Increased Microbial Butanol Tolerance by Exogenous Membrane Insertion Molecules

Escherichia coli displays a conserved membrane proteomic response to a range of alcohols

BACKGROUND

Alcohol is a good and environment-friendly fuel that can be microbially produced, capable of eliminating many of the limitations of the present-day fossil fuels. However, the inherent toxic nature of alcohols to the microbial cells leads to end-product inhibition that limits large-scale alcohol production by fermentation. Fundamental knowledge about the stress responses of microorganisms to alcohols would greatly facilitate to improve the microbial alcohol tolerance. The current study elucidates and compares the changes in the membrane proteome of Escherichia coli in response to a range of alcohols.

RESULTS

Although alcohol toxicity increased exponentially with alcohol chain length (2-6 carbon), similar stress responses were observed in the inner and outer membrane proteome of E. coli in the presence of 2-, 4- and 6-carbon alcohols at the MIC50. This pertains to: (1) increased levels of inner membrane transporters for uptake of energy-producing metabolites, (2) reduced levels of non-essential proteins, associated with anaerobic, carbon starvation and osmotic stress, for energy conservation, (3) increased levels of murein degrading enzymes (MltA, EmtA, MliC and DigH) promoting cell elongation and 4) reduced levels of most outer membrane β-barrel proteins (LptD, FadL, LamB, TolC and BamA). Major outer membrane β-barrel protein OmpC, which is known to contribute to ethanol tolerance and membrane integrity, was notably reduced by alcohol stress. While LPS is important for OmpC trimerisation, LPS release by EDTA did not lower OmpC levels. This suggests that LPS release, which is reported under alcohol stress, does not contribute to the reduced levels of OmpC in the presence of alcohol.

CONCLUSIONS

Since alcohol primarily targets the integrity of the membrane, maintenance of outer membrane OmpC levels in the presence of alcohol might help in the survival of E. coli to higher alcohol concentrations. The study provides important information about the membrane protein responses of E. coli to a range of alcohols, which can be used to develop targeted strategies for increased microbial alcohol tolerance and hence bioalcohol production.

Membrane-intercalating conjugated oligoelectrolytes

By acting as effective biomimetics of the lipid bilayers, membrane-intercalating conjugated oligoelectrolytes (MICOEs) can spontaneously insert themselves into both synthetic lipid bilayers and biological membranes. The modular and intentional molecular design of MICOEs enable a range of applications, such as bioproduction, biocatalysis, biosensing, and therapeutics. This tutorial review provides a structural evolution of MICOEs, which originated from the broader class of conjugated molecules, and analyses the drivers behind this evolutionary process. Various representative applications of MICOEs, accompanied by insights into their molecular design principles, will be reviewed separately. Perspectives on the current challenges and opportunities in research on MICOEs will be discussed at the end of the review to highlight their potential as unconventional and value-added materials for biological systems.

Transient Complexity of E. coli Lipidome Is Explained by Fatty Acyl Synthesis and Cyclopropanation

In the case of many bacteria, such as Escherichia coli, the composition of lipid molecules, termed the lipidome, temporally adapts to different environmental conditions and thus modifies membrane properties to permit growth and survival. Details of the relationship between the environment and lipidome composition are lacking, particularly for growing cultures under either favourable or under stress conditions. Here, we highlight compositional lipidome changes by describing the dynamics of molecular species throughout culture-growth phases. We show a steady cyclopropanation of fatty acyl chains, which acts as a driver for lipid diversity. There is a bias for the cyclopropanation of shorter fatty acyl chains (FA 16:1) over longer ones (FA 18:1), which likely reflects a thermodynamic phenomenon. Additionally, we observe a nearly two-fold increase in saturated fatty acyl chains in response to the presence of ampicillin and chloramphenicol, with consequences for membrane fluidity and elasticity, and ultimately bacterial stress tolerance. Our study provides the detailed quantitative lipidome composition of three E. coli strains across culture-growth phases and at the level of the fatty acyl chains and provides a general reference for phospholipid composition changes in response to perturbations. Thus, lipidome diversity is largely transient and the consequence of lipid synthesis and cyclopropanation.

Production of cholesterol-like molecules impacts Escherichia coli robustness, production capacity, and vesicle trafficking

The economic viability of bioprocesses is constrained by the limited range of operating conditions that can be tolerated by the cell factory. Engineering of the microbial cell membrane is one strategy that can increase robustness and thus alter this range. In this work, we targeted cellular components that contribute to maintenance of appropriate membrane function, such as: flotillin-like proteins, membrane structural proteins, and membrane lipids. Specifically, we exploited the promiscuity of squalene hopene cyclase (SHC) to produce polycyclic terpenoids with properties analogous to cholesterol. Strains producing these cholesterol-like molecules were visualized by AFM and height features were observed. Production of these cholesterol-like molecules was associated with increased tolerance towards a diversity of chemicals, particularly alcohols, and membrane trafficking processes such as lipid droplet accumulation and production of extracellular vesicles. This engineering approach improved the production titers for wax-esters and ethanol by 80- and 10-fold, respectively. Expression of SHC resulted in the production of steroids. Strains engineered to also express truncated squalene synthase (tERG9) produced diplopterol and generally did not perform as well. Increased expression of several membrane-associated proteins, such as YqiK, was observed to impact vesicle trafficking and further improve tolerance relative to SHC alone, but did not improve bio-production. Deletion of YbbJ increased lipid droplet accumulation as well as production of intracellular wax esters. This work serves as a proof of concept for engineering strategies targeting membrane physiology and trafficking to expand the production capacity of microbial cell factories.

