Synthesis and Characterization of the Highly Unstable Metalloid Cluster Ag64 (Pn Bu3 )16 Cl6

Recent advances in synthesis and properties of silver nanoclusters

Achieving atomic precision in nanostructured materials is essential for comprehending formation mechanisms and elucidating structure-property relationships. Within the realm of nanoscience and technology, atomically precise ligand-protected noble metal nanoclusters (NCs) have emerged as a rapidly expanding area of interest. These clusters manifest quantum confinement-induced optoelectronic, photophysical, and chemical properties, along with remarkable catalytic capabilities. Among coinage metals, silver distinguishes itself for the fabrication of stable nanoclusters, primarily due to its cost-effectiveness compared to gold. This minireview provides an overview of recent advancements since 2020 in synthetic methodologies and ligand selections toward attaining NCs boasting a minimum of two free valence electrons. Additionally, it explores strategies for fine-tuning optical properties. The discussion extends to surface reactivity, elucidating how exposure to ligands, heat, and light induces transformations in size and structure. Of paramount significance are the applications of silver NCs in catalytic reactions for energy and chemical conversion, supplemented by in-depth mechanistic insights. Furthermore, the review delineates challenges and outlines future directions in the NC field, with an eye toward the design of new functional materials and prospective applications in diverse technologies, including optoelectronics, energy conversion, and fine chemical synthesis.

Silvery fullerene in Ag102 nanosaucer

Despite the discovery of a series of fullerenes and a handful of noncarbon clusters with the typical topology of I h-C60, the smallest fullerene with a large degree of curvature, C20, and its other-element counterparts are difficult to isolate experimentally. In coinage metal nanoclusters (NCs), the first all-gold fullerene, Au32, was discovered after a long-lasting pursuit, but the isolation of similar silvery fullerene structures is still challenging. Herein, we report a flying saucer-shaped 102-nuclei silver NC (Ag102) with a silvery fullerene kernel of Ag32, which is embraced by a robust cyclic anionic passivation layer of (KPO4)10. This Ag32 kernel can be viewed as a non-centered icosahedron Ag12 encaged into a dodecahedron Ag20, forming the silvery fullerene of Ag12@Ag20. The anionic layer (KPO4)10 is located at the interlayer between the Ag32 kernel and Ag70 shell, passivating the Ag32 silvery fullerene and templating the Ag70 shell. The t BuPhS- and CF3COO- ligands on the silver shell show a regioselective arrangement with the 60 t BuPhS- ligands as expanders covering the upper and lower of the flying saucer and 10 CF3COO- as terminators neatly encircling the edges of the structure. In addition, Ag102 shows excellent photothermal conversion efficiency (η) from the visible to near-infrared region (η = 67.1% ± 0.9% at 450 nm, 60.9% ± 0.9% at 660 nm and 50.2% ± 0.5% at 808 nm), rendering it a promising material for photothermal converters and potential application in remote laser ignition. This work not only captures silver kernels with the topology of the smallest fullerene C20, but also provides a pathway for incorporating alkali metal (M) into coinage metal NCs via M-oxoanions.

Three in One: Three Different Molybdates Trapped in a Thiacalix[4]arene Protected Ag72 Nanocluster for Structural Transformation and Photothermal Conversion

Polyoxometalates (POMs) represent crucial intermediates in the formation of insoluble metal oxides from soluble metal ions, however, the rapid hydrolysis-condensation kinetics of MoVI or WVI makes the direct characterization of coexisted molecular species in a given medium extremely difficult. Silver nanoclusters have shown versatile capacity to encapsulate diverse POMs, which provides an alternative scene to appreciate landscape of POMs in atomic precision. Here, we report a thiacalix[4]arene protected silver nanocluster (Ag72b) that simultaneously encapsulates three kinds of molybdates (MoO4 2- , Mo6 O22 8- and Mo7 O25 8- ) in situ transformed from classic Lindqvist Mo6 O19 2- , providing more deep understanding on the structural diversity and condensation growth route of POMs in solution. Ag72b is the first silver nanocluster trapping so many kinds of molybdates, which in turn exert collective template effect to aggregate silver atoms into a nanocluster. The post-reaction of Ag72b with AgOAc or PhCOOAg produces a discrete Ag24 nanocluster (Ag24a) or an Ag28 nanocluster based 1D chain structure (Ag28a), respectively. Moreover, the post-synthesized Ag28a can be utilized as potential ignition material for further application. This work not only provides an important model for unlocking dynamic features of POMs at atom-precise level but also pioneers a promising approach to synthesize silver nanoclusters from known to unknown.

