Repositioning Chloride Transmembrane Transporters: Transport of Organic Ion Pairs

Exploiting the Mechanical Bond Effect for Enhanced Molecular Recognition and Sensing

The ubiquity of charged species in biological and industrial processes has resulted in ever-increasing interest in their selective recognition, detection, and environmental remediation. Building on the established coordination chemistry principles of the chelate and macrocyclic effects, and host preorganization, supramolecular chemists seek to construct specific 3D binding cavities reminiscent of biotic systems to enhance host-guest binding affinity and selectivity. Mechanically interlocked molecules (MIMs) present a wholly unique platform for synthetic host design, wherein topologies afforded by the mechanical bond enable the decoration of 3D cavities for non-covalent interactions with a range of target guest geometries. Notably, MIM host systems exhibit mechanical bond effect augmented affinities and selectivities for a variety of charged guest species, compared to non-interlocked acyclic and macrocycle host analogs. Furthermore, the modular nature of MIM synthesis facilitates incorporation of optical and electrochemical reporter groups, enabling fabrication of highly sensitive and specific molecular sensors. This review discusses the development of recognition and sensing MIMs, from the first reports in the late 20th century through to the present day, delineating how their topologically preorganized and dynamic host cavities enhance charged guest recognition and sensing, demonstrating the mechanical bond effect as a potent tool in future chemosensing materials.

Fullerene-Functionalized Halogen-Bonding Heteroditopic Hosts for Ion-Pair Recognition

Despite their hydrophobic surfaces with localized π-holes and rigid well-defined architectures providing a scaffold for preorganizing binding motifs, fullerenes remain unexplored as potential supramolecular host platforms for the recognition of anions. Herein, we present the first example of the rational design, synthesis, and unique recognition properties of novel fullerene-functionalized halogen-bonding (XB) heteroditopic ion-pair receptors containing cation and anion binding domains spatially separated by C60. Fullerene spatial separation of the XB donors and the crown ether complexed potassium cation resulted in a rare example of an artificial receptor containing two anion binding sites with opposing preferences for hard and soft halides. Importantly, the incorporation of the C60 motif into the heteroditopic receptor structure has a significant effect on the halide binding selectivity, which is further amplified upon K+ cation binding. The potassium cation complexed fullerene-based receptors exhibit enhanced selectivity for the soft polarizable iodide ion which is assisted by the C60 scaffold preorganizing the potent XB-based binding domains, anion-π interactions, and the exceptional polarizability of the fullerene moiety, as evidenced from DFT calculations. These observations serve to highlight the unique properties of fullerene surfaces for proximal charged guest binding with potential applications in construction of selective molecular sensors and modulating the properties of solar cell devices.

Selective binding of oxalate by a tris-ureido calix[6]tube in a protic environment

Due to their significant role in industry and biological systems, the interest in selectively recognizing and detecting small dicarboxylates has grown in recent years. In this study, we report on the binding properties of a family of tubular-shaped heterotritopic receptors based on bis-calix[6]arenes, which contain three (thio)urea bridges (C3U and C3TU) or six urea bridges (C6U), toward dicarboxylates. While poor binding properties were observed by NMR for the newly synthesized C6U, receptors C3U and C3TU exhibited a unique ability to cooperatively complex a dicarboxylate anion sandwiched between two ammonium ions. The three ions are complexed in contact and aligned within the tubular shape of the receptor, forming cascade complexes that are stable even in a competitive environment. The different binding properties between the receptors were rationalized in terms of size, flexibility, H-bond donor ability, and intramolecular H-bonding within the anion binding pocket between the calixarene cavities. With C3U, a rare selectivity for oxalate over other small dicarboxylates and various bicharged anions was observed. Molecular modeling of the cascade complex indicated that the oxalate anion is stabilized by an array of hydrogen bonds with the urea bridges of the receptor and both propylammonium cations nested within the calixarene cavities.

