Collaborating to Compete: Blood Profiling Atlas in Cancer (BloodPAC) Consortium

Subpar reporting of pre-analytical variables in RNA-focused blood plasma studies

Extracellular RNA (cell-free RNA; exRNA) from blood-derived liquid biopsies is an appealing, minimally invasive source of disease biomarkers. As pre-analytical variables strongly influence exRNA measurements, their reporting is essential for meaningful interpretation and replication of results. The aim of this review was to chart to what extent pre-analytical variables are documented, to pinpoint shortcomings and to improve future reporting. In total, 200 blood plasma exRNA studies published in 2018 or 2023 were reviewed for annotation of 22 variables associated with blood collection, plasma preparation, and RNA purification. Our results show that pre-analytical variables are poorly documented, with only three out of 22 variables described in over half of the publications. The percentage of variables reported ranged from 4.6% to 54.6% (mean 24.84%) in 2023 and from 4.6% to 57.1% (mean 28.60%) in 2018. Recommendations and guidelines (i.e., BRISQ, ASCO-CAP, BloodPAC, PPMPT, and CEN standards) have currently not resulted in improved reporting. In conclusion, our results highlight the lack of reporting pre-analytical variables in exRNA studies and advocate for a consistent use of available standards, endorsed by funders and journals.

A Case for Accelerating Standards to Achieve the FAIR Principles of Environmental Health Research Experimental Data

BACKGROUND

Funding agencies, publishers, and other stakeholders are pushing environmental health science investigators to improve data sharing; to promote the findable, accessible, interoperable, and reusable (FAIR) principles; and to increase the rigor and reproducibility of the data collected. Accomplishing these goals will require significant cultural shifts surrounding data management and strategies to develop robust and reliable resources that bridge the technical challenges and gaps in expertise.

OBJECTIVE

In this commentary, we examine the current state of managing data and metadata-referred to collectively as (meta)data-in the experimental environmental health sciences. We introduce new tools and resources based on in vivo experiments to serve as examples for the broader field.

METHODS

We discuss previous and ongoing efforts to improve (meta)data collection and curation. These include global efforts by the Functional Genomics Data Society to develop metadata collection tools such as the Investigation, Study, Assay (ISA) framework, and the Center for Expanded Data Annotation and Retrieval. We also conduct a case study of in vivo data deposited in the Gene Expression Omnibus that demonstrates the current state of in vivo environmental health data and highlights the value of using the tools we propose to support data deposition.

DISCUSSION

The environmental health science community has played a key role in efforts to achieve the goals of the FAIR guiding principles and is well positioned to advance them further. We present a proposed framework to further promote these objectives and minimize the obstacles between data producers and data scientists to maximize the return on research investments. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP11484.

Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) for non-invasive multiple biomarkers detection in an academic setting: a critical review of the literature for the RENOVATE study protocol

Liquid biopsy has the potential to drastically change clinical practice, paving the way to a novel non-invasive approach for cancer diagnosis and treatment. One of the limitations for the implementation of liquid biopsy in clinical practice is the lack of shared and reproducible standard operating procedures (SOPs) for sample collection, processing and storage. Here, we present a critical review of the literature focusing on the available SOPs to guide liquid biopsy management in research settings and describe SOPs that our laboratory developed and employed in the context of a prospective clinical-translational trial (RENOVATE, NCT04781062). The main aim of this manuscript is to address common issues, towards the implementation of interlaboratory shared protocols for optimized preanalytical handling of blood and urine samples. To our knowledge, this work is one of the few up-to-date, freely available comprehensive reports on trial-level procedures for the handling of liquid biopsy.

