Disease Progression in Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease Related to MPZ Mutations: A Longitudinal Study

Phenotypic spectrum of myelin protein zero-related neuropathies: a large cohort study from five mutation clusters across Italy

BACKGROUND

We aimed to investigate the clinical features of a large cohort of patients with myelin protein zero (MPZ)-related neuropathy, focusing on the five main mutation clusters across Italy.

METHODS

We retrospectively gathered a minimal data set of clinical information in a series of patients with these frequent mutations recruited among Italian Charcot-Marie-Tooth (CMT) registry centres, including disease onset/severity (CMTES-CMT Examination Score), motor/sensory symptoms and use of orthotics/aids.

RESULTS

We collected data from 186 patients: 60 had the p.Ser78Leu variant ('classical' CMT1B; from Eastern Sicily), 42 the p.Pro70Ser (CMT2I; mainly from Lombardy), 38 the p.Thr124Met (CMT2J; from Veneto), 25 the p.Ser44Phe (CMT2I; from Sardinia) and 21 the p.Asp104ThrfsX13 (mild CMT1B; from Apulia) mutation. Disease severity (CMTES) was higher (p<0.001) in late-onset axonal forms (p.Thr124Met=9.2±6.6; p.Ser44Phe=7.8±5.7; p.Pro70Ser=7.6±4.8) compared with p.Ser78Leu (6.1±3.5) patients. Disease progression (ΔCMTES/year) was faster in the p.Pro70Ser cohort (0.8±1.0), followed by p.Ser44Phe (0.7±0.4), p.Thr124Met (0.4±0.5) and p.Ser78Leu (0.2±0.4) patients. Disease severity (CMTES=1.2±1.5), progression (ΔCMTES/year=0.1±0.4) and motor involvement were almost negligible in p.Asp104ThrfsX13 patients, who, however, frequently (78%, p<0.001) complained of neuropathic pain. In the other four clusters, walking difficulties were reported by 69-85% of patients, while orthotic and walking aids use ranged between 40-62% and 16-28%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the largest MPZ (and late-onset CMT2) cohort ever collected, reporting clinical features and disease progression of 186 patients from five different clusters across Italy. Our findings corroborate the importance of differentiating between 'classical' childhood-onset demyelinating, late-onset axonal and mild MPZ-related neuropathy, characterised by different pathomechanisms, in view of different therapeutic targets.

Peripheral Nervous System (PNS) Myelin Diseases

This is a review of inherited and acquired causes of human demyelinating neuropathies and a subset of disorders that affect axon-Schwann cell interactions. Nearly all inherited demyelinating neuropathies are caused by mutations in genes that are expressed by myelinating Schwann cells, affecting diverse functions in a cell-autonomous manner. The most common acquired demyelinating neuropathies are Guillain-Barré syndrome and chronic, inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy, both of which are immune-mediated. An additional group of inherited and acquired disorders affect axon-Schwann cell interactions in the nodal region. Overall, these disorders affect the formation of myelin and its maintenance, with superimposed axonal loss that is clinically important.

Clinical practice guidelines for the diagnosis and management of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease

INTRODUCTION

Charcot-Marie-Tooth (CMT) disease is classified considering the neurophysiological and histological findings, the inheritance pattern and the underlying genetic defect. In recent years, with the advent of next generation sequencing, genetic complexity has increased exponentially, expanding the knowledge about disease pathways, and having an impact in clinical management. The aim of this guide is to offer recommendations for the diagnosis, prognosis, monitoring and treatment of this disease in Spain.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This consensus guideline has been developed by a multidisciplinary panel encompassing a broad group of professionals including neurologists, neuropediatricians, geneticists, rehabilitators, and orthopaedic surgeons.

RECOMMENDATIONS

The diagnosis is based in the clinical characterization, usually presenting with a common phenotype. It should be followed by an appropriate neurophysiological study that allows for a correct classification, specific recommendations are established for the parameters that should be included. Genetic diagnosis must be approached in sequentially, once the PMP22 duplication has been ruled out if appropriate, a next generation sequencing should be considered taking into account the limitations of the available techniques. To date, there is no pharmacological treatment that modifies the course of the disease, but symptomatic management is important, as are the rehabilitation and orthopaedic considerations. The latter should be initiated early to identify and improve the patient's functional impairments, including individualised exercise guidelines, orthotic adaptation, and assessment of conservative surgeries such as tendon transpositions. The follow-up of patients with CMT is exclusively clinical, ancillary testing are not necessary in routine clinical practice.

