Tracking Subtle Membrane Disruptions with a Tethered Photoacid

Proton diffusion on the surface of mixed lipid membranes highlights the role of membrane composition

Proton circuits within biological membranes, the foundation of natural bioenergetic systems, are significantly influenced by the lipid compositions of different biological membranes. In this study, we investigate the influence of mixed lipid membrane composition on the proton transfer (PT) properties on the surface of the membrane. We track the excited-state PT (ESPT) process from a tethered probe to the membrane with timescales and length scales of PT relevant to bioenergetic systems. Two processes can happen during ESPT: the initial PT from the probe to the membrane at short timescales, followed by diffusion of dissociated protons around the probe on the membrane, and the possible geminate recombination with the probe at longer timescales. Here, we use membranes composed of mixtures of phosphatidylcholine (PC) and phosphatidic acid (PA). We show that the changes in the ESPT properties are not monotonous with the concentration of the lipid mixture; at a low concentration of PA in PC, we find that the membrane is a poor proton acceptor. Molecular dynamics simulations indicate that the membrane is more structured at this specific lipid mixture, with the least number of defects. Accordingly, we suggest that the structure of the membrane is an important factor in facilitating PT. We further show that the composition of the membrane affects the geminate proton diffusion around the probe, whereas, on a timescale of tens of nanoseconds, the dissociated proton is mostly lateral restricted to the membrane plane in PA membranes, while in PC, the diffusion is less restricted by the membrane.

Solid-State Molecular Protonics Devices of Solid-Supported Biological Membranes Reveal the Mechanism of Long-Range Lateral Proton Transport

Lateral proton transport (PT) on the surface of biological membranes is a fundamental biochemical process in the bioenergetics of living cells, but a lack of available experimental techniques has resulted in a limited understanding of its mechanism. Here, we present a molecular protonics experimental approach to investigate lateral PT across membranes by measuring long-range (70 μm) lateral proton conduction via a few layers of lipid bilayers in a solid-state-like environment, i.e., without having bulk water surrounding the membrane. This configuration enables us to focus on lateral proton conduction across the surface of the membrane while decoupling it from bulk water. Hence, by controlling the relative humidity of the environment, we can directly explore the role of water in the lateral PT process. We show that proton conduction is dependent on the number of water molecules and their structure and on membrane composition, where we explore the role of the headgroup, the tail saturation, the membrane phase, and membrane fluidity. The measured PT as a function of temperature shows an inverse temperature dependency, which we explain by the desorption and adsorption of water molecules into the solid membrane platform. We explain our findings by discussing the role of percolating hydrogen bonding within the membrane structure in a Grotthuss-like mechanism.

The Dual Use of the Pyranine (HPTS) Fluorescent Probe: A Ground-State pH Indicator and an Excited-State Proton Transfer Probe

Molecular fluorescent probes are an essential experimental tool in many fields, ranging from biology to chemistry and materials science, to study the localization and other environmental properties surrounding the fluorescent probe. Thousands of different molecular fluorescent probes can be grouped into different families according to their photophysical properties. This Account focuses on a unique class of fluorescent probes that distinguishes itself from all other probes. This class is termed photoacids, which are molecules exhibiting a change in their acid-base transition between the ground and excited states, resulting in a large change in their pKa values between these two states, which is thermodynamically described using the Förster cycle. While there are many different photoacids, we focus only on pyranine, which is the most used photoacid, with pKa values of ∼7.4 and ∼0.4 for its ground and excited states, respectively. Such a difference between the pKa values is the basis for the dual use of the pyranine fluorescent probe. Furthermore, the protonated and deprotonated states of pyranine absorb and emit at different wavelengths, making it easy to focus on a specific state. Pyranine has been used for decades as a fluorescent pH indicator for physiological pH values, which is based on its acid-base equilibrium in the ground state. While the unique excited-state proton transfer (ESPT) properties of photoacids have been explored for more than a half-century, it is only recently that photoacids and especially pyranine have been used as fluorescent probes for the local environment of the probe, especially the hydration layer surrounding it and related proton diffusion properties. Such use of photoacids is based on their capability for ESPT from the photoacid to a nearby proton acceptor, which is usually, but not necessarily, water. In this Account, we detail the photophysical properties of pyranine, distinguishing between the processes in the ground state and the ones in the excited state. We further review the different utilization of pyranine for probing different properties of the environment. Our main perspective is on the emerging use of the ESPT process for deciphering the hydration layer around the probe and other parameters related to proton diffusion taking place while the molecule is in the excited state, focusing primarily on bio-related materials. Special attention is given to how to perform the experiments and, most importantly, how to interpret their results. We also briefly discuss the breadth of possibilities in making pyranine derivatives and the use of pyranine for controlling dynamic reactions.

Using Proton Geminate Recombination as a Probe of Proton Migration on Biological Membranes

Proton migration on biological membranes plays a major role in cellular respiration and photosynthesis, but it is not yet fully understood. Here we show that proton dissociation kinetics and related geminate recombination can be used as a probe of such proton migration mechanisms. We develop a simple model for the process and apply it to analyze the results obtained using a photo-induced proton release probe (chemically modified photoacid) tethered to phosphatidylcholine membranes. In our theoretical model, we apply approximate treatment for the diffusional cloud of the geminate proton around the dissociated photoacid and consider arbitrary dimension of the system, 1 < d < 3. We observe that in d > 2, there is a kinetic phase transition between an exponential and a power-law kinetic phases. The existence of an exponential decay phase at the beginning of the proton dissociation is a signature of d > 2 systems. In most other cases, the exponential decay phase is not present, and the kinetics follows a diffusional power-law P(t) ∼ t^-d/2 that develops after a short initiation time. Specifically, in a 1D case, which corresponds to the desorption of a proton from the surface, the dissociation occurs by the slow power-law ∼1/t and explains the abnormally slow desorption rate reported recently in experiments.