Thiacalix[4]arene-Protected Silver Nanoclusters Encapsulating Different Two-Electron Superatom Oligomers

The subvalent silver kernel represents the nascent state of silver cluster formation, yet the growth mechanism has long been elusive. Herein, two silver nanoclusters (Ag30 and Ag34) coprotected by TC4A4- (H4TC4A = p-tert-butylthiacalix[4]arene) and TBPMT- (TBPMTH = 4-tert-butylbenzenemethanethiol) containing 6e and 4e silver kernels are synthesized and characterized. The trimer of the 2e superatom Ag14 kernel in Ag30 is built from a central Ag6 octahedron sandwiched by two orthogonally oriented Ag5 trigonal bipyramids through sharing vertexes, whereas a double-octahedral Ag10 kernel in Ag34 is a dimer of 2e superatoms. They manifest disparate polyhedron fusion growth patterns at the beginning of the silver cluster formation. Their excellent solution stabilities are contributed by the multisite and multidentate coordination fashion of TC4A4- and the special valence electron structures. This work demonstrates the precise control of silver kernel growth by the solvent strategy and lays a foundation for silver nanocluster application in photothermal conversion.

Cocrystallization of Two Negatively Charged Dimercaptomaleonitrile-Stabilized Silver Nanoclusters

Studies on the assembly of atomically precise metal nanoclusters (NCs) are of great significance in the nanomaterial field, which has attracted increasing interest in the last few decades. Herein, we report the cocrystallization of two negatively charged atom-precise silver nanoclusters, the octahedral [Ag₆₂(MNT)₂₄(TPP)₆]^8- (Ag₆₂) and the truncated-tetrahedral [Ag₂₂(MNT)₁₂(TPP)₄]^4- (Ag₂₂) in a 1:2 ratio (MNT^2- = dimercaptomaleonitrile, TPP = triphenylphosphine). As far as we know, a cocrystal containing two negatively charged NCs has seldom been reported. Single-crystal structure determinations reveal that the component Ag₂₂ and Ag₆₂ NCs both adopt core-shell structures. In addition, the component NCs were separately obtained by adjusting the synthetic conditions. This work enriches the structural diversity of silver NCs and extends the family of cluster-based cocrystals.

Regulating the assembly and expansion of the silver cluster from the Ag37 to Ag46 nanowheel driven by heteroanions

Precise control over the shape and size of metal nanoclusters through anion template-driven self-assembly is one of the key scientific goals in the nanocluster community, however, it is still not understood comprehensively. In this work, we report the controllable synthesis and atomically precise structures of silver nanowheels Ag37 and Ag46, using homo (Cl^- ions) and heteroanion (Cl^- and CrO₄ ^2- ions) template strategies, along with macrocyclic p-phenyl-thiacalix[4]arene and small ⁱPrS^- ligands. Structural analyses revealed that in Ag37, Cl^- ions serve as both local and global templates, whereas CrO₄ ^2- ions function as local and Cl^- ions as global templates in Ag46, resulting in a pentagonal nanowheel (Ag37) and a hexagonal (Ag46) nanowheel. The larger ionic size and more negative charges of CrO₄ ^2- ions than Cl^- ions offer more coordination sites for the silver atoms and are believed to be the key factors that drive the nanowheel core to expand significantly. Also, by taking advantage of the deep cavity of thiacalix[4]arene with an extended phenyl group, Ag46 has been used as a host material for dye adsorption depending on the charge and size of organic dyes. The successful use of heteroanions to control the expansion of well-defined silver nanowheels fills the knowledge gap in understanding the directing role of heteroanions in dictating the shape and size of nanoclusters at the atomic level.

