Hürthle cell lesions of the thyroid: Progress made and challenges remaining

Oncocytic/Hürthle cell lesions have the same implied risk of neoplasm/malignancy as their follicular counterparts

INTRODUCTION

There are conflicting results on whether the presence of oncocytes modifies the risk of neoplasm (RON) or malignancy (ROM) for thyroid fine-needle aspirates (FNAs): Atypia of undetermined significance AUS and Follicular Neoplasm, FN, or Oncocytic Neoplasm, ON. To our knowledge, the effect of non-invasive follicular thyroid neoplasm with papillary-like nuclear features (NIFTP) has not yet been studied. We compared RON and ROM between follicular type AUS (AUS-FT) and oncocytic type AUS (AUS-OT) and between FN and ON.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively analysed all thyroid FNAs with the diagnostic category of AUS-other or Neoplasm (2005-2015). AUS-FT had predominance of microfollicles and AUS-OT had predominance of oncocytes. Histology follow-up was then reviewed and RON, ROM was then calculated and compared (significant at p < 0.05). We repeated the search for 2018 to evaluate for NIFTP effect.

RESULTS

Pre-NIFTP, 859/5063 cases (17%) were AUS-FT, AUS-OT, FN, and ON. Histology follow-up was available for 297 cases (35%). RON was 83/183 (45%) for AUS-FT, 35/76 (46%) for AUS-OT, 15/25 (60%) for FN and 11/13 (85%) for ON. Post-NIFTP, RON was 11/31 (35%) for AUS-FT, 5/8 (63%) for AUS-OT, 1/2 (50%) for FN and 4/5 (80%) for ON. For both periods, RON, ROM of AUS-FT was not significantly different than AUS-OT, and no significant differences were observed comparing FN and ON.

CONCLUSION

The predominance of oncocytes does not modify the implied RON, ROM for categories of AUS or FN\ON, even after the adoption of NIFTP.

A case series of thyroid fine needle aspiration biopsies diagnosed as follicular neoplasm with oncocytic features

Oncocytic lesions of the thyroid are a heterogeneous group encompassing nonneoplastic and neoplastic entities ranging from benign to malignant and have traditionally been classified as separate entities in thyroid pathology. To illustrate the diversity of these thyroid lesions, we describe three cases of fine needle aspiration biopsies (FNAB) diagnosed as Bethesda Category IV: Follicular neoplasm, oncocytic type, under the 2017 Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytopathology (TBSRTC), with ThyroSeq v3 molecular testing and subsequent surgical excision.

Diagnostic performance of molecular testing in indeterminate (Bethesda III and IV) thyroid nodules with Hürthle cell cytology

BACKGROUND

Indeterminate thyroid nodules with Hürthle cell cytology remain a diagnostic challenge. The low benign call rate and positive predictive value of first-generation molecular tests precluded their use to rule out malignancy. We examined the diagnostic performance of current tests.

METHOD

This subset analysis of our prospective randomized trial compared the benign call rate and positive predictive value of Afirma Gene Sequencing Classifier and Thyroseq v3 in Bethesda III and IV nodules with Hürthle cell cytology. Molecular test samples were obtained at initial fine-needle aspiration (8/2017-7/2022) and reflexively sent for processing.

RESULTS

Molecular testing was performed on 140 Hürthle cell nodules. Of 79 nodules tested with the Afirma Gene Sequencing Classifier, the benign call rate was 84% (66/79). Nine of 66 nodules with benign results were resected, with no malignancies. Twelve of 13 nodules with suspicious results were resected, revealing 3 malignancies-2 papillary thyroid carcinomas and one Hürthle cell carcinoma (positive predictive value 25%). Of 61 nodules tested with Thyroseq v3, the benign call rate was 56% (34/61; (P < .01 versus Afirma Gene Sequencing Classifier). Five of 34 nodules with negative results were resected, with no malignancies. Nineteen of 27 nodules with positive results were resected, revealing 3 malignancies-2 papillary thyroid carcinomas and 1 Hürthle cell carcinoma (positive predictive value 16%).

CONCLUSION

The high benign call rate of current molecular tests in Hürthle cell nodules strengthens their value in enabling patients to avoid surgery.

Indeterminate Thyroid Nodules and Advances in Molecular Pathology

Thyroid cytology has in recent years been augmented by molecular testing for indeterminate lesions. Three commercial molecular tests are available which provide variable amounts of detail regarding the genetic alterations identified in a sample. This paper will describe these tests, as well as the common molecular drivers associated with papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) and follicular patterned lesions, in order to help the practicing pathologist and clinician better interpret the results of these tests and incorporate this information into their management of cytologically indeterminate thyroid lesions.

