Immunophenotypic shift in the B-cell precursors from regenerating bone marrow samples: A critical consideration for measurable residual disease assessment in B-lymphoblastic leukemia

Microfluidic Affinity Selection of B-Lineage Cells from Peripheral Blood for Minimal Residual Disease Monitoring in Pediatric B-Type Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia Patients

Assessment of minimal residual disease (MRD) is the most powerful predictor of outcome in B-type acute lymphoblastic leukemia (B-ALL). MRD, defined as the presence of leukemic cells in the blood or bone marrow, is used for the evaluation of therapy efficacy. We report on a microfluidic-based MRD (MF-MRD) assay that allows for frequent evaluation of blood for the presence of circulating leukemia cells (CLCs). The microfluidic chip affinity selects B-lineage cells, including CLCs using anti-CD19 antibodies poised on the wall of the microfluidic chip. Affinity-selected cells are released from the capture surface and can be subjected to immunophenotyping to enumerate the CLCs, perform fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), and/or molecular analysis of the CLCs' mRNA/gDNA. During longitudinal testing of 20 patients throughout induction and consolidation therapy, the MF-MRD performed 116 tests, while only 41 were completed with multiparameter flow cytometry (MFC-MRD) using a bone marrow aspirate, as standard-of-care. Overall, 57% MF-MRD tests were MRD(+) as defined by CLC numbers exceeding a threshold of 5 × 10-4%, which was determined to be the limit of quantitation. Above a threshold of 0.01%, MFC-MRD was positive in 34% of patients. The MF offered the advantage of the opportunity for efficiently processing small volumes of blood (2 mL), which is important in the care of pediatric patients, especially infants. The minimally invasive means of blood collection are of high value when treating patients whose MRD is typically tested using an invasive bone marrow biopsy. MF-MRD detection can be useful for stratification of patients into risk groups and monitoring of patient well-being after completion of treatment for early recognition of potential impending disease recurrence.

Indeterminate measurable residual disease by multiparameter flow cytometry is associated with an intermediate risk of clinical relapse in adult patients with acute leukaemia

Measurable residual disease (MRD) is useful for prognostication and for monitoring response to treatment in patients with acute leukaemia. MRD by multiparametric flow cytometry (MFC-MRD) utilises the leukaemia-associated immunophenotype (LAIP) and difference from normal (DfN) strategies to identify the leukaemic clone. Difficulties arise when the LAIP overlaps with normal regeneration, there is clonal evolution, or when the abnormal clone population is exceptionally small e.g., <0.01% of CD45+ cells. Such cases are reported as 'indeterminate'; however, there is little international consensus on this reporting. The relationship between clinical outcomes and indeterminate MFC-MRD is unknown. Here we determine the rate of indeterminate MFC-MRD reporting, its relationship to concurrent molecular MRD results when available, and to clinical outcomes to 12 months. We performed an internal audit of all adult testing for MFC-MRD between January and December 2021. A total of 153 consecutive patients with a diagnosis of acute leukaemia were included. Successive MFC-MRD results and clinical outcomes were recorded over a 12-month period from time of inclusion into the study. In total, 460 MFC-MRD tests from 153 patients were reviewed and 73 (16%) MFC-MRD tests from 54 (35%) patients were reported as indeterminate. The majority (70%) were at low levels between 0.01-0.1% of CD45+ cells. Compared to patients with a negative result, acute myeloid leukaemia (AML) was more frequent in patients who had an indeterminate MFC-MRD (70% vs 36%), and B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukaemia was less common (20% vs 55%). In patients with indeterminate MFC-MRD results, one-third had received either chemotherapy or allogeneic haemopoietic stem cell transplant (aHSCT) within the preceding 3 months. Agreement between MFC and molecular MRD testing was low. Patients with indeterminate MFC-MRD had leukaemia relapse rates below patients with a positive MFC-MRD, but greater than those with negative MFC-MRD (positive 33% vs indeterminate 21% vs negative 8%, p = 0.038). Overall, these findings indicate that indeterminate MFC-MRD results are more common in adults with AML and also in those who have received chemotherapy or aHSCT within the previous 3 months. We report for the first time that indeterminate MFC-MRD is a finding of potential clinical significance, which associates with a numerically higher median relapse rate within 12 months when compared to a negative MFC-MRD result.

