Evidence of a Folding Intermediate in RNase H from Single‐Molecule FRET Experiments

FRET-based dynamic structural biology: Challenges, perspectives and an appeal for open-science practices

Single-molecule FRET (smFRET) has become a mainstream technique for studying biomolecular structural dynamics. The rapid and wide adoption of smFRET experiments by an ever-increasing number of groups has generated significant progress in sample preparation, measurement procedures, data analysis, algorithms and documentation. Several labs that employ smFRET approaches have joined forces to inform the smFRET community about streamlining how to perform experiments and analyze results for obtaining quantitative information on biomolecular structure and dynamics. The recent efforts include blind tests to assess the accuracy and the precision of smFRET experiments among different labs using various procedures. These multi-lab studies have led to the development of smFRET procedures and documentation, which are important when submitting entries into the archiving system for integrative structure models, PDB-Dev. This position paper describes the current 'state of the art' from different perspectives, points to unresolved methodological issues for quantitative structural studies, provides a set of 'soft recommendations' about which an emerging consensus exists, and lists openly available resources for newcomers and seasoned practitioners. To make further progress, we strongly encourage 'open science' practices.

Probing Deviation of Adhered Membrane Dynamics between Reconstituted Liposome and Cellular System

The dynamics of cell-cell adhesion are complicated due to complexities in cellular interactions and intra-membrane interactions. In the present work, we have reconstituted a liposome-based model system to mimic the cell-cell adhesion process. Our model liposome system consists of one fluorescein-tagged and one TRITC (tetramethyl-rhodamine isothiocyanate)-tagged liposome, adhered through biotin-neutravidin interaction. We monitored the adhesion process in liposomes using Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) between fluorescein (donor) and TRITC (acceptor). Occurrence of FRET is confirmed by the decrease in donor lifetime as well as distinct rise time of the acceptor fluorescence. Interestingly, the acceptor's emission exhibits fluctuations in the range of ≈3±1 s. This may be attributed to structural oscillations associated in two adhered liposomes arising from the flexible nature of biotin-neutravidin interaction. We have compared the dynamics in a cell-mimicking liposome system with that in an in vitro live cell system. In the adhered live cell system, we used CPM (7-diethylamino-3-(4-maleimido-phenyl)-4-methylcoumarin, donor) and nile red (acceptor), which are known to stain the membrane of CHO (Chinese Hamster Ovary) cells. The dynamics of the adhered membranes of two live CHO cells were observed through FRET between CPM and nile red. The acceptor fluorescence intensity exhibits an oscillation in the time-scale of ≈1±0.75 s, which is faster compared to the reconstituted liposome system, indicating the contributions and involvement of multiple dynamic protein complexes around the cell membrane. This study offers simple reconstituted model systems to understand the complex membrane dynamics using a FRET-based physical chemistry approach.

Packing energetics determine the folding routes of the RNase-H proteins

The RNase-H proteins show a diverse range of folding routes with structurally distinct folding nuclei.

Fast Folding Dynamics of an Intermediate State in RNase H Measured by Single-Molecule FRET

We have studied the folding kinetics of the core intermediate (I) state of RNase H by using a combination of single-molecule FRET (smFRET) and hidden Markov model analysis. To measure fast dynamics in thermal equilibrium as a function of the concentration of the denaturant GdmCl, a special FRET labeled variant, RNase H 60-113, which is sensitive to folding of the protein core, was immobilized on PEGylated surfaces. Conformational transitions between the unfolded (U) state and the I state could be described by a two-state model within our experimental time resolution, with millisecond mean residence times. The I state population was always a minority species in the entire accessible range of denaturant concentrations. By introducing the measured free energy differences between the U and I states as constraints in global fits of the GdmCl dependence of FRET histograms of a differently labeled RNase H variant (RNase H 3-135), we were able to reveal the free energy differences and, thus, population ratios of all three macroscopic state ensembles, U, I and F (folded state) as a function of denaturant concentration.

Functionally Relevant Specific Packing Can Determine Protein Folding Routes

Functional residues can modulate the folding mechanisms of proteins. In some proteins, mutations to such residues can radically change the primary folding route. Is it possible then to learn more about the functional regions of a protein by investigating just its choice of folding route? The folding and the function of the protein Escherichia coli ribonuclease H (ecoRNase-H) have been extensively studied and its folding route is known to near-residue resolution. Here, we computationally study the folding of ecoRNase-H using molecular dynamics simulations of structure-based models of increasing complexity. The differences between a model that correctly predicts the experimentally determined folding route and a simpler model that does not can be attributed to a set of six aromatic residues clustered together in a region of the protein called CORE. This clustering, which we term "specific" packing, drives CORE to fold early and determines the folding route. Both the residues involved in specific packing and their packing are largely conserved across E. coli-like RNase-Hs from diverse species. Residue conservation is usually implicated in function. Here, the identified residues either are known to bind substrate in ecoRNase-H or pack against the substrate in the homologous human RNase-H where a substrate-bound crystal structure exists. Thus, the folding mechanism of ecoRNase-H is a byproduct of functional demands upon its sequence. Using our observations on specific packing, we suggest mutations to an engineered HIV RNase-H to make its function better. Our results show that understanding folding route choice in proteins can provide unexpected insights into their function.

