Formation of Gas-Phase Formate in Thermal Reactions of Carbon Dioxide with Diatomic Iron Hydride Anions

Advances in Naked Metal Clusters for Catalysis

The properties of sub-nano metal clusters are governed by quantum confinement and their large surface-to-bulk ratios, atomically precise compositions and geometric/electronic structures. Advances in metal clusters lead to new opportunities in diverse aspects of sciences including chemo-sensing, bio-imaging, photochemistry, and catalysis. Naked metal clusters having synergic multiple active sites and coordinative unsaturation and tunable stability/activity enable researchers to design atomically precise metal catalysts with tailored catalysis for different reactions. Here we summarize the progress of ligand-free naked metal clusters for catalytic applications. It is anticipated that this review helps to better understand the chemistry of small metal clusters and facilitates the design and development of new catalysts for potential applications.

Carbon Dioxide and Water Activation by Niobium Trioxide Anions in the Gas Phase

Transition metals are important in various industrial applications including catalysis. Due to the current concentration of CO₂ in the atmosphere, various ways for its capture and utilization are investigated. Here, we study the activation of CO₂ and H₂O at [NbO₃]^- in the gas phase using a combination of infrared multiple photon dissociation spectroscopy and density functional theory calculations. In the experiments, Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry is combined with tunable IR laser light provided by the intracavity free-electron laser FELICE or optical parametric oscillator-based table-top laser systems. We present spectra of [NbO₃]^-, [NbO₂(OH)₂]^-, [NbO₂(OH)₂]^-(H₂O) and [NbO(OH)₂(CO₃)]^- in the 240-4000 cm^-1 range. The measured spectra and observed dissociation channels together with quantum chemical calculations confirm that upon interaction with a water molecule, [NbO₃]^- is transformed to [NbO₂(OH)₂]^- via a barrierless reaction. Reaction of this product with CO₂ leads to [NbO(OH)₂(CO₃)]^- with the formation of a [CO₃] moiety.

Plasma-promoted reactions of the heterobimetallic anions CuNb- with dinitrogen and subsequent reactions with carbon dioxide: formation of C-N bonds

The activation and functionalization of dinitrogen with carbon dioxide into useful chemicals containing C-N bonds are significant research projects but highly challenging. Herein, we report that N₂ molecules are dissociated by heterobimetallic CuNb^- anions assisted by surface plasma radiation, leading to the formation of CuNbN₂^- anions; the CuNbN₂^- anions can further react with CO₂ to generate products NCO^- with one C-N bond and NbO₂NCN^- with two C-N bonds under thermal collision conditions. For the activation of dinitrogen, the plasma atmosphere is conducive to the dissociation of the NN bond, which renders the coupling reactions of N₂ and CO₂ molecules easier to proceed. This is the first report of coupling of N₂ and CO₂ to generate C-N bonds by making good use of the plasma effect to assist in the activation of N₂ molecules. This new strategy with the assistance of plasma provides a practicable route to construct C-N bonds by directly using N₂ and CO₂ at room temperature.

Inverse Design of Nanoclusters for Light-Controlled CO2-HCOOH Interconversion

With global push of hydrogen economy, efficient scenarios for hydrogen storage, transportation, and generation are indispensable. Here we devise a strategy for controllable hydrogen fuel storage and retrieval via light-switched CO₂-to-HCOOH interconversion. To realize it, palladium sulfide nanocluster catalysts with multiple specific functionalities are directly searched by our home-developed inverse design approach based on genetic algorithm (IDOGA) and ab initio calculations. Over 500 low-energy Pd_xS_y (x + y ≤ 30) clusters are sieved through a multiobjective function combining stability, activity, optical absorption, and reduction capability of photocarriers. The structure-property relationships and key factors governing the trade-off among these stringent criteria are disclosed. Finally, 14 candidate Pd_xS_y clusters with proper sulfidation degree and high stability in an aqueous environment have been screened. Our IDOGA program provides a general approach for inverse search of nanoclusters with any designated elemental compositions and functionalities for any device applications.

