Thio effects on the departure of the 3'-linked ribonucleoside from diribonucleoside 3',3'-phosphorodithioate diesters and triribonucleoside 3',3',5'-phosphoromonothioate triesters: implications for ribozyme catalysis

Structural modifications as tools in mechanistic studies of the cleavage of RNA phosphodiester linkages

The cleavage of RNA phosphodiester bonds by RNase A and hammerhead ribozyme at neutral pH fundamentally differs from the spontaneous reactions of these bonds under the same conditions. While the predominant spontaneous reaction is isomerization of the 3',5'-phosphodiester linkages to their 2',5'-counterparts, this reaction has never been reported to compete with the enzymatic cleavage reaction, not even as a minor side reaction. Comparative kinetic measurements with structurally modified di-nucleoside monophosphates and oligomeric phosphodiesters have played an important role in clarification of mechanistic details of the buffer-independent and buffer-catalyzed reactions. More recently, heavy atom isotope effects and theoretical calculations have refined the picture. The primary aim of all these studies has been to form a solid basis for mechanistic analyses of the action of more complicated catalytic machineries. In other words, to contribute to conception of a plausible unified picture of RNA cleavage by biocatalysts, such as RNAse A, hammerhead ribozyme and DNAzymes. In addition, structurally modified trinucleoside monophosphates as transition state models for Group I and II introns have clarified some features of the action of large ribozymes.

Phosphodiester models for cleavage of nucleic acids

Nucleic acids that store and transfer biological information are polymeric diesters of phosphoric acid. Cleavage of the phosphodiester linkages by protein enzymes, nucleases, is one of the underlying biological processes. The remarkable catalytic efficiency of nucleases, together with the ability of ribonucleic acids to serve sometimes as nucleases, has made the cleavage of phosphodiesters a subject of intensive mechanistic studies. In addition to studies of nucleases by pH-rate dependency, X-ray crystallography, amino acid/nucleotide substitution and computational approaches, experimental and theoretical studies with small molecular model compounds still play a role. With small molecules, the importance of various elementary processes, such as proton transfer and metal ion binding, for stabilization of transition states may be elucidated and systematic variation of the basicity of the entering or departing nucleophile enables determination of the position of the transition state on the reaction coordinate. Such data is important on analyzing enzyme mechanisms based on synergistic participation of several catalytic entities. Many nucleases are metalloenzymes and small molecular models offer an excellent tool to construct models for their catalytic centers. The present review tends to be an up to date summary of what has been achieved by mechanistic studies with small molecular phosphodiesters.

Participation of an additional 4'-hydroxymethyl group in the cleavage and isomerization of ribonucleoside 3'-phosphodiesters

4'-(Hydroxymethyl)uridylyl-3',5'-thymidine, an RNA model bearing an extra hydroxymethyl group at the 4'-position of the 3'-linked nucleoside, has been prepared and its cleavage and isomerization reactions studied over a wide pH range (from 0 to 12). Overall, the pH-rate profiles of these reactions were very similar to those of uridylyl-3',5'-uridine (UpU) - only a very modest acceleration was observed under acidic and neutral conditions. Evidently, hydrogen bond assistance by the additional hydroxymethyl function does not play a significant role.

Intramolecular participation of amino groups in the cleavage and isomerization of ribonucleoside 3'-phosphodiesters: the role in stabilization of the phosphorane intermediate