Surface and Interface Coordination Chemistry Learned from Model Heterogeneous Metal Nanocatalysts: From Atomically Dispersed Catalysts to Atomically Precise Clusters

The surface and interface coordination structures of heterogeneous metal catalysts are crucial to their catalytic performance. However, the complicated surface and interface structures of heterogeneous catalysts make it challenging to identify the molecular-level structure of their active sites and thus precisely control their performance. To address this challenge, atomically dispersed metal catalysts (ADMCs) and ligand-protected atomically precise metal clusters (APMCs) have been emerging as two important classes of model heterogeneous catalysts in recent years, helping to build bridge between homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysis. This review illustrates how the surface and interface coordination chemistry of these two types of model catalysts determines the catalytic performance from multiple dimensions. The section of ADMCs starts with the local coordination structure of metal sites at the metal-support interface, and then focuses on the effects of coordinating atoms, including their basicity and hardness/softness. Studies are also summarized to discuss the cooperativity achieved by dual metal sites and remote effects. In the section of APMCs, the roles of surface ligands and supports in determining the catalytic activity, selectivity, and stability of APMCs are illustrated. Finally, some personal perspectives on the further development of surface coordination and interface chemistry for model heterogeneous metal catalysts are presented.

Bicarbonate insertion triggered self-assembly of chiral octa-gold nanoclusters into helical superstructures in the crystalline state

Constructing atomically precise helical superstructures of high order is an extensively pursued subject for unique aesthetic features and underlying applications. However, the construction of cluster-based helixes of well-defined architectures comes with a huge challenge owing to their intrinsic complexity in geometric structures and synthetic processes. Herein, we report a pair of unique P- and M-single stranded helical superstructures spontaneously assembled from R- and S-Au8c individual nanoclusters, respectively, upon selecting chiral BINAP (2,2'-bis(diphenylphosphino)-1,1'-binaphthalene) and hydrophilic o-H2MBA (o-mercaptobenzoic acid) as protective ligands to induce chirality and facilitate the formation of helixes. Structural analysis reveals that the chirality of the Au8c individual nanoclusters is derived from the homochiral ligands and the inherently chiral Au8 metallic kernel, which was further corroborated by experimental and computational investigations. More importantly, driven by the O-H⋯O interactions between (HCO3 -)2 dimers and achiral o-HMBA- ligands, R/S-Au8c individual nanoclusters can assemble into helical superstructures in a highly ordered crystal packing. Electrospray ionization (ESI) and collision-induced dissociation (CID) mass spectrometry of Au8c confirm the hydrogen-bonded dimer of Au8c individual nanoclusters in solution, illustrating that the insertion of (HCO3 -)2 dimers plays a crucial role in the assembly of helical superstructures in the crystalline state. This work not only demonstrates an effective strategy to construct cluster-based helical superstructures at the atomic level, but also provides visual and reliable experimental evidence for understanding the formation mechanism of helical superstructures.

A classical [V10O28]6- anion templated high-nuclearity silver thiolate cluster

Polyoxovanadates (POVs) as templates are still scarcely observed in silver clusters. Herein, the largest known POV-based silver cluster (Ag50) was synthesized, which is a core-shell conformation composed of the in situ generated classical [V₁₀O₂₈]^6- core and Ag₅₀ shell, constrained by the S- and O-donor ligands with a specific distribution. Such {V₁₀O₂₈@Ag₅₀} structure displays geometric inheritance from the D_2h symmetric decavanadate to the silver skeleton. The solution behavior, solid-state stability and photoelectric properties are discussed in detail. This work provides enlightenment for the further construction of POV-templated high-nuclearity silver clusters.

Solvent-Controlled Condensation of [Mo2 O5 (PTC4A)2 ]6- Metalloligand in Stepwise Assembly of Hexagonal and Rectangular Ag18 Nanoclusters

Stepwise assembly starting from a preassembled metalloligand is a promising approach to obtain otherwise unattainable silver nanoclusters, but hard to be intrinsically identified due to the lack of convincing evidence to justify such a process. Herein, hexagonal and rectangular Ag₁₈ nanoclusters are constructed from the [Mo₂ O₅ (PTC4A)₂ ]^6- (H₄ PTC4A=p-phenyl-thiacalix[4]arene) metalloligand through stepwise assembly. The formation of the metalloligand is confirmed by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, then assembled with silver ions to form two geometrically different Ag₁₈ nanoclusters in different solvents. The cyclization from the metalloligand to [(Mo₂ O₅ PTC4A)₆ ]^12- can be realized without alcohols and otherwise blocked by them. The installation of this metalloligand not only provides comprehensive understanding of how the solvents regulate the silver nanocluster structures, but also brings new insights for the controllable ligand metallization and subsequent condensation.

