Upper-limb resympathectomy

Thoracoscopic Sympathectomy for Primary Palmar Hyperhidrosis: Resection Versus Transection—A Prospective Trial

Upper dorsal sympathectomy is the only successful therapeutic method for idiopathic palmar hyperhidrosis (IPHH). However, the techniques for sympathetic ablation are still debated. The aim of this study was to compare prospectively two accepted methods for endoscopic sympathetic ablation: resection of T2-T3 ganglia versus transection of the chain over the second to fourth ribs. During the period September 2000 to June 2002, a total of 32 patients with IPHH were operated on. Operations were performed under general anesthesia through two 5-mm trocars using electrocautery. Resection was done on one side and transection on the other, with both sides being addressed during the same operation. The sides of resection/transection were alternated at each operation. There were 14 men and 18 women aged 18.8 +/- 4.7 years. The mean operating times for sympathectomy were 12.0 +/- 3.1 minutes for resection and 6.6 +/- 1.9 minutes for transection (p = 1.38). All patients were examined at 2 weeks postoperatively and again at 1 month. During November-December 2005, patients were approached by telephone questionnaire, the mean follow-up period being 4.3 +/- 0.9 years. Altogether, 26 of the 32 patients could be located (15 women, 11 men). There was no significant difference with regards to perioperative complications, immediate or long-term pain. All but two hands were warm and dry 1 month after operation and remained so at follow-up. The exceptions included one hand with recurrent hyperhidrosis after 1.5 years and one that became less dry and cold at 3 years. Both were on the transected sides. Our results suggest that sympathetic resection may achieve slightly better long-term results than transection in patients with IPHH. Large-scale prospective studies are needed to confirm these results.

Thoracic origin of a sympathetic supply to the upper limb: the 'nerve of Kuntz' revisited

An understanding of the origin of the sympathetic innervation of the upper limb is important in surgical sympathectomy procedures. An inconstant intrathoracic ramus which joined the 2nd intercostal nerve to the ventral ramus of the 1st thoracic nerve, proximal to the point where the latter gave a large branch to the brachial plexus, has become known as the 'nerve of Kuntz' (Kuntz, 1927). Subsequently a variety of sympathetic interneuronal connections down to the 5th intercostal space were reported and also described as the nerve of Kuntz. The aim of this study was to determine: (1) the incidence, location and course of the nerve of Kuntz; (2) the relationship of the nerve of Kuntz to the 2nd thoracic ganglion; (3) the variations of the nerve of Kuntz in the absence of a stellate ganglion; (4) to compare the original intrathoracic ramus with sympathetic variations at other intercostal levels; and (5) to devise an appropriate anatomical classification of the nerves of Kuntz. Bilateral microdissection of the sympathetic chain and somatic nerves of the upper 5 intercostal spaces was undertaken in 32 fetuses (gestational age, 18 wk to full term) and 18 adult cadavers. The total sample size comprised 99 sides. Sympathetic contributions to the first thoracic nerve were found in 60 of 99 sides (left 32, right 28). Of these, 46 were confined to the 1st intercostal space only. The nerve of Kuntz (the original intrathoracic ramus) of the 1st intercostal space had a demonstrable sympathetic connection in 34 cases, and an absence of macroscopic sympathetic connections in 12. In the remaining intercostal spaces, intrathoracic rami uniting intercostal nerves were not observed. Additional sympathetic contributions (exclusive of rami communicantes) were noted between ganglia, interganglionic segments and intercostal nerves as additional rami communicantes. The eponym nerve of Kuntz should be restricted to descriptions of the intrathoracic ramus of the 1st intercostal space. Any of these variant sympathetic pathways may be responsible for the recurrence of symptoms after sympathectomy surgery.

Pitfalls in thoracoscopic sympathectomy: mechanisms for failure

The technical ease of thoracoscopic sympathectomy has established this as the procedure of choice for upper-limb sympathectomy. Notwithstanding the invariable success of this procedure, those rare instances of unsuccessful sympathectomy are disconcerting to the surgeon. Unsuccessful sympathectomy manifests as persistent or recurrent sympathetic activity after a seemingly successful procedure. The causes of this phenomenon include misinterpretation of the sympathetic chain at thoracoscopy, regeneration of the sympathetic chain, and alternate neural pathways via the nerve of Kuntz. With the large numbers of sympathectomies being undertaken, the few instances of unsuccessful sympathectomy have prompted a review of this subject. Although alternate neural pathways may have little significance when a T2 ganglionectomy is undertaken, anatomic misinterpretation of the sympathetic chain is an important yet under-recognized cause of an unsuccessful sympathectomy. Sympathetic nerve regeneration remains extremely uncommon. Persistent and recurrent sympathetic activity may be successfully managed by resympathectomy performed thoracoscopically.

Gustatory facial sweating subsequent to upper thoracic sympathectomy

Gustatory facial sweating has been described as a consequence of upper thoracic sympathectomy. Patients may also develop compensatory hyperhidrosis, sensory deficits, nipple hypersensitivity, and Horner's syndrome. In this article, we have reviewed three patients with reflex sympathetic dystrophy who developed gustatory facial sweating subsequent to endoscopic T2 and T3 ganglionectomy. This article also discusses the possible mechanisms of gustatory facial sweating.

