The history of the DNA heteroduplex

Molecular sex: The importance of base composition rather than homology when nucleic acids hybridize

On learning that nucleic acid hybridization had been achieved in a test tube, Huxley hailed the discovery of "molecular sex." The description was apt, since sex involves recombination, which requires hybridization that, in turn, depends on a successful homology search. Conversely, when the homology search fails, recombination fails. In yeast, this failure has been attributed to "simple sequence divergence." But sequence divergence does not impair nucleic acid hybridization simply. Most natural single-stranded nucleic acids are predisposed to adopt higher-order structures containing stem-loops. Tomizawa showed that the rate-limiting step in the hybridization of single-stranded sequences is an initial "kissing" exploration between complementary loops, which must first be appropriately extruded and aligned. Successful duplex formation requires successful synchronization of matching higher-ordered structures, which depends, not so much on the degree of similarity between their base sequences as on the closeness of their base compositions (GC%). In these terms, we can understand how the anti-recombinational effect of GC% differences supports the duplication both of genes within a genome and of genomes within a genus (speciation).

Chromosomal speciation: a reply

The "genic" and the "non-genic" (chromosomal) hypotheses for the predominant mechanism by which species diverge into two have long been in contention. In 1998 Coyne and Orr attacked certain formulations of the chromosomal hypothesis on the grounds that they required macromutations (structural changes in chromosomes). In 1999 I replied that numerous independent micromutations (single DNA base changes) should suffice (GC% hypothesis). Kliman et al., with the support of Coyne and Charlesworth, have presented various counterarguments, to which the present paper responds with evidence that GC% differences are primary to genic differences and would operate by changing the structure of stem-loops extruded from duplex DNAs. Chromosomes attempting to align by means of complementary loop-loop interactions would fail if GC% differences exceeded a critical threshold. This would disrupt meiosis (hybrid sterility) and the parents of organisms with failed meiosis would be reproductively isolated from each other. If they could find new mates with which they were GC-compatible, then new species could emerge. The model leads to predictions consistent with several lines of evidence. The GC% version of the chromosomal hypothesis has a sound basis and deserves at least as much attention as its genic rival.

Early studies on recombination and DNA repair in Ustilago maydis

This historical review covers the period 1960 to mid-1980s. The first experiments were carried out at the John Innes Institute, Bayfordbury, Hertford, with a one year interlude in the Department of Genetics, University of Washington, Seattle. In 1965, I moved to the National Institute for Medical Research, Mill Hill, London, and became head of a new Genetics Division. The research on Ustilago was divided broadly into (1) experimental genetic studies, and (2) DNA enzymology, largely under the direction of the late Geoffrey Banks. The approaches involved isolating and characterizing mutants defective in repair and recombination (the first in any eukaryotic organism), with the longer term aim of identifying the function of genes through studies of enzymes and proteins which interact with DNA. An enzyme capable of recognizing mismatched bases in DNA was identified. A novel method exploited the inducible nitrate reductase gene, and revealed relationships between recombination, mutation, repair, transcription and cell survival. Several different studies provide strong evidence for the presence of an inducible repair pathway, dependent on recombination. Much more recently, the revolution in molecular genetics has been in exploited in several laboratories working with Ustilago maydis, and these have produced some completely new insights into recombination and repair.

Generation of adenovirus vectors devoid of all viral genes by recombination between inverted repeats

Direct or inverse repeated sequences are important functional features of prokaryotic and eukaryotic genomes. Considering the unique mechanism, involving single-stranded genomic intermediates, by which adenovirus (Ad) replicates its genome, we investigated whether repetitive homologous sequences inserted into E1-deleted adenoviral vectors would affect replication of viral DNA. In these studies we found that inverted repeats (IRs) inserted into the E1 region could mediate predictable genomic rearrangements, resulting in vector genomes devoid of all viral genes. These genomes (termed DeltaAd.IR) contained only the transgene cassette flanked on both sides by precisely duplicated IRs, Ad packaging signals, and Ad inverted terminal repeat sequences. Generation of DeltaAd.IR genomes could also be achieved by coinfecting two viruses, each providing one inverse homology element. The formation of DeltaAd.IR genomes required Ad DNA replication and appeared to involve recombination between the homologous inverted sequences. The formation of DeltaAd. IR genomes did not depend on the sequence within or adjacent to the inverted repeat elements. The small DeltaAd.IR vector genomes were efficiently packaged into functional Ad particles. All functions for DeltaAd.IR replication and packaging were provided by the full-length genome amplified in the same cell. DeltaAd.IR vectors were produced at a yield of approximately 10(4) particles per cell, which could be separated from virions with full-length genomes based on their lighter buoyant density. DeltaAd.IR vectors infected cultured cells with the same efficiency as first-generation vectors; however, transgene expression was only transient due to the instability of deleted genomes within transduced cells. The finding that IRs present within Ad vector genomes can mediate precise genetic rearrangements has important implications for the development of new vectors for gene therapy approaches.

