Structure-Activity and Stability Relationships for Cobalt Polypyridyl-Based Hydrogen-Evolving Catalysts in Water

Optimizing Photocatalytic H2 Production by Introduction of Pyrazinyls to WRCs and a New tris-Rhenium Photosensitizer

The replacement of pyridyl by pyrazinyl in ligands of polypyridyl-based cobalt water reducing catalysts (WRC) shifts reduction potentials anodically. Together with a new, trinuclear ReI photosensitizer, these WRCs show strongly improved photocatalytic performances in turnover numbers (TONs) and maximal H2 evolution rate. Depending on the catalyst structure, up to 65 kTONs at 1 μM WRC concentration were reached. Under electrocatalytic conditions in both DMF and H2O, one of the reported WRCs displays remarkable stability, producing H2 steadily over 21 and 14 d, respectively.

Mechanistic Insights into Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution by an Exceptionally Stable Cobalt Complex

Co(aPPy) is one of the most stable and active molecular first-row transition-metal catalysts for proton reduction reported to date. Understanding the origin of its high performance via mechanistic studies could aid in developing even better catalysts. In this work, the catalytic mechanism of Co(aPPy) was electrochemically probed, in both organic solvents and water. We found that different mechanisms can occur depending on the solvent and the acidity of the medium. In organic solvent with a strong acid as the proton source, catalysis initiates directly after a single-electron reduction of CoII to CoI, whereas in the presence of a weaker acid, the cobalt center needs to be reduced twice before catalysis occurs. In the aqueous phase, we found drastically different electrochemical behavior, where the Co(aPPy) complex was found to be a precatalyst to a different electrocatalytic species. We propose that in this active catalyst, the pyridine ring has dissociated and acts as a proton relay at pH ≤ 5, which opens up a fast protonation pathway of the CoI intermediate and results in a high catalytic activity. Furthermore, we determined with constant potential bulk electrolysis that the catalyst is most stable at pH 3. The catalyst thus functions optimally at low pH in an aqueous environment, where the pyridine acts as a proton shuttle and where the high acidity also prevents catalyst deactivation.

Switching Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution Pathways through Electronic Tuning of Copper Porphyrins

The electronic structure of metal complexes plays key roles in determining their catalytic features. However, controlling electronic structures to regulate reaction mechanisms is of fundamental interest but has been rarely presented. Herein, we report electronic tuning of Cu porphyrins to switch pathways of the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Through controllable and regioselective β-oxidation of Cu porphyrin 1, we synthesized analogues 2-4 with one or two β-lactone groups in either a cis or trans configuration. Complexes 1-4 have the same Cu-N4 core site but different electronic structures. Although β-oxidation led to large anodic shifts of reductions, 1-4 displayed similar HER activities in terms of close overpotentials. With electrochemical, chemical and theoretical results, we show that the catalytically active species switches from a CuI species for 1 to a Cu0 species for 4. This work is thus significant to present mechanism-controllable HER via electronic tuning of catalysts.

Mechanism-Guided Kinetic Analysis of Electrocatalytic Proton Reduction Mediated by a Cobalt Catalyst Bearing a Pendant Basic Site

Cobalt polypyridyl complexes stand out as efficient catalysts for electrochemical proton reduction, but investigations into their operating mechanisms, with broad-reaching implications in catalyst design, have been limited. Herein, we investigate the catalytic activity of a cobalt(II) polypyridyl complex bearing a pendant pyridyl base with a series of organic acids spanning 20 pKa units in acetonitrile. Structural analysis, as well as electrochemical studies, reveals that the Co(III) hydride intermediate is formed through reduction of the Co(II) catalyst followed by direct metal protonation in the initial EC step despite the presence of the pendant base, which is commonly thought of as a more kinetically accessible protonation site. Protonation of the pendant base occurs after the Co(III) hydride intermediate is further reduced in the overall ECEC pathway. Additionally, when the acid used is sufficiently strong, the Co(II) catalyst can be protonated, and the Co(III) hydride can react directly with acid to release H2. With thorough mechanistic understanding, the appropriate electroanalytical methods were identified to extract rate constants for the elementary steps over a range of conditions. Thermodynamic square schemes relating catalytic intermediates proposed in the three electrocatalytic HER mechanisms were constructed. These findings reveal a full description of the HER electrocatalysis mediated by this molecular system and provide insights into strategies to improve synthetic fuel-forming catalysts operative through metal hydride intermediates.