Molecular-level electrocatalytic CO2 reduction reaction mediated by single platinum atoms

The activation and transformation of H₂O and CO₂ mediated by electrons and single Pt atoms is demonstrated at the molecular level. The reaction mechanism is revealed by the synergy of mass spectrometry, photoelectron spectroscopy, and quantum chemical calculations. Specifically, a Pt atom captures an electron and activates H₂O to form a H-Pt-OH^- complex. This complex reacts with CO₂via two different pathways to form formate, where CO₂ is hydrogenated, or to form bicarbonate, where CO₂ is carbonated. The overall formula of this reaction is identical to a typical electrochemical CO₂ reduction reaction on a Pt electrode. Since the reactants are electrons and isolated, single atoms and molecules, we term this reaction a molecular-level electrochemical CO₂ reduction reaction. Mechanistic analysis reveals that the negative charge distribution on the Pt-H and the -OH moieties in H-Pt-OH^- is critical for the hydrogenation and carbonation of CO₂. The realization of the molecular-level CO₂ reduction reaction provides insights into the design of novel catalysts for the electrochemical conversion of CO₂.

Transforming CO2 into Methanol with N-Heterocyclic Carbene-Stabilized Coinage Metal Hydrides Immobilized in a Metal-Organic Framework UiO-68

By synergizing the advantages of homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysis, single-site heterogeneous catalysis represents a highly promising opportunity for many catalytic processes. Particularly, the unprecedented designability and versatility of metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) promote them as salient platforms for designing single-site catalytic materials by introducing isolated, well-defined active sites into the frameworks. Herein, we design new MOF-supported single-site catalysts for CO₂ hydrogenation to methanol (CH₃OH), a reaction of great significance in CO₂ valorization. Specifically, N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC), a class of excellent modifiers and anchors, is used to anchor coinage metal hydrides M(I)-H (M = Cu, Ag, and Au) onto the organic linker of UiO-68. The strong metal-ligand interactions between NHC and M(I)-H verify the robustness and feasibility of our design strategy. On the tailor-made catalysts, a three-stage sequential transformation is proposed for CH₃OH synthesis with HCOOH and HCHO as the transit intermediates. A density functional theory-based comparative study suggests that UiO-68 decorated with NHC-Cu(I)-H performs best for CO₂ hydrogenation to HCOOH. This is further rationalized by three linear relationships for the Gibbs energy barrier of CO₂ hydrogenation to HCOO intermediate, the first with the NBO charge of the hydride in NHC-M(I)-H, the second with the electronegativity of M, and the third with the gap between the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital of CO₂ and the highest occupied molecular orbital of the catalyst. It is confirmed that the high efficiency of MOF-supported NHC-Cu(I)-H for CO₂ transformation to CH₃OH is via the proposed three-stage mechanism, and in each stage, the step involving heterolytic dissociation of H₂ together with product generation is the most energy-intensive. The rate-limiting step in the entire mechanism is identified to be H₂ dissociation accompanying with simultaneous HCHO and H₂O formation. Altogether, the tailor-made UiO-68 decorated with NHC-Cu(I)-H features well-defined active sites, enables precise manipulation of reaction paths, and demonstrates excellent reactivity for CO₂ hydrogenation to CH₃OH. It is also predicted to surpass a recently reported MOF-808 catalyst consisting of neighboring Zn²⁺-O-Zr⁴⁺ sites. The designed MOFs as well as the proposed strategy here establish a new paradigm and can be extended to other hydrogenation reactions.

