Emergency oesophageal transection in uncontrolled variceal haemorrhage

Long-term outcome of patients with gastric varices treated by balloon-occluded retrograde transvenous obliteration

BACKGROUND AND AIM

To assess the short- and long-term outcome of patients with gastric varices (GV) after balloon-occluded retrograde transvenous obliteration (B-RTO) by comparing bleeding cases with prophylactic cases.

METHODS

Consecutive 100 patients with GV treated by B-RTO were enrolled in this retrospective cohort study. We compared the technical success, complications, and survival rates between bleeding and prophylactic cases.

RESULTS

Of 100 patients, 61 patients were bleeding cases and 39 patients were prophylactic cases. Technical success was achieved in 95% of bleeding case and in 100% of prophylactic case, with no significant difference between these groups (overall technical success rate, 97%). The survival rates at 5 and 10 years were 50% and 22% in bleeding case, and 49% and 36% in prophylactic case, respectively. There was also no significant difference (P = 0.420). By multivariate analysis, survival rates correlated significantly with liver function (hazard ratio 2.371, 95% CI 1.457-3.860, P = 0.001) and hepatocellular carcinoma development (HR 4.782, 95% CI 2.331-9.810, P < 0.001). The aggravating rates of esophageal varices (EV) were 21%, 50%, and 54% at 12, 60, and 120 months after B-RTO. By multivariate analysis, aggravating rates significantly correlated with EV existing before B-RTO (HR 18.114, 95% CI 2.463-133.219, P = 0.004).

CONCLUSION

B-RTO for GV could provide the high rate of complete obliteration and favorable long-term prognosis even in bleeding cases as well as prophylactic cases. Management of EV after B-RTO, especially in coexisting case of GV and EV, would be warranted.

Balloon-occluded retrograde transvenous obliteration of gastric fundal varices with hemorrhage

OBJECTIVE

This study was performed to evaluate the clinical efficacy, feasibility, and complications of balloon-occluded retrograde transvenous obliteration for patients with hemorrhage from gastric fundal varices.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Between December 1994 and February 2001, 24 consecutive patients with hemorrhage from gastric fundal varices were enrolled in this study. Balloon-occluded retrograde transvenous obliteration consisted of injecting 5% ethanolamine oleate iopamidol through the outflow vessels during balloon occlusion. The treatment was performed during acute bleeding in 11 patients and electively in 13 patients. Among those patients with acute bleeding, six were treated for temporary hemostasis with balloon tamponade, and five were treated endoscopically.

RESULTS

Cannulation into the outflow vessels was performed in 23 patients, but the balloon catheter could not be inserted in one patient who had inferior phrenic vein outflow. Complete success was obtained in 88% (21/24) of patients, and partial success was obtained in two patients. In nine of 11 patients with acute bleeding, complete success was achieved. Rebleeding from gastric varices was not observed in patients treated with complete success, whereas two patients treated partially rebled within 1 week of the treatment (rate of rebleeding, 9%). Eradication of gastric varices was obtained in all patients (n = 19) who were examined by endoscopy 3 months after the treatment. Eight patients experienced worsening of esophageal varices. These patients were treated endoscopically because of findings that suggested a risk of hemorrhage. The overall mortality rate was 4% (1/24). No damage to the kidney was observed, although 11 patients had macrohematuria.

CONCLUSION

Balloon-occluded retrograde transvenous obliteration followed by any hemostatic procedure might be effective for both prophylaxis of rebleeding and eradication of gastric fundal varices, even in urgent cases.

