Comparative Investigation into the Complexation and Extraction Properties of Tridentate and Tetradentate Phosphine Oxide-Functionalized 1,10-Phenanthroline Ligands toward Lanthanides and Actinides

Theoretical insights into selective extraction of Am(III) from Cm(III) and Eu(III) with asymmetric N-heterocyclic ligands

Separation of lanthanide (Ln) and minor actinide (MA) elements and mutual separation between minor actinide elements (e.g. Am(III) and Cm(III)) represent a crucial undertaking. However, separating these elements poses a significant challenge owing to their highly similar physicochemical properties. Asymmetric N-heterocyclic ligands such as N-ethyl-6-(1H-pyrazol-3-yl)-N-(p-tolyl)picolinamide (Et-p-Tol-A-PzPy) and N-ethyl-N-(p-tolyl)-1,10-phenanthroline-2-carboxamide (ETPhenAm) have recently received considerable attention in the separation of MAs over Ln from acid solutions. By changing the central skeleton structures of these ligands and introducing substituents with different properties on the side chains, their complexation behavior with Am(III), Cm(III), and Eu(III) may be affected. In this work, we explore four different asymmetric N-containing heterocyclic ligands, namely Et-p-Tol-A-PzPy (L1), N-ethyl-6'-(1H-pyrazol-3-yl)-N-(p-tolyl)-[2,2'-bipyridine]-6-carboxamide (L2), N-ethyl-9-(1H-pyrazol-3-yl)-N-(p-tolyl)-1,10-phenanthroline-2-carboxamide (L3), and ETPhenAm (L4) using density functional theory (DFT). The calculated results demonstrate the potential of ligands L1-L4 for the extraction and separation of Am(III), Cm(III), and Eu(III). Ligand analysis shows that ligand L3 binds more easily to the central metal atom, in line with the stronger extraction capacity of L3. In spite of the higher covalence between the side chain and the central metal atom for complexes with L1-L3, the main chain seems to control the stability of the extraction complexes. The preorganized 1,10-phenanthroline backbone also further enhances the extraction performance of L3 and L4. The difference in coordination ability between the side chain donors of these ligands and metal ions may affect their separation efficiency. This work presents theoretical insights into synthesizing novel ligands for separating trivalent actinides by adjusting N-heterocyclic ligands.

Sensing and extraction of hazardous metals by di-phosphonates of heterocycles: a combined experimental and theoretical study

In this study, pyridine and phenanthroline diphosphonate ligands were investigated for the first time from the context of solvent extraction and potentiometric sensing of Co(II), Ni(II), Cu(II), Zn(II), Cd(II), and Pb(II) cations. The extraction efficiency under the same conditions for phenanthroline-diphosphonates is considerably higher than that for pyridine ligands. At the same time, the pyridine-diphosphonates show pronounced selectivity towards lead in this metal series. The extraction systems with phenanthroline diphosphonates provided the most efficient extraction of Cd(II) and Pb(II) cations (D > 90). The newly developed pyridine and phenanthroline diphosphonate ligands have proven to be highly effective components in plasticized polymeric membranes. These ligands can be utilized to construct potentiometric ion sensors that exhibit a notable response specifically towards Pb(II) cations. Among the previously reported tetradentate ligands, the phenanthroline diphosphonate ligand, when incorporated into plasticized polymeric membranes, demonstrated the highest sensitivity towards d-metals and Pb(II). The structure of the single crystal complex of Pb(II) and Cd(II) with pyridine-diphosphonates was studied by X-ray diffraction analysis (XRD). The geometry of Cu(II), Zn(II), Cd(II) and Pb(II) complexes and the energy effect of the complex formation, including pseudo-oligomerization reactions, were determined by DFT calculations. The high sensing and extraction efficiency of diphosphonates with respect to Pb(II) is consistent with the minimum values of complex formation energies. The variation in sensory and extraction properties observed among the studied diphosphonate ligands is influenced by the ability to form polynuclear complexes with Pb(II) cations, whereas such properties are absent in the case of Cd(II) cations.