A dinucleoside-3',5'-phosphodiester model, 5'-amino-4'-aminomethyl-5'-deoxyuridylyl-3',5'-thymidine, incorporating two aminomethyl functions in the 4'-position of the 3'-linked nucleoside has been prepared and its hydrolytic reactions studied over a wide pH range. The amino functions were found to accelerate the cleavage and isomerization of the phosphodiester linkage in both protonated and neutral form. When present in protonated form, the cleavage of the 3',5'-phosphodiester linkage and its isomerization to a 2',5'-linkage are pH-independent and 50-80 times as fast as the corresponding reactions of uridylyl-3',5'-uridine (3',5'-UpU). The cleavage of the resulting 2',5'-isomer is also accelerated, albeit less than with the 3',5'-isomer, whereas isomerization back to the 3',5'-diester is not enhanced. When the amino groups are deprotonated, the cleavage reactions of both isomers are again pH-independent and up to 1000-fold faster than the pH-independent cleavage of UpU. Interestingly, the 2'- to 3'-isomerization is now much faster than its reverse reaction. The mechanisms of these reactions are discussed. The rate accelerations are largely accounted for by electrostatic and hydrogen-bonding interactions of the protonated amino groups with the phosphorane intermediate.

Impact of steric constraints on the product distribution of phosphate-branched oligonucleotide models of the large ribozymes

To assess the extent to which steric constraints may influence the product distribution of the reactions of the large ribozymes, phosphate-branched oligonucleotides of varying length and sequence have been synthesized and their alkaline hydrolysis studied over a wide temperature range. At low temperatures, the branching trinucleoside-3',3',5'-monophosphate moiety is hydrolyzed almost exclusively by P-O3' fission. At higher temperatures, P-O5' fission competes, accounting at most for 22% of the overall reaction. The results suggest that steric constraints imposed by the secondary structure of the reaction site may significantly contribute to the observed regioselectivity of the transesterification reactions catalyzed by the large ribozymes.

Investigation of the catalytic mechanism of a synthetic DNAzyme with protein-like functionality: an RNaseA mimic?

The protein enzyme ribonuclease A (RNaseA) cleaves RNA with catalytic perfection, although with little sequence specificity, by a divalent metal ion (M(2+))-independent mechanism in which a pair of imidazoles provides general acid and base catalysis, while a cationic amine provides electrostatic stabilization of the transition state. Synthetic imitation of this remarkable organo-catalyst ("RNaseA mimicry") has been a longstanding goal in biomimetic chemistry. The 9(25)-11 DNAzyme contains synthetically modified nucleotides presenting both imidazole and cationic amine side chains, and catalyzes RNA cleavage with turnover in the absence of M(2+) similarly to RNaseA. Nevertheless, the catalytic roles, if any, of the "protein-like" functional groups have not been defined, and hence the question remains whether 9(25)-11 engages any of these functionalities to mimic aspects of the mechanism of RNaseA. To address this question, we report a mechanistic investigation of 9(25)-11 catalysis wherein we have employed a variety of experiments, such as DNAzyme functional group deletion, mechanism-based affinity labeling, and bridging and nonbridging phosphorothioate substitution of the scissile phosphate. Several striking parallels exist between the results presented here for 9(25)-11 and the results of analogous experiments applied previously to RNaseA. Specifically, our results implicate two particular imidazoles in general acid and base catalysis and suggest that a specific cationic amine stabilizes the transition state via diastereoselective interaction with the scissile phosphate. Overall, 9(25)-11 appears to meet the minimal criteria of an RNaseA mimic; this demonstrates how added synthetic functionality can expand the mechanistic repertoire available to a synthetic DNA-based catalyst.

Phosphorane intermediate vs. leaving group stabilization by intramolecular hydrogen bonding in the cleavage of trinucleoside monophosphates: implications for understanding catalysis by the large ribozymes

Hydrolysis of 2',3'-O-methyleneadenosin-5'-yl 5'-O-methyluridin-2'-yl 5'-O-methyl-2'-trifluoroacetamido-2'-deoxyuridin-3'-yl phosphate (1b) has been followed by HPLC over a wide pH range to study the effects of potential hydrogen bonding interactions of the 2'-trifluoroacetamido function on the rate and product distribution of the reaction. At pH < 2, decomposition of 1b (and its 3',3',5'-isomer 1a) is first-order in hydronium-ion concentration and cleavage of the P-O3' bond of the 2'-trifluoroacetamido-modified nucleoside is slightly favored over cleavage of the P-O5' bond. Between pH 2 and 4, the overall hydrolysis is pH-independent and the P-O3' and P-O5' bonds are cleaved at comparable rates. At pH 5, the reaction becomes first-order in hydroxide-ion concentration, with P-O3' bond cleavage predominating. At 10 mmol L(-1) aqueous sodium hydroxide, no P-O5' bond cleavage is observed. Compared to the 2'-OH counterpart , a modest rate enhancement is observed over the entire pH range studied. The absence of P-O5' fission under alkaline conditions suggests hydrogen bond stabilization of the departing 3'-oxyanion by the neighboring 2'-trifluoroacetamido function.

