Prospective assessment of carotid endarterectomy by clinical and ultrasonic methods

Factors Affecting Recurrent Carotid Stenosis

Recurrent carotid stenosis is an ongoing process that may develop at or near the site of an operational or interventional procedure to treat an atheromatous stenosis. Although such a restenosis is most often initially without symptoms, as the disease progresses it may become symptomatic, and thus endanger the patient's life. Such patients are therefore candidates for revisional surgery. Extensive research investigation and numerous studies have incriminated several risk factors as predisposing conditions for recurrent carotid stenosis. The definite role of each predisposing factor, however, is still widely debated. Clarifying the extent of involvement of each factor in the pathogenesis of carotid restenosis is indeed demanding, as it would contribute enormously to the identification of the group of high-risk patients, and, therefore, determine the therapeutic approach in these patients.

Cost-effectiveness of Intraoperative Imaging in Carotid Endarterectomy

OBJECTIVE:

There has never been a large, randomized controlled trial to assess the impact of intraoperative imaging on the success of carotid endarterectomy (CEA). This comparison involves cost-effectiveness analysis.

METHODS:

We constructed a decision-analytic model to compare effectiveness and costs of intraoperative ultrasound (IUS) and completion angiography as adjuncts to CEA. Data on procedural mortality, morbidity, and costs were obtained from the English-language literature. The review included a total of 52 reports, encompassing more than 22,000 patients. The main components of costs were those of the monitoring interventions and the care of perioperative stroke.

RESULTS:

Mean perioperative outcome without completion imaging is approximately 96.7% of what it would be in the absence of perioperative stroke or death. IUS and completion angiography each result in approximately 2% improvement in expected outcome. Mean perioperative costs are $396.50 for IUS, $721.30 for no monitoring, and $840.90 for completion angiography. Because IUS is significantly more effective at detecting technical errors that would likely result in perioperative stroke than no imaging and is significantly less costly than angiography, this strategy dominates the other two (i.e., it provides greater effectiveness at lower cost).

CONCLUSION:

Although surgical complications are uncommon, IUS substantially lowers the rate of perioperative stroke and mortality and thus is significantly more cost-effective than either completion angiography or no operative imaging.

Analysis of regression of postoperative carotid stenosis from prospective randomized trial of carotid endarterectomy comparing primary closure versus patching

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Recurrent stenosis after carotid endarterectomy (CEA) has been reported to vary between a few percent and 30%. Regression of recurrent stenosis has been reported sporadically in the literature, but studies analyzing the factors affecting regression are lacking. This study analyzed factors affecting the regression of postoperative stenosis from a prospective randomized trial of CEA comparing primary closure (PC) versus patching.

PATIENT POPULATION AND METHODS

Three hundred ninety-nine CEAs were randomized into three groups: 135 PCs, 135 polytetrafluoroethylene patch closures (PTFE), and 130 vein patch closures (VPC). Postoperative duplex ultrasounds were done at 1, 6, and 12 months, and then yearly. The subgroup of these CEAs that exhibited postoperative stenosis was followed for possible regression of the stenosis. Analyses of various risk factors were examined for possible association with regression of recurrent stenosis. Mean follow-up was 46 months.

RESULTS

Of 105 postoperative stenoses, regression was noted in 6/64 (9%) in PC, 6/13 (46%) in PTFE, and 10/28 (36%) in VPC. Overall, 22 recurrent stenoses regressed; 19 regressed to normal and 3 regressed from 50% to 80% stenosis to 20% to <50% stenosis. The mean time to regression was 383 days. Regression was more common in patching than PC. Both VPC and PTFE had significantly more regression than PC. When stenoses of 50% to 80% were analyzed, patching had more regression than PC. None of the recurrent stenoses > or = 80% regressed. There was no association between regression and other factors, including gender, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, coronary artery disease, smoking, internal carotid artery diameter, hyperlipidemia, hypercholesterolemia, or aspirin intake.

CONCLUSIONS

Regression of recurrent stenosis was associated more strongly with patching than with PC. There was no association between regression and other factors.