A Simple yet Efficient Hydrophilic Phenanthroline-Based Ligand for Selective Am(III) Separation under High Acidity

Highly selective hydrophilic ligands were believed to be an efficient way to overcome the massive amount of hazardous organic solvent used in the liquid-liquid extraction process and stood as a new frontier in the Lns(III)/Ans(III) partition. Current reported hydrophilic ligands suffer from harsh preparation conditions, inferior extraction performances, limited available chemical structures, and inability to carry out extraction under high acidity. In this article, we report a simple yet efficient carboxylic group modified phenanthroline-diimide ligand which displayed unexpected Lns(III)/Ans(III) and Ans(III)/Ans(III) separation capabilities in 1.5 M HNO3. Unique dimeric architectures for Eu(III) complexes were observed, which could be the origin of the outperforming selectivity and acid resistance. We believe this crystal engineering approach could inspire a renaissance in searching for new functional groups and coordination modes for efficient, high-acid-tolerance Lns(III)/Ans(III) separation ligands.

Complexation of a Nitrilotriacetate-Derived Triamide Ligand with Trivalent Lanthanides: A Thermodynamic and Crystallographic Study

Non-heterocyclic N-donor nitrilotriacetate-derived triamide ligands are one of the most promising extractants for the selective extraction separation of trivalent actinides over lanthanides, but the thermodynamics and mechanism of the complexation of this kind of ligand with actinides and lanthanides are still not clear. In this work, the complexation behaviors of N,N,N',N',N″,N″-hexaethylnitrilotriacetamide (NTAamide(Et)) with four representative trivalent lanthanides (La³⁺, Nd³⁺, Eu³⁺, and Lu³⁺) were systematically investigated by using ¹H nuclear magnetic resonance (¹H NMR), ultraviolet-visible (UV-vis) and fluorescence spectrophotometry, microcalorimetry, and single-crystal X-ray diffractometry. ¹H NMR spectroscopic titration of La³⁺ and Lu³⁺ indicates that two species of 1:2 and 1:1 metal-ligand complexes were formed in NO₃^- and ClO₄^- media. The stability constants of NTAamide(Et) with Nd³⁺ and Eu³⁺ obtained by UV-vis and fluorescence titration show that the complexing strength of NTAamide(Et) with Nd³⁺ is lower than that with Eu³⁺ in the same anionic medium, while that of the same lanthanide complex is higher in ClO₄^- medium than in NO₃^- medium. Meanwhile, the formation reactions for all metal-ligand complexes are driven by both enthalpy and entropy. The structures of lanthanide complexes in the single ClO₄^- and NO₃^- medium and the mixed one were determined to be [LnL₂(MeOH)](ClO₄)₃ (Ln = La, Nd, Eu, and Lu), [LaL₂(EtOH)₂][La(NO₃)₆], and [LaL₂(NO₃)](ClO₄)₂, separately. The average bond lengths of lanthanide complexes decrease gradually with the decrease in ionic radii of Ln³⁺, indicating that heavier lanthanides form stronger complexes due to the lanthanide contraction effect, which coincides with the trend of the complexing strength obtained by spectroscopic titration. This work not only reveals the thermodynamics and mechanism of the complexation between NTAamide ligands and lanthanides but also obtains the periodic tendency of complexation between them, which may facilitate the separation of trivalent lanthanides from actinides.

Theoretical Insights into the Substitution Effect of Phenanthroline Derivatives on Am(III)/Eu(III) Separation

Separation of trivalent actinides (An(III)) and lanthanides (Ln(III)) poses a huge challenge in the reprocessing of spent nuclear fuel due to their similar chemical properties. N,N'-Diethyl-N,N'-ditolyl-2,9-diamide-1,10-phenanthroline (Et-Tol-DAPhen) is a potential ligand for the extraction of An(III) from Ln(III), while there are still few reports on the effect of its substituent including electron-withdrawing and electron-donating groups on An(III)/Ln(III) separation. Herein, the interaction of Et-Tol-DAPhen ligands modified by the electron-withdrawing groups (CF₃, Br) and electron-donating groups (OH) with Am(III)/Eu(III) ions was investigated using scalar relativistic density functional theory (DFT). The analyses of bond order, quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM), and molecular orbital (MO) indicate that the substitution groups have a slight effect on the electronic structures of the [M(L-X)(NO₃)₃] (X = CF₃, Br, OH) complexes. However, the thermodynamic results suggest that a ligand with the electron-donating group (L-OH) improves the extraction ability of metal ions, and the ligand modified by the electron-withdrawing group (L-Br) has the best Am(III)/Eu(III) selectivity. This work could render new insights into understanding the effect of electron-withdrawing and electron-donating groups in tuning the selectivity of Et-Tol-DAPhen derivatives and pave the way for designing new ligands modified by substituted groups with better extraction ability and An(III)/Ln(III) selectivity.