Transmembrane Transport of Inorganic Phosphate by a Strapped Calix[4]pyrrole

Synthetic anion receptors are increasingly being explored for the transport of anions across lipid membranes because of their potential therapeutic applications. A considerable amount of research focuses on the transport of chloride, whereas the transmembrane transport of inorganic phosphate has not been reported to date, despite the biological relevance of this anion. Here we present a calix[4]pyrrole with a bisurea strap that functions as a receptor and transporter for H₂PO₄^-, relying on the formation of eight hydrogen bonds and efficient encapsulation of the anion. Using a phosphate-sensitive lanthanide probe and ³¹P NMR spectroscopy, we demonstrate that this receptor can transport phosphate into vesicles by H₂PO₄^-/Cl^- antiport, H₂PO₄^- uniport, and Cs⁺/H₂PO₄^- symport mechanisms. This first example of inorganic phosphate transport by a neutral receptor opens perspectives for the future development of transporters for various biological phosphates.

Highly Selective Transport and Enrichment of Lithium Ions through Bionic Ion Pair Receptor Nanochannels

Inspired by ion pair cotransport channels in biological systems, a bionic nanochannel modified with lithium ion pair receptors is constructed for selective transport and enrichment of lithium ions (Li⁺). NH₂-pillar[5]arene (NP5) is chosen as ion pair receptors, and the theoretical simulation and NMR titration experiments illustrate that NP5 has good affinity for the ion pair of LiCl through a strong host-guest interaction at the molecular level. Due to the confinement effect and ion pair cooperation recognition, an NP5-based receptor was introduced into an artificial PET nanochannel. An I-V test indicated that the NP5 channel realized the highly selective recognition for Li⁺. Meanwhile, transmembrane transport and COMSOL simulation experiments proved that the NP5 channel achieved the transport and enrichment of Li⁺ through the cooperative interaction between NP5 and LiCl. Moreover, the receptor solution of transmembrane transport LiCl in the NP5 channel was used to cultivate wheat seedlings, which obviously promoted their growth. This nanochannel based on the ion pair recognition will be much useful for practical applications like metal ion extraction, enrichment, and recycle.

A 4-state acid-base controlled molecular switch based on a host-guest system

A novel Zn^II funnel complex that presents three phenol functions within a calix[6]arene macrocycle is described. Host-guest studies, monitored by ¹H NMR spectroscopy, evaluate the impact of the replacement of three anisole moieties present in a previously described system with phenols. It is now shown that the dicationic complex is responsive to anions, whereas deprotonation of one phenol unit completely inhibits any hosting response. These properties, combined with those of the corresponding protonated ligand, allow us to obtain different molecular switches, and one of them shows guest embedment changes between four different host states, thus giving rise to a rare case of a triple molecular switch.

Cholesterol-stabilized membrane-active nanopores with anticancer activities

Cholesterol-enhanced pore formation is one evolutionary means cholesterol-free bacterial cells utilize to specifically target cholesterol-rich eukaryotic cells, thus escaping the toxicity these membrane-lytic pores might have brought onto themselves. Here, we present a class of artificial cholesterol-dependent nanopores, manifesting nanopore formation sensitivity, up-regulated by cholesterol of up to 50 mol% (relative to the lipid molecules). The high modularity in the amphiphilic molecular backbone enables a facile tuning of pore size and consequently channel activity. Possessing a nano-sized cavity of ~ 1.6 nm in diameter, our most active channel Ch-C1 can transport nanometer-sized molecules as large as 5(6)-carboxyfluorescein and display potent anticancer activity (IC₅₀ = 3.8 µM) toward human hepatocellular carcinomas, with high selectivity index values of 12.5 and >130 against normal human liver and kidney cells, respectively.

Bacterial cells utilize cholesterol-enhanced pore formation to specifically target eukaryotic cells. Here, the authors present a class of bio-inspired, cholesterol-enhanced nanopores which display anticancer activities in vitro.

Dynamic Covalent Self-Assembly of Chloride- and Ion-Pair-Templated Cryptates

While supramolecular hosts capable of binding and transporting anions and ion pairs are now widely available, self‐assembled architectures are still rare, even though they offer an inherent mechanism for the release of the guest ion(s). In this work, we report the dynamic covalent self‐assembly of tripodal, urea‐based anion cryptates that are held together by two orthoester bridgeheads. These hosts exhibit affinity for anions such as Cl⁻, Br⁻ or I⁻ in the moderate range that is typically advantageous for applications in membrane transport. In unprecedented experiments, we were able to dissociate the Cs⋅Cl ion pair by simultaneously assembling suitably sized orthoester hosts around the Cs⁺ and the Cl⁻ ion.