Bioinspired motifs in proton and CO2 reduction with 3d-metal polypyridine complexes

The synthesis of active and efficient catalysts for solar fuel generation is nowadays of high relevance for the scientific community, but at the same time poses great challenges. Critical requirements are mainly associated with the kinetic barriers due to the multi-proton and multi-electron nature of the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) and the CO2 reduction reaction (CO2RR) as well as to selectivity issues. In this regard, natural enzymes can be a source of inspiration for the design of effective and selective catalysts to target such fundamental reactions. In this Feature Article we review some recent works on molecular catalysts for both the HER and the CO2RR performed in our labs and other research teams which mainly address (i) the role of redox non-innocent ligands, to lower the overpotential for catalysis and control the selectivity, and (ii) the role of internal relays, to assist formation of catalytic intermediates via intramolecular routes. The selected exemplars have been chosen to emphasize that, although the molecular structures and the synthetic motifs are different from those of the active sites of natural enzymes, many affinities in terms of catalytic mechanism and functionality are instead present, which account for the observed remarkable performances under operative conditions. The data discussed herein thus demonstrate the great potential and the privileged role of molecular catalysts towards the design and construction of hybrid photochemical systems for solar energy conversion into fuels.

Electro- and photochemical H2 generation by Co(ii) polypyridyl-based catalysts bearing ortho-substituted pyridines

Cobalt(ii) complexes featuring hexadentate amino-pyridyl ligands have been recently discovered as highly active catalysts for the Hydrogen Evolution Reaction (HER), whose high performance arises from the possibility of assisting proton transfer processes via intramolecular routes involving detached pyridine units. With the aim of gaining insights into such catalytic routes, three new proton reduction catalysts based on amino-polypyridyl ligands are reported, focusing on substitution of the pyridine ortho-position. Specifically, a carboxylate (C2) and two hydroxyl substituted pyridyl moieties (C3, C4) are introduced with the aim of promoting intramolecular proton transfer which possibly enhances the efficiency of the catalysts. Foot-of-the-wave and catalytic Tafel plot analyses have been utilized to benchmark the catalytic performances under electrochemical conditions in acetonitrile using trifluoroacetic acid as the proton source. In this respect, the cobalt complex C3 turns out to be the fastest catalyst in the series, with a maximum turnover frequency (TOF) of 1.6 (±0.5) × 10⁵ s^-1, but at the expense of large overpotentials. Mechanistic investigations by means of Density Functional Theory (DFT) suggest a typical ECEC mechanism (i.e. a sequence of reduction - E - and protonation - C - events) for all the catalysts, as previously envisioned for the parent unsubstituted complex C1. Interestingly, in the case of complex C2, the catalytic route is triggered by initial protonation of the carboxylate group resulting in a less common (C)ECEC mechanism. The pivotal role of the hexadentate chelating ligand in providing internal proton relays to assist hydrogen elimination is further confirmed within this novel class of molecular catalysts, thus highlighting the relevance of a flexible polypyridine ligand in the design of efficient cobalt complexes for the HER. Photochemical studies in aqueous solution using [Ru(bpy)₃]²⁺ (where bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine) as the sensitizer and ascorbate as the sacrificial electron donor support the superior performance of C3.

Rethinking Electronic Effects in Photochemical Hydrogen Evolution Using CuInS2@ZnS Quantum Dots Sensitizers

Molecular catalysts based on coordination complexes for the generation of hydrogen via photochemical water splitting exhibit a large versatility and tunability of the catalytic properties through chemical functionalization. In the present work, we report on light-driven hydrogen production in an aqueous solution using a series of cobalt polypyridine complexes as hydrogen evolving catalysts (HECs) in combination with CuInS₂@ZnS quantum dots (QDs) as sensitizers, and ascorbate as the electron donor. A peculiar trend in activity has been observed depending on the substituents present on the polypyridine ligand. This trend markedly differs from that previously recorded using [Ru(bpy)₃]²⁺ (where bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine) as the sensitizer and can be ascribed to different kinetically limiting pathways in the photochemical reaction (viz. protonation kinetics with the ruthenium chromophore, catalyst activation via electron transfer from the QDs in the present system). Hence, this work shows how the electronic effects on light-triggered molecular catalysis are not exclusive features of the catalyst unit but depend on the whole photochemical system.

Two Novel Dinuclear Cobalt Polypyridyl Complexes in Electro- and Photocatalysis for Hydrogen Production: Cooperativity Increases Performance

