Spectroscopic identification of a bidentate binding motif in the anionic magnesium-CO2 complex ([ClMgCO2 ](-))

Infrared Spectroscopy of [M(CO2)n]+ (M = Ca, Sr, and Ba; n = 1-4) in the Gas Phase: Solvation-Induced Electron Transfer and Activation of CO2

Cationic complexes of heavy alkaline earth metal and carbon dioxide [M(CO2)n]+ (M = Ca, Sr, and Ba) are produced by a laser vaporization-supersonic expansion ion source in the gas phase and are studied by infrared photodissociation spectroscopy in conjunction with quantum chemistry calculations. For the n = 1 complexes, the metal-ligand binding arises primarily from the electrostatic interaction with the CO2 ligand bound to the metal (+I) center in an end-on η1-O fashion. The more highly coordinated complexes [M(CO2)n]+ with n ≥ 2 are characterized to involve a [M2+(CO2-)] core ion with the CO2- ligand bound to the metal (+II) center in a bidentate η2-O, O manner. The activation of CO2 in forming a bent CO2- moiety occurs via solvation-induced metal cation-ligand electron transfer reactions. Bonding analyses reveal that the attractive forces between M2+ and CO2- in the core cation come mainly from electrostatic attraction, but the contribution of covalent orbital interactions should not be underestimated. The atomic orbitals of metal dications that are engaged in the orbital interactions are ns and (n - 1)d orbitals.

Carbon Dioxide Activation by Alkaline-Earth Metals: Formation and Spectroscopic Characterization of OCMCO3 and MC2O4 (M = Ca, Sr, Ba) in Solid Neon

The reactions of alkaline-earth metal atoms (Ca, Sr, and Ba) with carbon dioxide are investigated using matrix isolation infrared spectroscopy in solid neon. The ground-state metal atoms react with two carbon dioxide molecules to produce the oxalate complexes MC₂O₄ and the carbonate-carbonyl complexes OCMCO₃ (M = Ca, Sr, Ba) spontaneously on annealing. The species are identified by the effects of isotopic substitution on their infrared spectra as well as density functional calculations. Bonding analyses reveal that the attractive forces between M²⁺ and (CO₃)^2- or (C₂O₄)₂^- in the OCMCO₃ and MC₂O₄ complexes come mainly from electrostatic attraction, but covalent orbital interactions also play an important role, which are dominated by the ligand-to-metal donation bonding. The calcium, strontium, and barium metal centers in these complexes use their ns and predominately (n - 1)d atomic orbitals for covalent bonding that mimic transition metals.

Infrared spectroscopy of Be(CO2)4+ in the gas phase: electron transfer and C-C coupling of CO2

Beryllium-carbon dioxide cation complexes Be(CO₂)_n⁺ are produced by a laser vaporization-supersonic expansion ion source in the gas phase. Mass-selected infrared photodissociation spectroscopy supplemented by theoretical calculations confirms that Be(CO₂)₄⁺ is a coordination saturated complex that can be assigned to a mixture of two isomers. The first structure involves a bent CO₂^- ligand that is bound in a monodentate η¹-O coordination mode. Another isomer has a metal oxalate-type C₂O₄^- moiety with a C-C hemibond.

Plasma-promoted reactions of the heterobimetallic anions CuNb- with dinitrogen and subsequent reactions with carbon dioxide: formation of C-N bonds

The activation and functionalization of dinitrogen with carbon dioxide into useful chemicals containing C-N bonds are significant research projects but highly challenging. Herein, we report that N₂ molecules are dissociated by heterobimetallic CuNb^- anions assisted by surface plasma radiation, leading to the formation of CuNbN₂^- anions; the CuNbN₂^- anions can further react with CO₂ to generate products NCO^- with one C-N bond and NbO₂NCN^- with two C-N bonds under thermal collision conditions. For the activation of dinitrogen, the plasma atmosphere is conducive to the dissociation of the NN bond, which renders the coupling reactions of N₂ and CO₂ molecules easier to proceed. This is the first report of coupling of N₂ and CO₂ to generate C-N bonds by making good use of the plasma effect to assist in the activation of N₂ molecules. This new strategy with the assistance of plasma provides a practicable route to construct C-N bonds by directly using N₂ and CO₂ at room temperature.