Pyridine-di-phosphonates as chelators for trivalent f-elements: kinetics, thermodynamic and interfacial study of Am(III)/Eu(III) solvent extraction

The fractionation of high-level radioactive waste from nuclear power plants simplifies the handling of its components, and facilitates the reduction of radiotoxic effects on the environment. The search and study of new ligands for solvent extraction, as one of the methods in fractionation, remains a complex and important research task. In this work, four pyridine diphosphonate ligands were synthesized. These ligands are part of the class of the N,O-donor extractants, which are selective towards Am(III). The separation factor SF(Am/Eu) for the best extractant reached values up to 10. The influence of the substituents on the efficiency of extraction and complexation of trivalent f-elements, the kinetics of extraction, and the behavior of the ligand at the interface were described. The effect of nitric acid concentration on the extraction was shown. The stoichiometry of the complexes was determined by slope analysis in solvent extraction experiment and verified by spectrophotometric titration in acetonitrile. Liquid tension experiments with a pendant drop method revealed the interfacial properties of the ligands in "F-3 solvent/H₂O" and "F-3 solvent/HNO₃" systems. The relationship between the surface activity and the ligand structure was shown. Studies of the extraction kinetics were performed in a modified Lewis cell. The effect of the ligand structure on the extraction rate was shown. The DFT calculation with the B3LYP density functional was used to explain the extraction properties of the ligands, including selectivity. The calculation of the pre-organization energy of the ligands explained the kinetics and extraction patterns for the studied series.

Theoretical unraveling of the separation of trivalent Am and Eu ions by phosphine oxide ligands with different central heterocyclic moieties

The treatment of nuclear spent fuels, especially the separation of minor actinides, is an imperative task for the healthy development of the nuclear industry. Up to now, it still remains a worldwide challenge to separate trivalent An³⁺ from Ln³⁺ because of their similar chemical properties. Therefore, investigating the mechanism behind the selective extraction of An³⁺ by theoretical methods is necessary. In this work, three phosphine oxide ligands with the same side structures but different bridging frameworks, Ph₂PyPO, Ph₂BipyPO and Ph₂PhenPO, were investigated theoretically, and compared with each other using relativistic density functional theory. The results of QTAIM and MBO suggest that the Am-N bonds in the studied complexes have more covalent character than those in the Eu-N bonds, whereas the PDOS analysis indicates that more overlap exists between Am-5f and the Ph₂PyPO's N-2p orbital than between Am-5f and Ph₂BipyPO's N-2p, and Am-5f and Ph₂PhenPO's N-2p orbital. However, the studied ligands all possess stronger affinities towards Am³⁺ than Eu³⁺, which partly results in the Am³⁺ selectivity towards Eu³⁺ in these three ligands. The calculated reaction free energy can reproduce the Am/Eu separation ability difference of three ligands well. This work offers some useful information for An/Ln separation of phosphine oxide ligands, and may help to design more efficient An³⁺/Ln³⁺ separation ligands.

