Mediation of the Same Epigenetic and Transcriptional Effect by Independent Osteoarthritis Risk-Conferring Alleles on a Shared Target Gene, COLGALT2

Osteoarthritis year in review 2024: genetics, genomics, and epigenetics

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this narrative review is to highlight the advances made in the past 12 months in the field of osteoarthritis genetics, genomics and epigenetics.

METHODS

The Medline and Embase databases were systematically searched for original publications using terminology, and combinations of terminology, relating to: "osteoarthritis", "genetics", "genomics", and "epigenetics". Only original research articles published in the English language between the OARSI congresses of April 2032 and April 2024 were considered.

RESULTS

This narrative review focuses only on studies using genome-wide omics techniques in human material. There was a rise in functional genomics studies across different osteoarthritis-relevant tissues, which have robustly identified an additional 26 genes involved in osteoarthritis pathology. Two of such previously identified genes (MGP, ALDH1A2) are currently the target of ongoing clinical trials for osteoarthritis. This past year also saw the use of single-cell transcriptomics and two relatively new omics: epitranscriptomics and mitochondrial genomics.

CONCLUSION

This past year of genomics research has led to multiple exciting findings involving genes and mechanisms linked to osteoarthritis. Moreover, the comprehensive genome-wide omics datasets generated for diverse osteoarthritis tissues will prove invaluable for future research aimed at elucidating more causal biological mechanisms and possible therapeutic targets for osteoarthritis.

Evolution and advancements in genomics and epigenomics in OA research: How far we have come

OBJECTIVE

Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most prevalent musculoskeletal disease affecting articulating joint tissues, resulting in local and systemic changes that contribute to increased pain and reduced function. Diverse technological advancements have culminated in the advent of high throughput "omic" technologies, enabling identification of comprehensive changes in molecular mediators associated with the disease. Amongst these technologies, genomics and epigenomics - including methylomics and miRNomics, have emerged as important tools to aid our biological understanding of disease.

DESIGN

In this narrative review, we selected articles discussing advancements and applications of these technologies to OA biology and pathology. We discuss how genomics, deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) methylomics, and miRNomics have uncovered disease-related molecular markers in the local and systemic tissues or fluids of OA patients.

RESULTS

Genomics investigations into the genetic links of OA, including using genome-wide association studies, have evolved to identify 100+ genetic susceptibility markers of OA. Epigenomic investigations of gene methylation status have identified the importance of methylation to OA-related catabolic gene expression. Furthermore, miRNomic studies have identified key microRNA signatures in various tissues and fluids related to OA disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Sharing of standardized, well-annotated omic datasets in curated repositories will be key to enhancing statistical power to detect smaller and targetable changes in the biological signatures underlying OA pathogenesis. Additionally, continued technological developments and analysis methods, including using computational molecular and regulatory networks, are likely to facilitate improved detection of disease-relevant targets, in-turn, supporting precision medicine approaches and new treatment strategies for OA.

Specific isoforms of the ubiquitin ligase gene WWP2 are targets of osteoarthritis genetic risk via a differentially methylated DNA sequence

BACKGROUND

Transitioning from a genetic association signal to an effector gene and a targetable molecular mechanism requires the application of functional fine-mapping tools such as reporter assays and genome editing. In this report, we undertook such studies on the osteoarthritis (OA) risk that is marked by single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) rs34195470 (A > G). The OA risk-conferring G allele of this SNP associates with increased DNA methylation (DNAm) at two CpG dinucleotides within WWP2. This gene encodes a ubiquitin ligase and is the host gene of microRNA-140 (miR-140). WWP2 and miR-140 are both regulators of TGFβ signaling.

METHODS

Nucleic acids were extracted from adult OA (arthroplasty) and foetal cartilage. Samples were genotyped and DNAm quantified by pyrosequencing at the two CpGs plus 14 flanking CpGs. CpGs were tested for transcriptional regulatory effects using a chondrocyte cell line and reporter gene assay. DNAm was altered using epigenetic editing, with the impact on gene expression determined using RT-qPCR. In silico analysis complemented laboratory experiments.

