Unveiling the Binding Modes of the Crystallophore, a Terbium-based Nucleating and Phasing Molecular Agent for Protein Crystallography

Influence of Chemical Modifications of the Crystallophore on Protein Nucleating Properties and Supramolecular Interactions Network

Crystallophores are lanthanide complexes that have demonstrated outstanding induction of crystallization for various proteins. This article explores the effect of tailored modifications of the crystallophore first generation and their impact on the nucleating properties and protein crystal structures. Through high-throughput crystallization experiments and dataset analysis, we evaluated the effectiveness of these variants, in comparison to the first crystallophore generation G1. In particular, the V1 variant, featuring a propanol pendant arm, demonstrated the ability to produce new crystallization conditions for the proteins tested (hen-egg white lysozyme, proteinase K and thaumatin). Structural analysis performed in the case of hen egg-white lysozyme along with Molecular Dynamics simulations, highlights V1's unique behavior, taking advantage of the flexibility of its propanol arm to explore different protein surfaces and form versatile supramolecular interactions.

One touch is all it takes: the supramolecular interaction between ubiquitin and lanthanide complexes revisited by paramagnetic NMR and molecular dynamics

The supramolecular interaction between lanthanide complexes and proteins is at the heart of numerous chemical and biological studies. Some of these complexes have demonstrated remarkable interaction properties with proteins or peptides in solution and in the crystalline state. Here we have used the paramagnetism of lanthanide ions to characterize the affinity of two lanthanide complexes for ubiquitin. As the interaction process is dynamic, the acquired NMR data only reflect the time average of the different steps. We have used molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to get a deeper insight into the detailed interaction scenario at the microsecond scale. This NMR/MD approach enabled us to establish that the tris-dipicolinate complex interacts specifically with arginines and lysines, while the crystallophore explores the protein surface through weak interactions with carboxylates. These observations shed new light on the dynamic interaction properties of these complexes, which will ultimately enable us to propose a crystallization mechanism.

Biochemical, structural and dynamical characterizations of the lactate dehydrogenase from Selenomonas ruminantium provide information about an intermediate evolutionary step prior to complete allosteric regulation acquisition in the super family of lactate and malate dehydrogenases

In this work, we investigated the lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) from Selenomonas ruminantium (S. rum), an enzyme that differs at key amino acid positions from canonical allosteric LDHs. The wild type (Wt) of this enzyme recognises pyuvate as all LDHs. However, introducing a single point mutation in the active site loop (I85R) allows S. Rum LDH to recognize the oxaloacetate substrate as a typical malate dehydrogenase (MalDH), whilst maintaining homotropic activation as an LDH. We report the tertiary structure of the Wt and I85RLDH mutant. The Wt S. rum enzyme structure binds NADH and malonate, whilst also resembling the typical compact R-active state of canonical LDHs. The structure of the mutant with I85R was solved in the Apo State (without ligand), and shows no large conformational reorganization such as that observed with canonical allosteric LDHs in Apo state. This is due to a local structural feature typical of S. rum LDH that prevents large-scale conformational reorganization. The S. rum LDH was also studied using Molecular Dynamics simulations, probing specific local deformations of the active site that allow the S. rum LDH to sample the T-inactive state. We propose that, with respect to the LDH/MalDH superfamily, the S. rum enzyme possesses a specificstructural and dynamical way to ensure homotropic activation.

Protein Frameworks with Thiacalixarene and Zinc

Controlled protein assembly provides a means to generate biomaterials. Synthetic macrocycles such as the water-soluble sulfonato-calix[n]arenes are useful mediators of protein assembly. Sulfonato-thiacalix[4]arene (tsclx ₄ ), with its metal-binding capacity, affords the potential for simultaneous macrocycle- and metal-mediated protein assembly. Here, we describe the tsclx ₄ -/Zn-directed assembly of two proteins: cationic α-helical cytochrome c (cyt c) and neutral β-propeller Ralstonia solanacearum lectin (RSL). Two co-crystal forms were obtained with cyt c, each involving multinuclear zinc sites supported by the cone conformation of tsclx ₄ . The tsclx ₄ /Zn cluster acted as an assembly node via both lysine encapsulation and metal-mediated protein-protein contacts. In the case of RSL, tsclx ₄ adopted the 1,2-alternate conformation and supported a dinuclear zinc site with concomitant encapsulation and metal-binding of two histidine side chains. These results, together with the knowledge of thiacalixarene/metal nanoclusters, suggest promising applications for thiacalixarenes in biomaterials and MOF fabrication.

