Development and Bioequivalence of 3D-Printed Medication at the Point-of-Care: Bridging the Gap Toward Personalized Medicine

Spiked Systems for Colonic Drug Delivery: Architectural Opportunities and Quality Assurance of Selective Laser Sintering

Additive manufacturing has been a breakthrough therapy for the pharmaceutical industry raising opportunities for long-quested properties, such as controlled drug-delivery. The aim of this study was to explore the geometrical capabilities of selective laser sintering (SLS) by creating spiked (tapered-edged) drug-loaded specimens for administration in colon. Poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) was used as the binding material and loperamide hydrochloride was incorporated as the active ingredient. Printing was feasible without the addition of a sintering agent or other additives. Innovative printing protocols were developed to help improve the quality of the obtained products. Intentional vibrations were applied on the powder bed through rapid movements of the printing platform in order to facilitate rigidity and consistency of the printed objects. The drug-loaded products had physicochemical properties that met the pharmacopoeia standards and exhibited good biocompatibility. The behavior of spiked balls (spherical objects with prominent spikes) and their retention time in the colon was assessed using a custom ex vivo intestinal setup. The spiked balls showed favorable mucoadhesive properties over the unspiked ones. No movement on the tissue was recorded for the spiked balls, and specimens with more spikes exhibited longer retention times and potentially, enhanced bioavailability. Our results suggest that SLS 3D printing is a versatile technology that holds the potential to revolutionize drug delivery systems by enabling the creation of complex geometries and medications with tunable properties.

What Does Pharmaceutical 3D Printing Cost? A Framework and Case Study with Hydrocortisone for Adrenal Insufficiency

BACKGROUND

Pharmaceutical three-dimensional printing (3DP) technology offers an automated platform that can be utilized to manufacture personalized medicine, improving pharmacotherapy. Although 3D-printed products have entered clinical trials, no costing studies have been performed yet. Cost insights can aid researchers and industry in making informed decisions about the feasibility and scalability of 3DP.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this research was therefore to develop a framework that can be utilized to estimate the manufacturing cost of one 3D tablet in a hospital pharmacy setting.

METHODS

To develop the costing framework, general manufacturing phases were identified, consisting of (i) pre-printing, (ii) printing, and (iii) post-printing. For each phase, cost categories were defined, including personnel, materials, equipment, facility, and quality assurance. The three phases combined with the categories formed the base of the costing framework. An earlier developed 3D-printed hydrocortisone formulation (M3DICORT) was used as a case study. Costs were expressed in 2022 euros (€). The framework was applied to M3DICORT in four scenarios: a base case scenario, worst-case scenario, best-case scenario, and a scaling scenario. In the scaling scenario, we assumed that 3D inks were mass produced.

RESULTS

Costs of manufacturing a single M3DICORT tablet were €1.97-3.11 (best-case-worst-case) and €1.58-2.26 for the scaling scenario.

CONCLUSION

Manufacturing costs of 3D-printed pharmaceuticals were thus far unknown. The framework is translated into an open-access costing tool to facilitate adoption by other parties, and is also applicable for other pharmaceutical 3DP techniques.

3D printing of pharmaceutical dosage forms: Recent advances and applications

Three-dimensional (3D) printing, also referred to as additive manufacturing, is considered to be a game-changing technology in many industries and is also considered to have potential use cases in pharmaceutical manufacturing, especially if individualization is desired. In this review article the authors systematically researched literature published during the last 5 years (2019 - spring 2024) on the topic of 3D printed dosage forms. Besides all kinds of oral dosage forms ranging from tablets and capsules to films, pellets, etc., numerous reports were also identified on parenteral and cutaneous dosage forms and also rectal, vaginal, dental, intravesical, and ophthalmic preparations. In total, more than 500 publications were identified and grouped according to the site of administration, and an overview of the manuscripts is presented here. Furthermore, selected publications are described and discussed in more detail. The review highlights the very different approaches that are currently used in order to develop 3D printed dosage forms but also addresses remaining challenges.

