Selective Activation of the C-H Bond in Methane by Single Platinum Atomic Anions

Ab initio exploration of low-lying electronic states of linear and bent MNX+ (M = Ca, Sr, Ba, Ra; X = O, S, Se, Te, Po) and their origins

High-level multireference and coupled cluster quantum calculations were employed to analyze low-lying electronic states of linear-MNX+ and side-bonded-M[NX]+ (M = Ca, Sr, Ba, Ra; X = O, S, Se, Te, Po) species. Their full potential energy curves (PECs), dissociation energies (Des), geometric parameters, excitation energies (Tes), and harmonic vibrational frequencies (ωes) are reported. The first three chemically bound electronic states of MNX+ and M[NX]+ are 3∑-, 1Δ, 1∑+ and 3A″, 1A', 1A″, respectively. The 3∑-, 1Δ, 1∑+ of MNX+ originate from the M+(2D) + NX(2Π) fragments, whereas the 3A″, 1A', 1A″ states of M[NX]+ dissociate to M+(2S) + NX(2Π) as a result of avoided crossings. The MNX+ and M[NX]+ are real minima on the potential energy surface and their interconversions are possible. The M2+NX-/M2+[NX]- ionic structure is an accurate representation for their low-lying electronic states. The Des of MNX+ species were found to depend on the dipole moment (μ) of the corresponding NX ligands and a linear relationship between these two parameters was observed.

Wavefunction theory and density functional theory analysis of ground and excited electronic states of TaB and WB

Several low-lying electronic states of TaB and WB molecules were studied using ab initio multireference configuration interaction (MRCI), Davidson corrected MRCI (MRCI+Q), and coupled cluster singles doubles and perturbative triples [CCSD(T)] methods. Their full potential energy curves (PECs), equilibrium electron configurations, equilibrium bond distances (res), dissociation energies (Des), excitation energies (Tes), harmonic vibrational frequencies (ωes), and anharmonicities (ωexes) are reported. The MRCI dipole moment curves (DMCs) of the first 5 electronic states of both TaB and WB are also reported and the equilibrium dipole moment (μ) values are compared with the CCSD(T) μ values. The most stable 13Π (1σ22σ23σ11π3) and 15Δ (1σ22σ23σ11π21δ1) electronic states of TaB lie close in energy with ∼62 kcal mol-1De with respect to the Ta(4F) + B(2P) asymptote. However, spin-orbit coupling effects make the 15Δ0+ state the true ground state of TaB. The ground electronic state of WB (16Π) has the 1σ22σ13σ11π31δ2 electron configuration and is followed by the excited 16Σ+ and 14Δ states. Finally, the MRCI De, re, ωe, and ωexe values of the 13Π state of TaB and 16Π and 14Δ states of WB are used to assess the density functional theory (DFT) errors on a series of exchange-correlation functionals that span multiple-rungs of the Jacob's ladder of density functional approximations (DFA).

Highly efficient, selective, and stable photocatalytic methane coupling to ethane enabled by lattice oxygen looping

Light-driven oxidative coupling of methane (OCM) for multi-carbon (C2+) product evolution is a promising approach toward the sustainable production of value-added chemicals, yet remains challenging due to its low intrinsic activity. Here, we demonstrate the integration of bismuth oxide (BiOx) and gold (Au) on titanium dioxide (TiO2) substrate to achieve a high conversion rate, product selectivity, and catalytic durability toward photocatalytic OCM through rational catalytic site engineering. Mechanistic investigations reveal that the lattice oxygen in BiOx is effectively activated as the localized oxidant to promote methane dissociation, while Au governs the methyl transfer to avoid undesirable overoxidation and promote carbon─carbon coupling. The optimal Au/BiOx-TiO2 hybrid delivers a conversion rate of 20.8 millimoles per gram per hour with C2+ product selectivity high to 97% in the flow reactor. More specifically, the veritable participation of lattice oxygen during OCM is chemically looped by introduced dioxygen via the Mars-van Krevelen mechanism, endowing superior catalyst stability.

