Randomized clinical trial of routine preoperative duplex imaging before varicose vein surgery

Residual incompetent tributaries after varicose vein surgery increased the need for reintervention after 8 years

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to determine whether residual incompetent tributaries after varicose vein surgery affected the reintervention rate after longer follow-up.

METHODS

The study is a retrospective review of data from a cohort of a previous randomized controlled study comparing surgery with and without preoperative duplex ultrasound, with follow-up after 2 months, 2 years, and 5 to 9 years clinically and with duplex ultrasound. The cohort was subdivided according to the duplex ultrasound findings 2 months after surgery: no venous incompetence, residual incompetent tributaries only, truncal incompetence, and combined truncal and tributary incompetence. Reintervention rates were compared between groups.

RESULTS

There were 280 patients (326 legs) who attended follow-up 2 months postoperatively and 164 patients (190 legs) after a median of 8 years (5-9 years). Another 53 patients (62 legs) were interviewed by telephone or had been reoperated on earlier during follow-up; thus, information was available for 217 patients (252 legs). Of the 252 legs, 56 (22%) were reoperated on during follow-up. In the subgroup with no venous incompetence at all 2 months postoperatively, 4 of 74 legs (5%) were reoperated on; and in the group with residual incompetent tributaries without truncal incompetence, 16 of 56 legs (29%) were reoperated on (P = .000). There was no significant difference in reintervention rate of the group with incompetent tributaries only compared with those with truncal incompetence without incompetent tributaries (12/42 legs [29%]; P = 1) or with combined incompetence of truncal vein and tributaries (22/64 legs [34%]; P = .495). The presence of perforating vein incompetence at 2 months postoperatively did not significantly alter the rate of reoperations (P = .159). In legs that had not been reoperated on, more incompetent veins could be seen progressively. In the group without any incompetent veins postoperatively, 37% still had normal findings at 8 years.

CONCLUSIONS

Residual incompetent tributaries after treatment of varicose veins will increase the reintervention rate in the long term, as much as leaving a trunk vein untreated. Patients should be informed about the increased risk of reintervention if not all incompetent veins are targeted.

Superficial venous insufficiency from the infernal to the endothermal

This review presents the common diseases associated with superficial venous insufficiency of the leg. These include varicose veins, swelling, skin damage and ulceration. The benefits and rationale behind treatment are discussed, followed by the historical advances from ancient mortality and prayer to the modern endovenous revolution. Finally, an overview of modern treatment options will discuss the evidence supporting the gold standard of endothermal ablation and the cost effectiveness of treatment at this time of challenging resource limitation.

European guidelines for sclerotherapy in chronic venous disorders

Aim

Sclerotherapy is the targeted chemical ablation of varicose veins by intravenous injection of a liquid or foamed sclerosing drug. The treated veins may be intradermal, subcutaneous, and/or transfascial as well as superficial and deep in venous malformations. The aim of this guideline is to give evidence-based recommendations for liquid and foam sclerotherapy.

Methods

This guideline was drafted on behalf of 23 European Phlebological Societies during a Guideline Conference on 7–10 May 2012 in Mainz. The conference was organized by the German Society of Phlebology. These guidelines review the present state of knowledge as reflected in published medical literature. The regulatory situation of sclerosant drugs differs from country to country but this has not been considered in this document. The recommendations of this guideline are graded according to the American College of Chest Physicians Task Force recommendations on Grading Strength of Recommendations and Quality of Evidence in Clinical Guidelines.

Results

This guideline focuses on the two sclerosing drugs which are licensed in the majority of the European countries, polidocanol and sodium tetradecyl sulphate. Other sclerosants are not discussed in detail. The guideline gives recommendations concerning indications, contraindications, side-effects, concentrations, volumes, technique and efficacy of liquid and foam sclerotherapy of varicose veins and venous malformations.

