Probe-Molecule-Assisted NMR Spectroscopy: A Comparison with Photoluminescence and Electron Paramagnetic Resonance Spectroscopy as a Characterization Tool in Facet-Specific Photocatalysis

Spatially Decoupled H2O2 Activation Pathways and Multi-Enzyme Activities in Rod-Shaped CeO2 with Implications for Facet Distribution

CeO2, particularly in the shape of rod, has recently gained considerable attention for its ability to mimic peroxidase (POD) and haloperoxidase (HPO). However, this multi-enzyme activities unavoidably compete for H2O2 affecting its performance in relevant applications. The lack of consensus on facet distribution in rod-shaped CeO2 further complicates the establishment of structure-activity correlations, presenting challenges for progress in the field. In this study, the HPO-like activity of rod-shaped CeO2 is successfully enhanced while maintaining its POD-like activity through a facile post-calcination method. By studying the spatial distribution of these two activities and their exclusive H2O2 activation pathways on CeO2 surfaces, this study finds that the increased HPO-like activity originated from the newly exposed (111) surface at the tip of the shortened rods after calcination, while the unchanged POD-like activity is attributed to the retained (110) surface in their lateral area. These findings not only address facet distribution discrepancies commonly reported in the literature for rod-shaped CeO2 but also offer a simple approach to enhance its antibacterial performance. This work is expected to provide atomic insights into catalytic correlations and guide the design of nanozymes with improved activity and reaction specificity.

Regulating the H2O2 Activation Pathway on a Well-Defined CeO2 Nanozyme Allows the Entire Steering of Its Specificity between Associated Enzymatic Reactions

Nanozymes are promising alternatives to natural enzymes, but their use remains limited owing to poor specificity. For example, CeO2 activates H2O2 and displays peroxidase (POD)-like, catalase (CAT)-like, and haloperoxidase (HPO)-like activities. Since they unavoidably compete for H2O2, affecting its utilization in the target application, the precise manipulation of reaction specificity is thus imperative. Herein, we showed that one can simply achieve this by manipulating the H2O2 activation pathway on pristine CeO2 in well-defined shapes. This is because the coordination and electronic structures of Ce sites vary with CeO2 surfaces, wherein the (100) and (111) surfaces display nearly 100% specificity toward POD-/CAT-like and HPO-like activities, respectively. The antibacterial results suggest that the latter surface can well-utilize H2O2 to kill bacteria (cf., the former), which is promising for anti-biofouling applications. This work provides atomic insights into the synthesis of nanozymes with improved activity, reaction specificity, and H2O2 utilization.

Defect engineering of oxide surfaces: dream or reality?

In this brief perspective we analyze the present status of the field of defect engineering of oxide surfaces. In particular we discuss the tools and techniques available to generate, identify, quantify, and characterize point defects at oxide surfaces and the main areas where these centers play a role in practical applications.

Assessment of Lewis-Acidic Surface Sites Using Tetrahydrofuran as a Suitable and Smart Probe Molecule

Measuring the Lewis‐acidic surface sites in catalysis is problematic when the material‘s surface area is very low (S_BET ≤1 m² ⋅ g⁻¹). For the first time, a quantitative assessment of total acidic surface sites of very small surface area catalysts (MoO₃ as pure and mixed with 5–30 % CdO (wt/wt), as well as CdO for comparison) was performed using a smart new probe molecule, tetrahydrofuran (THF). The results were nearly identical compared to using another commonly used probe molecule, pyridine. This audition is based on the limited values of the surface area of these samples that likely require a relatively moderate basic molecule as THF with pK_b=16.08, rather than strong basic molecules such as NH₃ (pK_b=4.75) or pyridine (pK_b=8.77). We propose mechanisms for the interaction of vapour phase molecules of THF with the Lewis‐cationic Mo and Cd atoms of these catalysts. Besides, dehydration of isopropyl alcohol was used as a probe reaction to investigate the catalytic activity of these catalysts to further support our findings in the case of THF in a temperature range of 175–300 °C. A good agreement between the obtained data of sample MoO₃‐10 % CdO, which is characterised by the highest surface area value, the population of Lewis‐acidic sites and % selectivity of propylene at all the applied reaction temperatures was found.

Unusual Catalytic Properties of High-Energetic-Facet Polar Metal Oxides

ConspectusHeterogeneous catalysis is an area of great importance not only in chemical industries but also in energy conversion and environmental technologies. It is well-established that the specific surface morphology and structure of solid catalysts exert remarkable effects on catalytic performances, since most physical and chemical processes take place on the surface during catalytic reactions. Different from the widely studied faceted metallic nanoparticles, metal oxides give more complicated structures and surface features. Great progress has been achieved in controlling the shape and exposed facets of transition metal oxides during nanocrystal growth, usually by using surface-directing agents (SDAs). However, the effects of exposed facets remain controversial among researchers. It should be noted that high-energetic facets, especially polar facets, tend to lower their surface energy via different relaxation processes, such as surface reconstruction, redox change, adsorption of countercharged species, etc. These processes can subsequently lead to surface defect formation and break the surface stoichiometry, and the resulting changes in electronic configurations and charge migration properties all play important roles in heterogeneous catalysis. Because different materials prefer different relaxation methods, various surface features are created, and different techniques are required to investigate the different features from facet to facet. Conventional characterization techniques such as X-ray diffraction, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, transmission electron microscopy, etc. appear to be insufficient to elucidate the underlying principles of the facet effects. Consequently, an increasing number of novel techniques have been developed to differentiate the surface features, enabling greater understanding of the effects of facets on heterogeneous catalysis.In this Account, on the basis of previous studies by our own group, we will focus on the effects of tailored facets on heterogeneous catalysis introduced by engineered simple binary metal oxide nanomaterials primarily with exposed polar facets, in combination with detailed surface studies using a range of new characterization techniques. As a result, fundamental principles of the effects of facets are elucidated, and the structure-activity correlations are demonstrated. The surface features introduced by different relaxation processes are also investigated using a range of characterization techniques. For example, electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy is used to detect the oxygen vacancies, while probe-assisted solid-state NMR spectroscopy is shown to be facet-sensitive and able to evaluate the surface acidity. It is also shown that such different features influence the heterogeneous catalytic performances in different ways. With the help of first-principles density functional theory calculations, unique properties of the faceted metal oxides are discussed and unraveled. Besides, other materials such as transition metal chalcogenides and layered double hydroxides are also briefly discussed with regard to their application in facet-dependent catalysis studies.