Generation and Characterization of the Charge-Transferred Diradical Complex CaCO2 with an Open-Shell Singlet Ground State

The CaCO₂ complex is generated via the reaction of excited-state calcium atom with carbon dioxide in a solid neon matrix. Infrared absorption spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations reveal that the complex has a planar four-membered ring structure with a strongly bent CO₂ ligand side-on coordinated to the calcium center in an η^2-O, O manner. The complex has an open-shell singlet ground state, which can be described as the bonding interactions between a Ca⁺ (4s¹) cation in the doublet ground state and a doublet ground state CO₂^- anion. The analysis of the bonding situation suggests that the Ca-O₂C bonds have a large (75%) electrostatic character. The covalent (orbital) interactions come from the coupling of the unpaired electrons of Ca⁺ and CO₂^- giving rise to electron-sharing bonding and a stronger contribution from dative bonding (Ca⁺)←(CO₂^-). The atomic orbitals (AOs) of Ca⁺ that are engaged in the covalent bonds are the 4s AO for the electron-sharing bonds and the 3d AOs for the dative bonds. This is further evidence for the assignment of the heavier alkaline-earth atoms as transition metals rather than main-group elements.

ORGANOMETALLIC GAS-PHASE ION CHEMISTRY AND CATALYSIS: INSIGHTS INTO THE USE OF METAL CATALYSTS TO PROMOTE SELECTIVITY IN THE REACTIONS OF CARBOXYLIC ACIDS AND THEIR DERIVATIVES

Carboxylic acids are valuable organic substrates as they are widely available, easy to handle, and exhibit structural and functional variety. While they are used in many standard synthetic protocols, over the past two decades numerous studies have explored new modes of metal-mediated reactivity of carboxylic acids and their derivatives. Mass spectrometry-based studies can provide fundamental mechanistic insights into these new modes of reactivity. Here gas-phase models for the following catalytic transformations of carboxylic acids and their derivatives are reviewed: protodecarboxylation; dehydration; decarbonylation; reaction as coordinated bases in C-H bond activation; remote functionalization and decarboxylative C-C bond coupling. In each case the catalytic problem is defined, insights from gas-phase studies are highlighted, comparisons with condensed-phase systems are made and perspectives are reached. Finally, the potential role for mechanistic studies that integrate both gas- and condensed-phase studies is highlighted by recent studies on the discovery of new catalysts for the selective decomposition of formic acid and the invention of the new extrusion-insertion class of reactions for the synthesis of amides, thioamides, and amidines. © 2020 John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Mass Spec Rev.

Covalent Bonding Between Be+ and CO2 in BeOCO+ with a Surprisingly High Antisymmetric OCO Stretching Vibration

The cationic complex BeOCO⁺ is produced in a solid neon matrix. Infrared absorption spectroscopic study shows that it has a very high antisymmetric OCO stretching vibration of 2418.9 cm^-1, which is about 71 cm^-1 blue-shifted from that of free CO₂. The quantum chemical calculations are in very good agreement with the experimental observation. Depending on the theoretical method, a linear or quasi-linear structure is predicted for the cation. The analysis of the electronic structure shows that the bonding of Be⁺ to one oxygen atom induces very little charge migration between the two moieties, but it causes a significant change in the σ-charge distribution that strengthens the terminal C-O bond, leading to the observed blue shift. The bonding analysis reveals that the Be⁺ ← OCO donation results in strong binding due to the interference of the wave function and a charge polarization within the CO₂ fragment and hybridization to Be⁺ but only negligible charge donation.

Catalytic Co-Conversion of CH4 and CO2 Mediated by Rhodium-Titanium Oxide Anions RhTiO2. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl 2021;60:13788-13792. [PMID: 33890352 PMCID: PMC8251526 DOI: 10.1002/anie.202103808]

Catalytic co‐conversion of methane with carbon dioxide to produce syngas (2 H₂+2 CO) involves complicated elementary steps and almost all the elementary reactions are performed at the same high temperature conditions in practical thermocatalysis. Here, we demonstrate by mass spectrometric experiments that RhTiO₂⁻ promotes the co‐conversion of CH₄ and CO₂ to free 2 H₂+CO and an adsorbed CO (CO_ads) at room temperature; the only elementary step that requires the input of external energy is desorption of CO_ads from the RhTiO₂CO⁻ to reform RhTiO₂⁻. This study not only identifies a promising active species for dry (CO₂) reforming of methane to syngas, but also emphasizes the importance of temperature control over elementary steps in practical catalysis, which may significantly alleviate the carbon deposition originating from the pyrolysis of methane.