PET/CT May Assist in Avoiding Pointless Thyroidectomy in Indeterminate Thyroid Nodules: A Narrative Review

Indeterminate thyroid nodules (ITN) are commonly encountered among the general population, with a malignancy rate of 10 to 40%. However, many patients may be overtreated with futile surgery for benign ITN. To avoid unnecessary surgery, PET/CT scan is a possible alternative to help differentiate between benign and malignant ITN. In this narrative review, the major results and limitations of the most recent studies on PET/CT efficacy (from PET/CT visual assessment to quantitative PET parameters and recent radiomic features analysis) and on cost-effectiveness (compared to other alternatives (such as surgery)) are presented. PET/CT can reduce futile surgery with visual assessment (around 40%; if ITN ≥ 10 mm). Moreover, PET/CT conventional parameters and radiomic features extracted from PET/CT imaging can be associated together in a predictive model to rule out malignancy in ITN, with a high NPV (96%) when certain criteria are met. Even though promising results were obtained in these recent PET/CT studies, further studies are needed to enable PET/CT to become the definitive diagnostic tool once a thyroid nodule is identified as indeterminate.

Oncocytic nodular hyperplasia of the thyroid

Nodular hyperplasia of the thyroid is a process whereby the gland experiences growth by nodular expansion of thyroid parenchyma. We have encountered 45 patients in whom the process was caused by the growth of well-defined and sharply circumscribed but unencapsulated nodules composed of oncocytic thyroid follicular cells. The lesions arose in 39 women and 6 men, aged 25-69 years (mean = 50.3 years). The surrounding thyroid parenchyma showed features of chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis. The nodules varied from microscopic to 5 cm and appeared to compress the surrounding thyroid parenchyma. Most of the lesions lacked a well-defined capsule. In 26 tumors, the nodules displayed a predominantly follicular pattern of growth; in 8 cases there were admixtures of follicular and trabecular patterns with focal solid areas devoid of follicles. Clinical follow-up in 39 patients ranging from 7 to 22 years (median = 16 years) showed no evidence of recurrence, metastasis, or malignant transformation. One patient died of unknown causes 15 years after the diagnosis, and another patient died 4 years after diagnosis from metastatic colonic adenocarcinoma. Oncocytic nodular hyperplasia is a benign process associated with chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis that should be distinguished from benign and malignant oncocytic (Hurthle cell) tumors of the thyroid.

Hürthle cell-predominant thyroid fine needle aspiration cytology: A four risk-factor model highly accurate in excluding malignancy and predicting neoplasm

Background

Interpretation of Hürthle cell‐predominant cytologies (HCP) is very challenging as a majority is diagnosed as indeterminate. Prior studies have reported various cytologic features to help distinguish non‐neoplastic (NN) from neoplastic and malignant lesions but had contradicting results. Our aim was to identify risk factors predictive of neoplasm and/or malignancy by correlating cytologic features with clinical and ultrasound findings.

Methods

Sixty‐nine HCP cases with surgical follow‐up were identified, including 35 NN, 20 adenomas, and 14 carcinomas. Ultrasound data were recorded utilizing Thyroid Imaging Reporting and Data System (TI‐RADS) and American Thyroid Association (ATA) scoring systems. Sixteen cytologic criteria were evaluated and semi‐quantitatively scored. Data were assessed by univariable, multivariable and stepwise logistic regression analysis; and statistical significance achieved at P‐value <0.05.

Results

On univariable analysis, significant predictors of neoplasm were high cellularity, isolated single cells, absent colloid, non‐uniform HC population (anisonucleosis), larger nodule size, and higher ATA score. Large‐cell dysplasia and transgressing blood vessels were not found to be significant factors. Multivariable analysis identified a combination of four risk factors (high cellularity, anisonucleosis, absent colloid, and size ≥2.9 cm) that was associated with neoplasm in 10/11 patients. None of 15 patients with zero or 1 out of 4 risk factors had malignancy or neoplasm on follow‐up. This model also significantly outperformed ATA and TI‐RADS scoring systems.

Conclusion

In the absence of four or three risk factors, the model excluded malignancy and neoplasm in all patients. The presence of all four factors predicted neoplasm and malignancy in 91% and 46% of cases, respectively.