Conversion of Methane at Room Temperature Mediated by the Ta-Ta σ-Bond

Metal-metal bonds constitute an important type of reactive centers for chemical transformation; however, the availability of active metal-metal bonds being capable of converting methane under mild conditions, the holy grail in catalysis, remains a serious challenge. Herein, benefiting from the systematic investigation of 36 metal clusters of tantalum by using mass spectrometric experiments complemented with quantum chemical calculations, the dehydrogenation of methane at room temperature was successfully achieved by 18 cluster species featuring σ-bonding electrons localized in single naked Ta-Ta centers. In sharp contrast, the other 18 remaining clusters, either without naked Ta-Ta σ-bond or with σ-bonding electrons delocalized over multiple Ta-Ta centers only exhibit molecular CH4-adsorption reactivity or inertness. Mechanistic studies revealed that changing cluster geometric configurations and tuning the number of simple inorganic ligands (e.g., oxygen) could flexibly manipulate the presence or absence of such a reactive Ta-Ta σ-bond. The discovery of Ta-Ta σ-type bond being able to exhibit outstanding activity toward methane conversion not only overturns the traditional recognition that only the metal-metal π- or δ-bonds of early transition metals could participate in bond activation but also opens up a new access to design of promising metal catalysts with dual-atom as reactive sites for chemical transformations.

Spectroscopic Characterization of Thermal Methane Activation by Lewis-Acid-Base Pair in a Gas-Phase Metal Nitride Anion Ta2N3. Chemphyschem 2024;25:e202400116. [PMID: 38380870 DOI: 10.1002/cphc.202400116] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0]

Activation and transformation of methane is one of the "holy grails" in catalysis. Understanding the nature of active sites and mechanistic details via spectroscopic characterization of the reactive sites and key intermediates is of great challenge but crucial for the development of novel strategies for methane transformation. Herein, by employing photoelectron velocity-map imaging (PEVMI) spectroscopy in conjunction with quantum chemistry calculations, the Lewis acid-base pair (LABP) of [Taδ+-Nδ-] unit in Ta2N3 - acting as an active center to accomplish the heterolytic cleavage of C-H bond in CH4 has been confirmed by direct characterization of the reactant ion Ta2N3 - and the CH4-adduct intermediate Ta2N3CH4 -. Two active vibrational modes for the reactant (Ta2N3 -) and four active vibrational modes for the intermediate (Ta2N3CH4 -) were observed from the vibrationally resolved PEVMI spectra, which unequivocally determined the structure of Ta2N3 - and Ta2N3CH4 -. Upon heating, the LABP intermediate (Ta2N3CH4 -) containing the NH and Ta-CH3 unit can undergo the processes of C-N coupling and dehydrogenation to form the product with an adsorbed HCN molecule.

Thermal Reactions of NiAl3O6+ and Al4O6+ with Methane: Reactivity Enhancement by Doping

Investigation of the reactivity of heteronuclear metal oxide clusters is an important way to uncover the molecular-level mechanisms of the doping effect. Herein, we performed a comparative study on the reactions of CH4 with NiAl3O6+ and Al4O6+ cluster cations at room temperature to understand the role of Ni during the activation and transformation of methane. Mass spectrometric experiments identify that both NiAl3O6+ and Al4O6+ could bring about hydrogen atom abstraction reaction to generate CH3• radical; however, only NiAl3O6+ has the potential to stabilize [CH3] moiety and then transform [CH3] to CH2O. Density functional theory calculations demonstrate that the terminal oxygen radicals (Ot-•) bound to Al act as the reactive sites for the two clusters to activate the first C-H bond. Although the Ni atom cannot directly participate in methane activation, it can manipulate the electronic environment of the surrounding bridging oxygen atoms (Ob) and enable such Ob to function as an electron reservoir to help Ot-• oxidize CH4 to [H-O-CH3]. The facile reduction of Ni3+ to Ni+ also facilitates the subsequent step of activating the second C-H bond by the bridging "lattice oxygen" (Ob2-), finally enabling the oxidation of methane into formaldehyde. The important role of the dopant Ni played in improving the product selectivity of CH2O for methane conversion discovered in this study allows us to have a possible molecule-level understanding of the excellent performance of the catalysts doping with nickel.