Deciphering stage 0 hematogones by flow cytometry in follow-up bone marrow samples of pediatric B-Acute lymphoblastic leukemia cases: A potential mimicker of residual disease after anti CD19 therapy

CD19 is frequently targeted for immunotherapy in B cell malignancies, which may result in loss of CD19 expression in leukemic cells as an escape mechanism. Stage 0 hematogones (Hgs) are normal CD19-negative very early B cell precursors that can be potentially mistaken for CD19 negative residual leukemic cells by flow cytometry (FCM) in B cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (BCP-ALL) cases treated with anti CD19 therapy. Our main objective was to characterize and study the incidence of stage 0 hematogones in follow-up bone marrow samples of pediatric BCP-ALL cases. We analyzed the flow cytometry standard files of 61 pediatric BCP-ALL cases treated with conventional chemotherapy and targeted anti-CD19 therapy, for identifying the residual disease and normal B cell precursors including stage 0 Hgs. A non-CD19 alternate gating strategy was used to isolate the B cells for detecting the residual disease and stage 0 Hgs. The stage 0 Hgs were seen in 95% of marrow samples containing CD19+ Hgs. When compared with controls and posttransplant marrow samples, the fraction of stage 0 Hgs was higher in patients receiving anti CD19 therapy (p = 0.0048), but it was not significant when compared with patients receiving chemotherapy (p = 0.1788). Isolated stage 0 Hgs are found in samples treated with anti-CD19 therapy simulating CD19 negative residual illness. Our findings aid in understanding the stage 0 Hgs and its association with CD19+ Hgs in anti CD19 therapy and conventional chemotherapy. This is crucial as it can be potentially mistaken for residual disease in patients treated with anti CD19 therapy.

15-color highly sensitive flow cytometry assay for post anti-CD19 targeted therapy (anti-CD19-CAR-T and blinatumomab) measurable residual disease assessment in B-lymphoblastic leukemia/lymphoma: Real-world applicability and challenges

OBJECTIVES

Measurable residual disease (MRD) is the most relevant predictor of disease-free survival in B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (B-ALL). We aimed to establish a highly sensitive flow cytometry (MFC)-based B-ALL-MRD (BMRD) assay for patients receiving anti-CD19 immunotherapy with an alternate gating approach and to document the prevalence and immunophenotype of recurrently occurring low-level mimics and confounding populations.

METHODS

We standardized a 15-color highly-sensitive BMRD assay with an alternate CD19-free gating approach. The study included 137 MRD samples from 43 relapsed/refractory B-ALL patients considered for anti-CD19 immunotherapy.

RESULTS

The 15-color BMRD assay with CD22/CD24/CD81/CD33-based gating approach was routinely applicable in 137 BM samples and could achieve a sensitivity of 0.0005%. MRD was detected in 29.9% (41/137) samples with 31.7% (13/41) of them showing <.01% MRD. Recurrently occurring low-level cells that showed immunophenotypic overlap with leukemic B-blasts included: (a) CD19+CD10+CD34+CD22+CD24+CD81+CD123+CD304+ plasmacytoid dendritic cells, (b) CD73bright/CD304bright/CD81bright mesenchymal stromal/stem cells (CD10+) and endothelial cells (CD34+CD24+), (c) CD22dim/CD34+/CD38dim/CD81dim/CD19-/CD10-/CD24- early lymphoid progenitor/precursor type-1 cells (ELP-1) and (d) CD22+/CD34+/CD10heterogeneous/CD38moderate/CD81moderate/CD19-/CD24- stage-0 B-cell precursors or ELP-2 cells.