RESULTS

rs34195470 genotype associates with differential methylation at 14 of the 16 CpGs in OA cartilage, forming a methylation quantitative trait locus (mQTL). The mQTL is less pronounced in foetal cartilage (5/16 CpGs). The reporter assay revealed that the CpGs reside within a transcriptional regulator. Epigenetic editing to increase their DNAm resulted in altered expression of the full-length and N-terminal transcript isoforms of WWP2. No changes in expression were observed for the C-terminal isoform of WWP2 or for miR-140.

CONCLUSIONS

As far as we are aware, this is the first experimental demonstration of an OA association signal targeting specific transcript isoforms of a gene. The WWP2 isoforms encode proteins with varying substrate specificities for the components of the TGFβ signaling pathway. Future analysis should focus on the substrates regulated by the two WWP2 isoforms that are the targets of this genetic risk.

Osteoarthritis year in review 2023: genetics, genomics, and epigenetics

OBJECTIVE

To elucidate the scientific advances made in the last 12 months within the realm of osteoarthritis genetics, genomics, and epigenetics. This review paper highlights major research publications that enhance our current understanding of the role of genetics, genomics, and epigenetics in osteoarthritis.

METHODS

A systematic literature search was conducted on pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov on "March 17, 2023", using the following keywords: "osteoarthritis" in combination with any of these terms: "genetic(s)", "mutation(s)", "genomic(s)", "epigenetic(s)", "DNA methylation", "noncoding RNA", "lncRNA", "circular RNA", "microRNA", "transcriptomic(s)", "RNA sequencing", "single cell RNA sequencing", or "single nucleus RNA sequencing". The selection comprised original research articles published in the English language between the OARSI congresses of 2022 and 2023.

RESULTS

A total of 2178 research articles were identified, which subsequently reduced to 67 unique articles relevant to the field. Current trends in osteoarthritis genetics research involve meta-analyses of various cohorts to explore the impact of gene variants on osteoarthritis-related outcomes, such as pain. Early developmental changes within the joint were also found to influence osteoarthritis through genetic variations. Researchers also prioritize testing the mechanisms and functions of miRNAs, circRNAs, and lncRNAs. Potential drug targets began to emerge; however, independent validation studies are lacking. Single cell RNA sequencing studies revealed unique immune cell populations in the knee; however, no study reported single nucleus RNA sequencing analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

This review focused on recent advances in the above-mentioned themes within the field of osteoarthritis. These advances improve our understanding of the disease's complexity and guide us toward functional assessments of genetic/epigenetic outcomes and toward their translational and clinical applications.

Osteoarthritis genetic risk acting on the galactosyltransferase gene COLGALT2 has opposing functional effects in articulating joint tissues

BACKGROUND

Investigation of cartilage and chondrocytes has revealed that the osteoarthritis risk marked by the independent DNA variants rs11583641 and rs1046934 mediate  their effects by decreasing the methylation status of CpG dinucleotides in enhancers and increasing the expression of shared target gene COLGALT2. We set out to investigate if these functional effects operate in a non-cartilaginous joint tissue.

METHODS

Nucleic acids were extracted from the synovium of osteoarthritis patients. Samples were genotyped, and DNA methylation was quantified by pyrosequencing at CpGs within the COLGALT2 enhancers. CpGs were tested for enhancer effects using a synovial cell line and a reporter gene assay. DNA methylation was altered using epigenetic editing, with the impact on gene expression determined using quantitative polymerase chain reaction. In silico analysis complemented laboratory experiments.

RESULTS

The rs1046934 genotype did not associate with DNA methylation or COLGALT2 expression in the synovium, whereas the rs11583641 genotype did. Surprisingly, the effects for rs11583641 were opposite to those previously observed in cartilage. Epigenetic editing in synovial cells revealed that enhancer methylation is causally linked to COLGALT2 expression.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first direct demonstration for osteoarthritis genetic risk of a functional link between DNA methylation and gene expression operating in opposite directions between articular joint tissues. It highlights pleiotropy in the action of osteoarthritis risk and provides a cautionary note in the application of future genetically based osteoarthritis therapies: an intervention that decreases the detrimental effect of a risk allele in one joint tissue may inadvertently increase its detrimental effect in another joint tissue.