Tetrahedrane—Dossier of an Unknown

Bridging the gap: viable reaction pathways from tetrahedrane to benzyne

The addition of sp-carbon-containing molecules to polycyclic sp3 tetrahedrane (c-C4H4) results in the formation of both o-benzyne (c-C6H4) and benzene (c-C6H6). Since both c-C6H4 and c-C6H6 have been detected in the interstellar medium (ISM), providing additional pathways for their possible astrochemical formation mechanisms can lead to the discovery of other molecules, such as c-C4H4, benzvalyne, and vinylidene (:CCH2). Addition of diatomic carbon (C2), the ethynyl radical (C2H), vinylidene, and acetylene (HCCH) to c-C4H4 is undertaken in individual pathways through high-level quantum chemical computations at the CCSD(T)-F12b/cc-pVTZ-F12 level of theory. The resulting C2 addition pathway proceeds barrierlessly through benzvalyne as an intermediate and reaches a true minimum at c-C6H4, but no leaving groups are produced which is required to dissipate excess energy within an interstellar chemical scheme. Similarly, the C2H addition to c-C4H4 produces benzvalyne as well as its related isomers. This pathway allows for the loss of a hydrogen leaving group to dissipate the resulting energy. Lastly, the HCCH and :CCH2 addition pathways follow through both benzvalene and benzvalyne in order to reach c-C6H6 (benzene) and c-C6H4 (o-benzyne) as well as H2 as the required leaving group. Although there is a barrier to the HCCH addition, the :CCH2 addition presents the contrary with only submerged barriers. These proposed mechanisms provide alternative possibilities for the formation of complex organic molecules in space.

Bottom-Up Formation of Antiaromatic Cyclobutadiene (c-C4H4) in Interstellar Ice Analogs

Antiaromatic cyclobutadiene (c-C4H4) is the simplest prototype of [n]annulenes and a key reactive intermediate with significant ring strain, serving as the model compound for antiaromatic systems in organic chemistry. Here, we report the first bottom-up formation of cyclobutadiene in low-temperature acetylene (C2H2) ices exposed to energetic electrons. Cyclobutadiene was isolated and detected in the gas phase upon sublimation utilizing vacuum ultraviolet photoionization reflectron time-of-flight mass spectrometry along with ultraviolet photolysis studies. These findings advance our fundamental understanding of the exotic chemistry and preparation of highly strained antiaromatic cycles through non-equilibrium chemistry in interstellar environments, thus affording a possible route for the formation of highly strained molecules such as the hitherto elusive tetrahedrane (C4H4). Because acetylene is a major product of the photolysis and radiolysis of methane (CH4) ice, an abundant component of interstellar ices, our results suggest that cyclobutadiene can likely be formed in methane-rich ices of cold molecular clouds.

Molecular pyramids - from tetrahedranes to [6]pyramidanes

The study of 3D architectures at a molecular scale has fascinated chemists for generations. This includes molecular pyramids with all-carbon frameworks, such as trigonal, tetragonal and pentagonal pyramidal geometries. A small number of substituted tetrahedranes and all-carbon [4]-[5]pyramidanes have been experimentally generated and studied. Although the hypothetical unsubstituted parent [3]-[6]pyramidanes have only been explored computationally, the formal replacement of carbon vertices with isolobal main group element fragments has provided a number of examples of stable hetero[m]pyramidanes, which have been isolated and amply characterized. In this Review, we highlight the synthesis and chemical properties of [3]-[6]pyramidanes and summarize the progress in the development of chemistry of pyramid-shaped molecules.

Carbene Routes to Cyclopropatetrahedrane

The formation of cyclopropatetrahedrane (tetracyclo[2.1.0.01,3.02,4]pentane) via four different carbene reactions is computed using the (U)CCSD(T)(full)/cc-pVTZ//(U)ωB97X-D/cc-pVTZ + 1.3686(EZPVE) theoretical model. Intrinsic reaction coordinate plots confirm that each carbene is directly linked to cyclopropatetrahedrane via a unique cyclopropanation step. Each elementary step is assessed according to the structure and energy of its transition state.

Polycyclic Aliphatic Hydrocarbons: Is Tetrahedrane Present in UIR Spectra?

The smallest Platonic hydrocarbon, tetrahedrane, has been subject to frequent theoretical and experimental study for 50 years, but its infrared spectrum and synthetic pathway remain a mystery. The recent partial...