Contrived Materials and a Data Set for the Evaluation of Liquid Biopsy Tests: A Blood Profiling Atlas in Cancer (BLOODPAC) Community Study

The Blood Profiling Atlas in Cancer (BLOODPAC) Consortium is a collaborative effort involving stakeholders from the public, industry, academia, and regulatory agencies focused on developing shared best practices on liquid biopsy. This report describes the results from the JFDI (Just Freaking Do It) study, a BLOODPAC initiative to develop standards on the use of contrived materials mimicking cell-free circulating tumor DNA, to comparatively evaluate clinical laboratory testing procedures. Nine independent laboratories tested the concordance, sensitivity, and specificity of commercially available contrived materials with known variant-allele frequencies (VAFs) ranging from 0.1% to 5.0%. Each participating laboratory utilized its own proprietary evaluation procedures. The results demonstrated high levels of concordance and sensitivity at VAFs of >0.1%, but reduced concordance and sensitivity at a VAF of 0.1%; these findings were similar to those from previous studies, suggesting that commercially available contrived materials can support the evaluation of testing procedures across multiple technologies. Such materials may enable more objective comparisons of results on materials formulated in-house at each center in multicenter trials. A unique goal of the collaborative effort was to develop a data resource, the BLOODPAC Data Commons, now available to the liquid-biopsy community for further study. This resource can be used to support independent evaluations of results, data extension through data integration and new studies, and retrospective evaluation of data collection.

Creating Standards for Liquid Biopsies: The BLOODPAC Experience

Since the first Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval in 2013, liquid biopsy-based platforms have transformed the precision management of patients with advanced cancer. Liquid biopsy holds a demonstrated role in precision medicine that historically focused on targeted therapy selection. Yet, continued innovation in this area is expected to drive growing utility for liquid biopsy-based tests in other areas of clinical need, including minimal (or molecular) residual disease monitoring and early-stage.

Circulating Tumor Cell Kinetics and Morphology from the Liquid Biopsy Predict Disease Progression in Patients with Metastatic Colorectal Cancer Following Resection

Simple Summary

As a minimally invasive procedure, the liquid biopsy enables the longitudinal evaluation of a patient’s disease and response to treatment. Current clinical practice stratifies patient status based on a uniform threshold for circulating tumor cell (CTC) positivity, overlooking various cell subtypes and timepoints of sample collection. In a disease known for its tumor heterogeneity, we investigated colorectal cancer patients’ peripheral blood samples to determine whether the prevalence of morphologically distinct CTC subtypes and time-points of sample collection correlate with clinical disease hallmarks and survival data. Our results highlight nuances between the CTC subtypes’ clinical and survival significance. Furthermore, we found that time-point-conscious cell enumeration is critical, both for determining CTC positivity and the change in cell populations over time. To improve its clinical utility moving forward, we suggest that liquid biopsy analysis integrates morphology and time-based analysis alongside standard CTC enumeration at various stages of a patient’s treatment.

Abstract

The liquid biopsy has the potential to improve current clinical practice in oncology by providing real-time personalized information about a patient’s disease status and response to treatment. In this study, we evaluated 161 peripheral blood (PB) samples that were collected around surgical resection from 47 metastatic colorectal cancer (mCRC) patients using the High-Definition Single Cell Assay (HDSCA) workflow. In conjunction with the standard circulating tumor cell (CTC) enumeration, cellular morphology and kinetics between time-points of collection were considered in the survival analysis. CTCs, CTC-Apoptotic, and CTC clusters were found to indicate poor survival with an increase in cell count from pre-resection to post-resection. This study demonstrates that CTC subcategorization based on morphological differences leads to nuanced results between the subtypes, emphasizing the heterogeneity within the CTC classification. Furthermore, we show that factoring in the time-point of each blood collection is critical, both for its static enumeration and for the change in cell populations between draws. By integrating morphology and time-based analysis alongside standard CTC enumeration, liquid biopsy platforms can provide greater insight into the pathophysiology of mCRC by highlighting the complexity of the disease across a patient’s treatment.

Messenger RNA capture sequencing of extracellular RNA from human biofluids using a comprehensive set of spike-in controls

Comprehensive transcriptome analysis of extracellular RNA (exRNA) purified from human biofluids is challenging because of the low RNA concentration and compromised RNA integrity. Here, we describe an optimized workflow to (1) isolate exRNA from different types of biofluids and (2) to prepare messenger RNA (mRNA)-enriched sequencing libraries using complementary hybridization probes. Importantly, the workflow includes 2 sets of synthetic spike-in RNA molecules as processing controls for RNA purification and sequencing library preparation and as an alternative data normalization strategy.

