Biotinylated phosphoproteins from kinase-catalyzed biotinylation are stable to phosphatases: implications for phosphoproteomics

Kinase-catalyzed Biotinylation for Discovery and Validation of Substrates to Multi-specificity Kinases NME1 and NME2

Protein phosphorylation by kinases regulates mammalian cell functions, such as growth, division, and signal transduction. Among human kinases, NME1 and NME2 are associated with metastatic tumor suppression, but remain understudied due to the lack of tools to monitor their cellular substrates. In particular, NME1 and NME2 are multi-specificity kinases phosphorylating serine, threonine, histidine, and aspartic acid residues of substrate proteins, and the heat and acid sensitivity of phosphohistidine and phosphoaspartate complicates substrate discovery and validation. To provide new substrate monitoring tools, we established the γ-phosphate modified ATP analog, ATP-biotin, as a cosubstrate for phosphorylbiotinylation of NME1 and NME2 cellular substrates. Building upon this ATP-biotin compatibility, the Kinase-catalyzed Biotinylation with Inactivated Lysates for Discovery of Substrates (K-BILDS) method enabled validation of a known substrate and the discovery of seven NME1 and three NME2 substrates. Given the paucity of methods to study kinase substrates, ATP-biotin and the K-BILDS method are valuable tools to characterize the roles of NME1 and NME2 in human cell biology.

Phosphorylation of cell cycle and apoptosis regulatory protein-1 by stress activated protein kinase P38γ is a novel mechanism of apoptosis signaling by genotoxic chemotherapy

CARP-1, a perinuclear phospho-protein, regulates cell survival and apoptosis signaling induced by genotoxic drugs. However, kinase(s) phosphorylating CARP-1 and down-stream signal transduction events remain unclear. Here we find that CARP-1 Serine (S)626 and Threonine (T)627 substitution to Alanines (AA) inhibits genotoxic drug-induced apoptosis. CARP-1 T627 is followed by a Proline (P), and this TP motif is conserved in vertebrates. Based on these findings, we generated affinity-purified, anti-phospho-CARP-1 T627 rabbit polyclonal antibodies, and utilized them to elucidate chemotherapy-activated, CARP-1-dependent cell growth signaling mechanisms. Our kinase profiling studies revealed that MAPKs/SAPKs phosphorylated CARP-1 T627. We then UV cross-linked protein extracts from Adriamycin-treated HeLa cervical cancer cells with a CARP-1 (614-638) peptide, and conducted liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) analyses of the peptide-bound protein complexes. This experiment revealed SAPK p38γ interaction with CARP-1 (614-638) peptide. Our studies further established that SAPK p38γ, but not other MAPKs, phosphorylates CARP-1 T627 in cancer cells treated with genotoxic drugs. Loss of p38γ abrogates CARP-1 T627 phosphorylation, and results in enhanced survival of breast cancer cells by genotoxic drugs. CARP-1 T627 phosphorylation was also noted in breast tumors from patients treated with radiation or endocrine therapies. We conclude that genotoxic drugs activate p38γ-dependent CARP-1 T627 phosphorylation to inhibit cell growth.

Kinase-Catalyzed Biotinylation to Identify Phosphatase Substrates (K-BIPS)

Phosphorylation is a reversible post-translational modification that alters the functions of proteins to govern various cellular events, including cell signaling. Kinases catalyze the transfer of a phosphoryl group onto the hydroxyl residue of serine, threonine, and tyrosine, while phosphatases catalyze the removal. Unregulated kinase and phosphatase activity have been observed in various cancers and neurodegenerative diseases. Despite their importance in cell biology, the role of phosphatases in cellular events has yet to be fully characterized, partly due to the lack of tools to identify phosphatase-substrate pairs in a biological context. The method called kinase-catalyzed biotinylation to identify phosphatase substrates (K-BIPS) was developed to remedy the lack of information surrounding phosphatase biology, particularly focused on substrate identification. In the K-BIPS method, the γ-phosphoryl modified adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP) analog, ATP-biotin, is used by kinases to biotin-label phosphoproteins. Because phosphatases must initially remove a phosphoryl group for subsequent biotinylation by ATP-biotin, phosphatase substrates are identified in K-BIPS by comparing biotinylated proteins in the presence and absence of active phosphatases. K-BIPS has been used to discover novel substrates of both serine/threonine and tyrosine phosphatases. This chapter describes the K-BIPS method to enable the identification of substrates to any phosphatases of interest, which will augment studies of phosphatase biology.