CONCLUSIONS

We standardized a highly sensitive 15-color BMRD assay with a non-CD19-based gating strategy for patients receiving anti-CD19 immunotherapy. We also described the immunophenotypes of recurrently occurring low-level populations that can be misinterpreted as MRD in real-world practice.

Analytical Appraisal of Hematogones in B-ALL MRD Assessment Using Multidimensional Dot-Plots by Multiparametric Flow Cytometry: A Critical Review and Update

The spectrum of benign B-cell precursors, known as hematogones (HGs), shows a significant morphological and immunophenotypic overlap with their malignant counterpart i.e. B-lymphoid blasts (BLBs). This results in a diagnostic dilemma in assessment of cases wherein there is a physiological preponderance of HGs and also poses a significant challenge in measurable residual disease assessment in B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukaemia. Consequently, expression patterns of various immunophenotypic markers are considered the most important tool in identification and delineation of HGs from BLBs. However, certain aspects of B-cell compartment evaluation by flow cytometric immunophenotyping and its relevance in clinical scenarios is yet to be defined precisely. This review summarizes current flowcytometric data on HGs and its discrimination from BLBs based on thorough review of literature and evaluation of in-house data. Furthermore, it focuses on the utility of an additional analytical tool i.e., radar plot for a comprehensive representation of various subsets of the B-cell compartment and their differentiation from BLBs.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s12288-023-01696-5.

Flow cytometric assessment for minimal/measurable residual disease in B lymphoblastic leukemia/lymphoma in the era of immunotherapy

Minimal/measurable residual disease (MRD) is the most important independent prognostic factor for patients with B-lymphoblastic leukemia (B-LL). MRD post therapy has been incorporated into risk stratification and clinical management, resulting in substantially improved outcomes in pediatric and adult patients. Currently, MRD in B-ALL is most commonly assessed by multiparametric flow cytometry and molecular (polymerase chain reaction or high-throughput sequencing based) methods. The detection of MRD by flow cytometry in B-ALL often begins with B cell antigen-based gating strategies. Over the past several years, targeted immunotherapy directed against B cell markers has been introduced in patients with relapsed or refractory B-ALL and has demonstrated encouraging results. However, targeted therapies have significant impact on the immunophenotype of leukemic blasts, in particular, downregulation or loss of targeted antigens on blasts and normal B cell precursors, posing challenges for MRD detection using standard gating strategies. Novel flow cytometric approaches, using alternative strategies for population identification, sometimes including alternative gating reagents, have been developed and implemented to monitor MRD in the setting of post targeted therapy.

Mimics and artefacts of measurable residual disease in a highly sensitive multicolour flow cytometry assay for B-lymphoblastic leukaemia/lymphoma: critical consideration for analysis of measurable residual disease

High-sensitivity multicolour flow cytometry (MFC)-based B-lymphoblastic leukaemia (B-ALL) measurable residual disease (BMRD) assay is increasingly being used in clinical practice. Herein, we describe six consistently present low-level populations immunophenotypically mimicking abnormal B-ALL blasts in 441 BMRD samples from 301 children. These included CD19⁺ CD123⁺ plasmacytoid dendritic cells differentiating from lymphoid precursors, CD10⁺ transitional B cells with CD10⁺ /CD38dim-to-negative/CD20bright/CD45bright phenotype, CD19⁺ natural killer (NK) cells, CD73bright/CD10⁺ mesenchymal stromal/stem cells, CD73bright/CD34⁺ endothelial cells, and a CD34⁺ CD38dim-to-negative/CD10^- /CD20bright/CD45bright subset of mature B cells. We provide the proportions, comprehensive immunophenotype, and practical clues for proper identification of these low-level populations. Knowledge regarding the presence and immunophenotype of these mimics is essential for accurate interpretation in high-sensitivity MFC-BMRD analysis.