Quantitative classification and radiomics of [18F]FDG-PET/CT in indeterminate thyroid nodules

PURPOSE

To evaluate whether quantitative [¹⁸F]FDG-PET/CT assessment, including radiomic analysis of [¹⁸F]FDG-positive thyroid nodules, improved the preoperative differentiation of indeterminate thyroid nodules of non-Hürthle cell and Hürthle cell cytology.

METHODS

Prospectively included patients with a Bethesda III or IV thyroid nodule underwent [¹⁸F]FDG-PET/CT imaging. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis was performed for standardised uptake values (SUV) and SUV-ratios, including assessment of SUV cut-offs at which a malignant/borderline neoplasm was reliably ruled out (≥ 95% sensitivity). [¹⁸F]FDG-positive scans were included in radiomic analysis. After segmentation at 50% of SUV_peak, 107 radiomic features were extracted from [¹⁸F]FDG-PET and low-dose CT images. Elastic net regression classifiers were trained in a 20-times repeated random split. Dimensionality reduction was incorporated into the splits. Predictive performance of radiomics was presented as mean area under the ROC curve (AUC) across the test sets.

RESULTS

Of 123 included patients, 84 (68%) index nodules were visually [¹⁸F]FDG-positive. The malignant/borderline rate was 27% (33/123). SUV-metrices showed AUCs ranging from 0.705 (95% CI, 0.601-0.810) to 0.729 (0.633-0.824), 0.708 (0.580-0.835) to 0.757 (0.650-0.864), and 0.533 (0.320-0.747) to 0.700 (0.502-0.898) in all (n = 123), non-Hürthle (n = 94), and Hürthle cell (n = 29) nodules, respectively. At SUV_max, SUV_peak, SUV_max-ratio, and SUV_peak-ratio cut-offs of 2.1 g/mL, 1.6 g/mL, 1.2, and 0.9, respectively, sensitivity of [¹⁸F]FDG-PET/CT was 95.8% (95% CI, 78.9-99.9%) in non-Hürthle cell nodules. In Hürthle cell nodules, cut-offs of 5.2 g/mL, 4.7 g/mL, 3.4, and 2.8, respectively, resulted in 100% sensitivity (95% CI, 66.4-100%). Radiomic analysis of 84 (68%) [¹⁸F]FDG-positive nodules showed a mean test set AUC of 0.445 (95% CI, 0.290-0.600) for the PET model.

CONCLUSION

Quantitative [¹⁸F]FDG-PET/CT assessment ruled out malignancy in indeterminate thyroid nodules. Distinctive, higher SUV cut-offs should be applied in Hürthle cell nodules to optimize rule-out ability. Radiomic analysis did not contribute to the additional differentiation of [¹⁸F]FDG-positive nodules.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

This trial is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT02208544 (5 August 2014), https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02208544 .

The dilemma of 18F-FDG PET/CT thyroid incidentaloma: what we should expect from FNA. A systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

¹⁸F-FDG thyroid incidentaloma (TI) occurs in ~2% of PET/CT examinations with a cancer prevalence of up to 35-40%. Guidelines recommend fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNA) if a focal ¹⁸F-FDG TI corresponds to a sonographic nodule >1 cm. The aim of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to provide evidence-based data on the diagnostic distribution of ¹⁸F-FDG TIs in the six Bethesda systems for reporting thyroid cytopathology (BETHESDA) subcategories.

METHODS

Original studies reporting ¹⁸F-FDG TIs and cytologically classified according to BETHESDA were included. Six separate meta-analyses were performed to obtain the pooled prevalence (95% confidence interval, 95% CI) of ¹⁸F-FDG TIs in the six BETHESDA subcategories.

RESULTS

Fifteen studies were finally included. Nine studies were from Asian/Eastern and six from Western countries. FNA data according to BETHESDA was available in 2304 cases. The pooled prevalence of ¹⁸F-FDG TIs according to BETHESDA was BETHESDA I 10% (6-14), BETHESDA II 45% (37-53), BETHESDA III 8% (3-13), BETHESDA IV 8% (5-12), BETHESDA V 6% (4-9), BETHESDA VI 19% (13-25). A significantly different prevalence was found in the BETHESDA IV between Asian/Eastern (2%) and Western (19%) studies.

CONCLUSION

Two-thirds of focal ¹⁸F-FDG TIs undergoing FNA have either malignant (BETHESDA VI) or benign (BETHESDA II) cytology while a minority will have indeterminate (BETHESDA III or IV) FNA results. Significant differences between Asian/Eastern and Western studies are also present in the prevalence of indeterminate FNA results.

