The role of hydrophobic bonding in collagen fibril formation: a quantitative model

Collagen type II-hyaluronan interactions - the effect of proline hydroxylation: a molecular dynamics study

Hyaluronan-collagen composites have been employed in numerous biomedical applications. Understanding the interactions between hyaluronan and collagen is particularly important in the context of joint cartilage function and the treatment of joint diseases. Many factors affect the affinity of collagen for hyaluronan. One of the important factors is the ratio of 3- or 4-hydroxy proline to proline residues. This article presents the results from molecular dynamics calculations of HA-collagen type II interactions with hyaluronan. The applied protocol employed docking and geometry optimization of complexes built using collagen structures with different numbers of hydroxyl groups attached to proline moieties. It was established that the hydroxyproline/proline ratio affects both structural and energetic features of the collagen-hyaluronan complex. Proline hydroxylation was found to significantly influence the number of all identified types of molecular forces, hydrophobic interactions, water bridges and hydrogen bonds, which can be formed between collagen and hyaluronan. Importantly, an increase in the hydroxyproline/proline ratio in the collagen chain increases the binding affinity for hyaluronan. This is illustrated by the linear correlation between the binding free energy and the hydroxylation degree. A comparison of the results obtained for 3 and 4 hydroxylation of proline indicates that the hydroxyl group attachment position plays a minor role in complex stabilization. However, a slightly stronger affinity was observed for 4 hydroxylation. In order to evaluate the effect of the aqueous environment on the collagen-hyaluronan complex stability, the enthalpic and entropic contributions to the free energy of solvation were analyzed.

Stick-slip friction and wear of articular joints

Stick-slip friction was observed in articular cartilage under certain loading and sliding conditions and systematically studied. Using the Surface Forces Apparatus, we show that stick-slip friction can induce permanent morphological changes (a change in the roughness indicative of wear/damage) in cartilage surfaces, even under mild loading and sliding conditions. The different load and speed regimes can be represented by friction maps--separating regimes of smooth and stick-slip sliding; damage generally occurs within the stick-slip regimes. Prolonged exposure of cartilage surfaces to stick-slip sliding resulted in a significant increase of surface roughness, indicative of severe morphological changes of the cartilage superficial zone. To further investigate the factors that are conducive to stick-slip and wear, we selectively digested essential components of cartilage: type II collagen, hyaluronic acid (HA), and glycosaminoglycans (GAGs). Compared with the normal cartilage, HA and GAG digestions modified the stick-slip behavior and increased surface roughness (wear) during sliding, whereas collagen digestion decreased the surface roughness. Importantly, friction forces increased up to 2, 10, and 5 times after HA, GAGs, and collagen digestion, respectively. Also, each digestion altered the friction map in different ways. Our results show that (i) wear is not directly related to the friction coefficient but (ii) more directly related to stick-slip sliding, even when present at small amplitudes, and that (iii) the different molecular components of joints work synergistically to prevent wear. Our results also suggest potential noninvasive diagnostic tools for sensing stick-slip in joints.

Fibrillogenesis in dense collagen solutions: a physicochemical study

Fibrillogenesis, the formation of collagen fibrils, is a key factor in connective tissue morphogenesis. To understand to what extent cells influence this process, we systematically studied the physicochemistry of the self-assembly of type I collagen molecules into fibrils in vitro. We report that fibrillogenesis in solutions of type I collagen, in a high concentration range close to that of living tissues (40-300 mg/ml), yields strong gels over wide pH and ionic strength ranges. Structures of gels were described by combining microscopic observations (transmission electron microscopy) with small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering analysis, and the influence of concentration, pH, and ionic strength on the fibril size and organization was evaluated. The typical cross-striated pattern and the corresponding small-angle X-ray scattering 67-nm diffraction peaks were visible in all conditions in the pH 6 to pH 12 range. In reference conditions (pH 7.4, ionic strength=150 mM, 20 degrees C), collagen concentration greatly influences the overall macroscopic structure of the resultant fibrillar gels, as well as the morphology and structure of the fibrils themselves. At a given collagen concentration, increasing the ionic strength from 24 to 261 mM produces larger fibrils until the system becomes biphasic. We also show that fibrils can form in acidic medium (pH approximately 2.5) at very high collagen concentrations, beyond 150 mg/ml, which suggests a possible cholesteric-to-smectic phase transition. This set of data demonstrates how simple physicochemical parameters determine the molecular organization of collagen. Such an in vitro model allows us to study the intricate process of fibrillogenesis in conditions of molecular packing close to that which occurs in biological tissue morphogenesis.