[Mo3 S13 ]2- as a Model System for Hydrogen Evolution Catalysis by MoSx : Probing Protonation Sites in the Gas Phase by Infrared Multiple Photon Dissociation Spectroscopy

Materials based on molybdenum sulfide are known as efficient hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) catalysts. As the binding site for H atoms on molybdenum sulfides for the catalytic process is under debate, [HMo3 S13 ]- is an interesting molecular model system to address this question. Herein, we probe the [HMo3 S13 ]- cluster in the gas phase by coupling Fourier-transform ion-cyclotron-resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS) with infrared multiple photon dissociation (IRMPD) spectroscopy. Our investigations show one distinct S-H stretching vibration at 2450 cm-1 . Thermochemical arguments based on DFT calculations strongly suggest a terminal disulfide unit as the H adsorption site.

Spectroscopic Identification of Transition-Metal M[η2-(O,O)C] Species for Highly-Efficient CO2 Activation

The CO₂ activation by transition metals is important in CO₂ utilization but has proven to be challenging for experimental targets. Here we report first synthesis and spectroscopic characterization of transition-metal M[η²-(O,O)C] species with bidentate double oxygen metal-CO₂ coordination in the [ZrO(CO₂)_n≥4]⁺ complexes. The Zr[η²-(O,O)C] species yields a CO₂^- radical ligand, showing a high efficiency in CO₂ activation. We find that two important prerequisites are demanded for certain metals to form this intriguing M[η²-(O,O)C] species. One is that the metal center has high reduction capability, and the other is that the oxidation state of the metal center is lower than its highest one by 1. This study highlights the pivotal roles played by the M[η²-(O,O)C] species in CO₂ activation and also open new avenues toward the development of related single-atom catalysts with isolated transition-metal atoms dispersed on supports.

Carbon Dioxide Activation at Metal Centers: Evolution of Charge Transfer from Mg .+ to CO2 in [MgCO2 (H2 O)n ].+ , n=0-8

We investigate activation of carbon dioxide by singly charged hydrated magnesium cations Mg ^.+(H₂O)_n, through infrared multiple photon dissociation (IRMPD) spectroscopy combined with quantum chemical calculations. The spectra of [MgCO₂(H₂O)_n]^.+ in the 1250–4000 cm⁻¹ region show a sharp transition from n=2 to n=3 for the position of the CO₂ antisymmetric stretching mode. This is evidence for the activation of CO₂ via charge transfer from Mg ^.+ to CO₂ for n≥3, while smaller clusters feature linear CO₂ coordinated end‐on to the metal center. Starting with n=5, we see a further conformational change, with CO₂^.− coordination to Mg²⁺ gradually shifting from bidentate to monodentate, consistent with preferential hexa‐coordination of Mg²⁺. Our results reveal in detail how hydration promotes CO₂ activation by charge transfer at metal centers.

Infrared Multiple Photon Dissociation Spectroscopy of Hydrated Cobalt Anions Doped with Carbon Dioxide CoCO2 (H2 O)n - , n=1-10, in the C-O Stretch Region

We investigate anionic [Co,CO2 ,nH2 O]- clusters as model systems for the electrochemical activation of CO2 by infrared multiple photon dissociation (IRMPD) spectroscopy in the range of 1250-2234 cm-1 using an FT-ICR mass spectrometer. We show that both CO2 and H2 O are activated in a significant fraction of the [Co,CO2 ,H2 O]- clusters since it dissociates by CO loss, and the IR spectrum exhibits the characteristic C-O stretching frequency. About 25 % of the ion population can be dissociated by pumping the C-O stretching mode. With the help of quantum chemical calculations, we assign the structure of this ion as Co(CO)(OH)2 - . However, calculations find Co(HCOO)(OH)- as the global minimum, which is stable against IRMPD under the conditions of our experiment. Weak features around 1590-1730 cm-1 are most likely due to higher lying isomers of the composition Co(HOCO)(OH)- . Upon additional hydration, all species [Co,CO2 ,nH2 O]- , n≥2, undergo IRMPD through loss of H2 O molecules as a relatively weakly bound messenger. The main spectral features are the C-O stretching mode of the CO ligand around 1900 cm-1 , the water bending mode mixed with the antisymmetric C-O stretching mode of the HCOO- ligand around 1580-1730 cm-1 , and the symmetric C-O stretching mode of the HCOO- ligand around 1300 cm-1 . A weak feature above 2000 cm-1 is assigned to water combination bands. The spectral assignment clearly indicates the presence of at least two distinct isomers for n ≥2.