Alleviating Strain in Organic Molecules by Incorporation of Phosphorus: Synthesis of Triphosphatetrahedrane

Phosphatetrahedranes (^tBuCP)₂ and (^tBuC)₃P were recently reported and represent the first tetrahedranes containing a mixed carbon/phosphorus core. Herein, we report that tetrahydrofuran (THF) solutions of the parent triphosphatetrahedrane HCP₃ may be generated in 31% yield (NMR internal standard yield) by combining [Na(THF)₃][P₃Nb(ODipp)₃] (Dipp = 2,6-diisopropylphenyl), INb(ODipp)₃(THF), and bromodichloromethane in thawing THF. While HCP₃ was found to be stable in dilute THF solutions for extended periods of time, the concentration of the solution at -40 °C led to the formation of a black precipitate, which has been tentatively assigned as a polymerized form of HCP₃. HCP₃ reacts readily with (dppe)Fe(Cp*)Cl (dppe = 1,2-bis(diphenylphosphino)ethane, Cp*= η⁵-C₅Me₅) in the presence of Na[BPh₄] to form a purple cationic iron complex of triphosphatetrahedrane (50% yield), which was structurally characterized in a single-crystal X-ray diffraction experiment. Additionally, we present a series of homodesmotic equations analyzed via quantum chemical calculations that suggest triphosphatetrahedrane is the least strained of the mixed C/P phosphatetrahedranes.

Highly Strained Pn(CH)3 (Pn = N, P, As, Sb, Bi) Tetrahedranes: Theoretical Characterization

Recent experimental research by Cummins and co-workers has established the existence of a tetrahedrane molecule with one CH moiety replaced by phosphorus. We present here the first theoretical studies of the entire Pn(CH)₃ (Pn = N, P, As, Sb, Bi) class of molecules. Geometries are obtained at the highly reliable CCSD(T)/aug-cc-pwCVTZ(-PP) level of theory. Harmonic vibrational frequencies are determined and analyzed to confirm the nature of each stationary point and provide helpful findings that may aid in the detection of each species. Most notable is the result that the geometric parameters associated with the (CH)₃ moiety in the tetrahedranes exhibit little change under pnictogen substitution, while the Pn-C bonds and C-Pn-C bond angles greatly increase and decrease, respectively. Strain energies are predicted and range from 122.3 kcal mol^-1 (N(CH)₃) to 99.4 kcal mol^-1 (Bi(CH)₃) at the DF-CCSD(T)//B3LYP-D3/aug-cc-pV(T+d)Z(-PP) level of theory. The obtained geometries are further analyzed with Natural Bond Orbital (NBO) methods to understand the bonding and electronic structure of each species. We also provide insight into how different substituents can help make the tetrahedrane structure more energetically favorable due to electron delocalization into substituent antibonding orbitals. The effect of additional delocalization also weakens the Pn-C bonds, especially for the heavier pnictogens. This work concludes with a list of considerations that summarize our key findings and motivate future work aimed at producing novel pnictogen-substituted tetrahedrane molecules.

Mixed Phosphatetrahedranes

P-yramids: Tetrahedranes are highly strained molecules, and the all-carbon (CtBu)₄ and all-phosphorus species P₄ have been known for decades and centuries, respectively. Despite this, the mixed P/C tetrahedranes were unknown until recently when the syntheses of the phosphatetrahedranes P(CtBu)₃ and P₂ (CtBu)₂ were reported by the research groups of Cummins and Wolf.

Isolation of an elusive phosphatetrahedrane

This exploratory synthesis investigation was undertaken to determine the viability of replacing a single carbon vertex with another p-block element in a highly strained tetrahedrane molecule. Phosphorus was selected for this purpose because the stable molecular form of elemental phosphorus is tetrahedral. Our synthetic strategy was to generate an unsaturated phosphorus center bonded to a substituted cyclopropenyl group, a situation that could lead to closure to provide the desired phosphatetrahedrane framework. This was accomplished by dehydrofluorination of the in situ generated fluorophosphine H(F)P(C ^t Bu)₃. Tri-tert-butyl phosphatetrahedrane, P(C ^t Bu)₃, was then isolated in 19% yield as a low-melting, volatile, colorless solid and characterized spectroscopically and by a single-crystal x-ray diffraction study, confirming the tetrahedral nature of the molecule's PC₃ core. The molecule exhibits unexpected thermal stability.

Di-tert-butyldiphosphatetrahedrane: Catalytic Synthesis of the Elusive Phosphaalkyne Dimer

While tetrahedranes as a family are scarce, neutral heteroatomic species are all but unknown, with the only reported example being AsP₃. Herein, we describe the isolation of a neutral heteroatomic X₂Y₂ molecular tetrahedron (X, Y=p‐block elements), which also is the long‐sought‐after free phosphaalkyne dimer. Di‐tert‐butyldiphosphatetrahedrane, (tBuCP)₂, is formed from the monomer tBuCP in a nickel‐catalyzed dimerization reaction using [(NHC)Ni(CO)₃] (NHC=1,3‐bis(2,4,6‐trimethylphenyl)imidazolin‐2‐ylidene (IMes) and 1,3‐bis(2,6‐diisopropylphenyl)imidazolin‐2‐ylidene (IPr)). Single‐crystal X‐ray structure determination of a silver(I) complex confirms the structure of (tBuCP)₂. The influence of the N‐heterocyclic carbene ligand on the catalytic reaction was investigated, and a mechanism was elucidated using a combination of synthetic and kinetic studies and quantum chemical calculations.

