, G9a, trr is required in the mushroom body for short term memory. Trr ChIP-seq identified 3371 binding sites, mainly in the promoter of genes involved in neuronal processes. Transcriptional profiling of pan-neuronal trr knockdown and G9a null mutant fly heads identified 613 and 1123 misregulated genes, respectively. These gene sets show a significant overlap and are associated with nearly identical gene ontology enrichments. The majority of the observed biological convergence is derived from predicted indirect target genes. However, trr and G9a also have common direct targets, including the Drosophila ortholog of Arc (Arc1), a key regulator of synaptic plasticity. Our data highlight the clinical and molecular convergence between the KMT2 and EHMT protein families, which may contribute to a molecular network underlying a larger group of ID/ASD-related disorders.

Neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs) like intellectual disability (ID) and autism spectrum disorder (ASD) present an enormous challenge to affected individuals, their families, and society. Understanding the mechanisms underlying NDDs may lead to the development of targeted therapeutics, but this is complicated by the great clinical and genetic heterogeneity seen in patients. Mutations in hundreds of genes have been implicated in NDDs, giving rise to diverse clinical presentations. However, evidence suggests that many of these genes lie in common biological pathways, and mutations in genes that are involved in similar biological functions give rise to more similar clinical phenotypes. Here, we define a novel ID disorder with comorbid ASD (ID/ASD) caused by mutations in KMT2C. This disorder is defined by clinical features that overlap with a group of other disorders, including Kleefstra syndrome, which is caused by EHMT1 mutations. In the fruit fly, we show that the KMT2 and EHMT protein families regulate a highly converging set of biological processes. Both EHMT1 and KMT2C encode histone methyltransferases, which regulate gene transcription by modifying chromatin structure. Further understanding of the common gene regulatory networks associated with this group of ID- and ASD-related disorders may lead to the identification of novel therapeutic targets.

A microdeletion encompassing PHF21A in an individual with global developmental delay and craniofacial anomalies

In Potocki-Shaffer syndrome (PSS), the full phenotypic spectrum is manifested when deletions are at least 2.1 Mb in size at 11p11.2. The PSS-associated genes EXT2 and ALX4, together with PHF21A, all map to this region flanked by markers D11S1393 and D11S1319. Being proximal to EXT2 and ALX4, a 1.1 Mb region containing 12 annotated genes had been identified by deletion mapping to explain PSS phenotypes except multiple exostoses and parietal foramina. Here, we report a male patient with partial PSS phenotypes including global developmental delay, craniofacial anomalies, minor limb anomalies, and micropenis. Using microarray, qPCR, RT-qPCR, and Western blot analyses, we refined the candidate gene region, which harbors five genes, by excluding two genes, SLC35C1 and CRY2, which resulted in a corroborating role of PHF21A in developmental delay and craniofacial anomalies. This microdeletion contains the least number of genes at 11p11.2 reported to date. Additionally, we also discuss the phenotypes observed in our patient with respect to those of published cases of microdeletions across the Potocki-Shaffer interval.

The first Korean patient with Potocki-Shaffer syndrome: a rare cause of multiple exostoses

Potocki-Shaffer syndrome (PSS, OMIM #601224) is a rare contiguous gene deletion syndrome caused by haploinsufficiency of genes located on the 11p11.2p12. Affected individuals have a number of characteristic features including multiple exostoses, biparietal foramina, abnormalities of genitourinary system, hypotonia, developmental delay, and intellectual disability. We report here on the first Korean case of an 8-yr-old boy with PSS diagnosed by high resolution microarray. Initial evaluation was done at age 6 months because of a history of developmental delay, hypotonia, and dysmorphic face. Coronal craniosynostosis and enlarged parietal foramina were found on skull radiographs. At age 6 yr, he had severe global developmental delay. Multiple exostoses of long bones were detected during a radiological check-up. Based on the clinical and radiological features, PSS was highly suspected. Subsequently, chromosomal microarray analysis identified an 8.6 Mb deletion at 11p11.2 [arr 11p12p11.2 (Chr11:39,204,770-47,791,278)×1]. The patient continued rehabilitation therapy for profound developmental delay. The progression of multiple exostosis has being monitored. This case confirms and extends data on the genetic basis of PSS. In clinical and radiologic aspect, a patient with multiple exostoses accompanying with syndromic features, including craniofacial abnormalities and mental retardation, the diagnosis of PSS should be considered.