Schistosoma mansoni Adult Worm Protective and Diagnostic Proteins in n-Butanol Extracts Revealed by Proteomic Analysis

The S. mansoni adult worm n-butanol extract (Sm-AWBE) has been previously shown to contain specific S. mansoni antigens that have been used for immunodiagnosis of schistosomiasis in solid phase alkaline phosphatase immunoassay (APIA) and western blot (WB) analyses. Sm-AWBE was also used in immunoprotection studies against a fatal live-cercariae challenge in experimental mouse vaccination (~43% protection). The Sm-AWBE fraction was prepared by mixing adult worm membranous suspensions with aqueous-saturated n-butanol, centrifuging and recovering n-butanol-resistant proteins in the aqueous phase. Here we report a preliminary identification of Sm-AWBE protein components as revealed from a qualitative proteomic study after processing Sm-AWBE by 1D-gel electrophoresis, in-gel and in-solution tryptic digestions, and mass spectrometry analyses. We identified 33 proteins in Sm-AWBE, all previously known S. mansoni proteins and antigens; among them, immunomodulatory proteins and proteins mostly involved in host–parasite interactions. About 81.8% of the identified Sm-AWBE proteins are antigenic. STRING analysis showed a set of Sm-AWBE proteins configuring a small network of interactive proteins and a group of proteins without interactions. Functional groups of proteins included muscle contraction, antioxidant, GPI-anchored phosphoesterases, regulatory 14-3-3, various enzymes and stress proteins. The results widen the possibilities to design novel antigen combinations for better diagnostic and immunoprotective strategies for schistosomiasis control.

Enhancing butanol tolerance of Escherichia coli reveals hydrophobic interaction of multi-tasking chaperone SecB

BACKGROUND

Escherichia coli has been proved to be one promising platform chassis for the production of various natural products, such as biofuels. Product toxicity is one of the main bottlenecks for achieving maximum production of biofuels. Host strain engineering is an effective approach to alleviate solvent toxicity issue in fermentation.

RESULTS

Thirty chaperones were overexpressed in E. coli JM109, and SecB recombinant strain was identified with the highest n-butanol tolerance. The tolerance (T) of E. coli overexpressing SecB, calculated by growth difference in the presence and absence of solvents, was determined to be 9.13% at 1.2% (v/v) butanol, which was 3.2-fold of the control strain. Random mutagenesis of SecB was implemented and homologously overexpressed in E. coli, and mutant SecB_T10A was identified from 2800 variants rendering E. coli the highest butanol tolerance. Saturation mutagenesis on T10 site revealed that hydrophobic residues were required for high butanol tolerance of E. coli. Compared with wild-type (WT) SecB, the T of SecB_T10A strain was further increased from 9.14 to 14.4% at 1.2% butanol, which was 5.3-fold of control strain. Remarkably, E. coli engineered with SecB_T10A could tolerate as high as 1.8% butanol (~ 14.58 g/L). The binding affinity of SecB_T10A toward model substrate unfolded maltose binding protein (preMBP) was 11.9-fold of that of WT SecB as determined by isothermal titration calorimetry. Residue T10 locates at the entrance of hydrophobic substrate binding groove of SecB, and might play an important role in recognition and binding of cargo proteins.

CONCLUSIONS

SecB chaperone was identified by chaperone mining to be effective in enhancing butanol tolerance of E. coli. Maximum butanol tolerance of E. coli could reach 1.6% and 1.8% butanol by engineering single gene of SecB or SecB_T10A. Hydrophobic interaction is vital for enhanced binding affinity between SecB and cargo proteins, and therefore improved butanol tolerance.

Response of microbial membranes to butanol: interdigitation vs. disorder

Biobutanol production by fermentation is potentially a sustainable alternative to butanol production from fossil fuels. However, the toxicity of butanol to fermentative bacteria, resulting largely from cell membrane fluidization, limits production titers and is a major factor limiting the uptake of the technology. Here, studies were undertaken, in vitro and in silico, on the butanol effects on a representative bacterial (i.e. Escherichia coli) inner cell membrane. A critical butanol : lipid ratio for stability of 2 : 1 was observed, computationally, consistent with complete interdigitation. However, at this ratio the bilayer was ∼20% thicker than for full interdigitation. Furthermore, butanol intercalation induced acyl chain bending and increased disorder, measured as a 27% lateral diffusivity increase experimentally in a supported lipid bilayer. There was also a monophasic Tm reduction in butanol-treated large unilamellar vesicles. Both behaviours are inconsistent with an interdigitated gel. Butanol thus causes only partial interdigitation at physiological temperatures, due to butanol accumulating at the phospholipid headgroups. Acyl tail disordering (i.e. splaying and bending) fills the subsequent voids. Finally, butanol short-circuits the bilayer and creates a coupled system where interdigitated and splayed phospholipids coexist. These findings will inform the design of strategies targeting bilayer stability for increasing biobutanol production titers.