Sympathetic ganglion blockade for the management of hyperhidrosis

We present three patients with severe primary hyperhidrosis, refractory to conservative medical treatment, who were successfully managed with sympathetic ganglion blockade with ethanol. We also summarize 10 patients with hyperhidrosis who underwent sympathetic ganglion blockade in the past 2 years. This closed percutaneous method offers the patients considerably less discomfort and less stress with minimal morbidity and has a efficacy similar to that of surgical sympathectomy, which has previously been the only effective and permanent therapy for severe primary hyperhidrosis. It is concluded that chemical sympathectomy is an effective and useful method for treating severe hyperhidrosis which has advantages over surgical sympathectomy.

Video-assisted endoscopic thoracic ganglionectomy

Sympathetic nerve disorders of the upper extremities can be treated by neurosurgeons using upper thoracic sympathectomy via a posterior approach. Descriptions have been published of alternative endoscopic procedures involving thermocoagulation, laser coagulation, or nonvideo-assisted ganglionectomy using equipment not widely available, with low morbidity and excellent results. The authors describe the use of an endoscopic approach to the thoracic sympathetic ganglia with systems designed for laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Thoracic ganglionectomy is reported in 22 patients with primary palmar hyperhidrosis and eight patients with reflex sympathetic dystrophy. The patients underwent double-lumen endotracheal intubation, after which 11- and 5.5-mm trocars were introduced into the chest cavity. Pneumothorax was produced with CO2 insufflation. Fiberoptic closed-circuit television was used to visualize the structures to be dissected. The parietal pleura over the heads of the first and second ribs was excised using 5-mm blunt and sharp insulated coagulating microscissors. The stellate and upper thoracic ganglia were clearly identified and dissected. The T-2 and T-3 ganglia were grasped with forceps and excised. A No. 16 French chest tube was introduced through a trocar, placed under water seal after the lungs were reinflated, and removed in the recovery room. The average hospital stay was 15.4 hours. There were no intraoperative complications. The average operating time was 30 minutes per side. Five patients had mild pleuritic pain which resolved within 2 weeks after surgery. Six (75%) of the eight patients with reflex sympathetic dystrophy had complete or partial relief of their symptoms (average follow-up period 5 months), and all patients had complete relief of hyperhidrosis (average follow-up period 8 months). Endoscopic ganglionectomy requires readily available and easily used instrumentation and provides a well-tolerated, cost-effective alternative to posterior thoracic sympathectomy for primary palmar hyperhidrosis and reflex sympathetic dystrophy.

Surgical management of primary hyperhidrosis

Primary hyperhidrosis, although lacking a precise definition and of unknown aetiology, disrupts professional and social life and may lead to emotional problems. A variety of treatment methods are used to control or reduce the profuse sweating which involves mainly the palms, soles and axillae. The simplest method, the application of topical agents, is usually attempted first for axillary and plantar sweating. Iontophoresis may provide relief especially in patients with plantar or palmar involvement. In severe cases operative intervention is necessary. Excision of sweat glands is successful in patients with axillary hyperhidrosis but the role of suction-assisted removal of axillary sweat glands remains to be determined. Sympathectomy remains the standard by which other treatments must be judged. For upper thoracic sympathectomy a variety of surgical approaches are used with satisfactory relief of hyperhidrosis. Complications related to the surgical approach, such as Horner's syndrome, brachial plexus injuries, pneumothorax and painful scars may occur, while following sympathectomy compensatory hyperhidrosis is usual and hyperhidrosis may recur. Plantar hyperhidrosis which may be exacerbated or ameliorated by upper thoracic sympathectomy and which fails to respond to non-operative intervention is relieved by lumbar sympathectomy.

Resympathectomy of the upper extremity

Resympathectomy was performed in 27 patients (eight bilaterally) with ischaemic hand phenomena. An extended operative technique, resecting parts of the second and third intercostal nerves and their surrounding tissue, was used. In all 35 procedures the posterior extrapleural approach was used. Follow-up was from 3 to 12 years. Only the sympathetic ganglia had been removed during the previous surgery by the axillary approach (67 per cent of these patients had had a transient response for between 6 months and 2 years; 33 per cent had had no response at all). A direct subjective improvement was seen after 27 of the 35 reoperations (77 per cent). In 14 patients continuous wave Doppler ultrasound studies were available and showed a significant increase in peak forward frequency after operation (P less than 0.001). From these data it may be concluded that it is possible to obtain a resympathectomy effect, but reoperation should be reserved for special cases for whom survival of digits is essential.

Palmar hyperhidrosis and its surgical treatment: a report of 100 cases

One hundred patients with primary palmar hyperhidrosis (HH) underwent bilateral upper dorsal sympathectomy (UDS) by the supraclavicular approach. Pre-operative epidemiological and clinical data are described. The immediate and late results, as well as the complications and side-effects are detailed. Follow-up was completed on 93 patients between four and 50 months after the operation (average 18 months). Of 93 patients, 91 had drying of the hands. In 58% some moisture returned to the hands but in no case did the hyperhidrotic state recur. Subjective patient evaluation was excellent or good in 83 patients (89%) and only one patient (a technical failure) was completely dissatisfied. Reasons for some degree of dissatisfaction with operation were mainly compensatory HH in non denervated areas, and Horner's syndrome. Compensatory HH usually decreased with passage of time and, permanent Horner's syndrome occurred in 8% of patients (4% of procedures). Technical failure can be avoided by use of frozen section examination intraoperatively. For severe cases of palmar HH that cause social, professional and emotional embarassment, bilateral simultaneous UDS by the supraclavicular approach is the procedure of choice: Morbidity is small, and almost all patients enjoy improved quality of life after the operation.