Effect of oxazolidine E on collagen fibril formation and stabilization of the collagen matrix

Oxazolidine E, an aldehydic cross-linking agent, is used to impart hydrothermal stability to collagen. The purpose of this study was to investigate the exact nature of oxazolidine E induced cross-links with collagen by using synthetic peptides having sequence homology with collagen type I. Tandem mass spectrometry revealed the formation of methylol and Schiff-base adducts upon reaction of oxazolidine E with the peptides. This was confirmed by allowing the reaction to proceed under reducing conditions using cyanoborohydride. Mass spectrometry (MS)-MS analysis clearly showed interaction of tryptophan and lysine residues with oxazolidine E and demonstrated that arginine could be cross-linked with glycine in the presence of oxazolidine E through the formation of a methylene bridge. Collagen fibrils regenerated from monomers in the presence and absence of oxazolidine E were studied using atomic force microscopy to investigate morphological alterations. Regenerated fibrils showing the typical 65 nm D-banding pattern were obtained from those formed both in the presence and absence of oxazolidine E, and there was no evidence of a change in the D-periodicity of these fibrils. This indicated that oxazolidine E does not hinder collagen molecules from correctly aligning to form the quarter-stagger structure.

Biological liquid crystal elastomers

Liquid crystal elastomers (LCEs) have recently been described as a new class of matter. Here we review the evidence for the novel conclusion that the fibrillar collagens and the dragline silks of orb web spiders belong to this remarkable class of materials. Unlike conventional rubbers, LCEs are ordered, rather than disordered, at rest. The identification of these biopolymers as LCEs may have a predictive value. It may explain how collagens and spider dragline silks are assembled. It may provide a detailed explanation for their mechanical properties, accounting for the variation between different members of the collagen family and between the draglines in different spider species. It may provide a basis for the design of biomimetic collagen and dragline silk analogues by genetic engineering, peptide- or classical polymer synthesis. Biological LCEs may exhibit a range of exotic properties already identified in other members of this remarkable class of materials. In this paper, the possibility that other transversely banded fibrillar proteins are also LCEs is discussed.

Structure-function studies on hsp47: pH-dependent inhibition of collagen fibril formation in vitro

Hsp47, a 47 kDa heat shock protein whose expression level parallels that of collagen, has been regarded as a collagen-specific molecular chaperone. Studies from other laboratories have established the association of Hsp47 with the nascent as well as the triple-helical procollagen molecule in the endoplasmic reticulum and its dissociation from procollagen in the Golgi. One of several roles suggested for Hsp47 in collagen biosynthesis is the prevention of aggregation of procollagen in the endoplasmic reticulum. However, no experimental evidence has been available to verify this suggestion. In the present study we have followed the aggregation of mature triple-helical collagen molecules into fibrils by using turbidimetric measurements in the absence and presence of Hsp47. In the pH range 6-7, fibril formation of type I collagen, as monitored by turbidimetry, proceeds with a lag of approx. 10 min and levels off by approx. 60 min. The addition of Hsp47 at pH 7 effectively inhibits fibril formation at and above a 1:1 molar ratio of Hsp47 to triple-helical collagen. This inhibition is markedly pH-dependent, being significantly diminished at pH 6. CD and fluorescence spectral data of Hsp47 in the pH range 4.2-7.4 reveal a significant alteration in its structure at pH values below 6.2, with a decrease in alpha-helix and an increase in beta-structure. This conformational change is likely to be the basis of the decreased binding of Hsp47 to collagen in vitro at pH 6.3 as well as its inability to inhibit collagen fibril formation at this pH. Our results also provide a functional assay for Hsp47 that can be used in studies on collagen and Hsp47 interactions.

Early assembly pathways of type I collagen

A method was developed for computing the free energy (delta Fi) of aggregates of type I collagen. The method was based on a treatment of Matheson and Flory describing phase equilibria of rigid rod polymers. It included a polymer-solvent interaction term that depended on near neighbor transfer energies. Extrahelical portions of the molecule were assigned local interaction energies differing from that assigned to the helix. Free energies of reaction for successive steps along assembly pathways (delta Fi-i+1) were computed. When allowance was made for specific pairing between extrahelical and helical domains, the so-called D-staggered (D = 670 A) alignment of molecules was preferred, as opposed to a nonstaggered, or nematic, alignment. Based on delta Fi-i+1 alone, it appeared that 1D-staggered oligomers arise first in assembly, followed later by addition of molecules in 4D alignment. Neither 4D dimers nor 4D-8D trimers were predicted to be major intermediates in assembly. This result is contrary to previous hypotheses. When energies of activation were included in the analysis, the prediction was less certain, and specific circumstances were identified in which 4D dimers and 4D-8D trimers were the earliest aggregated species in assembly.