Calix[6]arenes with halogen bond donor groups as selective and efficient anion transporters

Here we present the anion binding and anion transport properties of a series of calix[6]arenes decorated on their small rim with either halogen bond or hydrogen bond donating groups. We show that the halogen bond donating iodotriazole groups enable highly selective transport of chloride and nitrate anions, without transport of protons or hydroxide, at rates similar to those observed with thiourea or squaramide groups.

A calix[6]arene with three preorganised halogen bond donating groups gives >100-fold selectivity for Cl⁻ uniport over HCl symport, in contrast to analogous compounds with strong hydrogen bond donating groups.

Membrane-Active Molecular Machines

Both biological and artificial membrane transporters mediate passive transmembrane ion flux predominantly via either channel or carrier mechanisms, tightly regulating the transport of materials entering and exiting the cell. One early elegant example unclassifiable as carriers or channels was reported by Smith who derivatized a phospholipid molecule into an anion transporter, facilitating membrane transport via a two-station relay mechanism (Smith et al. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2008, 130, 17274-17275). Our journey toward blurring or even breaking the boundaries defined by the carrier and channel mechanisms starts in January of 2018 when seeing a child swinging on the swing at the playground park. Since then, I have been wondering whether we could build a nanoscale-sized molecular swing able to perform the swing function at the molecular level to induce transmembrane ion flux. Such research journey culminates in several membrane-active artificial molecular machines, including molecular swings, ion fishers, ion swimmers, rotors, tetrapuses and dodecapuses that permeabilize the membrane via swinging, ion-fishing, swimming, rotating, or swing-relaying actions, respectively. Except for molecular ion swimmers, these unconventional membrane transporters in their most stable states readily span across the entire membrane in a way akin to channels. With built-in flexible arms that can swing or bend in the dynamic membrane environment, they transport ions via constantly changing ion permeation pathways that are more defined than carriers but less defined than channels. Applying the same benzo-crown ether groups as the sole ion-binding and -transporting units, these transporters however differ immensely in ion transport property. While the maximal K⁺ transport activity is achieved by the molecular swing also termed "motional channel" that displays an EC₅₀ value of 0.021 mol % relative to lipid and transports K⁺ ions at rate 27% faster than gramicidin A, the highest K⁺/Na⁺ selectivity of 18.3 is attained by the molecular ion fisher, with the highest Na⁺/K⁺ selectivity of 13.7 by the molecular dodecapus. Having EC₅₀ values of 0.49-1.60 mol % and K⁺/Na⁺ values of 1.1-6.3, molecular rotors and tetrapuses are found to be generally active but weakly to moderately K⁺-selective. For molecular ion swimmers that contain 10 to 14 carbon atom alkyl linkers, they all turn out to be highly active (EC₅₀ = 0.18-0.41 mol %) and highly selective (R_K⁺/R_Na⁺ = 7.0-9.5) transporters. Of special note are crown ether-appended molecular dodecapuses that establish the C₆₀-fullerene core as an excellent platform to allow for a direct translation of solution binding affinity to transmembrane ion transport selectivity, providing a de novo basis for rationally designing artificial ion transporters with high transport selectivity. Considering remarkable cytotoxic activities displayed by molecular swings and ion swimmers, the varied types of existing and emerging unconventional membrane transporters with enhanced activities and selectivities eventually might lead to medical benefits in the future.

Cation-chloride cotransport mediated by an ion pair transporter

Ion transport mediated by an ion pair receptor 1 bearing both cation and anion binding sites is presented. The ion pair binding property was revealed by means of ¹H NMR titrations in organic solutions and X-ray analysis in the solid state. Single crystal structures demonstrated that 1 and CaI₂ formed a solvent-separated ion-pair complex with two iodides each interacting with a triazine ring through anion-π interactions, whereas the calcium ion is bound by a pentaethylene glycol moiety. The ion transport activity was studied by monitoring the efflux of ions from salt-loaded EYPC large unilamellar vesicles (EYPC-LUVs) using ion selective electrodes. Chloride transport across the membrane mediated by the ion pair receptor through K⁺/Cl^- or Na⁺/Cl^- cotransport with a selectivity towards the K⁺/Cl^- symport was realized.