Impact of molecular testing on detecting mimics of oncocytic neoplasms in thyroid fine-needle aspirates diagnosed as follicular neoplasm of Hürthle cell (oncocytic) type

BACKGROUND

Some thyroid nodules cytologically presenting as follicular neoplasm, Hürthle cell (Oncocytic) type (FNHCT), are not oncocytic tumors and represent autonomously functioning thyroid nodules (AFTNs) with TSHR, GNAS, and EZH1 mutations or oncocytic metaplasia. A to be defined subset of FNHCT harbors genome haploidisation-type DNA copy number alterations (GH-CNA). Molecular profiling of FNHCT may distinguish oncocytic neoplasms from its mimics.

METHODS

Consecutive fine-needle aspirates of 180 thyroid nodules over 37 months diagnosed as FNHCT and tested by ThyroSeq v3 were identified. Histologic follow-up was available for 79 of 180 nodules (44%).

RESULTS

No molecular alterations were found in 76 of 180 nodules (42%), of which 15 were resected (oncocytic metaplasia, n = 7; follicular oncocytic adenoma, n = 8). Of nodules followed without surgery, 17 of 101 (17%) showed TSHR, EZH1, and GNAS mutations of AFTNs. Papillary thyroid carcinoma was identified by BRAF V600E (n = 2) and hyalinizing trabecular adenoma by PAX8-GLIS3 (n = 1). GH-CNA alone was detected in 42 of 180 FNHCT nodules (23%), of which 29 were resected and histologically diagnosed as follicular oncocytic neoplasms. All remaining resected nodules were histologically proven oncocytic neoplasms: 1) RAS-like alterations without GH-CNA (n = 25) and 2) TERT and/or TP53 mutations co-occurring with GH-CNA (n = 6), including anaplastic thyroid carcinoma arising from follicular oncocytic carcinoma with TP53, TERT mutations with GH-CNA (n = 2).

CONCLUSIONS

A proportion of FNHCT nodules are AFTNs and oncocytic metaplasias, which can be suspected based on characteristic mutations or lack of alterations on molecular testing. Among resected FNHCTs, GH-CNAs characterize approximately half of histologically confirmed follicular oncocytic neoplasms.

Challenges in Cytology Specimens With Hürthle Cells

In fine-needle aspirations (FNA) of thyroid, Hürthle cells can be found in a broad spectrum of lesions, ranging from non-neoplastic conditions to aggressive malignant tumors. Recognize them morphologically, frequently represents a challenging for an adequately diagnosis and are associated with a significant interobserver variability. Although the limitations of the morphologic diagnosis still exist, the interpretation of the context where the cells appear and the recent advances in the molecular knowledge of Hürthle cells tumors are contributing for a more precise diagnosis. This review aims to describe the cytology aspects of all Hürthle cells neoplastic and non-neoplastic thyroid lesions, focusing on the differential diagnosis and reporting according to The Bethesda System for Reporting Thyroid Cytology (TBSRTC). New entities according to the latest World Health Organization (WHO) classification are included, as well as an update of the current molecular data.

Genetics, Diagnosis, and Management of Hürthle Cell Thyroid Neoplasms

Hürthle cell lesions have been a diagnostic conundrum in pathology since they were first recognized over a century ago. Controversy as to the name of the cell, the origin of the cell, and even which cells in particular may be designated as such still challenge pathologists and confound those treating patients with a diagnosis of "Hürthle cell" anything within the diagnosis, especially if that anything is a sizable mass lesion. The diagnosis of Hürthle cell adenoma (HCA) or Hürthle cell carcinoma (HCC) has typically relied on a judgement call by pathologists as to the presence or absence of capsular and/or vascular invasion of the adjacent thyroid parenchyma, easy to note in widely invasive disease and a somewhat subjective diagnosis for minimally invasive or borderline invasive disease. Diagnostic specificity, which has incorporated a sharp increase in molecular genetic studies of thyroid tumor subtypes and the integration of molecular testing into preoperative management protocols, continues to be challenged by Hürthle cell neoplasia. Here, we provide the improving yet still murky state of what is known about Hürthle cell tumor genetics, clinical management, and based upon what we are learning about the genetics of other thyroid tumors, how to manage expectations, by pathologists, clinicians, and patients, for more actionable, precise classifications of Hürthle cell tumors of the thyroid.