Prospective randomized trial of carotid endarterectomy with primary closure and patch angioplasty with saphenous vein, jugular vein, and polytetrafluoroethylene: long-term follow-up

PURPOSE

This study examines the long-term clinical outcome and the incidence of recurrent stenosis (> or = 50%) after carotid endarterectomy (CEA) with primary closure (PC) versus vein patch closure (VPC), saphenous (SVP), and jugular vein (JVP) and polytetrafluoroethylene patch closure (PTFE-P).

METHODS

A total of 399 CEAs were randomized into the following groups: 135 PC, 134 PTFE-P, and 130 VPC (SVP alternating with JVP). Postoperative duplex ultrasound scans were performed at 1, 6, and 12 months and every year thereafter. The mean follow-up was 30 months with a range of 1 to 62 months, and demographic characteristics were similar in all groups. Kaplan-Meier analysis was used to estimate the risk of restenosis and the stroke-free survival.

RESULTS

The incidence of ipsilateral stroke was 5% (seven of 135) for PC, 1% (one of 134) for PTFE-P, and 0% for VPC (PC vs VPC, p = 0.008; PC vs PTFE-P, p = 0.034). Seven strokes occurred in the perioperative period. All three groups had similar mortality rates. The cumulative stroke-free survival rate at 48 months was 82% for PC, 84% for PTFE-P, and 88% for VPC (p < 0.01 for PC vs PTFE-P or VPC). PC had a higher incidence of recurrent stenosis and occlusion (34%) than PTFE-P (2%) and VPC (9%) (SVP 9%, JVP 8%) (p < 0.001). PTFE-P had a lower recurrent stenosis rate than VPC (p < 0.045). Restenoses necessitating a redo CEA were also higher for PC (11%) than for PTFE-P (1%) and VPC (2%) (p < 0.001). Women with PC had a higher recurrent stenosis rate than men (46% vs 23%, p = 0.008). Kaplan-Meier analysis showed that freedom from recurrent stenosis at 48 months was 47% for PC, 84% for VPC, and 96% for PTFE-P (p < 0.001). The SVP and JVP results were comparable. The mean operative diameter of the internal carotid artery was similar in patients with or without restenosis. Significantly more late internal carotid artery dilatations occurred in the VPC group compared with the PC group.

CONCLUSIONS

Patch closure (VPC or PTFE-P) is less likely than PC to cause perioperative stroke. Patching was also superior in lowering the incidence of late recurrent stenoses, especially in women.

Relationship between intraoperative color-flow duplex findings and early restenosis after carotid endarterectomy: a preliminary report

PURPOSE

This study was undertaken to examine the relationship between intraoperative color-flow duplex (CFD) findings and the development of restenosis in patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy (CEA).

METHODS

Seventy-eight patients (43 male and 35 female; mean age, 65 years) underwent 86 CEAs (eight staged bilateral) and intraoperative CFD during a 31-month period. Three patients (three CEAs, 3%) underwent both CFD and a completion arteriographic scan. Patients were observed in a postoperative protocol using CFD surveillance. The follow-up interval ranged from 6 to 24 months (average, 12 months).

RESULTS

After undergoing CEA, 10 patients (10 CEAs, 11%) had an abnormality detected by intraoperative CFD; one was confirmed with a completion arteriographic scan. These abnormalities consisted of elevated peak systolic velocities (PSV) with a mosaic color pattern suggesting turbulence seen in six CEAs, including one internal carotid artery (ICA) with abnormal hemodynamics and an unremarkable completion arteriogram. Intimal defects on B-mode were seen in another four CEAs. These carotid arteries were reexplored, defects (intimal flaps with platelet thrombus) were confirmed by direct examination, and all were repaired with or without a patch (six ICAs, three external carotid arteries, and one common carotid artery). No cerebrovascular events occurred in the perioperative period. No carotid restenosis (> or = 50% diameter reduction) was identified during follow-up of 43 patients (48 CEAs, 56%). Two patients had recurrent neurologic symptoms.

CONCLUSION

Intraoperative CFD is an effective test for detecting flow abnormalities or intimal defects in patients undergoing CEA. Ensuring normal intraoperative hemodynamics after CEA may be a major factor associated with decreased incidence of perioperative cerebrovascular events and subsequent carotid artery restenosis.