Syntheses and mechanisms of two dinuclear Co-polypyridyl catalysts for the H₂ evolution reaction (HER) were reported and compared to their mononuclear analogue (R1). In both catalysts, two di-(2,2'-bipyridin-6-yl)-methanone units were linked by either 2,2'-bipyridin-6,6'-yl or pyrazin-2,5-yl. Complexation with Co^II gave dinuclear compounds bridged by pyrazine (C2) or bipyridine (C1). Photocatalytic HER gave turnover numbers (TONs) of up to 20000 (C2) and 7000 (C1) in water. Electrochemically, C1 was similar to the R1, whereas C2 showed electronic coupling between the two Co centers. The E(Co^II/I ) split by 360 mV into two separate waves. Proton reduction in DMF was investigated for R1 with [HNEt₃ ](BF₄ ) by simulation, foot of the wave analysis, and linear sweep voltammetry (LSV) with in-line detection of H₂ . All methods agreed well with an (E)ECEC mechanism and the first protonation being rate limiting (≈10⁴  m^-1  s^-1 ). The second reduction was more anodic than the first one. pK_a values of around 10 and 7.5 were found for the two protonations. LSV analysis with H₂ detection for all catalysts and acids with different pK_a values [HBF₄ , pK_a (DMF)≈3.4], intermediate {[HNEt₃ ](BF₄ ), pK_a (DMF)≈9.2} to weak [AcOH, pK_a (DMF)≈13.5] confirmed electrochemical H₂ production, distinctly dependent on the pK_a values. Only HBF₄ protonated Co^I intermediates. The two metals in the dualcore C2 cooperated with an increase in rate to a competitive 10⁵  m^-1  s^-1 with [HNEt₃ ](BF₄ ). The overpotential decreased compared to R1 by 100 mV. Chronoamperometry established high stabilities for all catalysts with TON_lim of 100 for R1 and 320 for C1 and C2.

Recent findings and future directions in photosynthetic hydrogen evolution using polypyridine cobalt complexes

The production of hydrogen gas using water as the molecular substrate currently represents one of the most challenging and appealing reaction schemes in the field of artificial photosynthesis (AP), i.e., the conversion of solar energy into fuels. In order to be efficient, this process requires a suitable combination of a light-harvesting sensitizer, an electron donor, and a hydrogen-evolving catalyst (HEC). In the last few years, cobalt polypyridine complexes have been discovered to be competent molecular catalysts for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER), showing enhanced efficiency and stability with respect to previously reported molecular species. This perspective collects information about all relevant cobalt polypyridine complexes employed for the HER in aqueous solution under light-driven conditions in the presence of Ru(bpy)₃²⁺ (where bpy = 2,2'-bipyridine) as the photosensitizer and ascorbate as the electron donor, trying to highlight promising chemical motifs and aiming towards efficient catalytic activity in order to stimulate further efforts to design molecular catalysts for hydrogen generation and allow their profitable implementation in devices. As a final step, a few suggestions for the benchmarking of HECs employed under light-driven conditions are introduced.

Rationalizing Photo-Triggered Hydrogen Evolution Using Polypyridine Cobalt Complexes: Substituent Effects on Hexadentate Chelating Ligands

Four novel polypyridine cobalt(II) complexes were developed based on a hexadentate ligand scaffold bearing either electron-withdrawing (-CF₃ ) or electron-donating (-OCH₃ ) groups in different positions of the ligand. Experiments and theoretical calculations were combined to perform a systematic investigation of the effect of the ligand modification on the hydrogen evolution reaction. The results indicated that the position, rather than the type of substituent, was the dominating factor in promoting catalysis. The best performances were observed upon introduction of substituents on the pyridine moiety of the hexadentate ligand, which promoted the formation of the Co(II)H intermediate via intramolecular proton transfer reactions with low activation energy. Quantum yields of 11.3 and 10.1 %, maximum turnover frequencies of 86.1 and 76.6 min^-1 , and maximum turnover numbers of 5520 and 4043 were obtained, respectively, with a -OCH₃ and a -CF₃ substituent.

Polypyridyl Co complex-based water reduction catalysts: why replace a pyridine group with isoquinoline rather than quinoline?

The electronic effect of the substituent has been fully leveraged to improve the activity of molecular water reduction catalysts (WRCs). However, the steric effect of the substituents has received less attention. In this work, a steric hindrance effect was observed in a quinoline-involved polypyridyl Co complex-based water reduction catalyst (WRC), which impedes the formation of Co(iii)-H from Co(i), two pivotal intermediates for H₂ evolution, leading to significantly impaired electrocatalytic and photocatalytic activity with respect to its parent complex, [Co(TPA)Cl]Cl (TPA = tris(2-pyridinylmethyl)-amine). In sharp contrast, two isoquinoline-involved polypyridyl Co complexes exhibited significantly improved H₂ evolution efficiencies compared to [Co(TPA)Cl]Cl, benefitting mainly from the more basic and conjugated features of isoquinoline over pyridine. The dramatically different influences caused by the replacement of a pyridine group in the TPA ligand by quinoline and isoquinoline fully demonstrates the important roles of both the electronic and steric effects of a substituent. Our results may provide novel insights for designing more efficient WRCs.