Pt+(C2H2)n Complexes Studied with Selected-Ion Infrared Spectroscopy

Platinum cation complexes with multiple acetylene molecules are studied with mass spectrometry and infrared laser spectroscopy. Complexes of the form Pt⁺(C₂H₂)_n are produced in a molecular beam by laser vaporization, analyzed with a time-of-flight mass spectrometer, and selected by mass for studies of their vibrational spectroscopy. Photodissociation action spectra in the C-H stretching region are compared to the spectra predicted for different structural isomers using density functional theory. The comparison between experiment and theory demonstrates that platinum forms cation-π complexes with up to three acetylene molecules, producing an unanticipated asymmetric structure for the three-ligand complex. Additional acetylenes form solvation structures around this three-ligand core. Reacted structures that couple acetylene molecules (e.g., to form benzene) are found by theory to be energetically favorable, but their formation is inhibited under the conditions of these experiments by large activation barriers.

Transition metal oxide complexes as molecular catalysts for selective methane to methanol transformation: any prospects or time to retire?

Transition metal oxides have been extensively used in the literature for the conversion of methane to methanol. Despite the progress made over the past decades, no method with satisfactory performance or economic viability has been detected. The main bottleneck is that the produced methanol oxidizes further due to its weaker C-H bond than that of methane. Every improvement in the efficiency of a catalyst to activate methane leads to reduction of the selectivity towards methanol. Is it therefore prudent to keep studying (both theoretically and experimentally) metal oxides as catalysts for the quantitative conversion of methane to methanol? This perspective focuses on molecular metal oxide complexes and suggests strategies to bypass the current bottlenecks with higher weight on the computational chemistry side. We first discuss the electronic structure of metal oxides, followed by assessing the role of the ligands in the reactivity of the catalysts. For better selectivity, we propose that metal oxide anionic complexes should be explored further, while hydrophylic cavities in the vicinity of the metal oxide can perturb the transition-state structure for methanol increasing appreciably the activation barrier for methanol. We also emphasize that computational studies should target the activation reaction of methanol (and not only methane), the study of complete catalytic cycles (including the recombination and oxidation steps), and the use of molecular oxygen as an oxidant. The titled chemical conversion is an excellent challenge for theory and we believe that computational studies should lead the field in the future. It is finally shown that bottom-up approaches offer a systematic way for exploration of the chemical space and should still be applied in parallel with the recently popular machine learning techniques. To answer the question of the title, we believe that metal oxides should still be considered provided that we change our focus and perform more systematic investigations on the activation of methanol.

CH4 activation by PtX+ (X = F, Cl, Br, I)

Reactions of PtX⁺ (X = F, Cl, Br, I) with methane have been investigated at the density functional theory (DFT) level. These reactions take place more easily along the low-spin potential energy surface. For HX (X = F, Cl, Br, I) elimination, the formal oxidation state of the metal ion appears to be conserved, and the importance of this reaction channel decreases in going as the sequence: X = F, Cl, Br, I. A reversed trend is observed in the loss of H₂ for X = F, Cl, Br, while it is not favorable for PtI⁺ in the loss of either HI or H₂. For HX eliminations, the transfer form of H is from proton to atom, last to hydride, and the mechanisms are from PCET to HAT, last to HT for the sequence of X = F, Cl, Br, I. One reason is mainly due to the electronegativity of halogens. Otherwise, the mechanisms of HX eliminations also can be explained by the analysis of Frontier Molecular Orbitals. While for the loss of H₂, the transfer of H is in the form of hydride for all the X ligands. Noncovalent interactions analysis also can be explained the reaction mechanisms.