Surveillance imaging of the operated artery does not alter clinical outcome following carotid endarterectomy

Clinical outcome was studied in 243 patients undergoing 260 carotid endarterectomies; 166 of these patients underwent serial postoperative surveillance imaging. Including perioperative events, cumulative freedom from ipsilateral stroke was 86 and 82 per cent at 5 and 10 years respectively; the mean incidence of ipsilateral stroke was 1.8 per cent per annum. Twenty patients (8 per cent) suffered cerebral ischaemic events in the hemisphere of the operated side during follow-up: eight transient ischaemic attacks (TIA) and 12 strokes (only two preceded by TIA). Two symptomatic patients were found to have occluded the operated artery but the remainder had no evidence of significant recurrent disease. Cumulative freedom from occlusion or severe (greater than 70 per cent) recurrent stenosis was 87 and 78 per cent at 5 and 10 years respectively; the mean incidence of recurrence of significant disease was 2.2 per cent per annum. No revisional surgery was performed on the operated arteries. In its current format, neither clinical nor surveillance imaging could have prevented any of the strokes observed during follow-up.

Intraoperative duplex monitoring of the carotid bifurcation for the detection of technical defects

OBJECTIVES

Intraoperative Duplex examination can be used to identify technical imperfections during carotid endarterectomy. The objectives of this study were: (1) to evaluate the technical feasibility of intraoperative Duplex; (2) to compare Duplex findings with contrast arteriography; (3) to correlate intraoperative Duplex findings with postoperative complications and with Duplex data obtained during follow-up.

DESIGN

Prospective clinical study.

SETTING

Department of Vascular Surgery, Catharina Hospital, Eindhoven, The Netherlands.

MATERIALS

44 patients underwent Duplex scanning at the completion of carotid endarterectomy. In addition intraoperative arteriography was performed in the first 16 consecutive patients. Follow-up included a Duplex examination at three monthly intervals during the first postoperative year.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Technical defects and flow disturbance at the time of surgery, and postoperative restenosis.

RESULTS

At contrast arteriography a distal intimal ridge with 15-20% diameter reduction was observed in two, an occlusion of the external carotid artery in three and moderate kinking in one patient. All abnormalities were identified at Duplex imaging. In none of the cases were the Duplex findings considered an indication to re-explore the endarterectomised internal carotid artery. Postoperative complications occurred in six patients: three strokes, two transient ischaemic attacks and two internal carotid occlusions (in one patient combined with a stroke). Severe spectral broadening (spectral class D) correlated significantly with early postoperative complications (p = 0.027). In contrast, moderate defects on Duplex imaging did not correlate significantly with early complications. Duplex examination during the first year of follow-up demonstrated recurrent stenosis in four patients. Intraoperative spectral broadening did not correlate significantly with the development of common or internal carotid restenosis. However, external carotid recurrent stenosis was positively related to intraoperative flow disturbance (p = 0.0003).

CONCLUSION

Duplex scanning is easy to use after completion of carotid endarterectomy. There is good agreement between intraoperative Duplex scanning and contrast arteriography. Extensive spectral broadening of the Doppler velocity signal is associated with an increased prevalence of early postoperative complications. Restenosis at follow-up appears to be related to severe flow disturbance as was demonstrated for the external carotid artery.

Randomized controlled trial of patch angioplasty for carotid endarterectomy. The Joint Vascular Research Group

A randomized controlled trial was performed to evaluate patch angioplasty for patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy. There were 213 patient episodes affecting 148 men and 65 women, with 109 allocated to patch angioplasty. Following surgery six patients suffered transient ischaemic attacks but these did not delay discharge from hospital. Six individuals (four patched operations, two not patched) required re-exploration for postoperative haemorrhage and eight (two patched procedures, six not) had potentially serious neurological problems after operation. Of these eight patients, four (none receiving patch angioplasty) underwent re-exploration and in each case a clot was removed and a patch inserted; three of the four made a good long-term recovery. The other four patients suffered completed strokes from which one died. Two further patients (one patched procedure, one not) died after operation from myocardial events, giving an overall 30-day stroke or mortality rate of 2.8 per cent. Objective follow-up assessment with duplex scanning at 1 year was completed by 94.8 per cent of patients; significantly more vessel restenoses and occlusions were observed in those not receiving patches (P < 0.01). Patch angioplasty reduces the number of immediate postoperative complications, and significantly lowers vessel restenosis and occlusion rates at 1 year after operation.