Nanoisozymes: The Origin behind Pristine CeO2 as Enzyme Mimetics

It is known that the interplay between molecules and active sites on the topmost surface of a solid catalyst determines its activity in heterogeneous catalysis. The electron density of the active site is believed to affect both adsorption and activation of reactant molecules at the surface. Unfortunately, commercial X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, which is often adopted for such characterization, is not sensitive enough to analyze the topmost surface of a catalyst. Most researchers fail to acknowledge this point during their catalytic correlation, leading to different interpretations in the literature in recent decades. Recent studies on pristine Cu₂ O [Nat. Catal. 2019, 2, 889; Nat. Energy 2019, 4, 957] have clearly suggested that the electron density of surface Cu is facet dependent and plays a key role in CO₂ reduction. Herein, it is shown that pristine CeO₂ can reach 2506/1133 % increase in phosphatase-/peroxidase-like activity if the exposed surface is wisely selected. By using NMR spectroscopy with a surface probe, the electron density of the surface Ce (i.e., the active site) is found to be facet dependent and the key factor dictating their enzyme-mimicking activities. Most importantly, the surface area of the CeO₂ morphologies is demonstrated to become a factor only if surface Ce can activate the adsorbed reactant molecules.

Unravelling the Role of Structural Geometry and Chemical State of Well-Defined Oxygen Vacancies on Pristine CeO2 for H2O2 Activation

Although H₂O₂ has been often employed as a green oxidant for many CeO₂-catalyzed reactions, the underlying principle of its activation by surface oxygen vacancy (V_o) is still elusive due to the irreversible removal of postgenerated V_o by water (or H₂O₂). The metastable V_o (ms-V_o) naturally preserved on pristine CeO₂ surfaces was adopted herein for an in-depth study of their interplay with H₂O₂. Their well-defined local structures and chemical states were found facet-dependent affecting both the adsorption and subsequent activation of H₂O₂. It is concluded that a strong adsorption of H₂O₂ on ms-V_o may not guarantee its subsequent activation. The ms-V_o can be only free for the next catalytic cycle when the electron density of surface Ce is high enough to reduce/break the O-O bond of adsorbed H₂O₂. This explains the 211.8 and 35.8 times enhancement in H₂O₂ reactivity when the CeO₂ surface is changed from (111) and (110) to (100).

Unravelling the key role of surface features behind facet-dependent photocatalysis of anatase TiO2

The high activity of the anatase TiO₂(001) facet in photocatalytic H₂ evolution is due to local electronic effects created by surface F on the facet.

Differentiating surface titanium chemical states of anatase TiO2 functionalized with various groups

The local electronic effects on surface Ti, caused by adsorbates on TiO₂ facets, are probed experimentally (using probe-assisted NMR spectroscopy) and theoretically (using DFT).

As the chemical state of titanium on the surface of TiO₂ can be tuned by varying its host facet and surface adsorbate, improved performance has been achieved in fields such as heterogeneous (photo)catalysis, lithium batteries, dye-sensitized solar cells, etc. However, at present, no acceptable surface technique can provide information about the chemical state and distribution of surface cations among facets, making it difficult to unambiguously correlate facet-dependent properties. Even though X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) is regarded as a sensitive surface technique, it collects data from the top few layers of the sample, instead of a specific facet, and hence fails to distinguish small changes in the chemical state of Ti imposed by adsorbates on a facet. Herein, based on experimental (chemical probe-assisted NMR) and theoretical (DFT) studies, the true surface Ti chemical states associated with surface modification using –O–, –F, –OH and –SO₄ functional groups on the (001) and (101) facets of anatase TiO₂ are clearly distinguished. It is also demonstrated, for the first time, that the local electronic effects on surface Ti imposed by adsorbates vary depending on the facet, due to different intrinsic electronic structures.

Mapping surface-modified titania nanoparticles with implications for activity and facet control

The use of surface-directing species and surface additives to alter nanoparticle morphology and physicochemical properties of particular exposed facets has recently been attracting significant attention. However, challenges in their chemical analysis, sometimes at trace levels, and understanding their roles to elucidate surface structure–activity relationships in optical (solar cells) or (photo)catalytic performance and their removal are significant issues that remain to be solved. Here, we show a detailed analysis of TiO₂ facets promoted with surface species (OH, O, SO₄, F) with and without post-treatments by ³¹P adsorbate nuclear magnetic resonance, supported by a range of other characterization tools. We demonstrate that quantitative evaluations of the electronic and structural effects imposed by these surface additives and their removal mechanisms can be obtained, which may lead to the rational control of active TiO₂ (001) and (101) facets for a range of applications.

Metal oxide nanocrystals can be grown with different facets exposed to give variations in reactivity, but the chemical state of these surfaces is not clear. Here, the authors make use of a phosphine probe molecule allowing the differences in surface chemistry to be mapped by NMR spectroscopy.