Analysis of tenodesis techniques for treatment of scapholunate instability using the finite element method

Finite Element Modeling of the Human Wrist: A Review

Background  Understanding wrist biomechanics is important to appreciate and treat the wrist joint. Numerical methods, specifically, finite element method (FEM), have been used to overcome experimental methods' limitations. Due to the complexity of the wrist and difficulty in modeling, there is heterogeneity and lack of consistent methodology in the published studies, challenging our ability to incorporate information gleaned from the various studies. Questions/Purposes  This study summarizes the use of FEM to study the wrist in the last decade. Methods  We included studies published from 2012 to 2022 from databases: EBSCO, Research4Life, ScienceDirect, and Scopus. Twenty-two studies were included. Results  FEM used to study wrist in general, pathology, and treatment include diverse topics and are difficult to compare directly. Most studies evaluate normal wrist mechanics, all modeling the bones, with fewer studies including cartilage and ligamentous structures in the model. The dynamic effect of the tendons on wrist mechanics is rarely accounted for. Conclusion  Due to the complexity of wrist mechanics, the current literature remains incomplete. Considering published strategies and modeling techniques may aid in the development of more comprehensive and improved wrist model fidelity.

Load Distribution in Dorsally-Angulated Distal Radius Deformity Using Finite Element Analysis

PURPOSE

The load axis of the carpals is located on the volar side of the normal distal radius. A volar lunate facet fracture (VLFF) is exposed to volar-shearing stress, which can cause volar displacement of the carpus. A previous biomechanical study reported that the load at the scaphoid fossa was located more dorsally and the pressure at the lunate fossa decreased in a dorsally-angulated model. However, the distal radius load distribution for various volar tilts remains unclear. We speculate that if the volar tilt decreases, the load distribution moves dorsally and decreases the stress on the VLFF. Therefore, we analyzed a dorsally-angulated distal radius model to evaluate changes in the load distribution using finite element analysis.

METHODS

A 3-dimensional finite element wrist model was developed using computed tomography images. The ligaments were modeled as tension-only spring elements. We considered the intact wrist model for a volar tilt of 15° and created 5 additional models for volar tilts of 10°, 5°, 0°, -5°, and -10°.

RESULTS

As the dorsal angulation increased, the stress distribution moved from volar to dorsal and from the lunate fossa toward the scaphoid fossa. The maximum stress on the volar lunate facet was reduced as volar tilt decreased. The maximum stress was higher on the lunate fossa for volar tilts from 15° to 5°. In contrast, the maximum stress was higher on the scaphoid fossa for volar tilts of ≤0°.

CONCLUSIONS

Load transmission moved from volar to dorsal and from the lunate fossa to the scaphoid fossa when the volar tilt decreased. Therefore, a decrease in the volar tilt would reduce the load on the VLFF.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

This study provides surgeons accurate knowledge regarding load distribution of the distal radius for various volar tilts that could be helpful in treating patients with VLFFs.

A Biomechanical Evaluation of the ECRL Tenodesis for Reconstruction of the Scapholunate Ligament

PURPOSE

Reconstruction of the scapholunate ligament (SLL) in the setting of dynamic instability remains a surgical challenge, with lack of consensus on the best reconstructive procedure. Reconstruction of only the dorsal component may lead to volar gapping and abnormal wrist kinematics. This cadaveric active motion simulation study determined whether scapholunate (SL) motion, angulation, and contact are restored following open reconstruction using the extensor carpi radialis longus (ECRL) tenodesis, which reconstructs both the volar and the dorsal SLL components.

METHODS

Seven fresh-frozen cadaveric upper limbs (mean age, 68 ± 10.1 years) underwent a 4-stage protocol of cyclic dart-throw motion and flexion-extension motion (utilizing an active wrist motion simulator that used tendon load/motion-controlled actuation. Scaphoid and lunate motion, relative scaphoid translation, SL angle, and dorsal-volar SL diastasis were measured with (1) wrist ligaments intact, (2) following complete sectioning of the SLL, and (3) following SL reconstruction using the ECRL tenodesis technique.