Optimising 3D printed medications for rare diseases: In-line mass uniformity testing in direct powder extrusion 3D printing

Biotinidase deficiency is a rare inherited disorder characterized by biotin metabolism issues, leading to neurological and cutaneous symptoms that can be alleviated through biotin administration. Three-dimensional (3D) printing (3DP) offers potential for personalized medicine production for rare diseases, due to its flexibility in designing dosage forms and controlling release profiles. For such point-of-care applications, rigorous quality control (QC) measures are essential to ensure precise dosing, optimal performance, and product safety, especially for low personalized doses in preclinical and clinical studies. In this work, we addressed QC challenges by integrating a precision balance into a direct powder extrusion pharmaceutical 3D printer (M3DIMAKER™) for real-time, in-line mass uniformity testing, a critical quality control step. Small and large capsule-shaped biotin printlets (3D printed tablets) for immediate- and extended-release were printed. The integrated balance monitored and registered each printlet's weight, identifying any deviations from acceptable limits. While all large printlet batches met mass uniformity criteria, some small printlet batches exhibited weight deviations. In vitro release studies showed large immediate-release printlets releasing 82% of biotin within 45 min, compared to 100% for small immediate-release printlets. For extended-release formulations, 35% of the drug was released from small printlets, whereas 24% was released from large printlets at the same time point. The integration of process analytical technology tools in 3DP shows promise in enhancing QC and scalability of personalized dosing at the point-of-care, demonstrating successful integration of a balance into a direct powder extrusion 3D printer for in-line mass uniformity testing across different sizes of capsule-shaped printlets.

3D printed personalized therapies for pediatric patients affected by adrenal insufficiency

BACKGROUND

Adrenal insufficiency is usually diagnosed in children who will need lifelong hydrocortisone therapy. However, medicines for pediatrics, in terms of dosage and acceptability, are currently unavailable.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

Semi-solid extrusion (SSE) 3D printing (3DP) was utilized for manufacturing of personalized and chewable hydrocortisone formulations (printlets) for an upcoming clinical study in children at Vall d'Hebron University Hospital in Barcelona, Spain. The 3DP process was validated using a specific software for dynamic dose modulation.

RESULTS

The printlets contained doses ranging from 1 to 6 mg hydrocortisone in three different flavor and color combinations to aid adherence among the pediatric patients. The pharma-ink (mixture of drugs and excipients) was assessed for its rheological behavior to ensure reproducibility of printlets through repeated printing cycles. The printlets showed immediate hydrocortisone release and were stable for 1 month of storage, adequate for prescribing instructions during the clinical trial.

CONCLUSIONS

The results confirm the suitability and safety of the developed printlets for use in the clinical trial. The required technical information from The Spanish Medicines Agency for this clinical trial application was compiled to serve as guidelines for healthcare professionals seeking to apply for and conduct clinical trials on 3DP oral dosage forms.

Application of 3D printing on the design and development of pharmaceutical oral dosage forms

3D printing technologies confer an unparalleled degree of control over the material distribution on the structures they produce, which has led them to become an extremely attractive research topic in pharmaceutical dosage form development, especially for the design of personalized treatments. With fine tuning in material selection and careful design, these technologies allow to tailor not only the amount of drug administered but the biopharmaceutical behaviour of the dosage forms as well. While fused deposition modelling (FDM) is still the most studied 3D printing technology in this area, others are gaining more relevance, which has led to many new and exciting dosage forms developed during 2022 and 2023. Considering that these technologies, in time, will join the current manufacturing methods and with the ever-increasing knowledge on this topic, our review aims to explore the advantages and limitations of 3D printing technologies employed in the design and development of pharmaceutical oral dosage forms, giving special focus to the most important aspects governing the resulting drug release profiles.

Lessons to Learn for 3D Printing of Drug Products by Semisolid Extrusion (SSE)

Semisolid extrusion (SSE) 3D printing (3DP) technology is emerging due to its simplicity and potential for on-site manufacturing of personalized drug products with tailored functionality (dose, release profile), as well as recognizability (size, shape, color). However, even a minor change in the composition of the ink (the feedstock material) and the printing process parameters can largely influence the outcome of printing. This paper summarizes the recent SSE 3DP studies, where the important factors affecting the quality of the printed drug products are discussed. Further challenges are showcased by introducing a case study focusing on the design of oral theophylline immediate-release drug products. The identified crucial factors, such as the printing hardware and connected software, printing parameters, and composition of the ink are discussed. Especially, the rheological properties of the ink during the printing process, together with solidification, mechanical properties, and morphology studies of already printed products are deliberated to gain more understanding of the printability of drug products by SSE. This work aims to provide an overview of design aspects related to SSE-based fabrication of personalized drug products.

