Comment on "The 'Inverted Bonds' Revisited. Analysis of 'in Silico' Models and of [1.1.1]Propellane Using Orbital Forces"

When, Where and Why Boron Prefers Boron to Nitrogen

Boron is the archetypal Lewis acid, and therefore it is only natural that it prefers to bind nitrogen, its usual Lewis base counterpart. To challenge this assumption, we present a computationally designed bicyclopentane molecule akin to [1.1.1]propellane, but with pyramidal B and N inner atoms bonded by an "inverted" dative bond. Unexpectedly, the dimer of this system prefers to interact via an atypical boron-boron bond over the supposedly obvious boron-nitrogen bond. A molecular orbital analysis shows that the boron in this peculiar entity acts both as an electron donor and an electron acceptor, making the dimerization an amphoteric-amphoteric interaction process.

Magnetic Shielding Analysis of Bonding in [1.1.1]Propellane

The bonding in [1.1.1]propellane, bicyclo[1.1.0]butane, bicyclo[1.1.1]pentane, tetrahedrane, and cyclopropane is investigated by analyzing changes in the off-nucleus isotropic magnetic shielding within the space surrounding each of these molecules and, for [1.1.1]propellane, by examining also the diamagnetic and paramagnetic contributions to this shielding. Any shielding arising from the two "exo" sp³-like hybrid atomic orbitals on the bridgehead carbon atoms that have been used to support the idea of an inverted bond between these two atoms is found to be almost entirely contained within the [1.1.1]propellane cage and to contribute to a strongly shielded central region. This strongly shielded region suggests the establishment of a mainly covalent bonding interaction involving all carbon atoms that cannot be straightforwardly decomposed into contributions from individual carbon-carbon bonds. The emergence of the strongly shielding central region is traced by comparing the shielding variations in and around molecules with one three-membered carbon ring (cyclopropane), two fused three-membered carbon rings (bicyclo[1.1.0]butane), and three fused three-membered carbon rings ([1.1.1]propellane).