RESULTS

Complete SLL sectioning resulted in a typical pattern of SL instability. Following the ECRL tenodesis, lunate extension was not corrected. Scaphoid flexion, however, was not significantly different from the native state in FEM but remained significantly flexed during dart-throw motion. Differential dorsal and volar gapping did not significantly improve following ECRL tenodesis (dorsal, 1.2-2.3 mm; volar, 1.1-1.7 mm).

CONCLUSIONS

This biomechanical study demonstrates that the ECRL tenodesis did not fully restore native carpal kinematics, despite dorsal and volar SLL, and scaphotrapeziotrapezoid reconstruction.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

A biomechanical analysis of 3D stress and strain patterns in patellar tendon during knee flexion

Patellar tendinopathy is among the most widespread patellar tendon diseases in athletes that participate in activities involving running and jumping. Although their symptoms can be detected, especially at the inferior pole of the patella, their biomechanical cause remains unknown. In this study, a three-dimensional finite element model of knee complex was developed to investigate principal stress and strain distributions in the patellar tendon during 0° to 90° knee flexion and slow and fast level-ground walking. Results indicate that the patellar tendon is subjected to tensile stress and strains during all three activities. During flexion, its central proximal posterior region exhibited highest peak stress and strain, followed by central distal posterior, central distal anterior and central proximal anterior region. Similar trends and magnitudes were reported during slow and fast walking. The region with highest principal stresses and strains, central proximal anterior region, also corresponds to the most commonly reported patellar tendinopathy lesion site, suggesting that principal stress and strain are good indicators of lesion site location. Additional factors such as regional variations in material properties and frequency and duration of cyclic loading also need to be considered when determining the biomechanical aetiology of patellar tendinopathy.

Performance evaluation of surgical techniques for treatment of scapholunate instability in a type II wrist

We investigated the performance of three tenodesis techniques, modified Brunelli, Corella, and scapholunate axis (SLAM) methods in repairing scapholunate interosseous ligament (SLIL) disruption for a type II wrist using finite element-based virtual surgery and compared the results with those of a previous investigation for a type I wrist. In addition, a comparison of the carpal mechanics of type I and type II wrists was undertaken in order to elucidate the difference between the two types. For the type II wrist, following simulated SLIL disruption, the Corella reconstruction technique provided a superior outcome, restoring dorsal gap, volar gap, and SL angle to within 3.5%, 7.1%, and 8.4%, respectively, of the intact wrist. Moreover, application of the ligament reconstruction techniques did not significantly alter the motion pattern of the type II and type I wrists. For the type I wrist, SLIL disruption resulted in no contact between scaphoid-lunate cartilage articulation, whereas for the type II wrist, some contact was maintained. We conclude that the Corella ligamentous reconstruction technique is best able to restore SL gap, angle, and stability following SL ligament injury for both type II and type I wrists and is able to do so without altering wrist kinematics. Our findings also support the view that type I wrists exhibit row behaviour and type II wrists column behaviour. In addition, our analysis suggests that the extra articulation between the lunate and hamate in a type II wrist may help improve stability following SL ligament injury.

Evaluation of the performance of three tenodesis techniques for the treatment of scapholunate instability: flexion-extension and radial-ulnar deviation

Chronic scapholunate ligament (SL) injuries are difficult to treat and can lead to wrist dysfunction. Whilst several tendon reconstruction techniques have been employed in the management of SL instability, SL gap reappearance after surgery has been reported. Using a finite element model and cadaveric study data, we investigated the performance of the Corella, scapholunate axis (SLAM) and modified Brunelli tenodesis (MBT) techniques. Scapholunate dorsal and volar gap and angle were obtained following virtual surgery undertaken using each of the three reconstruction methods with the wrist positioned in flexion, extension, ulnar deviation and radial deviation, in addition to the ulnar-deviated clenched fist and neutral positions. From the study, it was found that, following simulated scapholunate interosseous ligament rupture, the Corella technique was better able to restore the SL gap and angle close to the intact ligament for all wrist positions investigated, followed by SLAM and MBT. The results suggest that for the tendon reconstruction techniques, the use of multiple junction points between scaphoid and lunate may be of benefit.

Graphical abstract