A Chain-Elongated Oligophenylenevinylene Electrolyte Increases Microbial Membrane Stability

A novel conjugated oligoelectrolyte (COE) material, named S6, is designed to have a lipid-bilayer stabilizing topology afforded by an extended oligophenylenevinylene backbone. S6 intercalates biological membranes acting as a hydrophobic support for glycerophospholipid acyl chains. Indeed, Escherichia coli treated with S6 exhibits a twofold improvement in butanol tolerance, a relevant feature to achieve within the general context of modifying microorganisms used in biofuel production. Filamentous growth, a morphological stress response to butanol toxicity in E. coli, is observed in untreated cells after incubation with 0.9% butanol (v/v), but is mitigated by S6 treatment. Real-time fluorescence imaging using giant unilamellar vesicles reveals the extent to which S6 counters membrane instability. Moreover, S6 also reduces butanol-induced lipopolysaccharide release from the outer membrane to further maintain cell integrity. These findings highlight a deliberate effort in the molecular design of a chain-elongated COE to stabilize microbial membranes against environmental challenges.

Interactions of a paracyclophane-based conjugated oligoelectrolyte with biological membranes

We report a non-planar conjugated oligoelectrolyte as a membrane permeabilizing material and its membrane interactions compared to the linear analog.

Progress and perspectives on improving butanol tolerance

Fermentative production of butanol for use as a biofuel or chemical feedstock is regarded as a promising renewable technology that reduces greenhouse gas emissions and has the potential to become a substitute for non-sustainable chemical production route. However, butanol toxicity to the producing microbes remains a barrier to achieving sufficiently high titers for cost-effective butanol fermentation and recovery. Investigations of the external stress of high butanol concentration on butanol-producing microbial strains will aid in developing improved microbes with increased tolerance to butanol. With currently available molecular tool boxes, researchers have aimed to address and understand how butanol affects different microbes. This review will cover the individual organism's inherent responses to surrounding butanol levels, and the collective efforts by researchers to improve production and tolerance. The specific microorganisms discussed here include the native butanol producer Clostridium species, the fermentation industrial model Saccharomyces cerevisiae and the photosynthetic cyanobacteria, the genetic engineering workhorse Escherichia coli, and also the butanol-tolerant lactic acid bacteria that utilize diverse substrates. The discussion will help to understand the physiology of butanol resistance and to identify specific butanol tolerance genes that will lead to informed genetic engineering strategies for new strain development.

Influence of molecular structure on the antimicrobial function of phenylenevinylene conjugated oligoelectrolytes

Structure/property relationships were obtained to understand the antimicrobial function of conjugated oligoelectrolytes toward Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria.

Conjugated oligoelectrolytes (COEs) with phenylenevinylene (PV) repeat units are known to spontaneously intercalate into cell membranes. Twelve COEs, including seven structures reported here for the first time, were investigated for the relationship between their membrane disrupting properties and structural modifications, including the length of the PV backbone and the presence of either a tetraalkylammonium or a pyridinium ionic pendant group. Optical characteristics and interactions with cell membranes were determined using UV-Vis absorption and photoluminescence spectroscopies, and confocal microscopy. Toxicity tests on representative Gram-positive (Enterococcus faecalis) and Gram-negative (Escherichia coli) bacteria reveal generally greater toxicity to E. faecalis than to E. coli and indicate that shorter molecules have superior antimicrobial activity. Increased antimicrobial potency was observed in three-ring COEs appended with pyridinium ionic groups but not with COEs with four or five PV repeat units. Studies with mutants having cell envelope modifications indicate a possible charge based interaction with pyridinium-appended compounds. Fluorine substitutions on COE backbones result in structures that are less toxic to E. coli, while the addition of benzothiadiazole to COE backbones has no effect on increasing antimicrobial function. A weakly membrane-intercalating COE with only two PV repeat units allowed us to determine the synthetic limitations as a result of competition between solubility in aqueous media and association with cell membranes. We describe, for the first time, the most membrane disrupting structure achievable within two homologous series of COEs and that around a critical three-ring backbone length, structural modifications have the most effect on antimicrobial activity.

Recent progress in biobutanol tolerance in microbial systems with an emphasis on Clostridium

Biobased production of butanol promises a more sustainable route for industrial production. However, butanol toxicity remains a barrier for achieving high product titers. Investigation into butanol stress has shed some light on its modes of toxicity. Unfortunately, there still remain significant shortfalls in our understanding of the complex interactions of butanol with cells. To address this knowledge gap, a diverse range of tools have been employed to gain a better understanding of the adverse effects of butanol on the cell. These findings have lead to the identification of possible molecular mechanisms associated with butanol tolerance, which can be harnessed for future strain development efforts. This review focuses on recent efforts to address the toxicity of butanol in microbial producers and offers some perspectives on the future direction of this research sector.