Lower limb muscle MRI fat fraction is a responsive outcome measure in CMT X1, 1B and 2A

OBJECTIVE

With potential therapies for many forms of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT), responsive outcome measures are urgently needed for clinical trials. Quantitative lower limb MRI demonstrated progressive calf intramuscular fat accumulation in the commonest form, CMT1A with large responsiveness. In this study, we evaluated the responsiveness and validity in the three other common forms, due to variants in GJB1 (CMTX1), MPZ (CMT1B) and MFN2 (CMT2A).

METHODS

22 CMTX1, 21 CMT1B and 21 CMT2A patients and matched controls were assessed at a 1-year interval. Intramuscular fat fraction (FF) was evaluated using three-point Dixon MRI at thigh and calf level along with clinical measures including CMT examination score, clinical strength assessment, CMT-HI and plasma neurofilament light chain.

RESULTS

All patient groups had elevated muscle fat fraction at thigh and calf levels, with highest thigh FF and atrophy in CMT2A. There was moderate correlation between calf muscle FF and clinical measures (CMTESv2 rho = 0.405; p = 0.001, ankle MRC strength rho = -0.481; p < 0.001). Significant annualised progression in calf muscle FF was seen in all patient groups (CMTX1 2.0 ± 2.0%, p < 0.001, CMT1B 1.6 ± 2.1% p = 0.004 and CMT2A 1.6 ± 2.1% p = 0.002). Greatest increase was seen in patients with 10-70% FF at baseline (calf 2.7 ± 2.3%, p < 0.0001 and thigh 1.7 ± 2.1%, p = 0.01).

INTERPRETATION

Our results confirm that calf muscle FF is highly responsive over 12 months in three additional common forms of CMT which together with CMT1A account for 90% of genetically confirmed cases. Calf muscle MRI FF should be a valuable outcome measure in upcoming CMT clinical trials.

Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease with Myelin Protein Zero Mutation Presenting as Painful, Predominant Small-Fiber Neuropathy

Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT) rarely presents with painful symptoms, which mainly occur in association with myelin protein zero (MPZ) gene mutations. We aimed to further characterize the features of painful neuropathic phenotypes in MPZ-related CMT. We report on a 58-year-old woman with a longstanding history of intermittent migrant pain and dysesthesias. Examination showed minimal clinical signs of neuropathy along with mild changes upon electroneurographic examination, consistent with an intermediate pattern, and small-fiber loss upon skin biopsy. Genetic testing identified the heterozygous variant p.Trp101Ter in MPZ. We identified another 20 CMT patients in the literature who presented with neuropathic pain as a main feature in association with MPZ mutations, mostly in the extracellular MPZ domain; the majority of these patients showed late onset (14/20), with motor-nerve-conduction velocities predominantly in the intermediate range (12/20). It is hypothesized that some MPZ mutations could manifest with, or predispose to, neuropathic pain. However, the mechanisms linking MPZ mutations and pain-generating nerve changes are unclear, as are the possible role of modifier factors. This peculiar CMT presentation may be diagnostically misleading, as it is suggestive of an acquired pain syndrome rather than of an inherited neuropathy.

PMP22 associates with MPZ via their transmembrane domains and disrupting this interaction causes a loss-of-function phenotype similar to hereditary neuropathy associated with liability to pressure palsies (HNPP)

PMP22 and MPZ are major myelin proteins in the peripheral nervous system. MPZ is a single pass integral membrane protein with an extracellular immunoglobulin (Ig)-like domain and works as an adhesion protein to hold myelin wraps together across the intraperiod line. Loss of MPZ causes severe demyelinating Charcot-Marie-Tooth (CMT) peripheral neuropathy. PMP22 is an integral membrane tetraspan protein belonging to the Claudin superfamily. Homozygous loss of PMP22 also leads to severe demyelinating neuropathy, and duplication of wildtype PMP22 causes the most common form of CMT, CMT1A. Yet the molecular functions provided by PMP22 and how its alteration causes CMT are unknown. Here we find that these abundant myelin proteins form a strong and specific complex. Mutagenesis and domain swapping experiments reveal that these proteins interact through interfaces within their transmembrane domains. We also find that the PMP22 A67T patient variant that causes an HNPP (Hereditary neuropathy with pressure palsies) phenotype, reflecting a heterozygous loss-of-function, maps to this interface. The PMP22 A67T variant results in the specific loss of MPZ association with PMP22 without affecting PMP22 localization to the plasma membrane or its interactions with other proteins. These data define the molecular basis for the MPZ∼PMP22 interaction and indicate that the MPZ∼PMP22 complex fulfills an important function in myelinating cells.