Developing an innovative 3D printing platform for production of personalised medicines in a hospital for the OPERA clinical trial

Breast cancer is the most frequently diagnosed cancer in women worldwide, and non-adherence to adjuvant hormonotherapy can negatively impact cancer recurrence and relapse. Non-adherence is associated with side effects of hormonotherapy. Pharmacological strategies to mitigate the side effects include coadministration of antidepressants, however patients remain non-adherent. The aim of this work was to develop medicines containing both hormonotherapy, tamoxifen (20 mg), along with anti-depressants, either venlafaxine (37.5 or 75 mg) or duloxetine (30 or 60 mg), to assess the acceptability and efficacy of this personalised approach for mitigating tamoxifen side effects in a clinical trial. A major criterion for the developed medicines was the production rate, specified at minimum 200 dosage units per hour to produce more than 40,000 units required for the clinical trial. A novel capsule filling approach enabled by the pharmaceutical 3D printer M3DIMAKER 2 was developed for this purpose. Firstly, semi-solid extrusion 3D printing enabled the filling of tamoxifen pharma-ink prepared according to French compounding regulation, followed by filling of commercial venlafaxine or duloxetine pellets enabled by the development of an innovative pellet dispensing printhead. The medicines were successfully developed and produced in the clinical pharmacy department of the cancer hospital Gustave Roussy, located in Paris, France. The developed medicines satisfied quality and production rate requirements and were stable for storage up to one year to cover the duration of the trial. This work demonstrates the feasibility of developing and producing combined tamoxifen medicines in a hospital setting through a pharmaceutical 3D printer to enable a clinical trial with a high medicines production rate requirement.

Paediatric clinical study of 3D printed personalised medicines for rare metabolic disorders

Rare diseases are infrequent, but together they affect up to 6-10 % of the world's population, mainly children. Patients require precise doses and strict adherence to avoid metabolic or cardiac failure in some cases, which cannot be addressed in a reliable way using pharmaceutical compounding. 3D printing (3DP) is a disruptive technology that allows the real-time personalization of the dose and the modulation of the dosage form to adapt the medicine to the therapeutic needs of each patient. 3D printed chewable medicines containing amino acids (citrulline, isoleucine, valine, and isoleucine and valine combinations) were prepared in a hospital setting, and the efficacy and acceptability were evaluated in comparison to conventional compounded medicines in six children. The inclusion of new flavours (lemon, vanilla and peach) to obtain more information on patient preferences and the implementation of a mobile app to obtain patient feedback in real-time was also used. The 3D printed medicines controlled amino acid levels within target levels as well as the conventional medicines. The deviation of citrulline levels was narrower and closer within the target concentration with the chewable formulations. According to participants' responses, the chewable formulations were well accepted and can improve adherence and quality of life. For the first time, 3DP enabled two actives to be combined in the same formulation, reducing the number of administrations. This study demonstrated the benefits of preparing 3D printed personalized treatments for children diagnosed with rare metabolic disorders using a novel technology in real clinical practice.

Automated Non-Sterile Pharmacy Compounding: A Multi-Site Study in European Hospital and Community Pharmacies with Pediatric Immediate Release Propranolol Hydrochloride Tablets