For complete details on the use and execution of this protocol, please refer to Hulstaert et al. (2020).

•

Extracellular RNA from biofluids has a low concentration and a compromised integrity

•

An optimized workflow for mRNA capture sequencing of human biofluids is provided

•

Synthetic spike-in RNA molecules serve as processing controls

•

Spike-in RNAs allow for data normalization and calculation of mRNA concentration

BloodPAC Data Commons for Liquid Biopsy Data

PURPOSE

The Blood Profiling Atlas in Cancer (BloodPAC) Data Commons (BPDC) is being developed and is operated by the public-private BloodPAC Consortium to support the liquid biopsy community. It is an interoperable data commons with the ultimate aim of serving as a recognized source of valid scientific evidence for liquid biopsy assays for industry, academia, and standards and regulatory stakeholders.

METHODS

The BPDC is implemented using the open source Gen3 data commons platform (https://gen3.org). In particular, the BPDC Data Exploration Portal, BPDC Data Submission Portal, the BPDC Workspace Hub, and the BloodPAC application programming interface (API) were all automatically generated from the BloodPAC Data Model using the Gen3 data commons platform. BPDC uses Gen3's implementation of the data commons framework services so that it can interoperate through secure, compliant APIs with other data commons using data commons framework service, such as National Cancer Institute's Cancer Research Data Commons.

RESULTS

The BPDC contains 57 studies and projects spanning more than 4,100 cases. This amounts to 5,700 aliquots (blood plasma, serum, or a contrived sample) that have been subjected to a liquid biopsy assay, quantified, and then contributed by members of the BloodPAC Consortium. In all, there are more than 31,000 files in the commons as of December 2020. We describe the BPDC, the data it manages, the process that the BloodPAC Consortium used to develop it, and some of the applications that have been developed using its API.

CONCLUSION

The BPDC has been the data platform used by BloodPAC during the past 4 years to manage the data for the consortium and to provide workspaces for its working groups.

Circulating tumor DNA-based predictive biomarkers in breast cancer clinical trials: a narrative review

Breast carcinoma is the most frequent and the second leading cause of cancer mortality in women worldwide. Current treatment decisions are based on tumor profiling of the initial tissue biopsy. Cancer though evolves both spatially and temporarily in a significant percentage of patients during treatment. However, sequential biopsies from the primary tumor or its metastatic sites are not either convenient or feasible in the majority of cases. In the era of precision medicine, analysis of circulating blood-based biomarkers in the field of liquid biopsies provides an insight into the dynamic molecular profiling of the primary tumor and its metastases, in a relatively non-invasive way. The latter permits not only patient stratification but also longitudinal evaluation of treatment response, when incorporated into clinical trials. This review summarizes the results from recent and ongoing circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA)-based biomarker-driven clinical trials, with respect to ctDNA analysis’ predictive role, both in adjuvant, neo-adjuvant, and metastatic setting. Furthermore, current challenges in ctDNA analysis applications are critically discussed, including pre-analytical and analytical issues, and future perspectives in this field, through the conduct of well-designed, multicenter, randomized, large-scale, biomarker-stratified trials, with robust statistical methods. Despite in its infancy, ctDNA analysis holds great promise as a minimally invasive tool regarding tailored, personalized treatment guidance for breast cancer patients.

Generic Protocols for the Analytical Validation of Next-Generation Sequencing-Based ctDNA Assays: A Joint Consensus Recommendation of the BloodPAC's Analytical Variables Working Group