Nuclearity enlargement from [PW9O34@Ag51] to [(PW9O34)2@Ag72] and 2D and 3D network formation driven by bipyridines

The structural transformations of metal nanoclusters are typically quite complex processes involving the formation and breakage of several bonds, and thus are challenging to study. Herein, we report a case where two lacunary Keggin polyoxometallate templated silver single-pods [PW9O34@Ag51] (SD/Ag51b) fuse to a double-pod [(PW9O34)2@Ag72] by reacting with 4,4’-bipyridine (bipy) or 1,4-bis(4-pyridinylmethyl)piperazine (pi-bipy). Their crystal structures reveal the formation of a 2D 44-sql layer (SD/Ag72a) with bipy and a 3D pcu framework (SD/Ag72c) with pi-bipy. The PW9O349− retains its structure during the cluster fusion and cluster-based network formation. Although the two processes, stripping of an Ag-ligands interface followed by fusion, and polymerization, are difficult to envisage, electrospray ionization mass spectrometry provides enough evidences for such a proposal to be made. Through this example, we expect the structural transformation to become a powerful method for synthesizing silver nanoclusters and their infinite networks, and to evolve from trial-and-error to rational.

Atomic structure of a seed-sized gold nanoprism

The growth of nanoparticles along one or two directions leads to anisotropic nanoparticles, but the nucleation (i.e., the formation of small seeds of specific shape) has long been elusive. Here, we show the total structure of a seed-sized Au₅₆ nanoprism, in which the side Au{100} facets are surrounded by bridging thiolates, whereas the top/bottom {111} facets are capped by phosphine ligands at the corners and Br⁻ at the center. The bromide has been proved to be the key to effectively stabilize the Au{111} to fulfill a complete face-centered-cubic core. In femtosecond electron dynamics analysis, the non-evolution of transient absorption spectra of Au₅₆ is similar to that of larger-sized gold nanoclusters (n > 100), which is ascribed to the completeness of the prismatic Au₅₆ core and an effective electron relaxation pathway created by the stronger Au-Au bonds inside. This work provides some insights for the understanding of plasmonic nanoprism formation.

The formation pathway of shape-anisotropic nanoparticles is difficult to characterize and not well understood. The authors synthesize a prismatic-shaped Au₅₆ nanocluster as possible seed of a prismatic nanoparticle and characterize the structure and ligand bonding motifs, providing insight into the formation and surface protection mechanisms.

Structural rearrangement of Ag60 nanocluster endowing different luminescence performances

It is well known that structure determines property, but obtaining a pair of silver nanoclusters with comparable structures to understand the structure-property relationship is a very challenging task. A new 60-nuclei silver nanocluster (SD/Ag60a) protected by a mixed-ligand shell of ^tBuS^- and o-CH₃OPhCOO^- was obtained and characterized. Single crystal x-ray diffraction reveals that SD/Ag60a has an identical metal nuclearity and core-shell structural type to SD/Ag1 previously reported by our group, whereas the compositions of the core and shell have undergone a rearrangement from an Ag₁₂ cuboctahedron core and an Ag₄₈ rhombicuboctahedron shell in SD/Ag1 to an Ag₁₄ rhombic dodecahedron core and an oval Ag₄₆ shell in SD/Ag60a. The core enlargement from Ag₁₂ to Ag₁₄ originates from the replacement of two S^2- in Ag₁₂S₁₅ by two Ag⁺, which gives a new Ag₁₄S₁₃ core. This result indicates that the metal frameworks of silver nanoclusters have some extent flexibility despite the same nuclearity, which can be influenced by ligands, solvents, anion templates, and others in the embryonic stage of the assembly. Interestingly, different core-shell architectures of Ag₆₀ nanoclusters also significantly endow the different optical absorption bands, photocurrent-generating properties, and luminesecent behaviors. This work not only realizes the regulation of the core-shell structure of silver nanoclusters with the same nuclearity but also provides a comparable model for investigating the relationship of structure-photoelectric properties.