Direct Conversion of Methane with Carbon Dioxide Mediated by RhVO3 - Cluster Anions

Direct conversion of methane with carbon dioxide to value-added chemicals is attractive but extremely challenging because of the thermodynamic stability and kinetic inertness of both molecules. Herein, the first dinuclear cluster species, RhVO₃ ^- , has been designed to mediate the co-conversion of CH₄ and CO₂ to oxygenated products, CH₃ OH and CH₂ O, in the temperature range of 393-600 K. The resulting cluster ions RhVO₃ CO^- after CH₃ OH formation can further desorb the [CO] unit to regenerate the RhVO₃ ^- cluster, leading to the successful establishment of a catalytic cycle for methanol production from CH₄ and CO₂ (CH₄ +CO₂ →CH₃ OH+CO). The exceptional activity of Rh-V dinuclear oxide cluster (RhVO₃ ^- ) identified herein provides a new mechanism for co-conversion of two very stable molecules CH₄ and CO₂ .

Release of Formic Acid from Copper Formate: Hydride, Proton-Coupled Electron and Hydrogen Atom Transfer All Play their Role

Although the mechanism for the transformation of carbon dioxide to formate with copper hydride is well understood, it is not clear how formic acid is ultimately released. Herein, we show how formic acid is formed in the decomposition of the copper formate clusters Cu(II)(HCOO)3- and Cu(II)2 (HCOO)5- . Infrared irradiation resonant with the antisymmetric C-O stretching mode activates the cluster, resulting in the release of formic acid and carbon dioxide. For the binary cluster, electronic structure calculations indicate that CO2 is eliminated first, through hydride transfer from formate to copper. Formic acid is released via proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) to a second formate ligand, evidenced by close to zero partial charge and spin density at the hydrogen atom in the transition state. Concomitantly, the two copper centers are reduced from Cu(II) to Cu(I). Depending on the detailed situation, either PCET or hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) takes place.

Structures and Infrared Spectra of [M(CO2)7]+ (M = V, Cr, and Mn) Complexes

Gas-phase infrared photodissociation spectra of [V(CO₂) _n]⁺ complexes revealed three new vibrational bands at 1140, 1800, and 3008 cm^-1 at n = 7, the features of which are retained in the larger clusters (Ricks, A. M.; Brathwaite, A. D.; Duncan, M. A. J. Phys. Chem. A 2013, 117, 11490-11498). However, structural assignment of this intriguing feature remains open. Herein, quantum chemical calculations on [V(CO₂)₇]⁺ were carried out to identify the structure of the low-lying isomers and to assign the observed spectral features. The comparison of calculated infrared spectra of [V(CO₂)₇]⁺ with experimental infrared spectra identified the formation of a bent CO₂^- species, suggesting the ligand-induced activation of CO₂ by the vanadium cation. The structures and infrared spectra of [Cr(CO₂)₇]⁺ and [Mn(CO₂)₇]⁺ were also predicted and discussed.

CO2/O2 Exchange in Magnesium-Water Clusters Mg+(H2O) n

Hydrated singly charged metal ions doped with carbon dioxide, Mg2+(CO2)-(H2O) n, in the gas phase are valuable model systems for the electrochemical activation of CO2. Here, we study these systems by Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometry combined with ab initio calculations. We show that the exchange reaction of CO2 with O2 proceeds fast with bare Mg+(CO2), with a rate coefficient kabs = 1.2 × 10-10 cm3 s-1, while hydrated species exhibit a lower rate in the range of kabs = (1.2-2.4) × 10-11 cm3 s-1 for this strongly exothermic reaction. Water makes the exchange reaction more exothermic but, at the same time, considerably slower. The results are rationalized with a need for proper orientation of the reactants in the hydrated system, with formation of a Mg2+(CO4)-(H2O) n intermediate while the activation energy is negligible. According to our nanocalorimetric analysis, the exchange reaction of the hydrated ion is exothermic by -1.7 ± 0.5 eV, in agreement with quantum chemical calculations.