Nonshunting operations for variceal hemorrhage

To evaluate the various nonshunting treatment modalities currently being used, it is difficult to make comparative assessments by reviewing the literature. There is varied composition in the groups studied; numerous major modifications, but more often subtle but poorly described differences in surgical techniques; and lack of uniform definitions and methods of reporting even the most basic of results, be it recurrent hemorrhage, encephalopathy, or survival. Series often lump together patients with cirrhosis, both alcoholic and nonalcoholic, noncirrhotic intrahepatic block, and extrahepatic block, each of which has a different natural history, prognosis, and physiologic and hemodynamic response to interventions. Classification of severity of cirrhosis, although commonly referred to as Child's class A, B, or C, may be based on time of assessment, worst criteria present, or a point scoring system. The operations are described as "emergency," "urgent," "emergent," or "elective," and the definition of each varies with investigator. Clearly, the ability of the patient to stop bleeding and survive the hazards and high mortality of the early hours of the acute event places him in a better risk group irrespective of whether the surgical intervention is performed "urgently" within 24 hours or electively in 24 days. Expressions of long-term survival frequently do not always take into account the operative deaths or the mean follow-up time. However, some general remarks can be made. The Sugiura procedure can be performed with an extremely low mortality in selected elective patients, particularly the nonalcoholic, with virtually no postoperative encephalopathy and negligible variceal rebleeding. Postoperative major hepatic decompensation does not appear to occur with time, and long-term survival would appear superior to DSR shunt. In the class A or B alcoholic cirrhotic, results are certainly as good as and perhaps better than DSR shunt, and it is a reasonable alternative, particularly when technical and other considerations make the performance of such a shunt difficult. Surgeons who routinely perform the Warren shunt should have this operation available in their repertoire as an alternative. Attempts to compromise and reduce the extent of devascularization utilizing only a thoracic or abdominal venue or to violate Sugiura's principle of leaving intact the coronary-periesophageal-azygos venous pathway generally result in a progressively higher incidence of recurrent hemorrhage with time. The early success reported by Perecchia, Abouna, and Franco, with a transabdominal approach and lesser thoracic devascularization, which avoids "entry" into the chest, is noted with interest for the future and suggests such an approach for the more critically bleeding patients rather than the initial thoracic approach of others.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

A clinical controlled trial of endoscopic sclerotherapy for repeated esophageal variceal bleeding

Thirty-seven patients with postnecrotic cirrhosis of the liver and 13 patients with primary hepatoma were proven to have repeated bleeding from ruptured esophageal varices. Clinically controlled trials were performed by assigning patients to either sclerotherapy or control arms (25 patients each). Combined intra-variceal and para-variceal injection before an upper endoscopic examination was performed in the sclerotherapy group. In all 25 sclerotherapy cases (100%) hemostasis was successful, which was a statistically significant success rate compared to the control group (52.0%) (p less than 0.01). In the sclerotherapy group 20% (5/25 cases) developed rebleeding, which was less than the 48.0% (7 cases of continuous bleeding and 5 cases of rebleeding) of the control group (p less than 0.05). Four cases (16.0%) in the sclerotherapy group died of erosive gastritis with massive bleeding, compared to 8 fatalities (32.0%) in the control group, because of uncontrolled esophageal variceal bleeding. Endoscopic sclerotherapy is a very effective method for arresting bleeding esophageal varices, and for decreasing the rebleeding rate.

Esophageal procedures to control bleeding from varices

Portal-systemic shunting of all types has failed to improve long-term survival in patients with bleeding esophageal varices and carries a high morbidity and prohibitive mortality in the emergency setting. Direct esophageal approaches are receiving renewed attention. Sclerotherapy promises to be the simplest, safest, and most effective treatment for acute bleeding. Rebleeding is frequent with this technique unless all the varices are subsequently obliterated. Even then, rebleeding may be a recurring hazard, albeit with reduced frequency and increasing interval. For the nonalcoholic patient with a significant life expectancy or in the young patient with cirrhosis, this can be a significant factor. Simple esophageal resection-transection using stapling devices is a rapidly accomplished, simple, and effective operative approach if combined with coronary vein ligation. This procedure deserves a trial earlier in such patients and in those who are failures of repeated sclerotherapy. Extensive esophagogastric devascularization preserving the paraesophageal veins--the Sugiura procedure--is a more extensive undertaking that is probably unnecessary for most and too dangerous for some. At present, it should be reserved for failures of other techniques. It shows promise of long-term effectiveness if performed safely on only certain patients.

Randomised, controlled study of transhepatic obliteration of varices and oesophageal stapling transection in uncontrolled variceal haemorrhage

Percutaneous transhepatic obliteration and surgical stapling transection of the oesophagus with the EEA gun were compared prospectively in the treatment of uncontrolled oesophageal variceal haemorrhage unresponsive to conservative measures. Twenty patients with cirrhosis, with a patient portal vein and who were considered suitable for general anaesthesia and surgery, were randomised to two treatment groups (10 patients each). Immediate arrest of haemorrhage was achieved in 17 patients (nine surgery, eight obliteration). In one other patient, stapling transection succeeded where attempted transhepatic obliteration failed, and in another patient obliteration succeeded where attempted transection had failed. One patient continued to bleed and died following attempts at both procedures. Two other patients also died in hospital, without rebleeding following surgery. Variceal rebleeding during the same hospital admission occurred in two patients in the obliteration group and in none after surgery. Oesophageal stapling transection compares very favourably with a non-surgical technique such as transhepatic obliteration of varices in the emergency treatment of uncontrolled variceal haemorrhage in patients with moderate liver failure.