The effects of sulfur substitution for the nucleophile and bridging oxygen atoms in reactions of hydroxyalkyl phosphate esters

The effects of sulfur substitution on the reactions of hydroxyalkyl phosphate esters are examined. These compounds are models for the intramolecular phosphoryl transfer reaction involved in the cleavage of the internucleotide bond in RNA. The models studied here lack the ribose ring and their conformational flexibility results in greater stability and the availability of different reaction pathways. Sulfur in the nucleophilic position shows no nucleophilic reaction at phosphorus, instead rapidly attacking at the beta carbon atom, forming thiirane with departure of a phosphomonoester. Sulfur substitution at either of the two bridging positions leads to cleavage of the diester via formation of a cyclic intermediate, but with significant rate acceleration when compared to the oxygen analogues. The bridge-substituted models react substantially slower than the analogous ribose compounds with sulfur substitution at comparable positions. Kinetic isotope effects reveal significant differences in the transition state depending on which bridging position sulfur occupies. When sulfur is in the scissile bridging position, a highly associative transition state is indicated, with a largely formed bond to the nucleophile and the scissile P-S bond is little changed. When sulfur occupies the other bridging position, the isotope effects imply a very early transition state in a concerted reaction.

Discrimination in metal-ion binding to RNA dinucleotides with a non-bridging oxygen or sulfur in the phosphate diester link

Replacement of a non-bridging oxygen in the phosphate diester bond by a sulfur has become quite popular in nucleic acid research and is often used as a probe, for example, in ribozymes, where the normally essential Mg(2+) is partly replaced by a thiophilic metal ion to reactivate the system. Despite these widely applied rescue experiments no detailed studies exist quantifying the affinity of metal ions to such terminal sulfur atoms. Therefore, we performed potentiometric pH titrations to determine the binding properties of pUp((S))U(3-) towards Mg(2+), Mn(2+), Zn(2+), Cd(2+), and Pb(2+), and compared these data with those previously obtained for the corresponding pUpU(3-) complexes. The primary binding site in both dinucleotides is the terminal phosphate group. Theoretically, also the formation of 10-membered chelates involving the terminal oxygen or sulfur atoms of the (thio)phosphate bridge is possible with both ligands. The results show that Mg(2+) and Mn(2+) exist as open (op) isomers binding to both dinucleotides only at the terminal phosphate group. Whereas Cd(pUpU)(-) only exists as Cd(pUpU)(-)(op), Cd(pUp((S))U)(-) is present to about 64 % as the S-coordinated macrochelate, Cd(pUp((S))U)(-)(cl/PS). Zn(2+) forms with pUp((S))U(3-) three isomeric species, that is, Zn(pUp((S))U)(-)(op), Zn(pUp((S))U)(-)(cl/PO), and Zn(pUp((S))U)(-)(cl/PS), which occur to about 33, 12 (O-bound), and 55 %, respectively. Pb(2+) forms the 10-membered chelate with both nucleotides involving only the terminal oxygen atoms of the (thio)phosphate bridge, that is, no indication of S binding was discovered in this case. Hence, Zn(2+) and Cd(2+) show pronounced thiophilic properties, whereas Mg(2+), Mn(2+), and Pb(2+) coordinate to the oxygen, macrochelate formation being of relevance with Pb(2+) only.