Liquid biopsy, particularly the analysis of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA), has demonstrated considerable promise for numerous clinical intended uses. Successful validation and commercialization of novel ctDNA tests have the potential to improve the outcomes of patients with cancer. The goal of the Blood Profiling Atlas Consortium (BloodPAC) is to accelerate the development and validation of liquid biopsy assays that will be introduced into the clinic. To accomplish this goal, the BloodPAC conducts research in the following areas: Data Collection and Analysis within the BloodPAC Data Commons; Preanalytical Variables; Analytical Variables; Patient Context Variables; and Reimbursement. In this document, the BloodPAC's Analytical Variables Working Group (AV WG) attempts to define a set of generic analytical validation protocols tailored for ctDNA-based Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) assays. Analytical validation of ctDNA assays poses several unique challenges that primarily arise from the fact that very few tumor-derived DNA molecules may be present in circulation relative to the amount of nontumor-derived cell-free DNA (cfDNA). These challenges include the exquisite level of sensitivity and specificity needed to detect ctDNA, the potential for false negatives in detecting these rare molecules, and the increased reliance on contrived samples to attain sufficient ctDNA for analytical validation. By addressing these unique challenges, the BloodPAC hopes to expedite sponsors' presubmission discussions with the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) with the protocols presented herein. By sharing best practices with the broader community, this work may also save the time and capacity of FDA reviewers through increased efficiency.

Preanalytical Variables for the Genomic Assessment of the Cellular and Acellular Fractions of the Liquid Biopsy in a Cohort of Breast Cancer Patients

Liquid biopsy allows assessment of multiple analytes, providing temporal information with potential for improving understanding of cancer evolution and clinical management of patients. Although liquid biopsies are intensely investigated for prediction and response monitoring, preanalytic variables are of primary concern for clinical implementation, including categories of collection method and sample storage. Herein, an integrated high-density single-cell assay workflow for morphometric and genomic analysis of the liquid biopsy is used to characterize the effects of preanalytical variation and reproducibility of data from a breast cancer cohort. Following prior work quantifying performance of commonly used blood collection tubes, this study completes the analysis of four time points to assay (24, 48, 72, and 96 hours), demonstrating precision up to 48 hours after collection for assay sensitivity, highly reproducible rare cell enumeration, morphometric characterization, and high efficiency and capacity for single-cell genomic analysis. For the cell-free analysis, both freezing and use of fresh plasma produced similar quality and quantity of cell-free DNA for sequencing. The genomic analysis (copy number variation and single-nucleotide variation) described herein is broadly applicable to liquid biopsy platforms capable of isolating cell-free and cell-based DNA. Morphometric parameters and genomic signatures of individual circulating tumor cells were evaluated in relation to patient clinical response, providing preliminary evidence of clinical validity as a potential biomarker aiding clinical diagnostics or monitoring progression.

Preoperative detection of KRAS G12D mutation in ctDNA is a powerful predictor for early recurrence of resectable PDAC patients

Background

About 25–37% of resectable pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) had a great chance of early recurrence after radical resection, which is mainly due to preoperative micrometastasis. We herein demonstrated the profiles of ctDNA in resectable PDAC and use of ctDNA to identify patients with potential micrometastasis.

Methods

A total of 113 and 44 resectable PDACs were enrolled in discovery and validation cohorts, separately. A panel containing 50 genes was used to screen ctDNA by an NGS-based assessment with high specificity.

Results

In the discovery cohort, the overall detection rate was 38.05% (43/113). Among positive ctDNA, KRAS mutation had the highest detection rate (23.01%, 26/113), while the others were <5%. Survival analysis showed that plasma KRAS mutations, especially KRAS G12D mutation, had significant association with OS and RFS of resectable PDAC. Plasma KRAS G12D mutation showed a strong correlation with early distant metastasis. In the validation cohort, survival analysis showed similar association between plasma KRAS G12D mutation and poor outcomes.

Conclusions

This study demonstrated that plasma KRAS mutations, especially KRAS G12D mutation, served as a useful predictive biomarker for prognosis of resectable PDAC. More importantly, due to high correlation with micrometastasis, preoperative detection of plasma KRAS G12D mutation helps in optimising surgical selection of resectable PDAC.