Ion spectroscopy in methane activation

This review is devoted to ion spectroscopy studies of complexes relevant for the understanding of methane activation with metal ions and clusters. Methane activation starts with the formation of a complex with a metal ion. The degree of the interaction between an intact methane molecule and the ion can be monitored by the perturbations of C-H stretch vibrations in the methane molecule. Binding mediated by the electrostatic interaction results in a η3 type coordination of methane. In contrast, binding governed by orbital interactions results in a η2 type coordination of methane. We further review the spectroscopic characterization of activation products of metal-methane reactions, such as the metal-carbene and carbyne products resulting from the interaction of selected 5d metals with methane. The focus of recent research in the field has shifted towards the investigation of interactions between methane and metal clusters. We show examples highlighting that metal clusters can be more reactive in methane activation reactions.

Gas-Phase Synthesis of Metal Olefins: Plasma-Assisted Methane Dehydrogenation and C═C Bond Formation

Methane dehydrogenation and C-C coupling under mild conditions are very important but challenging in chemistry. Utilizing a customized time of flight mass spectrometer combined with a magnetron sputtering (MagS) cluster source, here, we have conducted a study on the reactions of methane with small silver and copper clusters simply by introducing methane in argon as the working gas for sputtering. Interestingly, a series of [M(C_nH_2n)]⁺ (M = Cu and Ag; n = 2-12) clusters were observed, indicating high-efficiency methane dehydrogenation in such a plasma-assisted chamber system. Density functional theory calculations find the lowest energy structures of the [M(C_nH_2n)]⁺ series pertaining to olefins indicative of both C-H bond activation of methane and C-C bond coupling. We analyzed the interactions involved in the [Cu(C_nH_2n)]⁺ and [Ag(C_nH_2n)]⁺ (n = 1-6) clusters and demonstrated the reaction coordinates for the "Cu⁺ + CH₄" and "Ag⁺ + CH₄." It is illustrated that the presence of a second methane molecule enables us to reduce the necessary energy of dehydrogenation, which concurs with the experimental observation of an absence of the metal carbine products Cu⁺CH₂ and Ag⁺CH₂, which are short-lived. Also, it is elucidated that the higher-lying excitation states of Cu⁺ and Ag⁺ ions enable more favorable dehydrogenation process and C═C bond formation, shedding light on the plasma assistance of the essence.

Study of the Reaction of Hydroxylamine with Iridium Atomic and Cluster Anions (n = 1-5)

Elucidating the multifaceted processes of molecular activation and subsequent reactions gives a fundamental view into the development of iridium catalysts as they apply to fuels and propellants, for example, for spacecraft thrusters. Hydroxylamine, a component of the well-known hydroxylammonium nitrate (HAN) ionic liquid, is a safer alternative and mimics the chemistry and performance standards of hydrazine. The activation of hydroxylamine by anionic iridium clusters, Ir_n^- (n = 1-5), depicts a part of the mechanism, where two hydrogen atoms are removed, likely as H₂, and Ir_n(NOH)^- clusters remain. The significant photoelectron spectral differences between these products and the bare clusters illustrate the substantial electronic changes imposed by the hydroxylamine fragment on the iridium clusters. In combination with DFT calculations, a preliminary reaction mechanism is proposed, identifying the possible intermediate steps leading to the formation of Ir(NOH)^-.

Room-Temperature Methane Activation Mediated by Free Tantalum Cluster Cations: Size-by-Size Reactivity

The energetics of small cationic tantalum clusters and their gas-phase adsorption and dehydrogenation reaction pathways with methane are investigated with ion-trap experiments and spin-density-functional-theory calculations. Ta_n⁺ clusters are exposed to methane under multicollision conditions in a cryogenic ring electrode ion-trap. The cluster size affects the reaction efficiency and the number of consecutively dehydrogenated methane molecules. Small clusters (n = 1-4) dehydrogenate CH₄ and concurrently eliminate H₂, while larger clusters (n > 4) demonstrate only molecular adsorption of methane. Unique behavior is found for the Ta⁺ cation, which dehydrogenates consecutively up to four CH₄ molecules and is predicted theoretically to promote formation of a [Ta(CH₂-CH₂-CH₂)(CH₂)]⁺ product, exhibiting C-C coupled groups. Underlying mechanisms, including reaction-enhancing couplings between potential energy surfaces of different spin-multiplicities, are uncovered.