Randomized controlled trial of injection sclerotherapy for bleeding oesophageal varices--an interim report

Oesophageal varices are the commonest cause of acute upper gastrointestinal bleeding in Egypt, due to the prevalence not only of schistosomiasis but also chronic hepatitis. Poor results of conventional treatment and shunt surgery led us to evaluate injection sclerotherapy, using fibreoptic endoscopy. In a controlled trial, 108 patients were randomly allocated to injection sclerotherapy or to conventional treatment (medical measures, with modified splenectomy and oesophagogastric devascularization in selected cases). We report the results in the first 108 patients, with a follow-up of 1-35 months. Fifty-three patients received injection sclerotherapy; 5 died (2 of recurrent bleeding) and 5 others had recurrent bleeding but were controlled by further injections. Thirty-six of the 55 control patients underwent surgery; 5 died (2 of recurrent bleeding) and 2 others developed recurrent bleeding. Further bleeding occurred in 12 of the 19 patients who were managed by medical measures alone, with 7 dying. These early results indicate that injection sclerotherapy can be effective in urgent and elective situations and that it appears to have advantages over conventional medical and surgical treatments.

The acute treatment of haemorrhage from oesophageal varices: a comparison of oesophageal transection and staple gun anastomosis with mesocaval shunt

Two matched groups of 20 patients with bleeding oesophageal varices were treated by the same surgical team by either oesophagogastric transection and anastomosis using a mechanical stapling instrument or by mesocaval portosystemic shunt operation. Five of the patients treated by transection died postoperatively, 2 of the survivors developed portosystemic encephalopathy (PSE). 2 died later and 5 rebled. Seven of the patients who had a mesocaval shunt died postoperatively, 8 developed PSE, 3 died later and 4 rebled. It is concluded that oesophagogastric transection and anastomosis using a mechanical instrument is preferable to portal decompression for managing bleeding oesophageal varices in the urgent situation.

'Currents and clots'--an approach to the problem of acute variceal bleeding

The Sengstaken-Blakemore tube will frequently control haemorrhage from oesophageal varices but a large proportion of patients rebleed soon after removing the tube and the hospital mortality in these patients is high. It has been demonstrated that the passage of an electric current across a blood vessel wall will precipitate a thrombus on the positively charged electrode, leading to complete occlusion of the vessel. A direct current of 3.2 mA/cm2 of electrode passed for 1 h produced complete occlusion of the femoral vein in the dog, without arterial occlusion or adjacent tissue damage. A system of longitudinal flexible gold-plated strip electrodes was placed around the oesophageal component of a Sengstaken tube. The technique has been applied in 8 poor risk patients with active variceal bleeding; haemorrhage was arrested in 7 of these on removal of the tube.

Emergency treatment of variceal haemorrhage

For the initial control of haemorrhage from oesophageal varices, two methods of vasopressin administration have been compared--the conventional bolus of 20 units and a low dose infusion of 0.4 units per minute. Twenty patients bleeding from oesophageal varices, confirmed by endoscopy, were allocated into either treatment group (10 in each). Vasopressin infusion stopped bleeding in 86 per cent of the episodes in contrast to 12.5 per cent (P less than 0.01) with bolus doses. Balloon tamponade with a Sengstaken-Blakemore tube was used to control bleeding in only 2 episodes in patients on infusion and in 10 episodes in patients on bolus doses of vasopressin (P less than 0.05). Our study confirms that low dose vasopressin infusion in more effective in controlling bleeding from oesophageal varices than conventional bolus doses.

Simplified oesophageal transection for bleeding varices

Thirty patients with bleeding oesophageal varices were treated by oesophageal transection using the SPTU gun. Any form of shunt was contraindicated in all the patients. Twelve operations were done as urgent procedures within 36 hours of haemorrhage. The overall operative mortality rate was 10%, and there were two late deaths during follow-up, which has so far extended from two months to two years. Three of the patients had recurrent bleeding, and residual varices were probably the source in two. There were no cases of portal systemic encephalopathy. Although the follow-up is too short to allow any definite conclusions, these early results suggest that oesophageal transection with the SPTU gun may be useful in the large proportion of patients in whom injection sclerotherapy, shunt surgery, or conservative treatment is inappropriate.

