Cyclical mastopathy: a critical review of therapy

Evaluation and management of breast pain

Pain is one of the most common breast symptoms experienced by women. It can be severe enough to interfere with usual daily activities, but the etiology and optimal treatment remain undefined. Breast pain is typically approached according to its classification as cyclic mastalgia, noncyclic mastalgia, and extramammary (nonbreast) pain. Cyclic mastalgia is breast pain that has a clear relationship to the menstrual cycle. Noncyclic mastalgia may be constant or intermittent but is not associated with the menstrual cycle and often occurs after menopause. Extramammary pain arises from the chest wall or other sources and is interpreted as having a cause within the breast. The risk of cancer in a woman presenting with breast pain as her only symptom is extremely low. After appropriate clinical evaluation, most patients with breast pain respond favorably to a combination of reassurance and nonpharmacological measures. The medications danazol, tamoxifen, and bromocriptine are effective; however, the potentially serious adverse effects of these medications limit their use to selected patients with severe, sustained breast pain. The status of other therapeutic strategies and directions for future research are discussed.

A double-blind randomized controlled trial of isoflavones in the treatment of cyclical mastalgia

Cyclical mastalgia is very common in Western populations and is believed to have an hormonal basis. Simple measures such as vitamins or evening primrose oil are not very effective, yet the disease rarely warrants anti-oestrogen therapies. Isoflavones are a subgroup of phytoestrogens which we hypothesized might be a simple and effective means of therapy as they act as a weak anti-oestrogen in pre-menopausal women and have no side-effects. A double-blind randomized control trial of either placebo, 40 mg or 80 mg of isoflavones was undertaken after an initial 2 month single-blind 'Placebo Lead-in' to exclude women with a significant placebo response. Eighteen women were randomized to the treatment phase of the trial. Nine of the 12 women on treatment had a worthwhile improvement in their pain compared to only two of six on placebo. The reduction in pain was 13% for placebo, 44% for 40 mg of isoflavone per day and 31% for 80 mg per day. There have been no previous clinical studies of isoflavones for the treatment of mastalgia and the benefit demonstrated in this study adds another valuable arm to therapy.

Symptomatic treatment of premenstrual mastalgia in premenopausal women with lisuride maleate: a double-blind placebo-controlled randomized study

OBJECTIVE

To determine the therapeutic effect of lisuride maleate on premenstrual mastalgia in premenopausal women.

DESIGN

Double-blind randomized prospective study.

SETTING

Department of obstetrics and gynecology at a university hospital.

PATIENT(S)

Sixty women with premenstrual mastalgia were included in the study. Study and control groups consisted of 30 women each.

INTERVENTION(S)

Women enrolled in the study and control group were given one tablet daily (0.2 mg) of lisuride maleate or placebo orally for 2 months. Severity of mastalgia was evaluated using the visual analog scale.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Severity of mastalgia and side effects of the drug administered.

RESULT(S)

Mastalgia subsided significantly in women receiving lisuride maleate compared with controls. There were no significant side effects from lisuride maleate. Prolactin levels decreased significantly in the group receiving lisuride, which correlated well with pain resolution.

CONCLUSION(S)

Lisuride maleate may be useful for the symptomatic treatment of premenstrual mastalgia.

Potential mechanisms of diet therapy for fibrocystic breast conditions show inadequate evidence of effectiveness

Fibrocystic breast conditions, formerly referred to as fibrocystic breast disease, affect about half of all women and typically present as any combination of breast nodularity, swelling, and pain. We reviewed the literature to evaluate evidence supporting nutrition interventions commonly recommended for fibrocystic breast conditions by health care providers. Randomized, controlled studies of the effectiveness of caffeine restriction fail to support any benefit in fibrocystic breast conditions. Similarly, evidence supporting evening primrose oil, vitamin E, or pyridoxine as treatments for the discomforts of fibrocystic breast conditions is insufficient to draw conclusions about effectiveness. Dietary alterations that influence the intermediate markers for fibrocystic breast conditions include low-fat (15% to 20% energy), high-fiber (30 g/day), and soy isoflavone regimens. However, our findings provide no solid evidence for secondary prevention or treatment of fibrocystic breast conditions through a dietary approach. Health care providers should limit recommendations to proven diet therapies supported by randomized, placebo-controlled trials, given the instability inherent in fibrocystic breast conditions and the near 20% placebo effect associated with intervention. Because excessive estrogen or altered sensitivity to estrogen is the dominant theory of etiology, interventions that may modulate endogenous steroid hormones warrant further investigation as potential treatments for symptomatic fibrocystic breast conditions.