Homomeric interactions of the MPZ Ig domain and their relation to Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease

Mutations in MPZ (myelin protein zero) can cause demyelinating early-onset Charcot-Marie-Tooth type 1B disease or later onset type 2I/J disease characterized by axonal degeneration, reflecting the diverse roles of MPZ in Schwann cells. MPZ holds apposing membranes of the myelin sheath together, with the adhesion role fulfilled by its extracellular immunoglobulin-like domain (IgMPZ), which oligomerizes. Models for how the IgMPZ might form oligomeric assemblies has been extrapolated from a protein crystal structure in which individual rat IgMPZ subunits are packed together under artificial conditions, forming three weak interfaces. One interface organizes the IgMPZ into tetramers, a second 'dimer' interface links tetramers together across the intraperiod line, and a third hydrophobic interface that mediates binding to lipid bilayers or the same hydrophobic surface on another IgMPZ domain. Presently, there are no data confirming whether the proposed IgMPZ interfaces actually mediate oligomerization in solution, whether they are required for the adhesion activity of MPZ, whether they are important for myelination, or whether their loss results in disease. We performed nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and small angle X-ray scattering analysis of wild-type IgMPZ as well as mutant forms with amino acid substitutions designed to interrupt its presumptive oligomerization interfaces. Here, we confirm the interface that mediates IgMPZ tetramerization, but find that dimerization is mediated by a distinct interface that has yet to be identified. We next correlated different types of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease symptoms to subregions within IgMPZ tetramers. Variants causing axonal late-onset disease (CMT2I/J) map to surface residues of IgMPZ proximal to the transmembrane domain. Variants causing early-onset demyelinating disease (CMT1B) segregate into two groups: one is described by variants that disrupt the stability of the Ig-fold itself and are largely located within the core of the IgMPZ domain; whereas another describes a region on the surface of IgMPZ tetramers, accessible to protein interactions. Computational docking studies predict that this latter disease-relevant subregion may potentially mediate dimerization of IgMPZ tetramers.

Genetic analysis and natural history of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease CMTX1 due to GJB1 variants

Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT) due to GJB1 variants (CMTX1) is the second most common form of CMT. It is an X-linked disorder characterized by progressive sensory and motor neuropathy with males affected more severely than females. Many reported GJB1 variants remain classified as variants of uncertain significance (VUS). In this large, international, multicentre study we prospectively collected demographic, clinical and genetic data on patients with CMT associated with GJB1 variants. Pathogenicity for each variant was defined using adapted American College of Medical Genetics criteria. Baseline and longitudinal analyses were conducted to study genotype-phenotype correlations, to calculate longitudinal change using the CMT Examination Score (CMTES), to compare males versus females, and pathogenic/likely pathogenic (P/LP) variants versus VUS. We present 387 patients from 295 families harbouring 154 variants in GJB1. Of these, 319 patients (82.4%) were deemed to have P/LP variants, 65 had VUS (16.8%) and three benign variants (0.8%; excluded from analysis); an increased proportion of patients with P/LP variants compared with using ClinVar's classification (74.6%). Male patients (166/319, 52.0%, P/LP only) were more severely affected at baseline. Baseline measures in patients with P/LP variants and VUS showed no significant differences, and regression analysis suggested the disease groups were near identical at baseline. Genotype-phenotype analysis suggested c.-17G>A produces the most severe phenotype of the five most common variants, and missense variants in the intracellular domain are less severe than other domains. Progression of disease was seen with increasing CMTES over time up to 8 years follow-up. Standard response mean (SRM), a measure of outcome responsiveness, peaked at 3 years with moderate responsiveness [change in CMTES (ΔCMTES) = 1.3 ± 2.6, P = 0.00016, SRM = 0.50]. Males and females progressed similarly up to 8 years, but baseline regression analysis suggested that over a longer period, females progress more slowly. Progression was most pronounced for mild phenotypes (CMTES = 0-7; 3-year ΔCMTES = 2.3 ± 2.5, P = 0.001, SRM = 0.90). Enhanced variant interpretation has yielded an increased proportion of GJB1 variants classified as P/LP and will aid future variant interpretation in this gene. Baseline and longitudinal analysis of this large cohort of CMTX1 patients describes the natural history of the disease including the rate of progression; CMTES showed moderate responsiveness for the whole group at 3 years and higher responsiveness for the mild group at 3, 4 and 5 years. These results have implications for patient selection for upcoming clinical trials.