The activation of carbon dioxide by first row transition metals (Sc-Zn)

The activation of CO2 by chloride-tagged first-row transition metal anions [ClM]- (M = Sc-Zn), was examined by mass spectrometry, quantum chemical calculations, and statistical analysis. The direct formation of [ClM(CO2)]- complexes was demonstrated in the reaction between [ClM]- and neutral CO2. In addition, the reverse reaction was investigated by energy-variable collisionally induced dissociation (CID) of the corresponding [ClM(CO2)]- anions generated in-source. Five different mono- and bi-dentate binding motifs present in the ion/CO2 complexes were identified by quantum chemical calculations and the relative stability of each of these isomers was established and analyzed for all first-row transition metals based on the experimental and theoretical ion/molecule binding energies. It was found that the early first row transition metals form strong covalent bonds with the neutral CO2 molecule, while the late ones and in particular copper and zinc are weakly bonded. Using simple valence bond Lewis diagrams, the different binding motifs and their relative stabilities across the first row were described using multi-configurational self consistent field (MSCSCF) wavefunctions in a quantitative manner based on the electronic structure of the individual metals. This analysis provides an explanation for the change of the most favorite bonding motif of the transition metals with CO2 along the 1st transition metal row. The nature of the activated CO2 complex and the relationship between its stability and other structural and spectral properties was also analyzed by Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and artificial neural networks.

Coupling of Methane and Carbon Dioxide Mediated by Diatomic Copper Boride Cations

The use of CH₄ and CO₂ to produce value-added chemicals via direct C-C coupling is a challenging chemistry problem because of the inertness of these two molecules. Herein, mass spectrometric experiments and high-level quantum-chemical calculations have identified the first diatomic species (CuB⁺ ) that can couple CH₄ with CO₂ under thermal collision conditions to produce ketene (H₂ C=C=O), an important intermediate in synthetic chemistry. The order to feed the reactants (CH₄ and CO₂ ) is important and CH₄ should be firstly fed to produce the C₂ product. Molecular-level mechanisms including control of product selectivity have been revealed for coupling of CH₄ with CO₂ under mild conditions.

Vibrational Characterization of Radical Ion Adducts between Imidazole and CO2

We address the molecular level origins of the dramatic difference in the catalytic mechanisms of CO₂ activation by the seemingly similar molecules pyridine (Py) and imidazole (Im). This is accomplished by comparing the fundamental interactions of CO₂ radical anions with Py and Im in the isolated, gas phase PyCO₂^- and ImCO₂^- complexes. These species are prepared by condensation of the neutral compounds onto a (CO₂) _n^- cluster ion beam by entrainment in a supersonic jet ion source. The structures of the anionic complexes are determined by theoretical analysis of their vibrational spectra, obtained by IR photodissociation of weakly bound CO₂ molecules in a photofragmentation mass spectrometer. Although the radical PyCO₂^- system adopts a carbamate-like configuration corresponding to formation of an N-C covalent bond, the ImCO₂^- species is revealed to be best described as an ion-molecule complex in which an oxygen atom in the CO₂^- radical anion is H-bonded to the NH group. Species that feature a covalent N-C interaction in ImCO₂^- are calculated to be locally stable structures, but are much higher in energy than the largely electrostatically bound ion-molecule complex. These results support the suggestion from solution phase electrochemical studies (Bocarsly et al. ACS Catal. 2012, 2, 1684-1692) that the N atoms are not directly involved in the catalytic activation of CO₂ by Im.

Infrared Photodissociation Spectra of [Sn(CO2) n]- Cluster Ions

We present infrared spectra and density functional theory calculations of mass selected [Sn(CO₂) _n]^- cluster anions ( n = 2-6). The spectra and structures of these clusters exhibit less structural diversity than those of analogous clusters with first-row transition metals, but are more complex than those for the heavy coinage metals or for the related [Bi(CO₂) _n]^- clusters. The most favorable core ion structure for all cluster sizes can be characterized as a Sn-oxalate complex, Sn[C₂O₄]^-. Higher energy isomers based on a bidentate η²-(C,O) CO₂ ligand tightly bound to the metal atom in SnCO₂^- complexes are also observed, even for the largest cluster sizes studied here. For n = 2, another high energy isomer is found, featuring a CO₂ ligand weakly bound to the metal atom in a SnCO₂^- ion.