Reflux patterns and risk factors of primary varicose veins’ clinical severity

Objectives

Primarily, to determine the association between the clinical severity of primary varicose veins and different reflux patterns in an anatomic and haemodynamic clinical study using duplex ultrasonography (DU). Secondly, to analyse the association of clinical severity with other aspects, such as risk factors for chronic venous insufficiency (CVI) and other concurrent diseases.

Method

A total of 2036 limbs were evaluated using DU. Clinical status was characterized by the CEAP (clinical, aetiological, anatomical and pathological elements) classification. The degree of clinical severity was grouped into two categories, mild to moderate CVI (C1–C3) and severe CVI, characterized by the presence of skin changes (C4–C6). We analysed the association of the different reflux patterns with CEAP status.

Results

Saphenofemoral junction (SFJ) reflux of the great saphenous vein (GSV) was associated with the most severe form of the disease (odds ratio [OR] = 2.96; confidence interval [CI] 95%: 2.2–3.8), whereas competent SFJ of the GSV with reflux from proximal veins (OR = 2; CI 95%: 1.4 –2.7) and the pure non-saphenous reflux (OR = 4.1; CI 95%: 1.8–9.0) were associated with mild to moderate CVI. Obesity increased the frequency of severe CVI 2.7 times (OR = 2.7; CI 95%: 1.6–4.6); being a woman also increased the frequency of more severe disease 1.3 times (OR = 1.3; CI 95%: 1.0–1.7).

Conclusion

Anatomical and haemodynamic studies by DU are postulated as a useful diagnostic tool that allow, by identifying the pattern of venous reflux of varicose pathology, characterization of the probable association to CVI clinical severity.

Laparoscopic umbilical hernia repair in the presence of extensive paraumbilical collateral veins: a case report

A patient with an umbilical hernia presenting with collateral veins in the abdominal wall and umbilicus is a case that every hernia surgeon has to deal with occasionally. Several underlying diseases have been described to provoke collateral veins in the abdominal wall. However, the treatment strategy should be uniform. We herein report a case of a successful laparoscopic umbilical hernia repair in a patient with collateral veins in the abdominal wall and umbilicus. A 63-year-old man was referred to the surgical outpatient clinic with a large symptomatic umbilical hernia and collateral veins in the abdominal wall, secondary to an occlusion of both common iliac veins. Because of collateral veins in the umbilicus and the size of the hernial defect, he was offered laparoscopic hernia repair without compromising these veins. Because of the extensive abdominal wall collaterals, duplex sonography vein mapping was performed preoperatively to mark a safe collateral-free area for trocar introduction. The defect was repaired by mesh prosthesis.

Late follow-up of a randomized trial of routine duplex imaging before varicose vein surgery

Background

Routine preoperative duplex examination led to an improvement in results 2 years after surgery for primary varicose veins. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the impact of preoperative duplex imaging after 7 years, in relation to other risk factors for varicose vein recurrence.

Methods

Patients with primary varicose veins were randomized to operation with (group 1), or without (group 2) preoperative duplex imaging. The same patients were invited to attend follow-up with interview, clinical examination and duplex imaging. Quality of life (QoL) was measured with the Short Form 36 questionnaire.

Results

Some 293 patients (343 legs) were included initially; after 7 years 227 were interviewed, or their records reviewed: 114 in group 1 and 113 in group 2. One hundred and ninety-four legs (95 in group 1 and 99 in group 2) were examined clinically and with duplex imaging. Incompetence was seen at the saphenofemoral junction and/or saphenopopliteal junction in 14 per cent of legs in group 1 and 46 per cent in group 2 (P < 0·001). QoL was similar in both groups. After a mean follow-up of 7 years (and including patients who underwent surgery after the review), 15 legs in group 1 needed reoperation and 38 in group 2 (P = 0·001).

Conclusion

Routine preoperative duplex imaging improved the results of surgery for primary varicose veins for at least 7 years. Registration number: NCT01195623 (http://www.clinicaltrials.gov).