Validation of the recently developed aromaticity index D3BIA for benzenoid systems. Case study: acenes

There are four types of aromaticity criteria: energetic, electronic, magnetic and geometric. The delocalization, density and degeneracy-based index of aromaticity, D3BIA, is an electronic aromaticity index from QTAIM that is not reference dependent and can be used for aromatic, homoaromatic, sigma aromatic and other aromatic systems with varying ring size containing hetereoatoms or not. We used B3LYP, MP2 and MP3 methods to search for linear relations between well-known aromaticity indices and D3BIA for a series of acenes. We found that the D3BIA versus FLU correlation exceeded 91 % and reasonably good correlations exist between D3BIA and HOMA and between D3BIA and PDI. Previous works have shown that D3BIA can be used for homoaromatic systems and tetrahedrane derivatives (sigma aromaticity), but no previous work has validated D3BIA for benzenoid systems. This is the first time we have shown that D3BIA can be used successfully for benzenoid systems, for example, acenes. This work supports and validates the use of D3BIA in classical aromatic systems.

Photoisomerization of silyl-substituted cyclobutadiene induced by σ → π* excitation: a computational study

Photoinduced chemical processes upon Franck-Condon (FC) excitation in tetrakis(trimethylsilyl)-cyclobutadiene (TMS-CBD) have been investigated through the exploration of potential energy surface crossings among several low-lying excited states using the complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) method. Vertical excitation energies are also computed with the equation-of-motion coupled-cluster model with single and double excitations (EOM-CCSD) as well as the multireference Møller-Plesset (MRMP) methods. Upon finding an excellent coincidence between the computational results and experimental observations, it is suggested that the Franck-Condon excited state does not correspond to the first π-π* single excitation state (S1, 1(1)B1 state in terms of D2 symmetry), but to the second (1)B1 state (S3), which is characterized as a σ-π* single excitation state. Starting from the Franck-Condon region, a series of conical intersections (CIs) are located along one isomerization channel and one dissociation channel. Through the isomerization channel, TMS-CBD is transformed to tetrakis(trimethylsilyl)-tetrahedrane (TMS-THD), and this isomerization process could take place by passing through a "tetra form" conical intersection. On the other hand, the dissociation channel yielding two bis(trimethylsilyl)-acetylene (TMS-Ac) molecules through further stretching of the longer C-C bonds might be more competitive than the isomerization channel after excitation into S3 state. This mechanistic picture is in good agreement with recently reported experimental observations.

Experimental and theoretical studies into the formation of C4-C6 products in partially chlorinated hydrocarbon pyrolysis systems: a probabilistic approach to congener-specific yield predictions

This work presents a study of the pyrolytic formation of vinylacetylene and benzene congeners formed from chlorinated hydrocarbon precursors, a complex, multipath polymerization system formed in a monomer-rich environment. (Co-)pyrolyses of dichloro- and trichloroethylene yield a rich array of products, and assuming a single dominant underlying growth mechanism, this (on comparing expected and observed products) allows a number of potentially competing channels to C4 and C6 products to be ruled out. Poor congener/isomer descriptions rule out even-carbon radical routes, and the absence of C3 and C5 products rule out odd-carbon processes. Vinylidenes appear unable to describe the increased reactivity of acetylenes with chlorination noted in our experiments, leaving molecular acetylene dimerization processes and, in C6 systems, the closely related Diels-Alder cyclization as the likely reaction mechanism. The feasibility of these routes is further supported by ab initio calculations. However, some of the most persuasive evidence is provided by congener-specific yield predictions enabled by the construction of a probability tree analogue of kinetic modeling. This approach is relatively quick to construct, provides surprisingly accurate predictions, and may be a very useful tool in screening for important reaction channels in poorly understood congener- or isomer-rich reaction systems.

A constrained disorder refinement: "Reinvestigation of "Single-crystal X-ray structure of 1,3-dimethylcyclobutadiene" by M. Shatruk and I. V. Alabugin"

Shatruk and Alabugin propose an alternative structural model for the observed electron density that we have attributed to the photochemical formation of 1,3-dimethylcyclobutadiene in a protective solid crystalline matrix. The main criticism from Shatruk and Alabugin concerns the modeling of the disorder in the calixarene cavity and in particular the neglect of a residual electron density close to the O1 atom. We published (Chem. Eur. J. 2011, 17, 10021) our opinion concerning this "ignored peak" in the Supporting Information of the paper. The current response to the Correspondence demonstrates that Shatruk and Alabugin have over-modeled our data by assigning a small electron density peak, which is hardly more than the density corresponding to a hydrogen atom, to an under-occupied oxygen site, using inappropriate refinement contraints.