Influence of Divalent Cations in the Protein Crystallization Process Assisted by Lanthanide-Based Additives

The use of lanthanide complexes as powerful auxiliaries for biocrystallography prompted us to systematically analyze the influence of the commercial crystallization kit composition on the efficiency of two lanthanide additives: [Eu(DPA)₃]^3- and Tb-Xo4. This study reveals that the tris(dipicolinate) complex presents a lower chemical stability and a strong tendency toward false positives, which are detrimental for its use in a high-throughput robotized crystallization platform. In particular, the crystal structures of (Mg(H₂O)₆)₃[Eu(DPA)₃]₂·7H₂O (1), {(Ca(H₂O)₄)₃[Eu(DPA)₃]₂}_n·10nH₂O (2), and {Cu(DPA)(H₂O)₂}_n (3), resulting from spontaneous crystallization in the presence of a divalent alkaline-earth cation and transmetalation, are reported. On the other hand, Tb-Xo4 is perfectly soluble in the crystallization media, stable in the presence of alkaline-earth dications, and slowly decomposes (within days) by transmetalation with transition metals. The original structure of [Tb₄L₄(H₂O)₄]Cl₄·15H₂O (4) is also described, where L represents a bis(pinacolato)triazacyclononane ligand. This paper also highlights a potential synergy of interactions between Tb-Xo4 and components of the crystallization mixtures, leading to the formation of complex adducts like {AdkA/Tb-Xo4/Mg²⁺/glycerol} in the protein binding sites. The observation of such multicomponent adducts illustrated the complexity and versatility of the supramolecular chemistry occurring at the surface of the proteins.

Capturing the dynamic association between a tris-dipicolinate lanthanide complex and a decapeptide: a combined paramagnetic NMR and molecular dynamics exploration

In the realm of biomolecules, peptides can present a large diversity of structures. Our study sheds new light on the structural interplay between a tris-dipicolinate lanthanide probe and a decapeptide SASYKTLPRG. Although a rather trivial, electrostatically driven interaction was expected, the combination of paramagnetic NMR and molecular dynamics simulations reveals a highly dynamic association process and allows for providing extensive insights into the interaction sites and their occupancy. This study highlights the importance of a large conformational sampling to reconcile characteristic time in NMR with molecular dynamics simulations, where sampling in the microsecond range is needed. This study opens the door for a detailed mechanistic elucidation of the early steps of lanthanide complex-peptide or lanthanide complex-protein interaction or self-assembly processes.

Biochemical, structural and dynamical studies reveal strong differences in the thermal-dependent allosteric behavior of two extremophilic lactate dehydrogenases

In this work, we combined biochemical and structural investigations with molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to analyze the very different thermal-dependent allosteric behavior of two lactate dehydrogenases (LDH) from thermophilic bacteria. We found that the enzyme from Petrotoga mobilis (P. mob) necessitates an absolute requirement of the allosteric effector (fructose 1, 6-bisphosphate) to ensure functionality. In contrast, even without allosteric effector, the LDH from Thermus thermophilus (T. the) is functional when the temperature is raised. We report the crystal structure of P. mob LDH in the Apo state solved at 1.9 Å resolution. We used this structure and the one from T. the, obtained previously, as a starting point for MD simulations at various temperatures. We found clear differences between the thermal dynamics, which accounts for the behavior of the two enzymes. Our work demonstrates that, within an allosteric enzyme, some areas act as local gatekeepers of signal transmission, allowing the enzyme to populate either the T-inactive or the R-active states with different degrees of stringency.

Molecular Dynamics Approach for Capturing Calixarene-Protein Interactions: The Case of Cytochrome C

Functionalized supramolecular cages are of growing importance in biology and biochemistry. They have recently been proposed as efficient auxiliaries to obtain high-resolution cocrystallized proteins. Here, we propose a molecular dynamics investigation of the supramolecular association of sulfonated calix-[8]-arenes to cytochrome c starting from initially distant proteins and ligands. We characterize two main binding sites for the sulfonated calixarene on the cytochrome c surface which are in perfect agreement with the previous experiments with regard to the structure (comparison with the X-ray structure PDB 6GD8) and the binding free energies [comparison between the molecular mechanics Poisson-Boltzmann surface area analysis and the isothermal titration calorimetry measurements]. The per-residue decomposition of the interaction energies reveals the detailed picture of this electrostatically driven association and notably the role of arginine R13 as a bridging residue between the two main anchoring sites. In addition, the analysis of the residue behavior by means of a supervised machine learning protocol unveils the formation of a hydrogen bond network far from the binding sites, increasing the rigidity of the protein. This study paves the way toward an automated procedure to predict the supramolecular protein-cage association, with the possibility of a computational screening of new promising derivatives for controlled protein assembly and protein surface recognition processes.