Leg ulceration: the importance of treating the underlying pathophysiology

The last 20 years have seen considerable advances in the management of vascular diseases both in non-invasive imaging and minimally invasive surgical interventions. Colour duplex ultrasonography provides non-invasive and increasingly high-resolution anatomic and haemodynamic vascular information. This has been complimented by the development of minimally invasive interventional procedures such as subintimal angioplasty and endovenous treatments, all of which can be performed under local anaesthesia. These advances can now be utilized to improve both the assessment and management of patients with chronic leg ulceration where the aetiology is usually vascular and mostly primary venous insufficiency. Using non-invasive Doppler pressures and colour duplex imaging, the anatomic and haemodynamic pattern of the underlying vascular disease (and consequently the pathophysiology) can be precisely determined. This enables appropriate planning and targeting of effective management from an early stage in the history of any particular ulcer. This paper highlights the importance of achieving accurate diagnosis and instituting effective treatments that are appropriately targeted at the underlying pathophysiology, in patients with chronic leg ulceration, and describes how recent advances in technology and interventions have substantially increased the tools available to the vascular specialist. Thus allowing safe and effective management of what can otherwise become a prolonged or recurrent disease process.

Outcome following saphenopopliteal surgery: a prospective observational study

Objectives

High recurrence rates following small saphenous varicose vein surgery have been reported. The aim of this study was to ascertain initial success rates following saphenopopliteal junction (SPJ) surgery using pre- and postoperative duplex scanning.

Methods

A prospective study was performed on patients with ultrasound-proven SPJ reflux. Patients underwent preoperative duplex skin marking and a postoperative quality assurance scan.

Results

Ninety procedures were performed in 88 patients. The SPJ was successfully ligated in 87 (96.7%) cases. Reflux was completely abolished in 51 (56.7%) cases, but persisted solely in the small saphenous vein (SSV) in 32.2%. Subsequently, 10 consecutive patients underwent 11 SPJ ligations with stripping of the SSV. Follow-up ultrasound scan demonstrated successful ligation of the SPJ and elimination of superficial venous reflux.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that preoperative duplex SPJ marking results in a high percentage of successful ligation. Given that residual persistent reflux was avoided in patients who underwent stripping of the SSV, we propose that patients who require SPJ surgery undergo duplex marking along with specific consideration with regard to treatment of the residual SSV.

Selective loss of extracellular matrix proteins is linked to biophysical properties of varicose veins assessed by ultrasonography

BACKGROUND

Dilatation and enhanced distensibility are specific biophysical properties of varicose veins. Both can be assessed by ultrasonography. The aim of this study was to analyse correlations between the vein wall protein content and these two biophysical properties of varicose veins.

METHODS

Twenty-seven patients having surgery for varicose veins and six control patients with normal veins undergoing arterial bypass surgery were examined clinically and with ultrasonography the day before surgery. Fifty-two varicose and six control vein rings were harvested and analysed histopathologically and morphometrically; vascular tissue microarrays incorporated 116 vein wall sectors.

RESULTS

Elastin loss in the adventitia (P = 0.010) and reduction of type III collagen in the intima and media (P = 0.004) were observed in varicose veins. Elastin loss correlated negatively with vein diameter at rest (P = 0.005), whereas loss of type III collagen in the intima correlated negatively with the increase in vein diameter at the Valsalva manoeuvre (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Loss of elastin and type III collagen occurs in varicose veins and can be assessed with ultrasonography in vivo by measuring vein diameter and distensibility.

Duplex ultrasonography and varicose veins

Duplex scans for all

An “All-Comers” Venous Duplex Scan Policy for Patients with Lower Limb Varicose Veins Attending a One-stop Vascular Clinic: Is It Justified?

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether clinical assessment could predict the correct management of patients with varicose veins (VVs), select those who would need duplex scanning, and identify deep venous reflux (DVR).