Titanium Insertion into CO Bonds in Anionic Ti-CO2 Complexes

We explore the structures of [Ti(CO₂) _y]^- cluster anions using infrared photodissociation spectroscopy and quantum chemistry calculations. The existence of spectral signatures of metal carbonyl CO stretching modes shows that insertion of titanium atoms into C-O bonds represents an important reaction during the formation of these clusters. In addition to carbonyl groups, the infrared spectra show that the titanium center is coordinated to oxalato, carbonato, and oxo ligands, which form along with the metal carbonyls. The presence of a metal oxalato ligand promotes C-O bond insertion in these systems. These results highlight the affinity of titanium for C-O bond insertion processes.

C-C Bond Formation of Mg- and Zn-Activated Carbon Dioxide

Gas-phase activation of CO₂ by chloride tagged metal atoms, [ClM]^- (M=Mg, Zn), has been investigated by mass spectrometry and high-level quantum chemistry. Both metals activate CO₂ with significant bending of the CO₂ moiety to form complexes with the general formula [ClM,CO₂ ]^- . The structure of the metal-CO₂ complex depends on the method of formation, and the energy landscapes and reaction dynamics have been probed by collisional induced dissociation and thermal ion molecule reactions with isotopically labeled species. Having established these structural relationships, the gas-phase reactivity of [ClM(κ² -O₂ C)]^- with acetaldehyde (here considered a carbohydrate mimic) was then studied. Formation of lactate and enolate-pyruvate complexes are observed, showing that CO₂ fixation by C-C bond formation takes place. For M=Zn, even formation of free pyruvate ([C₃ H₃ O₃ ]^- ) is observed. Implications of the observed CO₂ reactivity for the electrochemical conversion of carbon dioxide, and to biochemical and artificial photosynthesis is briefly discussed. Detailed potential energy diagrams obtained by the quantum chemical calculations offer models consistent with experimental observation.

Coordination-induced CO2 fixation into carbonate by metal oxides

Infrared spectroscopic studies reveal how the coordination induces CO₂ fixation into carbonate by a cationic yttrium oxide model catalyst.

Preparation of Labile Ni+(cyclam) Cations in the Gas Phase Using Electron-Transfer Reduction through Ion-Ion Recombination in an Ion Trap and Structural Characterization with Vibrational Spectroscopy

Gas-phase ion chemistry methods that capture and characterize the degree of activation of small molecules in the active sites of homogeneous catalysts form a powerful new tool to unravel how ligand environments affect reactivity. A key roadblock in this development, however, is the ability to generate the fragile metal oxidation states that are essential for catalytic activity. Here we demonstrate the preparation of the key Ni(I) center in the widely used cyclam scaffold using ion-ion recombination as a gas-phase alternative to electrochemical reduction. The singly charged Ni⁺(cyclam) coordination complex is generated by electron transfer from fluoranthene and azobenzene anions to doubly charged Ni²⁺(cyclam), using the electron-transfer dissociation protocol in a commercial quadrupole ion trap instrument and in a custom-built octopole RF ion trap. The successful preparation of the Ni⁺(cyclam) cation is verified through analysis of its vibrational spectrum obtained using the infrared free electron laser FELIX.

Formation of Gas-Phase Formate in Thermal Reactions of Carbon Dioxide with Diatomic Iron Hydride Anions

The hydrogenation of carbon dioxide involves the activation of the thermodynamically very stable molecule CO₂ and formation of a C-H bond. Herein, we report that HCO₂^- and CO can be formed in the thermal reaction of CO₂ with a diatomic metal hydride species, FeH^- . The FeH^- anions were produced by laser ablation, and the reaction with CO₂ was analyzed by mass spectrometry and quantum-chemical calculations. Gas-phase HCO₂^- was observed directly as a product, and its formation was predicted to proceed by facile hydride transfer. The mechanism of CO₂ hydrogenation in this gas-phase study parallels similar behavior of a condensed-phase iron catalyst.

Dissociation of Mg(ii) and Zn(ii) complexes of simple 2-oxocarboxylates – relationship to CO2fixation, and the Grignard and Barbier reactions

The glyoxylate and pyruvate carboxylates have been complexed to Mg(ii) and Zn(ii) to investigate the intrinsic interactions of these important biochemical species in the gas phase.

Theoretical investigation of boron-doped lithium clusters, BLin (n = 3–6), activating CO2: an example of the carboxylation of C–H bonds

Boron-doped lithium clusters BLin activating CO₂ is reported. And the carboxylation of C–H bond of benzene can be achieved through C–C bond formation and H-atom-transfer from C to O via two H₂O molecules acting as an H-transfer tunnel.