Supramolecular chemistry in lipid bilayer membranes

Lipid bilayer membranes form compartments requisite for life. Interfacing supramolecular systems, including receptors, catalysts, signal transducers and ion transporters, enables the function of the membrane to be controlled in artificial and living cellular compartments. In this perspective, we take stock of the current state of the art of this rapidly expanding field, and discuss prospects for the future in both fundamental science and applications in biology and medicine.

Boosting Anion Transport Activity of Diamidocarbazoles by Electron Withdrawing Substituents

Artificial chloride transporters have been intensely investigated in view of their potential medicinal applications. Recently, we have established 1,8-diamidocarbazoles as a versatile platform for the development of active chloride carriers. In the present contribution, we investigate the influence of various electron-withdrawing substituents in positions 3 and 6 of the carbazole core on the chloride transport activity of these anionophores. Using lucigenin assay and large unilamellar vesicles as models, the 3,6-dicyano- and 3,6-dinitro- substituted receptors were found to be highly active and perfectly deliverable chloride transporters, with EC50,270s value as low as 22 nM for the Cl-/NO3 - exchange. Mechanistic studies revealed that diamidocarbazoles form 1:1 complexes with chloride in lipid bilayers and facilitate chloride/nitrate exchange by carrier mechanism. Furthermore, owing to its increased acidity, the 3,6-dinitro- substituted receptor acts as a pH-switchable transporter, with physiologically relevant apparent pKa of 6.4.

Fluorescent Molecular Cages with Sucrose and Cyclotriveratrylene Units for the Selective Recognition of Choline and Acetylcholine

The synthesis of four fluorescent diastereoisomeric molecular cages containing cyclotriveratrylene and sucrose moieties connected via the naphthalene linkers is reported. These diastereoisomers were found to be selective and efficient receptors for acetylcholine and choline. Compound P-5a has a better affinity for choline over acetylcholine, while cage M-5a exhibits a higher association constant for acetylcholine over choline. The highest selectivity value was observed for compound M-5a (K_ACh/K_Ch = 3.1). Cages P-5a, P-5b, M-5a, and M-5b were fully characterized by the advanced NMR techniques, and ECD spectroscopy was supported by DFT calculations. The binding constants K_a of these receptors were determined by fluorescence titration experiments in acetonitrile.

From Heteroditopic to Multitopic Receptors for Ion-Pair Recognition: Advances in Receptor Design and Applications

Ion-pair recognition has emerged from cation and anion recognition and become a diverse and active field in its own right. The last decade has seen significant advances in receptor design in terms of the types of binding motifs, understanding of cooperativity and increase in complexity from heteroditopic to multitopic receptors. As a result, attention has turned to applying this knowledge to the rational design of ion-pair receptors for applications in salt solubilisation and extraction, membrane transport and sensing. This Review highlights recent progress and developments in the design and applications of heteroditopic and multitopic receptors for ion-pair recognition.

Small Molecule-Based Highly Active and Selective K+ Transporters with Potent Anticancer Activities

We report here a novel class of cation transporters with extreme simplicity, opening a whole new dimension of scientific research for finding small molecule-based cation transporters for therapeutic applications. Comprising three modular components (a headgroup, a flexible alkyl chain-derived body, and a crown ether-derived foot for ion binding), these transporters efficiently (EC₅₀ = 0.18-0.41 mol % relative to lipid) and selectively (K⁺/Na⁺ selectivity = 7.0-9.5) move K⁺ ions across the membrane. Importantly, the most active (EC₅₀ = 0.18-0.22 mol %) and highly selective series of transporters A12, B12, and C12 concurrently possess potent anticancer activities with IC₅₀ values as low as 4.35 ± 0.91 and 6.00 ± 0.13 μM toward HeLa and PC3 cells, respectively. Notably, a mere replacement of the 18-crown-6 unit in the structure with 12-crown-4 or 15-crown-5 units completely annihilates the cation-transporting ability.