Identification of PP1c-PPP1R12A Substrates Using Kinase-Catalyzed Biotinylation to Identify Phosphatase Substrates

Protein phosphatase 1 regulatory subunit 12A (PPP1R12A) interacts with the catalytic subunit of protein phosphatase 1 (PP1c) to form the myosin phosphatase complex. In addition to a well-documented role in muscle contraction, the PP1c-PPP1R12A complex is associated with cytoskeleton organization, cell migration and adhesion, and insulin signaling. Despite the variety of biological functions, only a few substrates of the PP1c-PPP1R12A complex are characterized, which limit a full understanding of PP1c-PPP1R12A activities in muscle contraction and cytoskeleton regulation. Here, the chemoproteomics method Kinase-catalyzed Biotinylation to Identify Phosphatase Substrates (K-BIPS) was used to identify substrates of the PP1c-PPP1R12A complex in L6 skeletal muscle cells. K-BIPS enriched 136 candidate substrates with 14 high confidence hits. One high confidence hit, AKT1 kinase, was validated as a novel PP1c-PPP1R12A substrate. Given the previously documented role of AKT1 in PPP1R12A phosphorylation and cytoskeleton organization, the data suggest that PP1c-PPP1R12A regulates its own phosphatase activity through an AKT1-dependent feedback mechanism to influence cytoskeletal arrangement in muscle cells.

Kinase-catalyzed Biotinylation with Inactivated Lysates for Discovery of Substrates (K-BILDS)

Protein phosphorylation is catalyzed by kinases to regulate a large variety of cellular activities, including growth and signal transduction. Methods to identify kinase substrates are crucial to fully understand phosphorylation-mediated cellular events and disease states. Here, we report a set of protocols to identify substrates of a target kinase using Kinase-catalyzed Biotinylation with Inactivated Lysates for Discovery of Substrates (K-BILDS). As described in these protocols, K-BILDS involves inactivation of endogenous kinases in lysates, followed by addition of an active exogenous kinase and the γ-phosphate-modified ATP analog ATP-biotin for kinase-catalyzed biotinylation of cellular substrates. Avidin enrichment isolates biotinylated substrates of the active kinase, which can be monitored by western blot. Substrates of the target kinase can also be discovered using mass spectrometry analysis. Key advantages of K-BILDS include compatibility with any lysate, tissue homogenate, or complex mixture of biological relevance and any active kinase of interest. K-BILDS is a versatile method for studying or discovering substrates of a kinase of interest to characterize biological pathways thoroughly. © 2023 Wiley Periodicals LLC. Basic Protocol 1: FSBA treatment of lysates to inactivate kinases Basic Protocol 2: Kinase-catalyzed Biotinylation with Inactivated Lysates for Discovery of Substrates (K-BILDS).

Analysis of protein phosphorylation combining capillary electrophoresis with ATP analog labeling technique

Protein phosphorylation is one of the most basic mechanisms for regulating and controlling protein biological activity and function, and it is also a very important posttranslational modification process. Protein phosphorylation participates in and regulates many life activities such as signal transduction, gene expression, cell cycle, and so on. In this paper, we propose a method for the determination of the protein phosphorylation combining capillary electrophoresis (CE) with ATP analog labeling technique. We synthesized two new ATP analogs (ATP-NB and ATP-TATD-NB) functionalized by norbornene. Using Abl kinase as a model, we established a method for the determination of the kinase activity in solution and lysate by CE with laser-induced fluorescence detection (CE-LIF). This method was used to evaluate the efficiencies of kinase inhibitors. The IC₅₀ values obtained are basically consistent with the reports. By D-A reaction (inverse electron demand Diels-Alder reaction) to label TZ-BODIPY fluorescence, we also realized the phosphorylation fluorescence detection of substrate peptide. Then, we used fluorescence confocal microscopy imaging technology to study the phosphorylation of proteins in vivo by the D-A reaction of ATP-NB and TZ-BODIPY. Our preliminary results documented that the combination of CE-LIF with analog ATP-NB labeling technique is an effective strategy for the determination of the protein phosphorylation and the kinase activity and for screening of kinase inhibitors. The D-A reaction of ATP-NB and TZ-BODIPY also laid the foundation for the subsequent in situ study of protein phosphorylation.