Catalytic Co-Conversion of CH4 and CO2 Mediated by Rhodium-Titanium Oxide Anions RhTiO2. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl 2021;60:13788-13792. [PMID: 33890352 PMCID: PMC8251526 DOI: 10.1002/anie.202103808]

Catalytic co‐conversion of methane with carbon dioxide to produce syngas (2 H₂+2 CO) involves complicated elementary steps and almost all the elementary reactions are performed at the same high temperature conditions in practical thermocatalysis. Here, we demonstrate by mass spectrometric experiments that RhTiO₂⁻ promotes the co‐conversion of CH₄ and CO₂ to free 2 H₂+CO and an adsorbed CO (CO_ads) at room temperature; the only elementary step that requires the input of external energy is desorption of CO_ads from the RhTiO₂CO⁻ to reform RhTiO₂⁻. This study not only identifies a promising active species for dry (CO₂) reforming of methane to syngas, but also emphasizes the importance of temperature control over elementary steps in practical catalysis, which may significantly alleviate the carbon deposition originating from the pyrolysis of methane.

Methane to Methanol Conversion Facilitated by Anionic Transition Metal Centers: The Case of Fe, Ni, Pd, and Pt

Density functional theory and high-level ab initio electronic structure calculations are performed to study the mechanism of the partial oxidation of methane to methanol facilitated by the titled anionic transition metal atoms. The energy landscape for the overall reaction M^- + N₂O + CH₄ → M^- + N₂ + CH₃OH (M = Fe, Ni, Pd, Pt) is constructed for different reaction pathways for all four metals. The comparison with earlier experimental and theoretical results for cationic centers demonstrates the better performance of the metal anions. The main advantage is that anionic centers interact weakly with the produced methanol. This fact facilitates the fast removal of methanol from the catalytic center and prevents the overoxidation of methane. Moreover, a moderate or high energy barrier for the M^- + CH₄ → HMCH₃^- reaction step is observed, which protects the metal center from deactivation. Future work should focus on the identification of proper ligands, which stabilize the negative charge on the metal (electronic factors) and prevent the formation of the global CH₃MOH^- minimum (steric factors). Finally, a composite electronic structure method (combining size extensive coupled clusters approaches and accurate multireference configuration interaction) is proposed for computationally demanding systems and is applied to Fe^-.

CO2 Activation and Hydrogenation by Palladium Hydride Cluster Anions

Mass spectrometric analysis of the anionic products of interaction between palladium hydride anions, PdH^-, and carbon dioxide, CO₂, in a reaction cell shows an efficient generation of the PdHCO₂^- intermediate and isolated formate product. Multiple isomers of the PdHCO₂^- intermediates are identified by a synergy between negative ion photoelectron spectroscopy and quantum-chemical calculations. It is shown that a direct mechanism, in which the H atom in PdH^- directly activates and hydrogenates CO₂, leads to the formation of the formate product. An indirect mechanism, on the other hand, leads to a stable HPdCO₂^- structure, where CO₂ is chemisorbed onto the Pd atom.