Activation of CO2 by Alkaline-Earth Metal Hydrides: Matrix Infrared Spectra and DFT Calculations of HM(O2CH) and (MH2)(HCOOH) Complexes (M = Sr, Ba)

Reactions of MH₂ (M = Sr, Ba) with CO₂ were explored in pure parahydrogen at 3.5 K using matrix isolation infrared spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations. The formate complex HM(η²-O₂CH) and formic acid complex (MH₂)(HCOOH) were trapped and identified by isotopic substitutions and density functional theory (DFT) frequency calculations. Natural population analysis and the CO₂ reduction mechanism demonstrate that hydride ion transfer from a metal hydride to a CO₂ moiety facilitates the stabilization of such complexes.

Catalytic Co-Conversion of CH4 and CO2 Mediated by Rhodium-Titanium Oxide Anions RhTiO2. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl 2021;60:13788-13792. [PMID: 33890352 PMCID: PMC8251526 DOI: 10.1002/anie.202103808]

Catalytic co‐conversion of methane with carbon dioxide to produce syngas (2 H₂+2 CO) involves complicated elementary steps and almost all the elementary reactions are performed at the same high temperature conditions in practical thermocatalysis. Here, we demonstrate by mass spectrometric experiments that RhTiO₂⁻ promotes the co‐conversion of CH₄ and CO₂ to free 2 H₂+CO and an adsorbed CO (CO_ads) at room temperature; the only elementary step that requires the input of external energy is desorption of CO_ads from the RhTiO₂CO⁻ to reform RhTiO₂⁻. This study not only identifies a promising active species for dry (CO₂) reforming of methane to syngas, but also emphasizes the importance of temperature control over elementary steps in practical catalysis, which may significantly alleviate the carbon deposition originating from the pyrolysis of methane.

Activation of Carbon Dioxide by CoCDn- (n = 0-4) Anions

Laser ablation generated CoCD_n^- (n = 0-4) anions were mass selected and then reacted with CO₂ in an ion trap reactor. The reactions were characterized by mass spectrometry and quantum chemical calculations. The experimental results demonstrated that the CoC^- anion can convert CO₂ into CO. In contrast, the bare Co^- anion is inert toward CO₂. Coordinated D ligands can modify the reactivity of CoCD_1-4^- in which CoCD_1-3^- can reduce CO₂ into CO selectively and CoCD₄^- can only adsorb CO₂. The crucial roles of the coordinated C and D ligands to tune the reactivity of CoCD_n^- (n = 0-4) toward CO₂ were rationalized by theoretical calculations. Note that the hydrogenation process that is usually observed in the reactions of gas-phase metal hydrides with CO₂ is completely suppressed for the reactions CoCD_n^- + CO₂. This study provides insights into the molecular-level origin for the observations that CO can be selectively generated from CO₂ catalyzed by cobalt-containing carbides in heterogeneous catalysis.

Dinitrogen and Carbon Dioxide Activation to Form C-N Bonds at Room Temperature: A New Mechanism Revealed by Experimental and Theoretical Studies

In light of the current energy requirements, the conversion of CO₂ and N₂ into useful C-N bond-containing products under mild conditions has become an area of intense research. However, the inert nature of N₂ and CO₂ renders their coupling extremely challenging. Herein, nitrogen and carbon atoms originating from N₂ and CO₂, respectively, are fixed sequentially by NbH₂^- anions in the gas phase at room temperature. Isocyanate and NbO₂CN^- anions were formed under thermal collision conditions, thus achieving the formation of new C-N bonds directly from simple N₂ and CO₂. The anion structures and reaction details were studied by mass spectrometry, photoelectron spectroscopy, and quantum chemical calculations. A novel N₂ activation mode (metal-ligand activation, MLA) and a related mechanism for constructing C-N bonds mediated by a single non-noble metal atom are proposed. In this MLA mode, the C atom originating from CO₂ serves as an electron reservoir to accept and donate electrons.

