Experimental search for combined AC and DC magnetic field effects on ion channels

Morphological Changes Induced By Extremely Low-Frequency Electric Fields

In this paper, morphological effects of electric fields on avian erythrocytes (nucleated red blood cells) have been studied in detail. Morphological changes include rounding and cytoplasm transparency. It has been shown that the effect is non-thermal. Careful imaging and image analyses have been carried out to show that the degree of this effect is frequency-dependent, and has a higher conversion rate at higher temperatures. Furthermore, to better understand the mechanisms behind the morphological changes, we investigated the dedifferentiation hypothesis and performed a series of tests on avian erythrocytes including fluorescence spectroscopy for hemoglobin, and tests on human umbilical cord blood, mesenchymal stem cells, and bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells including flow-cytometry analysis for expression of certain markers and calcium staining. Bioelectromagnetics. 2019;40:375-390. © 2019 Bioelectromagnetics Society.

ELF magnetic fields tuned to ion parametric resonance conditions do not affect TEA-sensitive voltage-dependent outward K(+) currents in a human neural cell line

Despite the experimental evidence of significant biological effects of extremely low frequency (ELF) magnetic fields (MFs), the underlying mechanisms are still unclear. Among the few mechanisms proposed, of particular interest is the so called "ion parametric resonance (IPR)" hypothesis, frequently referred to as theoretical support for medical applications. We studied the effect of different combinations of static (DC) and alternating (AC) ELF MFs tuned on resonance conditions for potassium (K(+)) on TEA-sensitive voltage-dependent outward K(+) currents in the human neuroblastoma BE(2)C cell line. Currents through the cell membrane were measured by whole-cell patch clamp before, during, and after exposure to MF. No significant changes in K(+) current density were found. This study does not confirm the IPR hypothesis at the level of TEA-sensitive voltage-dependent outward K(+) currents in our experimental conditions. However, this is not a direct disprove of the hypothesis, which should be investigated on other ion channels and at single channel levels also.

Action potentials from human neuroblastoma cells in magnetic fields

The patch-clamp method was used to measure transmembrane Na(+) and K(+) currents of the action potential in SH-SY5Y neuroblastoma cells exposed to static magnetic fields of 1, 5, and 75 G, 60 Hz fields of 1 and 5 G, and to combined static and low-frequency fields tuned for resonance of Na(+) and K(+). The maximum currents and their inactivation rates, and the activation rate of the Na(+) current were measured. Application of the magnetic fields did not result in detectable changes in any of the parameters of the action potential chosen for study. The occurrence of effects due to the fields could be excluded down to at least one part in 1000. The results suggest that magnetic fields of the type studied do not affect the cellular mechanisms responsible for generating the action potential.

Effect of low frequency, low amplitude magnetic fields on the permeability of cationic liposomes entrapping carbonic anhydrase: I. Evidence for charged lipid involvement

The influence of low frequency (4-16 Hz), low amplitude (25-75 mu T) magnetic fields on the diffusion processes in enzyme-loaded unilamellar liposomes as bioreactors was studied. Cationic liposomes containing dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine, cholesterol, and charged lipid stearylamine (SA) at different molar ratios (6:3:1 or 5:3:2) were used. Previous kinetic experiments showed a very low self-diffusion rate of the substrate p-nitrophenyl acetate (p-NPA) across intact liposome bilayer. After 60 min of exposure to 7 Hz sinusoidal (50 mu T peak) and parallel static (50 mu T) magnetic fields the enzyme activity, as a function of increased diffusion rate of p-NPA, rose from 17 +/- 3% to 80 +/- 9% (P < .0005, n = 15) in the 5:3:2 liposomes. This effect was dependent on the SA concentration in the liposomes. Only the presence of combined sinusoidal (AC) and static (DC) magnetic fields affected the p-NPA diffusion rates. No enzyme leakage was observed. Such studies suggest a plausible link between the action of extremely low frequency magnetic field on charged lipids and a change of membrane permeability.

Action of extremely low frequency electric fields on the cytosolic calcium concentration of differentiated HL-60 cells: nonactivated cells

The effect of sinusoidal electric fields on the cytosolic free [Ca2+]i concentration in differentiated HL-60 cells was measured. The calcium concentration was measured in a fluorescence spectrometer using the fluorescence sample fluo-3. In the fluorescence spectrometer two samples can be measured simultaneously, one as the sham-exposed control and the other as the field-exposed sample. The effects of an external field, applied using two capacitor plates outside the cuvettes, and a field applied directly to the medium, using two platinum electrodes inside the cuvettes, were measured at selected frequencies between 0 and 100 Hz and field strengths from 1 to 2000 Vpp/m (external field) and from 0.1 to 1000 Vpp/m (in medium). No significant effects of the fields on the cytosolic free [Ca2+]i concentration in HL-60 cells have been observed at the measured frequencies and field strengths.