Photoassisted Selective Steam and Dry Reforming of Methane to Syngas Catalyzed by Rhodium-Vanadium Bimetallic Oxide Cluster Anions at Room Temperature

Photoassisted steam reforming and dry (CO₂ ) reforming of methane (SRM and DRM) at room temperature with high syngas selectivity have been achieved in the gas-phase catalysis for the first time. The catalysts used are bimetallic rhodium-vanadium oxide cluster anions of Rh₂ VO_1-3 ^- . Both the oxidation of methane and reduction of H₂ O/CO₂ can take place efficiently in the dark while the pivotal step to govern syngas selectivity is photo-excitation of the reaction intermediates Rh₂ VO_2,3 CH₂ ^- to specific electronically excited states that can selectively produce CO and H₂ . Electronic excitation over Rh₂ VO_2,3 CH₂ ^- to control the syngas selectivity is further confirmed from the comparison with the thermal excitation of Rh₂ VO_2,3 CH₂ ^- , which leads to diversity of products. The atomic-level mechanism obtained from the well-controlled cluster reactions provides insight into the process of selective syngas production from the photocatalytic SRM and DRM reactions over supported metal oxide catalysts.

Ab initio investigation of the ground and excited states of RuO+,0,- and their reaction with water

High-level quantum chemical calculations on RuO0,± elucidate the electronic structure of their low-lying electronic states. For thirty-two states, we report the electronic configurations, bond lengths, vibrational frequencies, spin-orbit splittings, and excitation energies. The electronic states of RuO can be generated from those of RuO+ by adding one electron to the σ non-bonding orbital closely resembling the 5s atomic orbital of Ru. The ground states for RuO and RuO- are clearly identified as 5Δ and 4Δ, but the two states (4Δ and 2Π) compete for RuO+. The difficulty of calculations is revealed by our small binding energies compared to the experimental values. In addition, we studied the reaction of the three species with water in their ground and selected low-lying electronic states. We found a consistent decrease of the activation energy barriers and higher exothermicity as we add electrons to the system. RuO- is found to facilitate the reaction for both kinetic and thermodynamic reasons.

CO2 Hydrogenation to Formate and Formic Acid by Bimetallic Palladium-Copper Hydride Clusters

Mass spectrometric analysis of the anionic products of interaction between bimetallic palladium-copper tetrahydride anions, PdCuH₄^-, and carbon dioxide, CO₂, in a reaction cell shows an efficient generation of the PdCuCO₂H₄^- intermediate and formate/formic acid complexes. Multiple structures of PdCuH₄^- and PdCuCO₂H₄^- are identified by a synergy between anion photoelectron spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations. The higher energy PdCuH₄^- isomer is shown to drive the catalytic hydrogenation of CO₂, emphasizing the importance of accounting for higher energy isomers for cluster catalytic activity. This study represents the first example of CO₂ hydrogenation by bimetallic hydride clusters.

Structures and bonding properties of CPt2 -/0 and CPt2H-/0: Anion photoelectron spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations

We present a combined anion photoelectron spectroscopic and quantum chemical investigation on the structures and bonding properties of CPt₂ ^-/0 and CPt₂H^-/0. The experimental vertical detachment energies of CPt₂ ^- and CPt₂H^- are measured to be 1.91 ± 0.08 and 3.54 ± 0.08 eV, respectively. CPt₂ ^- is identified as a C_2v symmetric Pt-C-Pt bent structure, and CPt₂ has a D_∞h symmetric Pt-C-Pt linear structure. Both anionic and neutral CPt₂H adopt a Pt-C-Pt-H chain-shaped structure, in which the ∠PtCPt and ∠CPtH bond angles of CPt₂H^- are larger than those of CPt₂H. The Pt-C bonds in CPt₂ ^-/0 and CPt₂H^-/0 exhibit covalent double bonding characters. The Pt=C bonds are much stronger than the C-H bond that may explain why the C atom CPt₂H^-/0 prefers to form Pt=C bonds rather than C-H bonds. It may also explain why platinum can insert into the C-H bond to activate the C-H bond as reported in the literature.

The metallo-formate anions, M(CO2)−, M = Ni, Pd, Pt, formed by electron-induced CO2 activation

The metallo-formate anions, M(CO₂)⁻, M = Ni, Pd, and Pt, were formed by electron-induced CO₂ activation.

de Oliveira-Filho AG, Braga AAC. Unveiling the potential of scandium complexes for methane C–H bond activation: a computational study

Sc(i) complexes activate methane C–H bonds under mild conditions.