[Ag71(S-tBu)31(Dppm)](SbF6)2: an intermediate-sized metalloid silver nanocluster containing a building block of Ag64

An intermediate-sized atomically precise metalloid silver nanocluster [Ag₇₁(SR)₃₁(Dppm)](SbF₆)₂ (Dppm = bis (diphenylphosphino)methane, SR = S-^tBu) is reported, which comprises one building block Ag₆₄, six SR₅ pentagons, one sole SR ligand, a DppmAg₂ handle, and an Ag₅ lid. Structurally, a decahedron Ag₂₃ kernel is observed in the metalloid silver nanocluster. Moreover, the Ag₆₄ unit provides insights into the growth of large clusters such as Ag₁₃₆(SR)₆₄Cl₃ and Ag₁₄₁(SR)₄₀Br₁₂via assembly. The observed decahedron Ag₂₃ provides a deeper understanding on Marks decahedron in larger nanoclusters, and the [Ag₇₁(S-^tBu)₃₁(Dppm)](SbF₆)₂ uses Ag₆₄ as a building block to predict the structure of larger metalloid nanoclusters.

A Nanocluster [Ag307Cl62(SPhtBu)110]: Chloride Intercalation, Specific Electronic State, and Superstability

The controlling synthesis of novel nanoclusters of noble metals (Au, Ag) and the determination of their atomically precise structures provide opportunities for investigating their specific properties and applications. Here we report a novel silver nanocluster [Ag₃₀₇Cl₆₂(SPh^tBu)₁₁₀] (Ag₃₀₇) whose structure is determined by X-ray single crystal diffraction. The structure analysis shows that nanocluster Ag₃₀₇ contains a Ag₁₆₇ core, a surface shell of [Ag₁₄₀Cl₂S₁₁₀], and a Cl₆₀ intermediate layer located between Ag₁₆₇ and [Ag₁₄₀Cl₂S₁₁₀]. It is a first example that such many chlorides are intercalated into a Ag nanocluster. Chlorides are released in situ from solvent CHCl₃. Nanocluster Ag₃₀₇ exhibits superstability. Differential pulse voltammetry experiment reveals that Ag₃₀₇ has continuous charging/discharging behavior with a capacitance value of 1.39 aF, while the Ag₃₀₇ has a surface plasmonic feature. These characteristics show that Ag₃₀₇ is of metallic behavior. However, its electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra display a spin magnetic behavior which could be originated from the unpassivated dangling bonds of surface atoms. The direct capture of EPR signals can be attributed to the Cl^- intercalating layer which partly suppresses the electronic interactions between core and surface atoms, resulting in the relatively independent electronic states for core and surface atoms.

Keplerate Ag192 Cluster with 6 Silver and 14 Chalcogenide Octahedral and Tetrahedral Shells

Silver clusters with more than 2 concentric silver shells are scarce. Here, we enable self-assembly and crystallize SD/Ag192a, a highly symmetric silver chalcogenide cluster (SCC) with 192 silver cations in 6 shells and 136 anionic groups in 14 shells. All but 1 of these 20 concentric shells are Platonic or Archimedean solids. All have octahedral or tetrahedral symmetry and align the maximum number of their 2-, 3-, and 4-fold axes of rotational symmetry, thus identifying the cluster as a Keplerate. A rhombic dodecahedron supershell, formed from the first 3 anionic shells, is the keystone for the entire structure. But, nearly all of the edges in these polyhedral shells are too long to represent bonds. What mechanism of coordination chemistry holds the shells together? Like Na⁺ ions held electrostatically inside adjacent cube-shaped anionic compartments in a crystal of NaCl, individual Ag⁺ ions sit inside adjacent octahedron-shaped anionic compartments that fill space. Similarly, like Cl^- ions in NaCl, individual anionic groups sit inside adjacent cationic (Ag⁺) compartments, mostly uniform polyhedra, that also fill space.