The reproducibility of colour-coded duplex scanning in measuring arterial wall dimensions

Intimal hyperplasia continues to be a major problem following vascular surgery but experimental evidence suggests that it can be reduced pharmacologically. For clinical studies an accurate, reproducible and non-invasive image of the intima and lumen is required. We have assessed the value of the Acuson 128 Colour Duplex for such studies. Ten patients had their common femoral arteries scanned at a fixed point by two experienced observers on two separate occasions. External vessel diameter, luminal diameter and internal diameter (i.e. the diameter within the internal elastic lamina) were measured in both longitudinal and cross-sectional views. Cross-sectional area and degree of stenosis were all measured and all parameters expressed as limits of agreement. The mean external diameter of the common femoral arteries was 10.5 +/- 1.6 mm. Measurements in the longitudinal view were highly reproducible with limits of agreement ranging from -0.67 - +0.25 mm (internal diameter) to -1.49 - +1.31 mm (luminal diameter). In order to detect a meaningful change in longitudinal external diameter a real difference of 0.86 mm is required representing a change of less than 10%. Cross-sectional diameter measurements were similarly reproducible (-0.73 - +0.47 mm to -1.97 - +1.79 mm). However, cross-sectional area measurements had a wide variation so that the error in degree of stenosis was -25.4 - +30.2%. Thus, duplex ultrasound reproducibly images the layers of the arterial wall. Prospective studies of intimal hyperplasia are feasible but must be based on longitudinal and cross-sectional diameters rather than cross-sectional areas.

Eight to ten years follow-up after carotid endarterectomy: clinical evaluation and Doppler examination of patients operated on between 1978-1980

Follow-up information was obtained on 185 patients who consecutively underwent carotid endarterectomy eight to ten years previously. Doppler ultrasound examination was performed in 59 patients who were still alive and living within 100 miles of the hospital. Using lifetable analysis, the annual rate of focal strokes was estimated to be 2% and 1.5% on the operated and the contralateral, non-operated carotid artery, respectively. Doppler examination revealed 48% re-stenoses, including 14% occlusion and 15% greater than 50% stenosis. However, there was no association between the occurrence of restenosis and the development of symptoms, perhaps with the exception of internal carotid artery occlusion, which is not an accepted indication for carotid endarterectomy. Together with recent data from the literature, these observations challenge the indication for reoperative carotid surgery.

Role for prazosin in reducing the development of rabbit intimal hyperplasia after endothelial denudation

Intimal hyperplasia is the universal response to endothelial denudation and occurs after a variety of vascular procedures. In a proportion of cases the smooth muscle cell proliferation may lead to stenosis of the blood vessels. These vessels exhibit increased sensitivity to noradrenaline that can be reduced by the alpha 1-adrenergic antagonist prazosin. Because the alpha 1-adrenergic receptor and platelet-derived growth factor (which promotes vascular smooth muscle cell proliferation) act through the same metabolic pathway, it was postulated that alpha 1-adrenergic blockade might reduce the development of intimal hyperplasia. Twenty-eight New Zealand White rabbits underwent endothelial denudation of the aorta using a Fogarty balloon catheter. Test rabbits were treated with prazosin from the day of operation until they were killed. All rabbits were killed either 1 or 4 weeks after endothelial denudation. Intimal hyperplasia in cross-sections of the aorta was measured using an X-Y digitizer and was standardized in terms of percentage luminal reduction. Prazosin-treated rabbits had significantly less luminal reduction at 1 week (0.75(1.8) versus 9.7(3.1) per cent, mean (s.d.), P less than 0.001) and at 4 weeks (14.7(4.4) versus 25.3(12.8) per cent, P less than 0.05) than control rabbits. It is concluded that prazosin caused a major reduction in the development of intimal hyperplasia.