Elevated high-density lipoprotein cholesterol and dietary fat intake in women with cyclic mastopathy

OBJECTIVE

This study was designed to examine the contribution of plasma lipids to the pathophysiology of cyclic mastopathy, before and after consideration of diet and sex hormones.

STUDY DESIGN

Thirty-four women with severe cyclic mastopathy (case patients) and 29 women without cyclic mastopathy (control subjects) recorded their breast symptoms daily during 1 menstrual cycle. During each menstrual phase (follicular, early luteal, late luteal, and menstrual) they prospectively completed 2 24-hour dietary diaries, provided blood for lipid and hormone assays, and underwent anthropometric measurements.

RESULTS

Mean age was 34 years. Premenstrual breast swelling and tenderness were significantly more severe in case patients (P < .0001). Cyclic change (late luteal vs follicular) of high-density lipoprotein cholesterol differed between case patients and control subjects, with case patients having a relative excess of high-density lipoprotein cholesterol in the premenstrual phase (P = .01). Dietary fat intake was greater throughout the cycle in case patients (37.5 vs 33.7% of calories, P = .02), and case patients reported increased appetite in the premenstrual phase (P = .01). In multivariate analyses the contributions of mean dietary fat intake and of cyclic change in high-density lipoprotein cholesterol were independently significant, with odds ratios for upper versus lower quintiles being slightly >5.

CONCLUSIONS

Women with cyclic mastopathy had a relative excess of high-density lipoprotein cholesterol during the symptomatic late luteal phase of the menstrual cycle and a higher fat intake throughout the cycle than did control subjects. These observations support the hypothesis that lipids (notably high-density lipoprotein cholesterol) and a high-fat diet play a role in the pathophysiologic characteristics of cyclic mastopathy.

Breast health and associated premenstrual symptoms in women with severe cyclic mastopathy

OBJECTIVES

A case-control study was undertaken to examine the association of cyclic mastopathy with premenstrual syndrome and prior breast health.

STUDY DESIGN

A total of 34 women with severe cyclic mastopathy (cases) and 29 women with no significant breast symptoms (controls) prospectively recorded breast pain and swelling and symptoms of premenstrual syndrome during one menstrual cycle. They also provided information on past breast health. The two study groups were compared by use of standard statistical methods.

RESULTS

Women with cyclic mastopathy reported more frequent consultations with physicians for specific breast lumpiness (p = 0.02) or generalized lumpiness (p = 0.004) and for all breast problems (p = 0.0001) and more frequent mammograms (p = 0.04), surgical breast biopsies (p = 0.06), and breast needle aspirations (p = 0.05). Premenstrual symptoms were more severe in women with cyclic mastopathy; this was most pronounced for physical symptoms (water retention and breast symptoms, p < 0.001) but also present for negative affect, behavior change, and impaired concentration (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Women with cyclic mastopathy have a spectrum of breast concerns and they undergo more frequent breast investigations than do women without the disorder. Most symptoms of premenstrual syndrome are also more severe in women with cyclic mastopathy.

Breast disease

Breast diseases are a common aspect of primary care practice. Common benign and malignant breast diseases are reviewed. The evaluation of common breast problems is presented and current recommendations for diagnostic and screening mammography are discussed.