NMR Spectroscopy of supramolecular chemistry on protein surfaces

As one of the few analytical methods that offer atomic resolution, NMR spectroscopy is a valuable tool to study the interaction of proteins with their interaction partners, both biomolecules and synthetic ligands. In recent years, the focus in chemistry has kept expanding from targeting small binding pockets in proteins to recognizing patches on protein surfaces, mostly via supramolecular chemistry, with the goal to modulate protein-protein interactions. Here we present NMR methods that have been applied to characterize these molecular interactions and discuss the challenges of this endeavor.

Engineered assembly of a protein–cucurbituril biohybrid

Additional Q7 binding sites drive protein aggregation in solution and statistical disorder in the crystalline biohybrid suggest new possibilities for protein-based materials.

Tuning Protein Frameworks via Auxiliary Supramolecular Interactions

Protein crystals with their precise, periodic array of functional building blocks have potential applications in biomaterials, sensing, and catalysis. This paper describes how a highly porous crystalline framework of a cationic redox protein and an anionic macrocycle can be modulated by a small cationic effector. Ternary composites of protein (∼13 kDa), calix[8]arene (∼1.5 kDa), and effector (∼0.2 kDa) formed distinct crystalline architectures, dependent on the effector concentration and the crystallization technique. A combination of X-ray crystallography and density functional theory (DFT) calculations was used to decipher the framework variations, which appear to be dependent on a calixarene conformation change mediated by the effector. This "switch" calixarene was observed in three states, each of which is associated with a different interaction network. Two structures obtained by co-crystallization with the effector contained an additional protein "pillar", resulting in framework duplication and decreased porosity. These results suggest how protein assembly can be engineered by supramolecular host-guest interactions.

Protein crystal structure determination with the crystallophore, a nucleating and phasing agent

Obtaining crystals and solving the phase problem remain major hurdles encountered by bio-crystallographers in their race to obtain new high-quality structures. Both issues can be overcome by the crystallophore, Tb-Xo4, a lanthanide-based molecular complex with unique nucleating and phasing properties. This article presents examples of new crystallization conditions induced by the presence of Tb-Xo4. These new crystalline forms bypass crystal defects often encountered by crystallographers, such as low-resolution diffracting samples or crystals with twinning. Thanks to Tb-Xo4's high phasing power, the structure determination process is greatly facilitated and can be extended to serial crystallography approaches.

The archaeal LDH-like malate dehydrogenase from Ignicoccus islandicus displays dual substrate recognition, hidden allostery and a non-canonical tetrameric oligomeric organization

The NAD(P)-dependent malate dehydrogenases (MalDHs) and NAD-dependent lactate dehydrogenases (LDHs) are homologous enzymes involved in central metabolism. They display a common protein fold and the same catalytic mechanism, yet have a stringent capacity to discriminate between their respective substrates. The MalDH/LDH superfamily is divided into several phylogenetically related groups. It has been shown that the canonical LDHs and LDH-like group of MalDHs are primarily tetrameric enzymes that diverged from a common ancestor. In order to gain understanding of the evolutionary history of the LDHs and MalDHs, the biochemical properties and crystallographic structure of the LDH-like MalDH from the hyperthermophilic archaeon Ignicoccus islandicus (I. isl) were determined. I. isl MalDH recognizes oxaloacetate as main substrate, but it is also able to use pyruvate. Surprisingly, with pyruvate, the enzymatic activity profile looks like that of allosteric LDHs, suggesting a hidden allosteric capacity in a MalDH. The I. isl MalDH tetrameric structure in the apo state is considerably different from those of canonical LDH-like MalDHs and LDHs, representing an alternative oligomeric organization. A comparison with MalDH and LDH counterparts provides strong evidence that the divergence between allosteric and non-allosteric members of the superfamily involves homologs with intermediate, atypical properties.

A simple and versatile microfluidic device for efficient biomacromolecule crystallization and structural analysis by serial crystallography

Determining optimal conditions for the production of well diffracting crystals is a key step in every biocrystallography project. Here, a microfluidic device is described that enables the production of crystals by counter-diffusion and their direct on-chip analysis by serial crystallography at room temperature. Nine 'non-model' and diverse biomacromolecules, including seven soluble proteins, a membrane protein and an RNA duplex, were crystallized and treated on-chip with a variety of standard techniques including micro-seeding, crystal soaking with ligands and crystal detection by fluorescence. Furthermore, the crystal structures of four proteins and an RNA were determined based on serial data collected on four synchrotron beamlines, demonstrating the general applicability of this multipurpose chip concept.

Crystal structure of a protein–aromatic foldamer composite: macromolecular chiral resolution

A protein–foldamer crystal structure illustrates protein assembly by a sulfonated aromatic oligoamide, and chiral resolution of the foldamer helix handedness.