Kinase-Catalyzed Biotinylation to Map Cell Signaling Pathways: Application to Epidermal Growth Factor Signaling

Cell signaling involves a network of protein-protein interactions and post-translational modifications that govern cellular responses to environmental cues. To understand and ultimately modulate these signaling pathways to confront disease, the complex web of proteins that becomes phosphorylated after extracellular stimulation has been studied using mass spectrometry-based proteomics methods. To complement prior work and fully characterize all phosphorylated proteins after the stimulation of cell signaling, we developed K-BMAPS (kinase-catalyzed biotinylation to map signaling), which utilizes ATP-biotin as a kinase cosubstrate to biotin label substrates. As a first application of the K-BMAPS method, the well-characterized epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) kinase signaling pathway was monitored by treating epidermal growth factor (EGF)-stimulated HeLa lysates with ATP-biotin, followed by streptavidin enrichment and quantitative mass spectrometry analysis. On the basis of the dynamic phosphoproteins identified, a pathway map was developed considering functional categories and known interactors of EGFR. Remarkably, 94% of the K-BMAPS hit proteins were included in the EGFR pathway map. With many proteins involved in transcription, translation, cell adhesion, and GTPase signaling, K-BMAPS identified phosphoproteins were associated with late and continuous signaling events. In summary, the K-BMAPS method is a powerful tool to map the dynamic phosphorylation governing cell signaling pathways.

l-Lactate Dehydrogenase Identified as a Protein Tyrosine Phosphatase 1B Substrate by Using K-BIPS

Kinases and phosphatases are major players in a variety of cellular events, including cell signaling. Aberrant activity or mutations in kinases and phosphatases can lead to diseases such as cancer, diabetes, and Alzheimer's. Compared to kinases, phosphatases are understudied; this is partly a result of the limited methods for identifying substrates. As a solution, we developed a proteomics-based method called kinase-catalyzed biotinylation to identify phosphatase substrates (K-BIPS) that previously identified substrates of Ser/Thr phosphatases using small molecule inhibitors. Here, for the first time, K-BIPS was applied to identify substrates of a tyrosine phosphatase, protein tyrosine phosphatase 1B (PTP1B), under siRNA knockdown conditions. Eight possible substrates of PTP1B were discovered in HEK293 cells, including the known substrate pyruvate kinase. In addition, l-lactate dehydrogenase (LDHA) was validated as a novel PTP1B substrate. With the ability to use knockdown conditions with Ser/Thr or Tyr phosphatases, K-BIPS represents a general discovery tool to explore phosphatases biology by identifying unanticipated substrates.

Chitosan-assisted permeabilization of ATP-biotin for live cell kinase-catalyzed biotinylation

Kinases are essential cell signaling enzymes that phosphorylate protein substrates using ATP as the universal cosubstrate. A wide variety of ATP analogs have been used in kinase research, although the studies are limited by the cell impermeability of ATP. Here we describe the use of the cationic polymer deacetylated chitosan to permeabilize ATP analogs for live cell applications, including kinase-catalyzed biotinylation.

Identification of PP1-Gadd34 substrates involved in the unfolded protein response using K-BIPS, a method for phosphatase substrate identification

Phosphorylation is a key post-translational modification in cell signaling, which is regulated by the equilibrium activities of kinases and phosphatases. The biological significance of many phosphorylation events remains poorly characterized due to the scarcity of tools to discover phosphatases substrates. In prior work, we established kinase-catalyzed biotinylation where kinases accept the γ-modified ATP analog, ATP-biotin, to label phosphoproteins. Here, we developed a novel method to study substrates of phosphatases using kinase-catalyzed biotinylation termed K-BIPS (Kinase-catalyzed Biotinylation to Identify Phosphatase Substrates). In a proof-of-concept experiment, K-BIPS was initially used to explore the substrates of phosphatases inhibited by okadaic acid. Many known phosphatase substrates were observed, confirming K-BIPS as a valid phosphatase substrate identification tool. Then, as a further application, K-BIPS was used to discover the substrates of the PP1-Gadd34 phosphatase complex in the context of unfolded protein response (UPR). In addition to the known substrate eIF2α, K-BIPS revealed several novel substrates, suggesting a more prominent role for the PP1-Gadd34 complex in UPR than previously appreciated. Overall, the two studies establish K-BIPS as a powerful tool to discover the cellular substrates of phosphatases.