METHODS

Prospective study of 342 consecutive limbs with VVs. These were divided into 3 groups: 170 (50%) limbs with primary VVs without skin changes (group I), 37 (11%) with recurrent VVs without skin changes (group II), and 135 (39%) with primary or recurrent VVs with skin changes (group III). Clinicians were asked to document whether they would normally request a duplex scan because of clinical uncertainty. Agreement between decision-making based on clinical and on duplex findings was documented.

RESULTS

Agreement between clinical and duplex findings for groups I, II, and III was 82%, 59%, and 67%, respectively. In 112 cases (66%) in group I, clinicians felt certain about the diagnosis and yet duplex scanning revealed they were wrong in 12% of cases. In group II, clinicians would request a duplex scan because of clinical uncertainty in 30 (81%) cases. In group III, the sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive value of clinical assessment in detecting DVR was 32%, 77%, 24%, and 83%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Clinical evaluation of patients with VVs is unreliable in planning their management. Clinicians can neither predict those who will require duplex scanning nor correctly identify DVR. Even experienced surgeons often "get it wrong" when assessing primary uncomplicated veins despite being certain about the diagnosis. Therefore, an "all-comers" duplex imaging policy should be implemented if optimal management is to be achieved.

How Should a Candidate Assess Varicose Veins in the MRCS Clinical Examination? A Vascular Viewpoint

INTRODUCTION

Varicose veins are a common problem and, therefore, regularly feature in the vascular bay of the MRCS clinical examination. Candidates are still being instructed to perform tests in the examination that are considered by many to be obsolete and inaccurate. Using the current cohort of vascular examiners, we aim to clarify which tests a candidate should be performing when assessing varicose veins. We also aim to assess basic surgical trainees' experience in the use of hand-held Doppler (HHD).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Postal questionnaires were sent to all English College Court examiners with a declared vascular interest to gain their opinion on what tests should be used in the vascular bay to assess primary varicose veins. E-mail questionnaires were also sent to basic surgical trainees to assess their experience in the use of hand-held Doppler to assess varicose veins.

RESULTS

There was a 100% response rate from the examiners with 93%, 86% and 79% feeling that clinical examination, HHD examination of the SFJ and HHD examination of the SPJ, respectively, should form part of the examination of primary varicose veins in the vascular bay. Only 50% indicated the Trendelenburg test and cough impulse and 57% believed the tap test should form part of the examination of varicose veins. Of the BSTs, 53% believed they could examine varicose veins with HHD. Of the BSTs who could use HHD, 74% had held a vascular SHO post.

DISCUSSION

Published data and opinion show many consultant surgeons have totally abandoned the use of the Trendelenberg, cough, tap and Perthes tests and support the opinion that HHD increases the accuracy of the examination of varicose veins. This study shows the opinions of the examiners supports the evidence-based recommendations that, in the light of easily accessible HHD, the older tests are now outdated. The majority of BSTs who were able to use HHD had held a vascular SHO post (74%) but otherwise it was unlikely that the BST would be comfortable with this skill.

CONCLUSIONS

The Brodie-Trendelenburg (tourniquet) test, cough impulse and tap test are outdated but candidates should be aware of the principles and failings behind them. In the MRCS clinical examination, candidates should examine varicose veins by means of clinical examination and HHD as this is now accepted standard practice. To aid candidate education, the HHD technique should replace traditional clinical tests which continue to be taught in medical school and remain within the classical surgical text books.

Service comparison between vascular and general surgery in the treatment of chronic venous insufficiency with special reference to preoperative Doppler techniques

AIMS

To compare the ability of vascular and general surgical services to abolish reflux in superficial venous system with a special reference to preoperative use of Doppler techniques.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

68 lower limbs operated on for venous insufficiency based on either preoperative Duplex evaluation and Doppler marking in a vascular surgical unit (Vascular Surgical Service, VSS: 33 limbs, clinical class C2-C6) or clinical findings in a general surgical unit (General Surgical Service, GSS: 35 limbs, clinical class C2-C4) were re-examined clinically and with duplex scanning for reflux some three years postoperatively.