Electronic effects on polypyridyl Co complex-based water reduction catalysts

Three new isomeric cobalt complexes of TPA (tris(2-pyridylmethyl)amine) based on methoxy substitution at the ortho, meta and para positions, respectively, were constructed and their photocatalytic proton reduction efficiencies were compared. It was found that there are good linear correlations with the Hammett constants of the substituents for the computed Co–N bond lengths, redox potentials of Co^II/I and Co^I/0 events, and the photocatalytic activities of the complexes. The ortho-substituted Co complex distinguished itself from the others remarkably in all these comparisons, demonstrating the presence of a steric effect besides the electronic effect. For other examined complexes, a stronger electron-donating substituent may lead to a higher hydrogen evolution efficiency, suggesting that the formation of a Co(iii) hydride intermediate is the rate-limiting step.

Three isomeric Co complexes showed a significant substituent electronic effect in photocatalytic hydrogen production.

[Re(η6-arene)2]+ as a highly stable ferrocene-like scaffold for ligands and complexes

Ferrocenes are versatile ligand scaffolds, complexes of which have found numerous applications in catalysis. Structurally similar but of higher redox stabilites are sandwich complexes of the [Re(η6-arene)2]+ type. We report herein routes for conjugating potential ligands to a single or to both arenes in this scaffold. Since the arene rings can freely rotate, the [Re(η6-arene)2]+ has a high degree of structural flexibility. Polypyridyl ligands were successfully introduced. The coordination of Co(ii) to such a model tetrapyridyl-Re(i)-bis-benzene complex produced a bimetallic Re(i)-Co(ii) complex. To show the stability of the resulting architecture, a selected complex was subjected to photocatalytic reactions. It showed good activity in proton reduction over a long time and did not decompose, corroborating its extraordinary stability even under light irradiation. Its activity compares well with the parent catalyst in turn over numbers and frequencies. The supply of electrons limits catalytic turnover frequency at concentrations below ∼10 μM. We also show that other ligands can be introduced along these strategies. The great diversity offered by [Re(η6-arene)2]+ sandwich complexes from a synthetic point allows this concept to be extended to other catalytic processes, comparable to ferrocenes.

Mechanistic insights into photocatalysis and over two days of stable H2 generation in electrocatalysis by a molecular cobalt catalyst immobilized on TiO2

Molecular and heterogeneous water reduction combined: Over 2 days of electrocatalysis of a cobalt polypyridyl catalyst immobilized on TiO₂.

Single crystal growth of water-soluble metal complexes with the help of the nano-crystallization method

Let pipetting robots set up nano crystallization trials of water-soluble metal complexes in order to obtain single crystals!

Influence of nitro substituents on the redox, electronic, and proton reduction catalytic behavior of phenolate-based [N2O3]-type cobalt(iii) complexes

We report on the synthesis, redox, electronic, and catalytic behavior of two new cobalt(iii) complexes, namely [CoIII(L1)MeOH] (1) and [CoIII(L2)MeOH] (2). These species contain nitro-rich, phenolate-based pentadentate ligands and present dramatically distinct properties associated with the position in which the -NO2 substituents are installed. Species 1 displays nitro-substituted phenolates, and exhibits irreversible redox response and negligible catalytic activity, whereas 2 has fuctionalized phenylene moieties, shows much improved redox reversibility and catalytic proton reduction activity at low overpotentials. A concerted experimental and theoretical approach sheds some light on these drastic differences.

Homogeneous vs. heterogeneous catalysis for hydrogen evolution by a nickel(ii) bis(diphosphine) complex

A nickel(ii) bis(diphosphine) complex bearing carboxylic acid groups has been tested as a catalyst for hydrogen evolution under different conditions.

Structure of the CoI Intermediate of a Cobalt Pentapyridyl Catalyst for Hydrogen Evolution Revealed by Time-Resolved X-ray Spectroscopy

Cobalt polypyridyls are highly efficient water-stable molecular catalysts for hydrogen evolution. The catalytic mechanism explaining their activity is under debate and the main question is the nature of the involvement of pyridyls in the proton transfer: the pentapyridyl ligand, acting as a pentadentate ligand, can provide stability to the catalyst or one of the pyridines can be involved in the proton transfer. Time-resolved Co K-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy in the microsecond time range indicates that, for the [Co^II (aPPy)] catalyst (aPPy=di([2,2'-bipyridin]-6-yl)(pyridin-2-yl)methanol), the pendant pyridine dissociates from the cobalt in the intermediate Co^I state. This opens the possibility for pyridinium to act as an intramolecular proton donor. In the resting state, the catalyst returns to the original six-coordinate high-spin Co^II state with a pentapyridyl and one water molecule coordinating to the metal center. Such a bifunctional role of the polypyridyl ligands can be exploited during further optimization of the catalyst.