National Cancer Institute Alliance for nanotechnology in cancer-Catalyzing research and translation toward novel cancer diagnostics and therapeutics

Nanotechnology has been a burgeoning research field, which is finding compelling applications in several practical areas of everyday life. It has provided novel, paradigm shifting solutions to medical problems and particularly to cancer. In order to accelerate integration of nanotechnology into cancer research and oncology, the National Cancer Institute (NCI) of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) established the NCI Alliance for Nanotechnology in Cancer program in 2005. This effort brought together scientists representing physical sciences, chemistry, and engineering working at the nanoscale with biologists and clinicians working on cancer to form a uniquely multidisciplinary cancer nanotechnology research community. The last 14 years of the program have produced a remarkable body of scientific discovery and demonstrated its utility to the development of practical cancer interventions. This paper takes stock of how the Alliance program influenced melding of disparate research disciplines into the field of nanomedicine and cancer nanotechnology, has been highly productive in the scientific arena, and produced a mechanism of seamless transfer of novel technologies developed in academia to the clinical and commercial space. This article is categorized under: Toxicology and Regulatory Issues in Nanomedicine > Regulatory and Policy Issues in Nanomedicine Therapeutic Approaches and Drug Discovery > Nanomedicine for Oncologic Disease Diagnostic Tools > in vivo Nanodiagnostics and Imaging.

The Veterans Precision Oncology Data Commons: Transforming VA data into a national resource for research in precision oncology

The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) has a strong track record providing high-quality, evidence-based care to cancer patients. In order to accelerate discoveries that will further improve care for Veterans with cancer, the VA has partnered with the Center for Translational Data Science at the University of Chicago and the Open Commons Consortium to establish a data sharing platform, the Veterans Precision Oncology Data Commons (VPODC). The VPODC makes clinical, genomic, and imaging data from the VA available to the research community at large. In this paper, we detail our motivation for data sharing, describe the VPODC, and outline our collaboration model. By transforming VA data into a national resource for research in precision oncology, the VPODC seeks to foster innovation through collaboration and resource sharing that will ultimately lead to improved care for Veterans with cancer.

Current and future perspectives of liquid biopsies in genomics-driven oncology

Precision oncology seeks to leverage molecular information about cancer to improve patient outcomes. Tissue biopsy samples are widely used to characterize tumours but are limited by constraints on sampling frequency and their incomplete representation of the entire tumour bulk. Now, attention is turning to minimally invasive liquid biopsies, which enable analysis of tumour components (including circulating tumour cells and circulating tumour DNA) in bodily fluids such as blood. The potential of liquid biopsies is highlighted by studies that show they can track the evolutionary dynamics and heterogeneity of tumours and can detect very early emergence of therapy resistance, residual disease and recurrence. However, the analytical validity and clinical utility of liquid biopsies must be rigorously demonstrated before this potential can be realized.

Data Harmonization for a Molecularly Driven Health System

Data commons have emerged as the best current method for enabling data aggregation across multiple projects and multiple data sources. Good data harmonization techniques are critical to maintain quality of data within a data commons, as well as to allow future meta-analysis across different data commons. We present some of the current best practices for data harmonization.

Progress Toward Cancer Data Ecosystems

One of the recommendations of the Cancer Moonshot Blue Ribbon Panel report from 2016 was the creation of a national cancer data ecosystem. We review some of the approaches for building cancer data ecosystems and some of the progress that has been made. A data commons is the colocation of data with cloud computing infrastructure and commonly used software services, tools, and applications for managing, integrating, analyzing, and sharing data to create an interoperable resource for the research community. We discuss data commons and their potential role in cancer data ecosystems and, in particular, how multiple data commons can interoperate to form part of the foundation for a cancer data ecosystem.

The cornerstone of integrating circulating tumor DNA into cancer management

Recent circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) research has demonstrated its potential as a non-invasive biomarker for cancer. However, the deployment of ctDNA assays in routine clinical practice remains challenging owing to variability in analytical approaches and the assessment of clinical significance. A well-developed, analytically valid ctDNA assay is a prerequisite for integrating ctDNA into cancer management, and an appropriate analytical technology is crucial for the development of a ctDNA assay. Other determinants including pre-analytical procedures, test validation, internal quality control (IQC), and continual proficiency testing (PT) are also important for the accuracy of ctDNA assays. In the present review, we will focus on the most widely used ctDNA detection technologies and the key quality management measures used to assure the accuracy of ctDNA assays. The aim of this review is to provide useful information for technology selection during ctDNA assay development and assure a reliable test result in clinical practice.