RESULTS

Marked superficial or perforator vein reflux was observed in 27 of 68 (39.7 %) operated limbs, thirteen of which in VSS and fourteen in GSS. However, axial reflux at saphenofemoral or thigh level was observed significantly less in VSS compared to GSS (3 vs 13, p = 0,006).

CONCLUSION

Total ablation of any reflux appeared difficult irrespective of the preoperative assessment. Preoperative Duplex examination, however, aided in identifying and treating axial reflux at thigh level.

Quality of Life after Surgery for Varicose Veins and the Impact of Preoperative Duplex: Results Based on a Randomized Trial

In a prospective randomized study, we found that the addition of a preoperative duplex scan before varicose vein (VV) surgery reduced recurrences and reoperations after 2 years. The aim of the present study was to investigate whether this correlates with an improved quality of life (QoL). We studied 293 patients scheduled for VV surgery with or without preoperative duplex. QoL was assessed preoperatively at 1 month, 1 year, and 2 years with the Short Form-36 (SF-36). Scores were compared with matched reference groups from the Swedish population. The 237 complete responders (81%) had a mean age of 47 (range 22-73) years, 169 (71%) were women, and 43 (18%) had skin changes. Both groups of VV patients scored significantly worse than the reference group in the domain Bodily Pain preoperatively (p < 0.001) and better after 1 year (p = 0.04), with no difference found after 2 years. There was no significant difference in QoL between the duplex and control groups at any time. We conclude that preoperative duplex before VV surgery did not significantly improve QoL after 2 years in spite of improved surgical results. VV surgery per se improved QoL as measured with the SF-36.

Changes in superficial and perforating vein reflux after varicose vein surgery

OBJECTIVES

This prospective duplex study was conducted to study the effect of current surgical treatment for primary varicose veins on the development of venous insufficiency < or = 2 years after varicose vein surgery.

METHODS

The patients were part of a randomized controlled study where surgery for primary varicose veins was planned from a clinical examination alone or with the addition of preoperative duplex scanning. Postoperative duplex scanning was done at 2 months and 2 years.

RESULTS

Operations were done on 293 patients (343 legs), 74% of whom were women. The mean age was 47 years. In 126 legs, duplex scanning was done preoperatively, at 2 months and 2 years, and at 2 months and 2 years in 251 legs. Preoperative perforating vein incompetence (PVI) was present in 64 of 126 legs. Perforator ligation was not done on 42 of these; at 2 months, 23 of these legs (55%) had no PVI, and at 2 years, 25 legs (60%) had no PVI. Sixty-one legs had no PVI preoperatively, 5 (8%) had PVI at 2 months, and 11 (18%) had PVI at 2 years. In the group of 251 legs, reversal of PVI between 2 months and 2 years was found in 28 (41%) of 68 and was more common than new PVI, which occurred in 41 (22%) of 183 (P = .003). After 2 years, the number of legs without venous incompetence in which perforator surgery was not performed was 11 (26%) of 42 legs with preoperative PVI and 18 (30%) of 61 legs without preoperative PVI, (P = .713). After 2 years, new vessel formation was more common in the surgically obliterated saphenopopliteal junction (SPJ), 4 (40%) of 10, than in the saphenofemoral junction (SFJ), 17 (11%) of 151(P = .027), and new incompetence in a previously normal junction was more common in the SFJ, 11 (18%) of 63, than in the SPJ, 3 (1%) of 226 (P < .001). Reflux in the great saphenous vein (GSV) below the knee was abolished after stripping above the knee in 17 (34%) of 50 legs at 2 months and in 22 legs (44%) after 2 years.

CONCLUSIONS

Varicose vein surgery induces changes in the remaining venous segments of the legs that continue for several months. In most patients, perforators and the GSV below the knee can be ignored at the primary surgery. A substantial number of recurrences in the SFJ and SPJ are unavoidable with present surgical knowledge because they stem from new vessel formation and progression of disease.