Pharmacy compounding, the art and science of preparing customized medications to meet individual patient needs, is on the verge of transformation. Traditional methods of compounding often involve manual and time-consuming processes, presenting challenges in terms of consistency, dosage accuracy, quality control, contamination, and scalability. However, the emergence of cutting-edge technologies has paved a way for a new era for pharmacy compounding, promising to redefine the way medications are prepared and delivered as pharmacy-tailored personalized medicines. In this multi-site study, more than 30 hospitals and community pharmacies from eight countries in Europe utilized a novel automated dosing approach inspired by 3D printing for the compounding of non-sterile propranolol hydrochloride tablets. CuraBlend® excipient base, a GMP-manufactured excipient base (pharma-ink) intended for automated compounding applications, was used. A standardized study protocol to test the automated dosing of tablets with variable weights was performed in all participating pharmacies in four different iterative phases. Integrated quality control was performed with an in-process scale and NIR spectroscopy supported by HPLC content uniformity measurements. In total, 6088 propranolol tablets were produced at different locations during this study. It was shown that the dosing accuracy of the process increased from about 90% to 100% from Phase 1 to Phase 4 by making improvements to the formulation and the hardware solutions. The results indicate that through this automated and quality controlled compounding approach, extemporaneous pharmacy manufacturing can take a giant leap forward towards automation and digital manufacture of dosage forms in hospital pharmacies and compounding pharmacies.

Perspectives on 3D printed personalized medicines for pediatrics

In recent years, the rapid advancement of three-dimensional (3D) printing technology has yielded distinct benefits across various sectors, including pharmaceuticals. The pharmaceutical industry has particularly experienced advantages from the utilization of 3D-printed medications, which have invigorated the development of tailored drug formulations. The approval of 3D-printed drugs by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has significantly propelled personalized drug delivery. Additionally, 3D printing technology can accommodate the precise requirements of pediatric drug dosages and the complexities of multiple drug combinations. This review specifically concentrates on the application of 3D printing technology in pediatric preparations, encompassing a broad spectrum of uses and refined pediatric formulations. It compiles and evaluates the fundamental principles associated with the application of 3D printing technology in pediatric preparations, including its merits and demerits, and anticipates its future progression. The objective is to furnish theoretical underpinning for 3D printing technology to facilitate personalized drug delivery in pediatrics and to advocate for its implementation in clinical settings.

3D Printing of Dietary Products for the Management of Inborn Errors of Intermediary Metabolism in Pediatric Populations

The incidence of Inborn Error of Intermediary Metabolism (IEiM) diseases may be low, yet collectively, they impact approximately 6-10% of the global population, primarily affecting children. Precise treatment doses and strict adherence to prescribed diet and pharmacological treatment regimens are imperative to avert metabolic disturbances in patients. However, the existing dietary and pharmacological products suffer from poor palatability, posing challenges to patient adherence. Furthermore, frequent dose adjustments contingent on age and drug blood levels further complicate treatment. Semi-solid extrusion (SSE) 3D printing technology is currently under assessment as a pioneering method for crafting customized chewable dosage forms, surmounting the primary limitations prevalent in present therapies. This method offers a spectrum of advantages, including the flexibility to tailor patient-specific doses, excipients, and organoleptic properties. These elements are pivotal in ensuring the treatment's efficacy, safety, and adherence. This comprehensive review presents the current landscape of available dietary products, diagnostic methods, therapeutic monitoring, and the latest advancements in SSE technology. It highlights the rationale underpinning their adoption while addressing regulatory aspects imperative for their seamless integration into clinical practice.

Quality attributes for printable emulsion gels and 3D-printed tablets: Towards production of personalized dosage forms

3D-printing technology offers a flexible manufacturing platform with the potential to address the need of personalized dosage forms. However, quality aspects of such small-scale, on-demand production of pharmaceutical products intended for personalization is still limited. The aim of this study was therefore to study critical quality control attributes of lipid tablets produced by semi-solid extrusion (SSE) 3D printing from emulsion gels incorporating a poorly water-soluble drug. Quality attributes for both the printable emulsion gel and the printed dosage forms were assessed. The emulsion gel was shown to be printable with accurate dosing for at least one month of storage at 4 °C. Tablets were 3D printed in different sizes and a correlation, R2 value of 0.99, was found between the weight and the drug content. The 3D-printed tablets complied with the mass and drug content uniformity requirements described in the European Pharmacopoeia.. Solid-state characterization of the tablets during short-term storage revealed no signs of crystallinity of the drug. Lastly, the lipid digestion and drug release were unchanged after short-term storage of the tablets. This study demonstrates the potential of SSE 3D printing for personalized dosing of a lipid-based formulation strategy and discusses central quality attributes for the printable formulation and the 3D-printed dosage form.