Anaplastic Lymphoma Kinase Mutation (ALK F1174C) in Small Cell Carcinoma of the Prostate and Molecular Response to Alectinib

Purpose: Small cell carcinoma of the prostate (SCCP) is an aggressive disease that can arise de novo or by transdifferentiation from prostate adenocarcinoma. Alterations in anaplastic lymphoma kinase (ALK) gene are involved in neuroblastoma, lung cancer, and other malignancies, but its role in SCCP has not been documented. We describe a patient with refractory de novo SCCP with ALK F1174C-activating mutation who obtained clinical benefit from treatment with ALK inhibitor.Experimental Design: Next-generation sequencing (NGS) was used to analyze primary and circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA). Prostate cancer databases were queried for alterations in ALK gene, mRNA, and its impact in clinical outcomes. In vitro prostate cell line/organoid models were generated by lentiviral-mediated expression of ALK and ALK F1174C and assessed for response to ALK inhibitors crizotinib and alectinib.Results: NGS analysis of the primary tumor and ctDNA of a 39-year-old patient with refractory SSCP identified ALK F1174C mutation. Treatment with second-generation ALK inhibitor alectinib resulted in radiographic stable disease for over 6 months, symptomatic improvement, and significant molecular response as reflected by declining ctDNA allele fraction. Analysis of prostate cancer datasets showed that ALK amplification was associated with poor outcome. In prostate cancer cells and organoids, ALK F1174C expression enhanced growth and induced expression of the neuroendocrine marker neuron-specific enolase. Alectinib was more effective than crizotinib in inhibiting ALK F1174C-expressing cell growth.Conclusions: These findings implicate ALK-activating mutations in SCCP pathogenesis and suggest the therapeutic potential of targeting ALK molecular alterations in some patients with SCCP. Clin Cancer Res; 24(12); 2732-9. ©2018 AACR.

Genomic Landscape of Cell-Free DNA in Patients with Colorectal Cancer

"Liquid biopsy" approaches analyzing cell-free DNA (cfDNA) from the blood of patients with cancer are increasingly utilized in clinical practice. However, it is not yet known whether cfDNA sequencing from large cohorts of patients with cancer can detect genomic alterations at frequencies similar to those observed by direct tumor sequencing, and whether this approach can generate novel insights. Here, we report next-generation sequencing data from cfDNA of 1,397 patients with colorectal cancer. Overall, frequencies of genomic alterations detected in cfDNA were comparable to those observed in three independent tissue-based colorectal cancer sequencing compendia. Our analysis also identified a novel cluster of extracellular domain (ECD) mutations in EGFR, mediating resistance by blocking binding of anti-EGFR antibodies. Patients with EGFR ECD mutations displayed striking tumor heterogeneity, with 91% harboring multiple distinct resistance alterations (range, 1-13; median, 4). These results suggest that cfDNA profiling can effectively define the genomic landscape of cancer and yield important biological insights.Significance: This study provides one of the first examples of how large-scale genomic profiling of cfDNA from patients with colorectal cancer can detect genomic alterations at frequencies comparable to those observed by direct tumor sequencing. Sequencing of cfDNA also generated insights into tumor heterogeneity and therapeutic resistance and identified novel EGFR ectodomain mutations. Cancer Discov; 8(2); 164-73. ©2017 AACR.This article is highlighted in the In This Issue feature, p. 127.

Liquid Biopsy in Clinical Management of Breast, Lung, and Colorectal Cancer

Examination of tumor molecular characteristics by liquid biopsy is likely to greatly influence personalized cancer patient management. Analysis of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA), circulating tumor cells (CTCs), and tumor-derived exosomes, all collectively referred to as “liquid biopsies,” are not only a modality to monitor treatment efficacy, disease progression, and emerging therapy resistance mechanisms, but they also assess tumor heterogeneity and evolution in real time. We review the literature concerning the examination of ctDNA and CTC in a diagnostic setting, evaluating their prognostic, predictive, and monitoring capabilities. We discuss the advantages and limitations of various leading ctDNA/CTC analysis technologies. Finally, guided by the results of clinical trials, we discuss the readiness of cell-free DNA and CTC as routine biomarkers in the context of various common types of neoplastic disease. At this moment, one cannot conclude whether or not liquid biopsy will become a mainstay in oncology practice.