Evidence for the sequential folding mechanism in RNase H from an ensemble-based model

The number of distinct protein folding pathways starting from an unfolded ensemble, and hence, the folding mechanism is an intricate function of protein size, sequence complexity, and stability conditions. This has traditionally been a contentious issue particularly because of the ensemble nature of conventional experiments that can mask the complexity of the underlying folding landscape. Recent hydrogen-exchange experiments combined with mass spectrometry (HX-MS) reveal that the folding of RNase H proceeds in a hierarchical fashion with distinct intermediates and following a single discrete path. In our current work, we provide computational evidence for this unique folding mechanism by employing a structure-based statistical mechanical model. Upon calibrating the energetic terms of the model with equilibrium measurements, we predict multiple intermediate states in the folding of RNase H that closely resemble experimental observations. Remarkably, a simplified landscape representation adequately captures the folding complexity and predicts the possibility of a well-defined sequence of folding events. We supplement the statistical model study with both explicit solvent molecular simulations of the helical units and electrostatic calculations to provide structural and energetic insights into the early and late stages of RNase H folding that hint at the frustrated nature of its folding landscape.

Single-molecule FRET studies of RNA folding: a Diels-Alderase ribozyme with photolabile nucleotide modifications

Enzymology at the single-molecule level by using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (smFRET) offers unprecedented insight into mechanistic aspects of catalytic reactions. Implementing spatiotemporal control of the reaction by using an external trigger is highly valuable in these challenging experiments. Here, we have incorporated a light-cleavable caging moiety into specific nucleotides of the Diels-Alderase (DAse) ribozyme. In this way, the folding energy landscape was significantly perturbed, and the catalytic activity was essentially suppressed. A careful smFRET efficiency histogram analysis at various Mg(2+) ion concentrations revealed an additional intermediate state that is not observed for the unmodified DAse ribozyme. We also observed that only a fraction of DAse molecules returns to the native state upon cleavage of the caged group by UV light. These constructs are attractive model RNA systems for further real-time single-molecule observation of the coupling between conformational changes and catalytic activity.

Self-assembly of Acridine Orange into H-aggregates at the air/water interface: tuning of orientation of headgroup

The surface active derivative of the organic dye Acridine Orange (N-10-dodecyl-acridine orange (DAO)) has been included in mixed Langmuir monolayers with stearic acid (SA). The maximum relative content on DAO for a stable mixed monolayer is a molar ratio of X(DAO) = 0.5. Brewster angle microscopy (BAM) reveals a high homogeneity at the micrometer level for the mixed monolayer in equimolar proportion (X(DAO) = 0.5), whereas the appearance of domains occurs for lower content of DAO, i.e., X(DAO) = 0.2 and 0.1. The aggregation of the DAO headgroup leads to well-defined H-aggregates at the air/water interface for those mixed monolayers with a low content of DAO. However, for the mixed monolayers enriched in DAO, e.g., X(DAO) = 0.5, the molecular crowding prevents the formation of defined supramolecular structures. Molecular organization and tilting of the DAO headgroup is quantitatively analyzed by in situ UV-visible reflection spectroscopy. The formation of H-aggregates of the DAO headgroup can be reversibly tuned with the applied surface pressure. A molecular mechanism for the conformational rearrangement of the DAO molecule is proposed using RM1 quantum semiempirical calculations.

How, when and why proteins collapse: the relation to folding

Unfolded proteins under strongly denaturing conditions are highly expanded. However, when the conditions are more close to native, an unfolded protein may collapse to a compact globular structure distinct from the folded state. This transition is akin to the coil-globule transition of homopolymers. Single-molecule FRET experiments have been particularly conducive in revealing the collapsed state under conditions of coexistence with the folded state. The collapse can be even more readily observed in natively unfolded proteins. Time-resolved studies, using FRET and small-angle scattering, have shown that the collapse transition is a very fast event, probably occurring on the submicrosecond time scale. The forces driving collapse are likely to involve both hydrophobic and backbone interactions. The loss of configurational entropy during collapse makes the unfolded state less stable compared to the folded state, thus facilitating folding.