Molecular diagnostics of cancer predisposition: hereditary non-polyposis colorectal carcinoma and mismatch repair defects

Hereditary non-polyposis colorectal carcinoma accounts for 5-13% of all colorectal carcinomas and is inherited in a dominant fashion. Two different forms can be distinguished. Type I is restricted to colorectal cancers, whereas type II patients acquire acolorectal, endometrial, gastric, small intestinal and transitional carcinomas of the upper urinary tract. Germline mutations in the human mismatch repair genes (hMSH2, hMSH6, hMLH1, hPMS2) account for the majority of hereditary non-polyposis colorectal carcinoma. As a result of the mismatch repair deficiency, replication errors are not repaired, resulting in a mutator phenotype. Simple repetitive sequences (microsatellites) are especially prone to replication errors and analysis of their stability combined with immunohistochemical analysis of mismatch repair protein expression provides a rapid diagnostic strategy. For patients either (1) fulfilling the Amsterdam criteria for HNPCC, (2) with synchronous or metachronous hereditary non-polyposis colorectal carcinoma-related tumors, (3) with hereditary non-polyposis colorectal carcinoma-related tumors before the age of 45 and/or (4) with right sided CRC and mucinous, solid, or cribriform growth patterns, screening for mismatch repair deficiencies should be performed. The identification of colorectal cancers displaying a mutator phenotype has implications for both treatment and prognosis.

DNA-sequence asymmetry directs the alignment of recombination sites in the FLP synaptic complex

The FLP recombinase promotes site-specific recombination in the 2 micrometer circle of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. FLP recognizes a 48 bp target site (FLP recombination target, or FRT) consisting of three 13 bp protein binding sites, or symmetry elements, flanking an 8 bp spacer region. Efficient recombination also occurs with DNA substrates that have minimal FRT sites, consisting only of the spacer and two surrounding 13 bp symmetry elements arranged in inverse orientation; thus, the wild-type spacer sequence is the main asymmetric feature of the minimal recombination site. FLP carries out recombination with many minimal target sites bearing symmetric or asymmetric mutant spacer sequences; however, the overall directionality of recombination defined in terms of inversion or excision of a DNA domain is determined by spacer-sequence asymmetry. In order to evaluate the potential influence of spacer-sequence asymmetry on structures formed during early steps in recombination, we used electron microscopy to investigate the structure of the FLP synaptic complex, which is the intermediate protein-DNA complex involved in site pairing and strand exchange. Using linear substrate DNAs that have minimal FRTs with wild-type spacer sequences, we find that 85 to 90% of the FLP synaptic complexes examined contain the two FRTs aligned in parallel. This strong preference for parallel site alignment stands in contrast with prevailing models for lambda integrase-class recombination systems, which postulate antiparallel site alignment, and results from biophysical studies on synthetic, immobile four-way DNA junctions. Our results show that the strong preference for parallel alignment can be attributed to conformational preferences of Holliday junctions present in the synaptosome.

Complementary recognition in condensed DNA: accelerated DNA renaturation

The functional consequences of DNA condensation are investigated. The recognition of complementary strands is profoundly modified by this critical phenomenon. (1) Condensation of denatured DNA greatly accelerates the kinetics of DNA renaturation. We propose a unifying explanation for the effects of several accelerating solvents studied here including polymers, di- and multivalent cations, as well as effects seen with the phenol emulsions and single-stranded nucleic acid binding proteins. Optimal conditions for renaturation at or above the calculated three dimensional diffusion limit are theoretically consistent with a limited search space in the condensed phases. (2) In addition to these effects on association of two single strands, similar condensation acceleration effects can be seen in strand exchange experiments with double stranded DNA without proteins. These may model a mechanism of recombinational protein function.