The relative contribution of electrostatic interactions to stabilization of collagen fibrils

Electrostatic energies of interaction between type I collagen molecules were calculated, using models developed by Timasheff and Hill. These energies, along with a contribution from hydrophobic forces, were then incorporated into an equation due to Flory that described phase equilibria of rod-like polymers. The Flory formalism in turn permitted a calculation of the overall free energy of fibril formation (delta Ff), and an assessment of the relative contribution of electrostatic and hydrophobic forces to delta Ff. Lastly, delta Ff was used in a nucleation-growth model relating halftimes of fibril formation (t1/2) to ionic strength (I) and temperature. Because the theory provided no basis for setting absolute levels of the energetic contributions, five parameters in the model had to be derived from experimental data. Based on the fit of theory to experimental results both for intact and pepsinized collagen, it was found that very low electrostatic energies (about -1 kcal/mole per collagen molecule) were sufficient to explain experimental t1/2 vs I relationships. This energy is equivalent to 1 close charge-pair interaction per molecule and appears to be lower than the energy assignable to hydrophobic interactions.

The role of extrahelical peptides in stabilization of collagen fibrils

A quantitative model for fibril assembly of type I collagen was extended to include the explicit effect of extrahelical peptides. The collagen molecule was simulated by rod-like sequences to which short, rigid tails were connected by "nondimensional" flexible joints. Three collagen structures were studied: (1) intact collagen, simulated by a rod of axial ratio 200 (The axial ratio x was taken as a segment length) with two tails of length x = 1 and x = 2, respectively, appended to each end; (2) pepsin-digested collagen, simulated by one rigid segment of length 200 and one tail of length 1; and (3) pronase-digested collagen, by a single rigid segment of length x = 200. Phase equilibria of such structures were calculated, using a lattice theory of Matheson and Flory, and the relation of the polymer-solvent interaction parameter chi to the equilibrium solubility was determined. The chi for each collagen species was then related to temperature (T) and ionic strength (I), based on the approximation that local (per segment) stabilization of collagen fibrils was due to hydrophobic and electrostatic forces only. Solubility vs temperature curves for all three collagen species were computed and compared to published experimental data. From the chi factors for each species, the composite chi was resolved into components representing energetic contributions of the extrahelical peptides relative to the helix, which were interpreted in terms of hydrophobic or electrostatic interactions stabilizing the collagen fibril.

The effects of heparin on the physicochemical properties of reconstituted collagen

Pepsin-solubilized bovine dermal collagen was reconstituted in 0.02 M sodium phosphate (pH 7.2), concentrated to 30-40 mg/ml, and adjusted to physiological ionic strength by addition of sodium chloride. These preparations, at 4-15 degrees C, are fibrillar suspensions composed of fibrils of varying diameters and nonassociated molecules. Addition of heparin to these suspensions promoted a dose-dependent increase in average fibril diameter as measured by turbidimetry and electron microscopic analyses. These effects were relatively specific for heparin and heparin-like glycosaminoglycans. Chondroitin sulfate and hyaluronic acid had little or no effect on fibrillar diameters under these conditions, whereas dermatan sulfate had an intermediate effect on fibrillar reorganization. Differential scanning calorimetry revealed that addition of optimal concentrations of heparin generated fibrils of higher stability and that this effect was associated with the disappearance of structures of lower stability, including nonassociated molecules and thin fibrils. Light microscopic analyses of the fibrillar collagen/heparin matrix showed it to be a more open network of distinct collagen fibers than was observed with the fibrillar collagen preparation alone. Binding experiments indicated that heparin bound to fibrillar collagen in a saturable fashion with a Kd of approximately 4 X 10(-7) M. Creep experiments provided evidence that the addition of heparin to fibrillar collagen suspensions greatly reduces the gelation phenomenon that is normally observed when such suspensions are warmed to 37 degrees C. These differences in fibrillar architecture may be in part responsible for differences noted in the biological response to fibrillar collagen and fibrillar collagen/heparin implants in vivo (McPherson et al., 1988).