The lack of evidence for ELF magnetic-field effects on bilayer membranes and reconstituted membrane channels

The effects of low-frequency (10-500 Hz) magnetic fields on the electrical properties of channel-free bilayer membranes, and on the single-channel conductance and macroscopic gating characteristics of porin channels incorporated into membranes, have been studied for field strengths in the range 10-100 microT. The field conditions that could in theory give rise to 'cyclotron resonance' effects were also studied. No evidence has been found to support the concept that cyclotron resonance and membrane ion channel effects are involved in the reported biological effects of ELF magnetic fields.

Biological responses to electromagnetic fields

Electrification in developed countries has progressively increased the mean level of extremely low-frequency electromagnetic fields (ELF-EMFs) to which populations are exposed; these humanmade fields are substantially above the naturally occurring ambient electric and magnetic fields of approximately 10(-4) Vm(-1) and approximately 10(-13) T, respectively. Several epidemiological studies have concluded that ELF-EMFs may be linked to an increased risk of cancer, particularly childhood leukemia. These observations have been reinforced by cellular studies reporting EMF-induced effects on biological systems, most notably on the activity of components of the pathways that regulate cell proliferation. However, the limited number of attempts to directly replicate these experimental findings have been almost uniformly unsuccessful, and no EMF-induced biological response has yet been replicated in independent laboratories. Many of the most well-defined effects have come from gene expression studies; several attempts have been made recently to repeat these key findings. This review analyses these studies and summarizes other reports of major cellular responses to EMFs and the published attempts at replication. The opening sections discuss quantitative aspects of exposure to EMFs and the incidence of cancers that have been correlated with such fields. The concluding section considers the problems that confront research in this area and suggests feasible strategies.

The effects of weak extremely low frequency magnetic fields on calcium/calmodulin interactions

Mechanisms by which weak electromagnetic fields may affect biological systems are of current interest because of their potential health effects. Lednev has proposed an ion parametric resonance hypothesis (Lednev, 1991, Bioelectromagnetics, 12:71-75), which predicts that when the ac, frequency of a combined dc-ac magnetic field equals the cyclotron frequency of calcium, the affinity of calcium for calcium-binding proteins such as calmodulin will be markedly affected. The present study evaluated Lednev's theory using two independent systems, each sensitive to changes in the affinity of calcium for calmodulin. One of the systems used was the calcium/calmodulin-dependent activation of myosin light chain kinase, a system similar to that previously used by Lednev. The other system monitored optical changes in the binding of a fluorescent peptide to the calcium/calmodulin complex. Each system was exposed to a 20.9 microT static field superimposed on a 20.9 microT sinusoidal field over a narrow frequency range centered at 16 Hz, the cyclotron frequency of the unhydrated calcium ion. In contrast to Lednev's predictions, no significant effect of combined dc-ac magnetic fields on calcium/calmodulin interactions was indicated in either experimental system.

Effects of electromagnetic fields on molecules and cells

Evidence suggests that cell processes can be influenced by weak electromagnetic fields (EMFs). EMFs appear to represent a global interference or stress to which a cell can adapt without catastrophic consequences. There may be exceptions to this observation, however, such as the putative role of EMFs as promoters in the presence of a primary tumor initiator. The nature of the response suggests that the cell is viewing EMFs as it would another subtle environmental change. The age and state of the cell can profoundly affect the EMF bioresponse. There is no evidence that direct posttranscription effects occur as a result of EMF exposure. Although transcription alterations occur, no apparent disruption in routine physiological processes such as growth and division is immediately evident. What is usually observed is a transient perturbation followed by an adjustment by the normal homeostatic machinery of the cells. DNA does not appear to be significantly altered by EMF. If EMF exposure is associated with an increased risk of cancer, the paucity of genotoxic effects would support the suggestion that the fields act in tumor promotion rather than initiation. The site(s) and mechanisms of interaction remain to be elaborated. Although there are numerous studies and hypotheses that suggest the membrane represents the primary site of interaction, there are also several different studies showing that in vitro systems, including cell-free systems, are responsive to EMFs. The debate about potential hazards or therapeutic value of weak electromagnetic fields will continue until the mechanism of interaction has been clarified.

Ca2+ ion transport through patch-clamped cells exposed to magnetic fields

The total current of Ca2+ ions through patch-clamped cell membranes was measured while exposing clonal insulin-producing beta-cells (RINm5F) to a combination of DC and AC magnetic fields at so-called cyclotron resonance conditions. Previous experimental evidence supports the theory that a resonant interaction between magnetic fields and organisms can exist. This experiment was designed to test one possible site of interaction: channels in the cell membrane. The transport of Ca2+ ions through the protein channels of the plasma membrane did not show any resonant behavior in the frequency range studied.