Bleeding oesophageal varices

At the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, most patients with bleeding varices have been poor-risk alcoholics. A high proportion were receiving a State pension. The early mortality due to bleeding varices was 53%. This figure comprised a 60% mortality following conservative management and 40% after urgent shunt. All patients having urgent operations which were not portal decompression died. No patient who had an elective shunt died. In a mean follow-up period of 15.4 months, a further 14% of survivors died. No form of conservative management appeared to have much effect on the natural history of the bleeding. A blood replacement of more than five litres indicated that spontaneous cessation of haemorrhage was unlikely. Shunt operations usually controlled haemorrhage, but hepatorenal failure was common after the urgent shunts. The cost of operation was greater than that of conservative management, but in neither case was it considered excessive.

Percutaneous transhepatic obliteration of gastro-oesophageal varices

Percutaneous transhepatic portal-vein catheterisation was attempted to obliterate the major variceal venous supply in 13 decompensated cirrhotic patients, who continued to bleed after conservative therapy. Obliteration was achieved and bleeding stopped in 7 patients. In 5 patients obliteration was technically unsuccessful. The remaining patient had an unsuspected portal-vein block diagnosed by the transhepatic technique. 1 patient with successfully obliterated varices died after a haemothorax and haemorperitoneum developed. Follow-up splenic venography at three to six months in the 6 successfully thrombosed patients showed that 4 had persistent obliteration and had not re-bled. 2 patients re-bled from incompletely obliterated varices. It is concluded that selective obliteration of the major variceal supply is effective in stopping acute gastro-oesophageal variceal bleeding, but that greater experience is necessary before the long-term effectiveness of the procedure can be determined.

Emergency portasystemic shunt for bleeding varices

Sixty-eight patients with bleeding oesophageal varices due to cirrhosis of the liver who have had an emergency portasystemic shunt are reviewed. The reasons for the emergency shunt surgery and the results are described and discussed. The low postoperative mortality is attributed to careful case selection. Apart from clinical and serological factors, the importance of the bromsulphthalein excretion test is stressed. Emergency shunts are now undertaken by the author in patients whose serum bilirubin is less than 2-5/100 ml and bromsulphthalein retention less than 10 per cent in 30 minutes. This is in marked contrast to the author's previous series in which there was a 30 per cent mortality. The poor results in patients treated conservatively and the disparity between the author's results and those of other reported series are reviewed and discussed.

Early experience with the Boerema button for bleeding oesophageal varices

Early experience with the use of the Boerema button for bleeding oesophageal varices is reported. A simplified technique for its insertion is described, and of the 6 patients so treated, only 1 died. No patient has re-bled in the short follow-up period available, and oesophageal appearances suggest that prolonged relief from bleeding can be anticipated. Further exploration of the button ligation transection technique is suggested not only for control of acute bleeding, but also for patients unsuitable for shunt surgery.

Interposition grafting for portal hypertension

During the past six years, thirty-seven patients underwent interposition graft shunting for thirty-three instances of bleeding from varices and five instances of intractable ascites, either electively (twenty-seven instances) or as an emergency (eleven instances). Autogenous jugular vein was used in twenty-five instances, homologous vena cava in nine, and Dacron in four. Portacaval and mesocaval anastomoses were done in equal numbers (nineteen). Using Childs' method of clinical evaluation, thirty-three patients were Class C and four Class B. There were five (13.2 per cent) early deaths with one (3.5 per cent) in the elective and four (36 per cent) in the emergency group. Twelve grafts were open at autopsy, fifteen at splenoportography, and seven assumed patent because patients were asymptomatic. Two Dacron grafts and two homografts thrombosed. There were ten late deaths, only one related to graft failure. Apparently, the operation controls ascites, with autogenous jugular vein being the ideal material. Interposition grafting is a simple, safe procedure that can be used for portal decompression in patients with bleeding varices.

Modified oesophagoscope for injecting oesophageal varices

Images

Abdominal approach for the ligation of bleeding oesophageal varices

The conventional surgical treatment of bleeding oesophageal varices in the emergency situation is based upon the Boerema-Crile operation of transthoracic oesophagotomy and ligation of the varices. This and the other methods of treatment of this condition in current practice are discussed. Two cases are reported in which a transabdominal oesophagogastrotomy was used to approach the site of bleeding. This operation is described and the theoretical and practical advantages it appears to offer over the standard approach are considered.