Fast transport of HCl across a hydrophobic layer over macroscopic distances by using a Pt(II) compound as the transporter: micro- and nanometric aggregates as effective transporters

Bis-(diethyl-dithioxamidate)platinum(ii) is able to transport HCl from the donor aqueous phase to the receiving one over a mean distance of 12 cm in about 3 minutes across an organic membrane in the bulk, without stirring of the organic phase, i.e. at a rate far exceeding the unidirectional macroscopic diffusion coefficient. The way in which this surprising phenomenon can happen is linked to the behaviour of HCl which, because of dynamic interactions with [Pt(HEt2C2N2S2)2] (in which HCl is hosted as a tight ion pair [Pt(H2Et2C2N2S2)2][Cl]2) and chloroform molecules, gives rise to observable nanometric and micrometric domains, more dense than the surrounding bulk, whose formation and disaggregation processes accelerate the unidirectional macroscopic diffusion of HCl. Thermodynamic parameters obtained from the study of acid-base behaviour of the system Pt(ii) species/HCl/CHCl3 also agree with the proposed mechanism of HCl transport.

Sensing and Liquid-Liquid Extraction of Dicarboxylates Using Dicopper Cryptates

We report the investigation of dicopper(II) bistren cryptate, containing naphthyl spacers between the tren subunits, as a receptor for polycarboxylates in neutral aqueous solution. An indicator displacement assay for dicarboxylates was also developed by mixing the azacryptate with the fluorescent indicator 5-carboxyfluorescein in a 50:1 molar ratio. Fluorimetric studies showed a significant restoration of fluorophore emission upon addition of fumarate anions followed by succinate and isophthalate. The introduction of hexyl chains on the naphthalene groups created a novel hydrophobic cage; the corresponding dicopper complex was investigated as an extractant for dicarboxylates from neutral water into dichloromethane. The liquid-liquid extraction of succinate-as a model anion-was successfully achieved by exploiting the high affinity of this anionic guest for the azacryptate cavity. Extraction was monitored through the changes in the UV-visible spectrum of the dicopper complex in dichloromethane and by measuring the residual concentration of succinate in the aqueous phase by HPLC-UV. The successful extraction was also confirmed by 1H-NMR spectroscopy. Considering the relevance of polycarboxylates in biochemistry and in the environmental field, e.g., as waste products of industrial processes, our results open new perspectives for research in all contexts where recognition, sensing, or extraction of polycarboxylates is required.

Enhancement of Ion Pairing of Sr(II) and Ba(II) Salts by a Tritopic Ion-Pair Receptor in Solution

Tritopic ion-pair receptors can bind bivalent salts in solution; yet, these salts have a tendency to form ion-pairs even in the absence of receptors. The extent to which such receptors can enhance ion pairing has however remained elusive. Here, we study ion pairing of M2+ (Ba2+ , Sr2+ ) and X- (I- , ClO4- ) in acetonitrile with and without a dichlorooxacalix[2]arene[2]triazine-related receptor containing a pentaethylene-glycol moiety. We find marked ion association already in receptor-free solutions. When present, most of the MX+ ion-pairs are bound to the receptor and the overall degree of ion association is enhanced due to coordinative, hydrogen-bonding, and anion-π interactions. The receptor shows higher selectivity for iodides but also stabilizes perchlorates, despite the latter are often considered as weakly coordinating anions. Our results show that ion-pair binding is strongly correlated to ion pairing in these solutions, thereby highlighting the importance of taking ion association in organic solvents into account.

Advances in anion transport and supramolecular medicinal chemistry

Advances in anion transport by synthetic supramolecular systems are discussed in this article. Developments in the design of discrete molecular carriers for anions and supramolecular anion channels are reviewed followed by an overview of the use of these systems in biological systems as putative treatments for diseases such as cystic fibrosis and cancer.

Transmembrane transport of copper(i) by imidazole-functionalised calix[4]arenes

Here we present the first synthetic transmembrane transporters for Cu⁺. Calix[4]arenes with two imidazole groups have a linear coordination motif, which allows selective extraction of Cu⁺ into chloroform. Transmembrane transport of Cu⁺ into liposomes was investigated with a newly developed assay and the results open the way to biomedical applications of these Cu⁺ ionophores.