Designing EMF experiments: what is required to characterize "exposure"?

Anyone who has attempted to organize and synthesize the results of research on biological effects of electric and magnetic fields (EMF) has experienced frustration when trying to evaluate the comparability of EMF exposures among separate studies. Reporting of exposure characteristics is often incomplete, and some investigators focus on particular nuances of exposure, which in other laboratories go unrecorded because they are not regarded as important. The obstacles encountered when comparing studies, when designing replication studies, and when evaluating research proposals could be reduced were a more standardized approach taken in describing "EMF exposure." To this end, a numerical listing of 18 separate parameters important to EMF exposure characterization is proposed. Although the goal of this list is primarily to expedite the description of EMF exposure, references are provided to examples of EMF exposures and to detailed discussions of EMF exposure systems.

Do ELF magnetic fields affect human reaction time?

Two double-blind studies were run in an attempt to confirm the finding that a 0.2 Hz magnetic field affects simple reaction time (RT) in humans, whereas a 0.1 Hz field does not. In the first experiment, 12 volunteer subjects were exposed to a continuous 0.2 Hz, 0.1 Hz, or sham field in a fully counterbalanced, within-subjects design. Subjects were run singly for one condition each day over 3 consecutive days with a field strength of 1.1 mT and a daily exposure duration of 5 min. Neither magnetic field had any effect on RT at any time during the exposure. One condition of a second study, using a new group of 24 volunteer subjects, also failed to find any field effects at 0.2 Hz. Additionally, the second study failed to show any effects when the frequency, flux density, and field orientation were set according to parametric resonance theory. It is suggested that, although ELF magnetic field effects on human behaviour may be elusive, future research can improve detection rates by paying greater attention to reducing error variance and increasing statistical power.

An upper limit for the effect of low frequency magnetic fields on ATP-sensitive potassium channels

Currents have been recorded for ATP-sensitive potassium channels in excised patches of membranes from an insulin secreting cell line, CRI-G1. The multi-channel records have been analyzed to reveal the single-channel conductance, the frequency and duration of bursts and the frequency of flickers (with periods between 0.5 and 5 ms). Control records in the absence of applied magnetic fields are similar to those reported by others. Patches have been exposed to parallel static and low frequency magnetic fields including a combination satisfying the 'cyclotron resonance' condition. The fields were applied for 30 s periods interleaved with 30 s controls. No significant differences in channel properties were observed between the control and field exposed periods. The largest change in position of the peak of the distribution of opening and closing transitions was 3%.

Absence of effects of low-frequency, low-amplitude magnetic fields on the properties of gramicidin A channels

The effects of static and low-frequency magnetic fields on gramicidin A channels have been investigated using bilayer patch clamp recording and a bridge technique capable of detecting 0.3% changes in the conductance of glyceryl monooleate membranes containing many channels. In the bridge technique the conductance was assessed using 10-ms voltage pulses applied at 10 Hz. Measurements were made for LiCl, KCl, and CsCl using magnetic fields of 50, 100, 500, and 5000 microT with the frequency scanned from 10-200 Hz. The combinations of static and low-frequency fields employed include the "cyclotron resonance" conditions at which effects had been predicted to occur. In no case was there any detectable change in conductance when the magnetic fields were applied or changed. Potassium currents through single gramicidin channels have been recorded for patches in which several channels may be open at once. Fields were applied for 2 min periods interleaved with 2 min controls. Methods have been developed to analyze the multichannel records to reveal the amplitude and duration of the channels together with the frequency, depth, and apparent period of flickers. No significant differences were observed between the control and field-exposed recording periods. The peak of the distribution of opening and closing transitions always coincided for fields on and off within the resolution, 0.4%, of the recordings. There are at least two types of flicker, one with typical period less than 0.1 ms, the other with typical period from 0.3-0.8 ms. Most of the latter were not complete closures with the conductance during a flicker 15-20% above the level for a full closure.

Theoretical study of the resonant behaviour of an ion confined to a potential well in a combination of AC and DC magnetic fields

Numerical solutions are presented to the equation of motion for an ion confined to a region of space by a restoring force and subject to DC and AC magnetic fields. We have expanded on the theoretical work of Durney et al. [1988] by including a potential well as a confining factor. This additional term in the equation of motion, being nondissipative, could allow for the buildup of stored energy within the system to a level necessary for a macroscopic resonant phenomenon. Resonant behaviour has been studied, including calculation of the trajectory and energy (kinetic and potential) of a confined ion, with emphases on the appearance of both amplitude and frequency windows. The results are discussed in relation to ion transport through transmembrane channels exposed to magnetic fields. When realistic values of the frictional and restoring-force coefficients are considered, all predicted resonant behaviour disappears, except at very high field strengths.