Probing the Difference in the Complexation of Trivalent Actinides and Lanthanides with a Tridentate N,O-Hybrid Ligand: Spectroscopy, Thermodynamics, and Coordination Modes

Comparatively revealing the complexation behavior of trivalent actinides and lanthanides with functional ligands in aqueous solution is of great importance to enrich our knowledge on the fundamental coordination chemistry of trivalent f-block elements and to control the fate of minor actinides in nuclear fuel cycles. In this work, the complexation of Am(III) and Nd(III), representatives for trivalent actinides and lanthanides, respectively, with a N,O-hybrid ligand 6-(dimethylcarbamoyl)picolinic acid (DMAPA, denoted as HL) was investigated by absorption spectroscopy, calorimetry, X-ray crystallography, and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Successive formation of 1:1, 1:2, and 1:3 (metal/ligand) complexes of Am(III) and Nd(III) with DMAPA was identified, and the corresponding thermodynamic parameters were determined. The binding strength of Am(III) with DMAPA is slightly stronger than that of Nd(III), and the complexation of Nd(III) with DMAPA is mainly entropy-driven. The crystal structure of the 1:2 Nd(III)/DMAPA complex and the DFT calculation shed additional light on the coordination and structural characteristics of the complexes. In contrast to the Nd-N bond in the Nd(III)/DMAPA complex, the Am-N bond in the Am(III)/DMAPA complex exhibits more covalency, which contributes to the slightly stronger complexation of Am(III) with DMAPA.

Preorganization of N, O-hybrid phosphine oxide chelators for effective extraction of trivalent Am/Eu ions - A computational study

N, O-hybrid phosphine oxide ligands with N-heterocyclic cores are the advanced extractants for extracting actinides over lanthanides. Yet, the challenging task in designing an efficient hybrid ligand is tracing the...

Effects of coordinating heteroatoms on molecular structure, thermodynamic stability and redox behavior of uranyl(vi) complexes with pentadentate Schiff-base ligands

Uranyl(vi) complexes with pentadentate N₃O₂-, N₂O₃- and N₂O₂S₁-donating Schiff base ligands, tBu,MeO–saldien–X²⁻ (X = NH, O and S), were synthesized and thoroughly characterized by ¹H NMR, IR, elemental analysis, and single crystal X-ray diffraction. The crystal structures of UO₂(tBu,MeO–saldien–X) showed that the U–X bond strength follows U–O ≈ U–NH > U–S. Conditional stability constants (β_X) of UO₂(tBu,MeO–saldien–X) in ethanol were investigated to understand the effect of X on thermodynamic stability. The log β_X decrease in the order of UO₂(tBu,MeO–saldien–NH) (log β_NH = 10) > UO₂(tBu,MeO–saldien–O) (log β_O = 7.24) > UO₂(tBu,MeO–saldien–S) (log β_S = 5.2). This trend cannot be explained only by Pearson's Hard and Soft Acids and Bases (HSAB) principle, but rather follows the order of basicity of X. Theoretical calculations of UO₂(tBu,MeO–saldien–X) suggested that the ionic character of U–X bonds decreases in the order of U–NH > U–O > U–S, while the covalency increases in the order U–O < U–NH < U–S. Redox potentials of all UO₂(tBu,MeO–saldien–X) in DMSO were similar to each other regardless of the difference in X. Spectroelectrochemical measurements and DFT calculations revealed that the center U⁶⁺ of each UO₂(tBu,MeO–saldien–X) undergoes one-electron reduction to afford the corresponding uranyl(v) complex. Consequently, the difference in X of UO₂(tBu,MeO–saldien–X) affects the coordination of tBu,MeO–saldien–X²⁻ with UO₂²⁺. However, the HSAB principle is not always prominent, but the Lewis basicity and balance between ionic and covalent characters of the U–X interactions are more relevant to determine the bond strengths.

The U–X bond strength and thermodynamic stability of uranyl(vi) complexes with pentadentate N₂O₂X₁-donating ligands (X = NH, O, S) are affected by the difference in X. In contrast, the X atom does not largely affect the redox behavior of the complexes.

Theoretical insights into the separation of Am(iii)/Eu(iii): designing ligands based on a preorganization strategy

The extraction behaviors of Am(iii) and Eu(iii) were investigated using phenanthroline and bipyridine ligands based on a preorganization strategy.

New tetradentate N,O-hybrid phenanthroline-derived organophosphorus extractants for the separation and complexation of trivalent actinides and lanthanides

Comparison of the extraction and separation properties between two novel phenanthroline-derived organophosphorus ligands, Et-Ph-BPPhen and Et-Ph-PIPhen.