Phosphate-Modified Nucleotides for Monitoring Enzyme Activity

Nucleotides modified at the terminal phosphate position have been proven to be interesting entities to study the activity of a variety of different protein classes. In this chapter, we present various types of modifications that were attached as reporter molecules to the phosphate chain of nucleotides and briefly describe the chemical reactions that are frequently used to synthesize them. Furthermore, we discuss a variety of applications of these molecules. Kinase activity, for instance, was studied by transfer of a phosphate modified with a reporter group to the target proteins. This allows not only studying the activity of kinases, but also identifying their target proteins. Moreover, kinases can also be directly labeled with a reporter at a conserved lysine using acyl-phosphate probes. Another important application for phosphate-modified nucleotides is the study of RNA and DNA polymerases. In this context, single-molecule sequencing is made possible using detection in zero-mode waveguides, nanopores or by a Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based mechanism between the polymerase and a fluorophore-labeled nucleotide. Additionally, fluorogenic nucleotides that utilize an intramolecular interaction between a fluorophore and the nucleobase or an intramolecular FRET effect have been successfully developed to study a variety of different enzymes. Finally, also some novel techniques applying electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR)-based detection of nucleotide cleavage or the detection of the cleavage of fluorophosphates are discussed. Taken together, nucleotides modified at the terminal phosphate position have been applied to study the activity of a large diversity of proteins and are valuable tools to enhance the knowledge of biological systems.

K-BILDS: A Kinase Substrate Discovery Tool

Kinases catalyze protein phosphorylation to regulate cell signaling events. However, identifying kinase substrates is challenging due to the often low abundance and dynamic nature of protein phosphorylation. Development of novel techniques to identify kinase substrates is necessary. Here, we report kinase-catalyzed biotinylation with inactivated lysates for discovery of substrates (K-BILDS) as a tool to identify direct substrates of a kinase. As a proof of concept, K-BILDS was applied to cAMP-dependent protein kinase A (PKA) with HeLa cell lysates. Subsequent enrichment and MS/MS analysis identified 279 candidate PKA substrates, including 56 previously known PKA substrates. Of the candidate substrates, nuclear autoantigenic sperm protein (NASP), BCL2-associated athanogene 3 (BAG3), and 14-3-3 protein Tau (YWHAQ) were validated as novel PKA substrates. K-BILDS provides a valuable tool to identify direct substrates of any protein kinase.

The generality of kinase-catalyzed biotinylation

Kinase-catalyzed protein phosphorylation is involved in a wide variety of cellular events. Development of methods to monitor phosphoproteins in normal and diseased states is critical to fully characterize cell signaling. Towards phosphoprotein analysis tools, our lab reported kinase-catalyzed labeling where γ-phosphate modified ATP analogs are utilized by kinases to label peptides or protein substrates with a functional tag. In particular, the ATP-biotin analog was developed for kinase-catalyzed biotinylation. However, kinase-catalyzed labeling has been tested rigorously with only a few kinases, preventing use of ATP-biotin as a general tool. Here, biotinylation experiments, gel or HPLC-based quantification, and kinetic measurements indicated that twenty-five kinases throughout the kinome tree accepted ATP-biotin as a cosubstrate. With this rigorous characterization of ATP-biotin compatibility, kinase-catalyzed labeling is now immediately useful for studying phosphoproteins and characterizing the role of phosphorylation in various biological events.

A Cell-Permeable ATP Analogue for Kinase-Catalyzed Biotinylation

ATP analogues have been powerful compounds for the study of kinase-catalyzed phosphorylation. However, the cell impermeability of ATP analogues has largely limited their use to in vitro lysate-based experiments. Herein, we report the first cell-permeable ATP analogue, ATP-polyamine-biotin (APB). APB is shown to promote biotin labeling of kinase substrates in live cells and has future applications in phosphoprotein purification and analysis. More generally, these studies provide a foundation for the development of additional cell-permeable ATP analogues for cell-signaling research.

Thiol-ene enabled detection of thiophosphorylated kinase substrates

Protein phosphorylation is a ubiquitous posttranslational modification that regulates cell signaling in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Although the study of phosphorylation has made great progress, several major hurdles remain, including the difficulty of the assignment of endogenous substrates to a discrete kinase and of global phosphoproteomics investigations. We have developed a novel chemical strategy for detecting phosphorylated proteins. This method utilizes adenosine 5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate) (ATPγS), which results in the transfer of a thiophosphate moiety by a kinase to its substrate(s). This group can subsequently be employed as a nucleophilic handle to promote protein detection. To selectively label thiophosphorylated proteins, cellular thiols (e.g., cysteine-containing proteins) must first be blocked. Most common cysteine-capping strategies rely upon the nucleophilicity of the sulfur group and would therefore also modify the thiophosphate moiety. We hypothesized that the radical-mediated thiol-ene reaction, however, would be selective for cysteine over thiophosphorylated amino acids due to the differences in the electronics and pKa values between these groups. Here, we report rapid and specific tagging of thiophosphorylated proteins in vitro following chemoselective thiol capping using the thiol-ene reaction.