CO2 Activation and Hydrogenation by Palladium Hydride Cluster Anions

Mass spectrometric analysis of the anionic products of interaction between palladium hydride anions, PdH^-, and carbon dioxide, CO₂, in a reaction cell shows an efficient generation of the PdHCO₂^- intermediate and isolated formate product. Multiple isomers of the PdHCO₂^- intermediates are identified by a synergy between negative ion photoelectron spectroscopy and quantum-chemical calculations. It is shown that a direct mechanism, in which the H atom in PdH^- directly activates and hydrogenates CO₂, leads to the formation of the formate product. An indirect mechanism, on the other hand, leads to a stable HPdCO₂^- structure, where CO₂ is chemisorbed onto the Pd atom.

The sequential activation of H2 and N2 mediated by the gas-phase Sc3N+ clusters: Formation of amido unit

The activation and hydrogenation of nitrogen are central in industry and in nature. Through a combination of mass spectrometry and quantum chemical calculations, this work reports an interesting result that scandium nitride cations Sc₃N⁺ can activate sequentially H₂ and N₂, and an amido unit (NH₂) is formed based on density functional theory calculations, which is one of the inevitable intermediates in the N₂ reduction reactions. If the activation step is reversed, i.e., sequential activation of first N₂ and then H₂, the reactivity decreases dramatically. An association mechanism, prevalent in some homogeneous catalysis and enzymatic mechanisms, is adopted in these gas-phase H₂ and N₂ activation reactions mediated by Sc₃N⁺ cations. The mechanistic insights are important to understand the mechanism of the conversion of H₂ and N₂ to NH₃ synthesis under ambient conditions.

CO2 activation by ligand-free manganese hydrides in a parahydrogen matrix

The reaction of MnH₂ with CO₂ gave insertion product HMn(η²-O₂CH) by concerted hydride ion transfer.

Reactivity of Iron Hydride Anions Fe2Hn- (n = 0-3) with Carbon Dioxide

The hydrogenation of CO₂ into value-added complexes is of great importance for both environmental and economic issues. Metal hydrides are good models for the active sites to explore the nature of CO₂ hydrogenation; however, the fundamental insights into C-H bond formation are still far from clear because of the complexity of real-life catalysts. Herein, gas-phase reactions of the Fe₂H_n^- (n = 0-3) anions with CO₂ were investigated using mass spectrometry and quantum chemical calculations. The experimental results showed that the reduction of CO₂ into CO dominates all of these reactions, whereas Fe₂H^- and Fe₂H₂^- can induce the hydrogenation of CO₂ effectively to give rise to products Fe(HCO₂)^- and HFe(HCO₂)^-, respectively. The mechanistic aspects and the reactivity of Fe₂H_n^- with an increased number of H atoms in CO₂ hydrogenation were rationalized by theoretical calculations.

Plasma-Assisted Chain Reactions of Rh3+ Clusters with Dinitrogen: N≡N Bond Dissociation

Dinitrogen activation is known as one of the most challenging subjects in chemistry. A number of well-defined metal complexes, nitrides, and clusters have been studied that show catalysis for dinitrogen activation. However, direct evidence of a complete cleavage of the N≡N triple bond at mild conditions is rather limited to date. Herein, we report a study on the dissociation of N₂ on small rhodium clusters assisted by surface plasma radiation. From mass spectrometry observation, a few rhodium nitride clusters with an odd number of nitrogen atoms are produced, such as the Rh₃N_2m-1⁺ (m = 1-5) series, indicative of N≡N bond dissociation in the mild plasma atmosphere. Interestingly, Rh₃N₇⁺ is identified with outstanding mass abundance among the Rh_nN_2m-1⁺ products, and its ground-state structure is in the form of Rh₃N(N₂)₃⁺ by capping a nitrogen atom on the top of Rh₃⁺ plane and hanging three N₂ molecules beneath the three Rh atoms respectively, giving rise to a C_3v symmetry and excellent stability. We demonstrate the catalysis of such a three-atom rhodium cluster and reveal a dinitrogen activation strategy by thermodynamics- and dynamics- favorable chain reactions of multiple N₂ molecules with two rhodium clusters under plasma atmosphere.