Cyclical mastopathy and premenopausal breast cancer risk. Results of a case-control study

Cyclical mastopathy (CM) is a common clinical syndrome of premenstrual breast swelling and tenderness. Its symptoms are relieved by reduction in dietary fat intake and, because fat intake may be associated with breast cancer risk, it was hypothesized that CM may also be related to breast cancer risk. This case-control study included 192 premenopausal women with a recent history of axillary node-negative breast cancer and 192 age-matched premenopausal controls. Subjects provided information on diet and risk factors, and they recorded breast symptoms prospectively during one menstrual cycle. Symptoms in the noncancerous breast of cases and the matched (right or left) breast of controls were examined. A cyclical pattern of symptoms was identified in both groups; breast tenderness scores were similar postmenstrually (p = 0.31) but were significantly higher premenstrually in the case group (p = 0.03). Cases also had a greater premenstrual increase in breast tenderness than controls (p = 0.03). When the effects of other risk factors for breast cancer were included in multivariate analyses, the association of cyclical tenderness with breast cancer persisted (p = 0.05), the odds ratio for severe tenderness being 3.32. Thus, we have identified an association of cyclical breast tenderness with breast cancer risk in premenopausal women. The association persists after consideration of diet and the effects of other breast cancer risk factors.

Multicentre study of gestrinone in cyclical breast pain

Although the aetiology of cyclical mastalgia is poorly understood, the consistent finding of an increased prolactin stimulation response probably due to oestrogen dominance has led to the use of treatment with prolactin-lowering drugs and antioestrogens. The efficacy and safety in cyclical mastalgia of gestrinone, which has androgenic, anti-oestrogenic, and antiprogestagenic properties, were investigated in a multicentre study. In a double-blind randomisation procedure, 72 patients were allocated placebo and 73 treatment with gestrinone (2.5 mg twice a week) for 3 months. The patients recorded the severity of breast pain on a visual analogue scale before and during treatment and scored other breast symptoms as not present (0), mild (1), moderate (2), or severe (3). The gestrinone group had significantly greater reductions than the placebo group in breast pain score at months 1, 2, and 3 of treatment (mean reduction 59.5 [SD 22.6] to 11.7 [17.0] vs 58.2 [17.6] to 36.7 [23.0] at month 3; p less than 0.0001). All six breast symptoms had lower scores in the gestrinone than in the placebo group by the end of treatment. In a subset of 30 participants (15 from each group), serum concentrations of oestradiol, progesterone, and tri-iodothyronine were significantly lower than baseline after 3 months of gestrinone, but concentrations of luteinising hormone, follicle-stimulating hormone, prolactin, thyroid-stimulating hormone, and thyroxine did not change. 41% of gestrinone-treated and 14% of placebo-treated patients reported at least one side-effect; most of these were androgen-mediated. 11 placebo-treated patients and 4 on gestrinone discontinued treatment. Thus, gestrinone was very effective in the treatment of cyclical mastalgia and was well tolerated.

Management of breast pain and nodularity

The management of mastalgia consists of classification into its various patterns: reassurance, drug therapy for severe cases, and, rarely, surgery. Differentiation into cyclical and noncyclical patterns on a simple pain chart is useful for objective assessment of pain severity and for selection of appropriate drug therapy and subsequent monitoring of response. About 85% of new patients will be satisfied with adequate reassurance, but some 15% will have persistent pain and warrant medical treatment. Only a small number of drugs have been adequately tested in controlled trails and have been demonstrated to be more effective than placebo; these are bromocriptine, danazol, evening primrose oil, and tamoxifen. No ideal agent exists and the choice of drug will depend on efficacy, side effects, and cost. Noncyclical pain has a lower response rate compared to cyclical mastalgia, but differentiation of a subgroup with chest wall pain leads to an overall 90% response to treatment by local infiltration with steroid and lignocaine. Newer agents such as LHRH agonists are currently undergoing evaluation in double-blind controlled trials against placebo. The management of nodularity is based on the clinical differentiation of the normal spectrum of physiological change within the breast (ANDI), requiring simple reassurance, from a true dominant breast nodule that will require excision biopsy to exclude malignancy. When pain and lumpiness coexist, some reduction in overall nodularity (with the use of agents given for mastalgia) may occur.