CO2 Hydrogenation to Formate and Formic Acid by Bimetallic Palladium-Copper Hydride Clusters

Mass spectrometric analysis of the anionic products of interaction between bimetallic palladium-copper tetrahydride anions, PdCuH₄^-, and carbon dioxide, CO₂, in a reaction cell shows an efficient generation of the PdCuCO₂H₄^- intermediate and formate/formic acid complexes. Multiple structures of PdCuH₄^- and PdCuCO₂H₄^- are identified by a synergy between anion photoelectron spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations. The higher energy PdCuH₄^- isomer is shown to drive the catalytic hydrogenation of CO₂, emphasizing the importance of accounting for higher energy isomers for cluster catalytic activity. This study represents the first example of CO₂ hydrogenation by bimetallic hydride clusters.

Nb2BN2− cluster anions reduce four carbon dioxide molecules: reactivity enhancement by ligands

The thermal gas-phase reactions of Nb₂BN₂⁻ cluster anions with carbon dioxide have been explored by using the art of time-of-flight mass spectrometry and density functional theory calculations.

Computational mechanistic investigation of the Fe + CO2 → FeO + CO reaction

High-level investigation of the kinetics of the Fe + CO₂ → FeO + CO reaction.

Structures and bonding properties of CPt2 -/0 and CPt2H-/0: Anion photoelectron spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations

We present a combined anion photoelectron spectroscopic and quantum chemical investigation on the structures and bonding properties of CPt₂ ^-/0 and CPt₂H^-/0. The experimental vertical detachment energies of CPt₂ ^- and CPt₂H^- are measured to be 1.91 ± 0.08 and 3.54 ± 0.08 eV, respectively. CPt₂ ^- is identified as a C_2v symmetric Pt-C-Pt bent structure, and CPt₂ has a D_∞h symmetric Pt-C-Pt linear structure. Both anionic and neutral CPt₂H adopt a Pt-C-Pt-H chain-shaped structure, in which the ∠PtCPt and ∠CPtH bond angles of CPt₂H^- are larger than those of CPt₂H. The Pt-C bonds in CPt₂ ^-/0 and CPt₂H^-/0 exhibit covalent double bonding characters. The Pt=C bonds are much stronger than the C-H bond that may explain why the C atom CPt₂H^-/0 prefers to form Pt=C bonds rather than C-H bonds. It may also explain why platinum can insert into the C-H bond to activate the C-H bond as reported in the literature.

Direct Conversion of Methane with Carbon Dioxide Mediated by RhVO3 - Cluster Anions

Direct conversion of methane with carbon dioxide to value-added chemicals is attractive but extremely challenging because of the thermodynamic stability and kinetic inertness of both molecules. Herein, the first dinuclear cluster species, RhVO₃ ^- , has been designed to mediate the co-conversion of CH₄ and CO₂ to oxygenated products, CH₃ OH and CH₂ O, in the temperature range of 393-600 K. The resulting cluster ions RhVO₃ CO^- after CH₃ OH formation can further desorb the [CO] unit to regenerate the RhVO₃ ^- cluster, leading to the successful establishment of a catalytic cycle for methanol production from CH₄ and CO₂ (CH₄ +CO₂ →CH₃ OH+CO). The exceptional activity of Rh-V dinuclear oxide cluster (RhVO₃ ^- ) identified herein provides a new mechanism for co-conversion of two very stable molecules CH₄ and CO₂ .

Size-Dependent Association of Cobalt Deuteride Cluster Anions Co3Dn- (n = 0-4) with Dinitrogen

Dinitrogen (N₂) activation by metal hydride species is of fundamental interest and practical importance while the role of hydrogen in N₂ activation is not well studied. Herein, the structures of Co₃D_n^- (n = 0-4) clusters and their reactions with N₂ have been studied by using a combined experimental and computational approach. The mass spectrometry experiments identified that the Co₃D_n^- (n = 2-4) clusters could adsorb N₂ while the Co₃D_n^- (n = 0 and 1) clusters were inert. The photoelectron imaging spectroscopy indicated that the electron detachment energies of Co₃D_2-4^- are smaller than those of Co₃D_0,1^-, which characterized that it is easier to transfer electrons from Co₃D_2-4^- than from Co₃D_0,1^- to activate N₂. The density functional theory calculations generally supported the experimental observations. Further analysis revealed that the H atoms in the Co₃H_n^- (n = 2-4) clusters generally result in higher energies of the Co 3d orbitals in comparison with the Co₃H_n^- (n = 0 and 1) systems. By forming chemical bonds with H atoms, the Co atoms of Co₃H_2-4^- are less negatively charged with respect to the naked Co₃^- system, which leads to higher N₂ binding energies of Co₃H_2-4N₂^- than that of Co₃N₂^-.

Release of Formic Acid from Copper Formate: Hydride, Proton-Coupled Electron and Hydrogen Atom Transfer All Play their Role

Although the mechanism for the transformation of carbon dioxide to formate with copper hydride is well understood, it is not clear how formic acid is ultimately released. Herein, we show how formic acid is formed in the decomposition of the copper formate clusters Cu(II)(HCOO)3- and Cu(II)2 (HCOO)5- . Infrared irradiation resonant with the antisymmetric C-O stretching mode activates the cluster, resulting in the release of formic acid and carbon dioxide. For the binary cluster, electronic structure calculations indicate that CO2 is eliminated first, through hydride transfer from formate to copper. Formic acid is released via proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) to a second formate ligand, evidenced by close to zero partial charge and spin density at the hydrogen atom in the transition state. Concomitantly, the two copper centers are reduced from Cu(II) to Cu(I). Depending on the detailed situation, either PCET or hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) takes place.

Unambiguous hydrogenation of CO2 by coinage-metal hydride anions: an intuitive idea based on in silico experiments

Coinage metal hydride anions, especially AgH⁻, can effectively and deterministically hydrogenate CO₂ to HCO₂⁻.

Carbon-carbon bond formation in the reaction of hydrated carbon dioxide radical anions with 3-butyn-1-ol

Electrochemical activation of carbon dioxide in aqueous solution is a promising way to use carbon dioxide as a C1 building block. Mechanistic studies in the gas phase play an important role to understand the inherent chemical reactivity of the carbon dioxide radical anion. Here, the reactivity of CO2 •-(H2O)n with 3-butyn-1-ol is investigated by Fourier transform ion cyclotron (FT-ICR) mass spectrometry and quantum chemical calculations. Carbon-carbon bond formation takes places, but is associated with a barrier. Therefore, bond formation may require uptake of several butynol molecules. The water molecules slowly evaporate from the cluster due to the absorption of room temperature black-body radiation. When all water molecules are lost, butynol evaporation sets in. In this late stage of the reaction, side reactions occur including H• atom transfer and elimination of HOCO•.

de Oliveira-Filho AG, Braga AAC. Unveiling the potential of scandium complexes for methane C–H bond activation: a computational study

Sc(i) complexes activate methane C–H bonds under mild conditions.

Coupling of Methane and Carbon Dioxide Mediated by Diatomic Copper Boride Cations

The use of CH₄ and CO₂ to produce value-added chemicals via direct C-C coupling is a challenging chemistry problem because of the inertness of these two molecules. Herein, mass spectrometric experiments and high-level quantum-chemical calculations have identified the first diatomic species (CuB⁺ ) that can couple CH₄ with CO₂ under thermal collision conditions to produce ketene (H₂ C=C=O), an important intermediate in synthetic chemistry. The order to feed the reactants (CH₄ and CO₂ ) is important and CH₄ should be firstly fed to produce the C₂ product. Molecular-level mechanisms including control of product selectivity have been revealed for coupling of CH₄ with CO₂ under mild conditions.